Etracker Debug:
	et_pagename = "Law & Ethics of Human Rights|lehr|C|[EN]"
	
        
Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation

Law & Ethics of Human Rights

Editor-in-Chief: Stopler, Gila

Ed. by Benvenisti, Eyal / Cohen-Eliya, Moshe / Macedo, Stephen / Rosenblum, Nancy

2 Issues per year

Justice, Work, and the Ghetto Poor

1Harvard University

Citation Information: The Law & Ethics of Human Rights. Volume 6, Issue 1, Pages 69–96, ISSN (Online) 1938-2545, DOI: 10.1515/1938-2545.1068, December 2012

Publication History

Published Online:
2012-12-06

Abstract

In view of the explanatory significance of joblessness, some social scientists, policymakers, and commentators have advocated strong measures to ensure that the ghetto poor work, including mandating work as a condition of receiving welfare benefits. Indeed, across the ideological political spectrum, work is often seen as a moral or civic duty and as a necessary basis for personal dignity. And this normative stance is now instantiated in federal and state law, from the tax scheme to public benefits. This Article reflects critically on this new regime of work. I ask whether the normative principles to which its advocates typically appeal actually justify the regime. I conclude that the case for a pro tanto moral or civic duty to work is not as strong as many believe and that there are reasonable responses to joblessness that do not involve instituting a work regime. However, even if we grant that there is a duty to work, I maintain that the ghetto poor would not be wronging their fellow citizens were they to choose not to work and to rely on public funds for material support. In fact, I argue that many among the black urban poor have good reasons to refuse to work. Throughout, I emphasize what too few advocates of the new work regime do, namely, that whether work is an obligation depends crucially on whether background social conditions within the polity are just.

KEYWORDS: reciprocity; joblessness; work regime; ghetto poor; duty to work

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content.