Medicine, anti-realism and ideology: Variation in medical genetics does not show that race is biologically real

Phila Mfundo Msimang 1
  • 1 Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Stellenbosch University, 80 Ryneveldt Street, Stellenbosch, South Africa
Phila Mfundo Msimang
  • Corresponding author
  • Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences, Stellenbosch University, 80 Ryneveldt Street, Stellenbosch, 7602, South Africa
  • Email
  • Search for other articles:
  • degruyter.comGoogle Scholar

Abstract

Lee McIntyre’s Respecting Truth chronicles the contemporary challenges regarding the relationship amongst evidence, belief formation and ideology. The discussion in his book focusses on the ‘politicisation of knowledge’ and the purportedly growing public (and sometimes academic) tendency to choose to believe what is determined by prior ideological commitments rather than what is determined by evidence-based reasoning. In considering these issues, McIntyre posits that the claim “race is a myth” is founded on a political ideology rather than on support from scientific evidence. He contrasts this view with the argument that racially correlated biomedical outcomes for self-identified racial groups suggest that biological races are real. I explore how McIntyre’s framing of the claim “race is a myth” as fundamentally ideological results in him failing to engage with the arguments and evidence many constructionists and biological anti-realists put forward in support of their views. I also show how the biomedical evidence he thinks supports biological realism is unconvincing.

  • Adler, Jerry. 2009. What’s race got to do with it? Newsweek 153(2). 16.

  • Anand, Inder S., Sithu Win, Thomas S. Rector, Jay N. Cohn & Anne L. Taylor. 2014. Effect of fixed-dose combination of isosorbide dinitrate and hydralazine on all hospitalizations and on 30-day readmission rates in patients with heart failure: Results from the African-American heart failure trial. Circulation, Heart Failure 7.5. 759–765.

  • Andreasen, Robin O. 2007. Biological conceptions of race. In M. Matthen & C. Stephens (eds.), Philosophy of biology, 455–481. The Netherlands: Elsevier.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Appiah, Kwame A. 1996. Race, culture, identity: Misunderstood connections. In K. A. Appiah & A. Guttmann (eds.), Color conscious: The political morality of race, 30–105. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

  • Baker, Jennifer L., Charles N. Rotimi & Daniel Shriner. 2017. Human ancestry correlates with language and reveals that race is not an objective genomic classifier. Scientific Reports 7. 1572.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Bibbins-Domingo, Kirsten & Alicia Fernandez. 2007. BiDil for heart failure in black patients. Annals of Internal Medicine 147(3). 214–215.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Blum, Lawrence. 2010. Racialized groups: The sociohistorical consensus. The Monist 93(2). 298–320.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Boghossian, Paul. 2006. Fear of knowledge: Against relativism and social constructionism. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

  • Brody, Howard & Linda M. Hunt. 2006. BiDil: Assessing a race-based pharmaceutical. Annals of Family Medicine 4. 556–560.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Brown, Ryan A. & George J. Armelagos. 2001. Apportionment of racial diversity: A review. Evolutionary Anthropology 10. 34–40.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Burchard, Esteban González, Elad Ziv, Natasha Coyle, Scarlett Lin Gomez, Hua Tang, Andrew J. Karter, Joanna L. Mountain, Eliseo J. Pérez-Stable, Dean Sheppard & Neil Risch. 2003. The importance of race and ethnic background in biomedical research and clinical practice. The New England Journal of Medicine 348(12). 1170–1175.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Chamorro-Premuzic, Tomas, Sophie Von Stumm & Adrian Furnham. 2011. The Wiley-Blackwell handbook of individual differences, T. Chamorro-Premuzic, S. Von Stumm and F. Furnham, eds. West Sussex: Wiley-Blackwell.

  • Cohn, Jay N., Donald G. Archibald, Susan Ziesche, Joseph A. Franciosa, W. Eugene Harston, Felix E. Tristani, W. Bruce Dunkman, William Jacobs, Gary S. Francis, Kathleen H. Flohr, Steven Goldman, Frederick R. Cobb, Pravin M. Shah, Robert Saunders, Ross D. Fletcher, Henry S. Loeb, Vincent C. Hughes & Bonnie Baker. 1986. Effect of vasodilator therapy on mortality in chronic congestive heart failure. New England Journal of Medicine 314. 1547–1552.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Cohn, Jay N., Gary Johnson, Susan Ziesche, Frederick Cobb, Gary Francis, Felix Tristani, Raphael Smith, W. Bruce Dunkman, Henry Loeb, Maylene Wong, Geetha Bhat, Steven Goldman, Ross D. Fletcher, James Doherty, C. Vincent Hughes, Peter Carson, Guillermo Cintron, Ralph Shabetai & Clair Haakenson. 1991. A comparison of enalapril with hydralazine–isosorbide dinitrate in the treatment of chronic congestive heart failure. New England Journal of Medicine 325. 303–310.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Coleman, Michael D. 2010. Human drug metabolism: An introduction. 2nd edn. West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons.

