Northern European Journal of Philosophy
Editor-in-Chief: Brock, Steen / Pedersen, Esther Oluffa / Pihlström, Sami / Rasmussen, Anders Moe
Ed. by Haraldsson, Robert H. / Johansson, Ingvar / Recki, Birgit / Verbeek, Peter-Paul / Serck-Hanssen, Camilla / Timmermann, Jens / Wallgren, Thomas
Editorial Board Member: Addis, Mark / Grassme Binderup, Lars / Carlshamre, Staffan / Emundts, Dina / Christensen, Anne-Marie / Gundersen, Lars Bo / Gustafsson, Martin / Hämäläinen, Nora / Hedberg, Petra / Heinämaa, Sara / Hutto, Daniel / Janvid, Mikael / Kappel, Klemens / / Nilsson, Jonas / Riis, Sören / Sundström, Pär / Tuinen, Sjoerd / Schwarz Wentzer, Thomas / Ylikoski, Petri / Kotkavirta, Jussi / Lippert-Rasmussen, Kasper / Zahavi, Dan
2 Issues per year
Most Downloaded Articles
- On Certainty, Skepticism and Berkeley's Idealism by Vaaja, Tero
- Masthead by null
- The throwing hand. An essay on human subjectivity by Lysemose, Kasper
- Relative Armut und soziale Wertschätzung by Schweiger, Gottfried
- Rehabilitating Ernst Cassirer and his Philosophy – Four Recent Contributions by Meland, Ingmar
Is There a Problem of Action at a Temporal Distance?
1Department of Philosophy and Linguistics, University of Umeå. email@example.com
Citation Information: SATS. Volume 8, Issue 1, Pages 138–154, ISSN (Online) 1869-7577, ISSN (Print) 1600-1974, DOI: 10.1515/SATS.2007.138, March 2010
- Published Online:
It has been claimed that the only way to avoid action at a temporal distance in a temporal continuum is if effects occur simultaneously with their causes, and that in fact Newton's second law of motion illustrates that they truly are simultaneous. Firstly, I point out that this interpretation of Newton's second law is problematic because in classical mechanics ‘acceleration’ denotes a scalar vector. It is controversial whether scalar vectors themselves are changes as opposed to properties of a change, and therefore if they can count as effects. Secondly, I argue that the problem of action at a temporal distance is generated by the assumption that forces operate on their effects, but that this assumption is not easily reconciled with Newton's third law of motion, which is best read as saying that forces operate between objects. On that reading, there is no problem of action at a temporal distance even in a temporal continuum just as long as interacting objects coexist.