Does the Digitalization of Manufacturing Boost a ‘Smart’ Era of Capital Accumulation?

  • 1 University of Cologne, Faculty of Management, Economics and Social Sciences, Department of Econonic and Social Geography, Albertus-Magnus-Platz, Cologne, Germany
Prof. Dr. Martina Fuchs
  • Corresponding author
  • University of Cologne, Faculty of Management, Economics and Social Sciences, Department of Econonic and Social Geography, Albertus-Magnus-Platz, 50923 Cologne,, 0049-221-470-7729, Cologne, Germany
  • Email
  • Search for other articles:
  • degruyter.comGoogle Scholar


‘Smart Manufacturing’ refers to a bundle of recent digital innovations together with the political initiatives that promote them. Public and academic debates indicate a fundamental shift in the socio-economic landscape, or a new era of capital accumulation in the language of regulation theory. A closer analysis of literature on Fordism and Postfordism, however, reveals that a ‘smart’ accumulation regime is at the most beginning to emerge, while earlier digitalization has already generated considerable impacts. This literature review first considers earlier contributions on digitalization and space that were published from the early 1980 s to the early 2000 s. It then discusses how this can inspire fresh views on Smart Manufacturing today.

  • Adams, P.C./Warf, B. (1997): Cyberspace and geographical space. In: The Geographical Review, 87(2), 139–146.

  • Aglietta, M. (1976): Régulation et Crises du Capitalisme: L’expérience des Etats Unis. Paris.

  • Albu-Schäffer, A. (2019): Von drehmomentgeregelten Roboterarmen zum intrinsisch nachgiebigen humanoiden Roboter. In: Woopen, C./Jannes, M. (eds.): Roboter in der Gesellschaft. Schriften zu Gesundheit und Gesellschaft. Berlin/Heidelberg, 1–14.

  • Altenburg, T. (1996): Entwicklungsländer im Schatten der Triade? In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, 40(1/2), 59–70.

  • Amirahmadi, H./Wallace, C. (1995): Information technology, the organization of production, and regional development. In: Environment and Planning A, 27(11), 1745–1775.

  • Aoyama, Y./Berndt, C./Glückler, J./Leslie, D (2011): Emerging Themes in Economic Geography: Outcomes of the Economic Geography 2010 Workshop. In: Economic Geography, 87(2), 111–126.

  • Bailey, D./De Propris, L. (2014): Manufacturing reshoring and its limits: the UK automotive case. In: Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 7(3), 379–395.

  • Bailey, D./De Propris, L. (2019): 6. Industry 4.0, Regional Disparities and Transformative Industrial Policy, Regional Studies Policy Impact Books, 1:2, 67–78.

  • Barzotto, M./Corradini, C./Fai, F.M./Labory, S./Tomlinson, P.R. (2019): 1. Introduction, Regional Studies Policy Impact Books, 1:2, 13–16. DOI:

  • Bathelt, H. (1991): Employment Changes and Input-Output Linkages in Key Technology Industries: A Comparative Analysis. In: Regional Studies, 25(1), 31–43.

  • Bathelt, H. (1994): Die Bedeutung der Regulationstheorie in der wirtschaftsgeographischen Forschung. In: Geographische Zeitschrift, 82(2), 63–90.

  • Berkeley, N./Clark, D./Ilbery, B. (1996): Regional Variations in Business Use of Information and Communication Technologies and their Implications for Policy: Case Study Evidence from Rural England. In: Geoforum, 27(1), 75–86.

  • Bogoviz, A.V./Osipov, V.S./Chistyakova, M.K./Borisov, M.Y. (2018): Comparative Analysis of Formation of Industry 4.0 in Developed and Developing Countries. In: Popkova, E./Ragulina, Y./Bogoviz, A. (eds.): Industry 4.0: Industrial Revolution of the 21st Century. Studies in Systems, Decision and Control. Cham, 155–164.

  • Boyer, R. (1986): La théorie de la régulation: Une analyse critique. Paris.

  • Boyer, R. (1995): Aux origenes de la théorie de la régulation. In: Boyer, R./Saillard, Y. (eds.): Théorie de la Régulation: L’état des Savoirs. Paris, 21–30.

  • Boyer, R. (2000): Is a finance-led growth regime a viable alternative to Fordism? A preliminary analysis. In: Economy and Society, 29(1), 111–145.