  • Cole, Robert T., Kalogeropoulos, Andreas P., Georgiopoulou, Vasiliki V., Gheorghiade, Mihai, Quyyumi, Arshed, Yancy, Clyde, & Butler, Javed. (2011). Hydralazine and Isosorbide Dinitrate in Heart Failure. Circulation, 123(21), 2414–2422.

    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Dalrymple, Ursula, Mappin, Bonnie, and Gething, Peter W. 2015. Malaria mapping: understanding the global endemicity of falciparum and vivax malaria. BMC Medicine 13(1). 1–8.

  • Edwards, Anthony W. F. 2003. Human genetic diversity: Lewontin’s Fallacy. Bioessays 25. 798–801.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Fofana, Mariam O. 2013. The spectre of race in American medicine. Medical Humanities 39. 137–141.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Foster, Morris W. 2009. Looking for race in all the wrong places: Analyzing the lack of productivity in the ongoing debate about race and genetics. Human Genetics 126. 355–362.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Fujimura, Joan H., Deborah A. Bolnick, Ramya Rajagopalan, Jay S. Kaufman, Richard C. Lewontin, Troy Duster, Pilar Ossorio & Jonathan Marks. 2014. Clines without classes: How to make sense of human variation. Sociological Theory 32(3). 208–227.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Galton, Francis. 1869. Hereditary genius: An inquiry into its laws and consequences. London: Macmillan & Co.

  • Gannett, Lisa. 2004. The biological reification of race. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science 55. 323–345.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Gillum, Richard F., Alem Mehari, Bryan Curry & Thomas O. Obisesan. 2012. Racial and geographic variation in coronary heart disease mortality trends. BMC Public Health 6(12). 410.

  • Glasgow, Joshua, Sally Haslanger, Chike Jeffers & Quayshawn Spencer. 2019. What is race? Four philosophical views. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Goodman, Alan H. 2000. Why genes don’t count (for racial differences in health). American Journal of Public Health 90(11). 1699–1702.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Gould, Steven J. 1996. The mismeasurement of man. New York & London: WW Norton & Company, Second Edition.

  • Hardimon, Michael O. 2013. Race concepts in medicine. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 38. 6–31.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Hardimon, Michael O. 2017. Rethinking race – The case for deflationary realism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

  • Haslanger, Sally. 2000. Gender and Race: (What) Are They? (What) Do We Want Them to Be? Noûs 34, 31–55.

  • Haslanger, Sally. 2012. A social constructionist analysis of race. In Haslanger (ed.) Resisting reality: Social construction and social critique, 298–310. New York: Oxford University Press.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Haslanger, Sally. 2019. Tracing the Ssocio-political reality of race. In J. Glasgow, S. Haslanger, C. Jeffers & Q. Spencer (eds.), What is race? Four philosophical views, 4–37. Oxford,: Oxford University Press.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Herrnstein, Richard J. & Charles Murray. 1994. The bell curve: Intelligence and class structure in American life. New York, NY: Free Press.

  • Hochman, Adam. 2013. Against the new racial naturalism. Journal of Philosophy 110. 331–351.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Hochman, Adam. 2014. Unnaturalised racial naturalism. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 46. 79–87.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Hochman, Adam. 2016. Race: Deflate or pop? Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 57. 60–68.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Hochman, Adam. 2017. Replacing race: Interactive constructionism about racialized groups. Ergo, an Open Access Journal of Philosophy 4.3. 61–92.

  • Hochman, Adam. 2019. Race and reference. Biology & Philosophy 34. 32 (online first).

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Jablonski, Nina G. 2012a. Living color: The biological and social meaning of skin color. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

  • Jablonski, Nina G. 2012b. The evolution of human skin colouration and its relevance to health in the modern world. Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh 42. 58–63.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Jablonski, Nina G. 2012c. Human skin pigmentation as an example of adaptive evolution. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 156(1). 45–57.

  • Jackson, John P. & Nadine M. Weidman. 2004. Race, racism, and science: Social impact and interaction. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.

  • Jeffers, Chike. 2019. Jeffer’s reply to Glasgow, Haslanger, and Spencer. In J. Glasgow, S. Haslanger, C. Jeffers & Q. Spencer (eds.), What is race? Four philosophical views, 176–202. Oxford,: Oxford University Press.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Kahn, Jonathan D. 2007. BiDil for heart failure in black patients. Annals of Internal Medicine 147. 215.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Kahn, Jonathan D. 2013. Race in a bottle: The story of BiDil and racialized medicine in a post-genomic age. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.

