Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation

Linguistic Typology

Ed. by Plank, Frans

3 Issues per year

ERIH category 2011: INT1

VolumeIssuePage

Issues

On the (un)suitability of semantic categories

Jan Rijkhoff1

1Aarhus Universitet

Correspondence address: Afdeling for Lingvistik, Aarhus Universitet, bygning 1410, Nordre Ringgade 1, 8000 Århus C, Denmark; e-mail:

Citation Information: Linguistic Typology. Volume 13, Issue 1, Pages 95–104, ISSN (Online) 1613-415X, ISSN (Print) 1430-0532, DOI: 10.1515/LITY.2009.005, May 2009

Publication History

Received:
2008-07-30
Revised:
2009-01-07
Published Online:
2009-05-20

Abstract

Since Greenberg's groundbreaking publication on universals of grammar, typologists have used semantic categories to investigate (constraints on) morphological and syntactic variation in the world's languages and this tradition has been continued in the WALS project. It is argued here that the employment of semantic categories has some serious drawbacks, however, suggesting that semantic categories, just like formal categories, cannot be equated across languages in morphosyntactic typology. Whereas formal categories are too narrow in that they do not cover all structural variants attested across languages, semantic categories can be too wide, including too many structural variants. Furthermore, it appears that in some major typological studies semantic categories have been confused with formal categories. A possible solution is pointed out: typologists first need to make sure that the forms or constructions under investigation do the same job in the various languages (functional sameness); subsequently this functional selection can be narrowed down on the basis of formal or semantic criteria to construct a set of elements that is similar enough to allow for crosslinguistic comparison (formal and semantic similarity).

Keywords:: categories; lingusitic atlas; semantics; word classes; word order

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Users without a subscription are not able to see the full content. Please, subscribe or login to access all content.