  • Busch, H.-C./Mühl, C./Fromhold-Eisebith, M./Fuchs, M. (2020): Hybrid forms of urban production through digitalization? Trends and cases from North Rhine-Westphalia. In: Spatial Research and Planning (in print).

  • Carbonero, F./Ernst, E./Weber, E. (2018): Robots worldwide: The impact of automation on employment and trade. (ILO Research Department working paper, 36), Genf., accessed 19 July 2019.

  • Caruso, L. (2018): Digital innovation and the fourth industrial revolution: epochal social changes? In: AI and Society, 33(3), 379–392.

  • Clarke, I.M. (1986): Labour dynamics and plant centrality in multinational corporations. In: Taylor, M./Thrift, N. (eds.): Multinationals and the restructuring of the world economy: The geography of multinationals. London, 21–48.

  • Cockayne, D.G. (2016): Sharing and neoliberal discourse: The economic function of sharing in the digital on-demand economy. In: Geoforum, 77(12), 73–82.

  • Cooley, M.J. (1972): Computer Aided Design. Stuttgart.

  • Dachs, B./Kinkel, S./Jäger, A./Palčič, I. (2019): Backshoring of production activities in European manufacturing. In: Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 25(3), Online First, accessed 2 December 2019.

  • Del Casino, V.J. (2016): Social geographies II: Robots. In: Progress in Human Geography, 40(6), 846–855.

  • Duncan, S./Goodwin, M./Halford, S. (1993): Regulation Theory, the Local State, and the Transition of Urban Politics. In: Environment and Planning D, Society and Space, (11) 1, 67–88.

  • Edwards, R./Whitston, C. (1989): Industrial Discipline, the Control of Attendance, and the Subordination of Labour: Towards an Integrated Analysis. In: Work, Employment and Society, 3(1), 1–28.

  • Ellegård, K. (1983): Människa – produktion: Tijdsbilder av ett produktionssystem. Göteborg.

  • Ellegård, K. (1989): Akrobatik i tidens väv: En dokumentation av projekteringen av Volvos bilfabrik i Uddevalla. Göteborg.

  • Erickson, R.A. (1980): Corporate organization and manufacturing branch plant closures in non-metropolitan areas. In: Regional Studies, 14(6), 491–501.

  • Ernst, D. (1985): Automation and the Worldwide Restructuring of the Electronics Industry: Strategic Implications for Developing Countries. In: World Development, 13(3), 333–352.

  • Esch, A. (2019): Additive Fertigung im automobilen Produktionssystem – Spannungsfeld von Paradigmenwandel und fortbestehenden Pfadabhängigkeiten. 15. Symposium of Economic Geography, 25–27. April 2019, Rauischholzhausen (Germany).

  • Essletzbichler, J. (2003): From Mass Production to Flexible Specialization: The Sectoral and Geographical Extent of Contract Work in US Manufacturing, 1963–1997. In: Regional Studies, 37(8), 753–771.

  • Ettlinger, N. (2016): The governance of crowdsourcing: Rationalities of the new exploitation. In: Environment and Planning A, 48(11), 2162–2180.

  • Foucault, M. (2008): The Birth of Biopolitics: Lectures at the Collège de France, 1978–1979. New York.

  • Ford, H./Graham, M. (2016): Provenance, power and place: Linked data and opaque digital geographies. In: Environment and Planning D, 34(6), 957–970.

  • Frey, C.B./Osborne, M.A. (2013): The future of employment: How susceptible are jobs to computerisation? Oxford., accessed 9 May 2019.

  • Fröbel, F./Heinrichs, J./Kreye, O. (1980): The New International Division of Labour: Structural Unemployment in Industrialised Countries and Industrialisation in Developing Countries. Cambridge.

  • Fromhold-Eisebith, M. (1999): Bangalore: A Network Model for Innovation-Oriented Regional Development in NICs? In: Malecki, E.J./Oinas, P. (eds.): Making Connections: Technological Learning and Regional Economic Change. Farnham, 231–260.

  • Fromhold-Eisebith, M. (2018): Research achievements in transition: German scholars’ contribution to economic geographies of knowledge, innovation and new technologies. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, 62(2), 152–162.

  • Fuchs, M. (1992): Standort und Arbeitsprozeß. Arbeitsveränderungen durch CAD in multistandörtlichen Unternehmen. Münster.