  • Kitcher, Philip. 1999. Race, ethnicity, biology, culture. In L. Harris (ed.), Racism, 87–117. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books.

  • Lakatos, Imre. 1978. The methodology of scientific research programmes. Philosophical papers. vol. I. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Levy, Samuel, Granger Sutton, Pauline C. Ng, Lars Feuk, Aaron L. Halpern, Brian P. Walenz, Nelson Axelrod, Jiaqi Huang, Ewen F. Kirkness, Gennady Denisov, Yuan Lin, Jeffrey R. MacDonald, Andy Wing Chun Pang, Mary Shago, Timothy B. Stockwell, Alexia Tsiamouri, Vineet Bafna, Vikas Bansal, Saul A. Kravitz, Dana A. Busam, Karen Y. Beeson, Tina C. McIntosh, Karin A. Remington, Josep F. Abril, John Gill, Jon Borman, Yu-Hui Rogers, Marvin E. Frazier, Stephen W. Scherer, Robert L. Strausberg & J. Craig Venter. 2007. The diploid genome sequence of an individual human. PLoS Biology 5(10). E254: 2113–2144.

    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Lewontin, Richard C. 1972. The apportionment of human diversity. In T. Dobzhansky, M. K. Hecht & W. C. Steer (eds.), Evolutionary biology, vol. 6, 381–398. New York, NY: Appleton Century Crofts.

  • Lindhorst, Jane, Nicole Alexander, Juliet Blignaut & Brian Rayner. 2007. Differences in hypertension between blacks and whites: An overview. Cardiovascular Journal of Africa 18(4). 241–247.

    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Livingstone, Frank B. & Theodosius Dobzhansky. 1962. On the non-existence of human races. Current Anthropology 3.3. 279–281.

  • Maglo, Koffi N., Tesfaye B. Mersha & Lisa J. Martin. 2016. Population genomics and the statistical values of race: An interdisciplinary perspective on the biological classification of human populations and implications for clinical genetic epidemiological research. Frontiers in Genetics 7(22). 1–13.

  • Mallon, Ron. 2006. Race: Normative, not metaphysical or semantic. Ethics 116. 525–551.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Mallon, Ron. 2007. A field guide to social construction. Philosophy Compass 2.1. 93–108.

  • Mallon, Ron. 2013. Naturalistic approaches to social construction. In E. N. Zalta (ed.),Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy, Winter 2014 ed. Available at: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2014/entries/social-construction-naturalistic/ (accessed 15 August 2016).

  • Mallon, Ron. 2018. Constructing race: Racialization, causal effects, or both? Philosophical Studies 175(5). 1039–1056.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • McIntyre, Lee. 2015. Respecting Truth: Willful ignorance in the internet age. Oxon: Routledge.

  • Msimang, Phila M. 2019. Racializing racers: The racialized groups of interactive constructionism do not undermine social theories of race. Ergo, an Open Access Journal of Philosophy 6(1). 1–30.

  • Nazha, Aziz, Karam Al-Issa, B. Przychodzen, Nour Abuhadra, Cassandra Hirsch, J. P. Maciejewski & Mikkael A. Sekeres. 2017. Differences in genomic patterns and clinical outcomes between African-American and white patients with myelodysplastic syndromes. Blood Cancer Journal 7.9. e602.

  • Norton, Heather L., Ellen E. Quillen, Abigail W. Bigham, Laurel N. Pearson & Holly Dunsworth. 2019. Human races are not like dog breeds: Refuting a racist analogy. Evolution: Education and Outreach 12(17). 1–20 (online first).

  • Pearson, Karl. 1919 [1902]. The function of science in the modern state. 2nd edn. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Piel, Frédéric B., Anand P. Patil, Rosalind E. Howes, Oscar A. Nyangiri, Peter W. Gething, Mewahyu Dewi & William H. Temperley. 2013. Global epidemiology of Sickle haemoglobin in neonates: A contemporary geostatistical model-based map and population estimates. The Lancet 381(9861). 142–151.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Piel, Frédéric B., Anand P. Patil, Rosalind E. Howes, Oscar A. Nyangiri, Peter W. Gething, Thomas N. Williams, David J. Weatherall & Simon I. Hay. 2010. Global distribution of the Sickle cell gene and geographical confirmation of the malaria hypothesis. Nature Communications 1(104). 1–7.

