Scientific rigor and practical relevance are extensively discussed and highly important criteria of the quality of scientific articles. This research examines the balance of these criteria within the domain of technology acceptance research for mobile services. 2073 articles were considered for the study and 24 that covered the topic were chosen for detailed review. Five sub-criteria for rigor (theoretical base, research model, sample choice, questionnaire and tests) and four sub-criteria for relevance (success factors, target group, timeliness and limitations) were elaborated to evaluate the articles. Most articles meet rigor criteria quite well, whereas the number of articles with sufficient relevance is significantly lower. The often-assumed contradiction of rigor and relevance could not be supported. The study thus concludes that both criteria are non-exclusive and can coexist in one article
Ed. by John, Nancy R. / Johnson, Ian M. / Larsen, Svend
4 Issues per year
iMPACT FACTOR 2011: 0.259
5-year IMPACT FACTOR: 0.373
Issues
Volume 63 (2013)
Volume 62 (2012)
Volume 61 (2011)
Volume 60 (2010)
Volume 59 (2009)
Volume 58 (2008)
Volume 57 (2007)
Volume 56 (2006)
Volume 55 (2005)
Volume 54 (2004)
Volume 53 (2003)
Volume 52 (2002)
Volume 51 (2001)
Volume 50 (2000)
Volume 49 (1999)
Volume 48 (1998)
Volume 47 (1997)
Volume 46 (1996)
Volume 45 (1995)
Volume 44 (1994)
Volume 43 (1993)
Volume 42 (1992)
Volume 41 (1991)
Volume 40 (1990)
Volume 39 (1989)
Volume 38 (1988)
Volume 37 (1987)
Volume 36 (1986)
Volume 35 (1985)
Volume 34 (1984)
Volume 33 (1983)
Volume 32 (1982)
Volume 31 (1981)
Volume 30 (1980)
Volume 29 (1979)
Volume 28 (1978)
Volume 27 (1977)
Volume 26 (1976)
Volume 25 (1975)
Volume 24 (1974)
Volume 23 (1973)
Volume 22 (1972)
Volume 21 (1971)
Volume 20 (1970)
Volume 19 (1969)
Volume 18 (1968)
Volume 17 (1967)
Volume 16 (1966)
Volume 15 (1965)
Volume 13 (1964)
Volume 14 (1964)
Volume 12 (1962)
Volume 11 (1961)
Volume 10 (1960)
Volume 9 (1959)
Volume 8 (1958)
Volume 7 (1958)
Volume 6 (1956)
Volume 5 (1955)
Volume 4 (1954)
Volume 3 (1954)
Volume 2 (1953)
Volume 1 (1950)
Most Downloaded Articles
- Towards Library 2.0: The Adoption of Web 2.0 Technologies in Public Libraries by Anttiroiko, Ari-Veikko and Savolainen, Reijo
- The Library-Community Convergence Framework for Community Action: Libraries as Catalysts of Social Change by Mehra, Bharat and Srinivasan, Ramesh
- Working with Facebook in Public Libraries: A Backstage Glimpse into the Library 2.0 Rhetoric by Carlsson, Hanna
- Google Scholar: The New Generation of Citation Indexes by Noruzi, Alireza
- Sense-Making and Synchronicity: Information-Seeking Behaviors of Millennials and Baby Boomers by Connaway, Lynn Silipigni/ Radford, Marie L./ Dickey, Timothy J./ De Angelis Williams, Jocelyn and Confer, Patrick
A Critical Review of User Acceptance Research in the Area of Mobile Services
Elisabeth Platzer1
1Research student in the doctoral programme at the Institute for Information Science and Information Systems, Karl Franzens University, Graz, Austria. Email: elisabeth.platzer@uni-graz.at
Citation Information: Libri. Volume 59, Issue 4, Pages 213–227, ISSN (Online) 1865-8423, ISSN (Print) 0024-2667, DOI: 10.1515/libr.2009.019, January 2010
Publication History:
- Received:
- 2009-05-10
- Accepted:
- 2009-08-10
- Published Online:
- 2010-01-29
Comments (0)