  • Fuchs, M. (2003): ‘Learning’ in Automobile Components Supply Companies. The Maquiladora of Ciudad Juárez, Mexico. In: Lo, V./Schamp, E.W. (eds.): Knowledge, Learning, and Regional Development. Münster, 107–130.

  • Fuchs, M. (2014): Worldwide Knowledge? Global Firms, Local Labour and the Region. Farnham.

  • Fuchs, M. (2019): Arbeit in Industrie 4.0 – Regionale Unterschiede, räumliche Abhängigkeiten, Place-Making. In: AIS-Studien, 12(2), 57–72., accessed 28 October 2019.

  • Fuchs, M./Schamp, E.W. (1990): Standard Elektrik Lorenz: Introducing CAD into a telecommunications firm: Its impact on labour. In: de Smidt, M./Wever, E. (eds.): The corporate firm in a changing world economy: Case studies in the geography of enterprise. London/New York, 77–99.

  • Gertler, M.S. (1988): The Limits of Flexibility: Comments on the Post-Fordist Vision of Production and its Geography. In: Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, 13(4), 419–432.

  • Goos, M./Manning, A. (2007): Lousy and lovely jobs: The rising polarization of work in Britain. In: Review of Economics and Statistics, 89(1), 118–133.

  • Graham, M./Straumann, R.K./Hogan, B. (2015): Digital Divisions of Labor and Informational Magnetism: Mapping Participation in Wikipedia. In: Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 105(6), 1158–1178.

  • Graham, M./Anwar, M.A. (2018): Digital Labour. In: Ash, J./Kitchin, R./Leszczynski, A. (eds.): Digital Geographies. London, 177–187.

  • Graham, M. (2019a): Digital Economies at Global Margins. Cambridge (Mass.)/London.

  • Graham, M. (2019b): Changing Connectivity and Digital Economies at Global Margins. In: Graham, M. (ed.): Digital Economies at Global Margins. Cambridge (Mass.)/London, 1–18.

  • Green Leigh, N./Kraft, B.R. (2017): Emerging robotic regions in the United States: insights for regional economic evolution. In: Regional Studies, 52(6), 804–815.

  • Gress, D.R./Kalafsky, R.V. (2015): Geographies of production in 3D: Theoretical and research implications stemming from additive manufacturing. In: Geoforum, 60(1), 43–52.

  • He, C./Zhu, S. (2017): Industrial Geography. In: Richardson, D. et al. (eds.): International Encyclopedia of Geography: People, the Earth, Environment and Technology. Chichester. Online first:, accessed 2 February 2020.

  • Hirsch-Kreinsen, H./Lay, G./Abel, J. (2012): Die Entwicklung sozialwissenschaftlicher Beiträge zur Produktionsforschung. In: Hirsch-Kreinsen, H./Lay, G./Abel, J. (eds.): Sozialwissenschaftliche Beiträge zur Produktionsforschung. Stuttgart, 9–24.

  • Hirsch-Kreinsen, H. (2018): Das Konzept des Soziotechnischen Systems – revisited. In: Arbeits- und Industriesoziologische Studien, 11(2), 11–28.

  • Hoffman, K. (1985): Clothing, Chips and Competitive Advantage. The Impact of Microelectronics on Trade and Production in the Garment Industry. In: World Development, 13(3), 371–392.

  • Hospers, G.-J. (2006): Silicon somewhere? Assessing the usefulness of best practices in regional policy. Policy Studies, 27 (1), 1–15.

  • IGM/IMU (2018): Digitale Transformation im Maschinen- und Anlagenbau. Frankfurt., accessed 19 July 2019.

  • James, J. (2002): Universal access to information technology in developing countries. In: Regional Studies, 36(9), 1093–1097.

  • Jessop, B./Sum, N.-L. (2006): Beyond the Regulation Approach: Putting Capitalist Economies in their Place. Cheltenham.

  • Jonas, E. G. (1996): Local Labour Control Regimes: Uneven Development and the Social Regulation of Production. In: Regional Studies, 30(4), 323–338.

  • Kagermann, H./Winter, J. (2017): Industrie 4.0 und plattformbasierte Geschäftsmodellinnovationen, in: Lucks, K. (ed.): Praxishandbuch Industrie 4.0., Stuttgart, 21–32.