  • Piel, Frédéric B. & Thomas N. Williams. 2016. Sickle cell anemia: History and epidemiology. In F. F. Costa & N. Conran (eds.), Sickle cell anemia, 23–47. The Netherlands: Springer.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Pigliucci, Massimo & Jonathan Kaplan. 2003. On the concept of biological race and its applicability to humans. Philosophy of Science 70(5). 1161–1172.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Risch, Neil, Esteban Burchard, Elad Ziv & Hua Tang. 2002. Categorization of humans in biomedical research: Genes, race and disease. Genome Biology 3. 1–12.

  • Rosenberg, Noah A., Saurabh Mahajan, Sohini Ramachandran, Chengfeng Zhao, Jonathan K. Pritchard & Marcus W. Feldman. 2005. Clines, clusters, and the effect of study design on the inference of human population structure. PLoS Genetics 1. 661–671.

  • Rotimi, Charles N. & Lynn B. Jorde. 2010. Ancestry and disease in the age of genomic medicine. New England Journal of Medicine 363. 1551–1558.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Sauer, Norman. 1992. Forensic anthropology and the concept of race: If races don’t exist, Why are forensic anthropologists so good at identifying them? Social Science and Medicine 34(2). 107–111.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Sesardić, N. 2010. Race: A social destruction of a biological concept. Biology and Philosophy 25. 143–162.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Sesardić, N. 2013. Confusions about race: A new installment. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 44. 287–293.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Shiao, Jiannbin L., Thomas Bode, Amber Beyer & Daniel Selvig. 2012. The genomic challenge to the social construction of race. Sociological Theory 30. 67–88.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Sinha, Moumita, Emma K. Larkin, Robert C. Elston & Susan Redline. 2006. Self-reported race and genetic admixture. New England Journal of Medicine 354. 421–422.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Smedley, Audrey & Brian D. Smedley. 2005. Race as biology is fiction, Race as social problem is real. The American Psychologist 60(1). 16–26.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Spencer, Quayshawn. 2015. Philosophy of race meets population genetics. Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 52. 46–55.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Spencer, Quayshawn. 2017a. Racial realism I: Are biological races real? Philosophy Compass 13(E12468). 1–13.

  • Spencer, Quayshawn. 2017b. Racial realism II: Are folk races real? Philosophy Compass 13(E12467). 1–16.

  • Spencer, Quayshawn. 2018. A Racial classification for medical genetics. Philosophical Studies 175. 1013–1037.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Spencer, Quayshawn. 2019. How to be a biological racial realist. In J. Glasgow, S. Haslanger, C. Jeffers & Q. Spencer (eds.), What is race? Four philosophical views, 73–110. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Temple, Robert & Norman L. Stockbridge. 2007. BiDil for heart failure in black patients: The U.S. food and drug administration perspective. Annals of Internal Medicine 146(1). 57–62.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Templeton, Alan R. 1999. Human races: A genetic and evolutionary perspective. American Anthropologist 100(3). 632–650.

  • Templeton, Alan R. 2013. Biological races in humans. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 44(3). 262–271.

    • Crossref
    • Export Citation
  • Valles, Sean A. 2012. Heterogeneity of risk within racial groups, A challenge for public health programs. Preventive Medicine 55(5). 405–408.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Vogenberg, F. Randy, Carol Isaacson Barash & Michael Pursel. 2010. Personalized medicine. part 1: Evolution and development into theranostics. Pharmacy and Therapeutics 35(10). 560–562, 565–567, 576.

  • Williams, Melissa J. & Jennifer L. Eberhardt. 2008. Biological conceptions of race and the motivation to cross racial boundaries. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 94(6). 1033–1047.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Winder, Isabelle C. & Nick P. Winder. 2014. Reticulate evolution and the human past: An anthropological perspective. Annals of Human Biology 41(4). 300–311.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Winther, Rasmus G. 2014. The genetic reification of ‘Race’?: A tale of two mathematical models. Critical Philosophy of Race 2(2). 204–223.

  • Yudell, Michael, Dorothy Roberts, Rob DeSalle & Sarah Tishkoff. 2016. Taking race out of human genetics. Science 351(6273). 564–565.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
    • Export Citation
  • Zack, Naomi. 1995. Race and mixed race. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

  • Zack, Naomi. 2003. Philosophy of science and race. Philadelphia, PA: Routledge.

Purchase article
Get instant unlimited access to the article.
$42.00
Log in
Already have access? Please log in.


or
Log in with your institution

Journal + Issues

This journal promotes current debates in all philosophical topics, historically and systematically. The aim of SATS is that each paper not only adds to these discussions but helps scholars who are not specialists in the specific fields to understand and assess the content of the debates. Thus each paper is reviewed by an ad hoc international expert on the given subject and by an editorial board member.

Search