  • Kaplinsky, R. (1985): Electronics-based Automation Technologies and the Onset of Systemofacture: Implications for Third World Industrialization. In: World Development, 13(3), 423–439.

  • Kenney, M./Zysman, J. (2019): The Platform Economy and Geography: Restructuring the Space of Capitalist Accumulation. BRIE Working Paper 2019–11. Online First, accessed 2 February 2020.

  • Kern, H./Schumann, M. (1987): Limits of the division of labour: New production and employment concepts in West German industry. Economic and Industrial Democracy, 8(2), 151–170.

  • Kinkel, S. (2012): Trends in production relocation and backshoring activities: Changing patterns in the course of the global economic crisis. In: International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 32(6), 696–720.

  • Kondratiev, N.D. (1935): The long waves in economic life. In: The Review of Economics and Statistics, 17(6), 105–115.

  • Krätke, S. (1996): Regulationstheoretische Perspektiven in der Wirtschaftsgeographie. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, 40(1/2), 6–19.

  • Krone, M./Dannenberg, P. (2018): Analysing the effects of information and communication technologies (ICTs) on the integration of East African farmers in a value chain context. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, 62(1), 65–81.

  • Krzywdzinski, M. (2017): Automation, skill requirements and labour-use strategies: high-wage and low-wage approaches to high-tech manufacturing in the automotive industry. In: New Technology, Work and Employment, 32(3), 247–267.

  • Kuhn, T. (1962): The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago.

  • Lange, B./Bürkner, H,-J. (2018): Flexible value creation: Conceptual prerequisites and empirical explorations in open workshops. In: Geoforum, 88(1), 96–104.

  • Leborgne, D./Lipietz, A. (1988): New technologies, new modes of regulation: Some spatial implications. In: Environment and Planning D, 6(3), 263–280.

  • Lipietz, A. (1986): Mirages et Miracles: Problèmes de l’Industrialisation dans le Tiers Monde. Paris.

  • Loebbecke, C./Picot, A. (2015): Reflections on societal and business model transformation arising from digitization and big data analytics: A research agenda. In: The Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 24(3), 149–157.

  • Lütkenhorst, W. (2018): Creating Wealth without Labour? Emerging Contours of a New Techno-Economic Landscape. German Development Institute, Discussion Paper 11/2018., accessed 4 December 2018.

  • Malecki, E.J./Moriset, B. (2008): The digital economy. Business organization, production processes and regional developments. London.

  • Massey, D. (1984): Spatial divisions of labour: Social structures and the geography of production. London.

  • Min, Y./Lee, S./Aoshima, Y. (2019): A comparative study on industrial spillover effects among Korea, China, the USA, Germany and Japan. In: Industrial Management & Data Systems, 119(3), 454–472.

  • Mittal, S./Khan, M.A./Romero, D./Wuest, T. (2019): Smart manufacturing: Characteristics, technologies and enabling factors. In: Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: Journal of Engineering Manufacture, 233(5), 1342–1361.

  • Morgan, K. (1992): Digital Highways: the New Telecommunications Era. In: Geoforum 23(3): 317–332.

  • Mühl, C./Busch, H.-C./Fromhold-Eisebith, M./Fuchs, M. (2019): Urbane Produktion: Dynamisierung stadtregionaler Arbeitsmärkte durch Digitalisierung und Industrie 4.0? FGW-Studie Digitalisierung von Arbeit 14., accessed 15 February 2019.

  • Norton, R.D./Rees, J. (1979): The Product Cycle and the Spatial Decentralization of American Manufacturing. In: Regional Studies, 13(2), 141–151.

  • NIST (2019): Product Definitions for Smart Manufacturing., accessed 28 October 2019.

  • Pavlínek, P./Ženka, J. (2011): Upgrading in the automotive industry: firm-level evidence from Central Europe. In: Journal of Economic Geography, 11(3), 559–586.

  • Peck, J. (2000): Places of Work. In: Sheppard, M./Barnes, T. (eds.): A companion to economic geography. Oxford, 133–148.

  • Peck, J./Tickell, A. (1992a): Accumulation, Regulation and the Geographies of Post-Fordism. Missing Links in Regulation and Research. In: Progress in Human Geography, 16(2), 190–218.

  • Peck, J./Tickell, A. (1992b): Local Modes of Social Regulation? Regulation Theory, Thatcherism and Uneven Development. In: Geoforum, (23) 3, 347–363.

  • Pickles J. (2020): Smart Geographies and the Political Economy of Innovation and Inequality. In: Nedkov, S. et al. (eds.): Smart Geography. Key Challenges in Geography. Cham, 29–39.

  • Piore, M.J./Sabel, C.F. (1985): Das Ende der Massenproduktion: Studie über die Requalifizierung der Arbeit und die Rückkehr der Ökonomie in die Gesellschaft. Berlin.

  • Richardson, L. (2018): Feminist geographies of digital work. Progress in Human Geography, 42(2), 244–263.

  • Richardson, L./Bissell, D. (2019): Geographies of digital skill. In: Geoforum, 99(2), 278–286.

  • Rodrik, D. (2016): Premature deindustrialization. In: Journal of Economic Growth, 21(1), 1–33.

  • Roper, S./Grimes, S. (2005): Wireless valley, silicon wadi and digital island – Helsinki, Tel Aviv and Dublin and the ICT global production network. In: Geoforum, 36(3), 297–313.

  • Sadowski, J. (2019): When data is capital: Datafication, accumulation, and extraction. In: Big Data and Society. Online first, accessed 2 February 2020.

  • Savey, S. (1983): Organization of production and the new spatial division of labour in France. In: Hamilton, F.E.I./Linge, G.J.R. (eds.): Spatial analysis, industry and the industrial environment: progress in research and applications. New York/Chichester, 103–120.

  • Sheppard, E./Barnes, T.J. (2017). Economic Geography. In: Richardson, D. et al. (eds.): International Encyclopedia of Geography: People, the Earth, Environment and Technology. Chichester. Online first, accessed 2 February 2020.

  • Der Spiegel (1964): Automation in Deutschland (14).

  • Der Spiegel (1978): Die Computer-Revolution. Fortschritt macht arbeitslos (16).

  • Der Spiegel (2016): Sie sind entlassen. Wie uns Computer und Roboter die Arbeit wegnehmen – und welche Berufe morgen noch sicher sind (36).

  • Sternberg, R./Tamásy, C. (1999): Munich as Germany’s No. 1 High Technology Region: Empirical Evidence, Theoretical Explanations and the Role of Small Firm/Large Firm Relationships. In: Regional Studies, 33(4), 367–377.

  • Storper, M. (2018): Separate Worlds? Explaining the current wave of regional economic polarization. In: Journal of Economic Geography, 18(2), 247–270.

  • Strange, R./Zucchella, A. (2017): Industry 4.0, global value chains and international business. In: Multinational Business Review, 25(3), 174–184.

  • Taylor, M./Thrift, N. (1986): Multinationals and the restructuring of the world economy: The geography of multinationals. London.

  • Thoben, K.-D./Wiesner, S./Wuest, T. (2017): “Industrie 4.0” and Smart Manufacturing – A Review of Research Issues and Application Examples. In: International Journal of Automation Technology, (11), 4–19.

  • Time Magazine (2013): Made in the USA: Manufacturing is back-but where are the jobs? (22).

  • Werner, M. (2019): Geographies of production I: Global production and uneven development. In: Progress in Human Geography, 43(5), 948–958.

  • Winter, J. (2017): Europa und die Plattformökonomie – Wie datengetriebene Geschäftsmodelle Wertschöpfungsketten verändern. In: Bruhn, M./Hadwich, K. (eds.): Dienstleistungen 4.0. Wiesbaden, 71–88.

  • World Economic Forum (2016): The Future of Jobs. Employment, Skills and Workforce Strategy for the Fourth Industrial Revolution., accessed 5 January 2019.

  • Zeller, C. (2003): Bausteine zu einer Geographie des Kapitalismus. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, 47(1), 215–230.

  • Zuboff, S. (2015): Big other: surveillance capitalism and the prospects of an information civilization. In: Journal of Information Technology, (30), 75–89.

Purchase article
Get instant unlimited access to the article.
Log in
Already have access? Please log in.

Log in with your institution

Journal + Issues

The primary focus of the German Journal for Economic Geography (ZFW) is on theory-led empirical research about spatial economic structures and regional dynamics. ZFW, which is the only scientific journal on Economic Geography in German speaking countries, addresses scientists and students as well as decision makers in private firms and economic promotion agencies.