Skip to content
BY-NC-ND 3.0 license Open Access Published by De Gruyter Open Access February 4, 2016

Migration patterns of San Francisco Bay Area Hermit Thrushes differ across a fine spatial scale

  • Allison R. Nelson , Renée L. Cormier , Diana L. Humple , Josh C. Scullen , Ravinder Sehgal and Nathaniel E. Seavy
From the journal Animal Migration


Effective conservation of short-distance migrants requires an understanding of intraspecific variation in migratory patterns across small spatial scales. Until the advent of ultra-light geolocation devices, our knowledge of the migratory connectivity of songbirds was limited. For the Hermit Thrush (Catharus guttatus), subspecies delineations and connectivity patterns have been unclear in the portion of their breeding range in western North America from southeastern Alaska to northwestern Washington, where individuals wintering in the San Francisco Bay Area of California purportedly breed. To determine breeding locations and migratory timing of the Bay Area’s wintering Hermit Thrushes, we deployed geolocators at sites to the north and south of the San Francisco Bay. We compared results from these two regions to one another and to connectivity patterns suggested by subspecies definitions. We collected morphometrics to identify regional differences. Hermit Thrushes that wintered in the North Bay had a wider and more southerly breeding distribution from the British Columbia coast to northwestern Washington, whereas South Bay thrushes migrated to southeastern Alaska and the British Columbia coast. In general, North Bay thrushes departed wintering grounds and arrived on breeding grounds earlier than South Bay thrushes, but we cannot eliminate sex as a factor in these differences. Regional morphology differed only in bill length. Intraspecific isolation in glacial refugia during the Late Pleistocene may explain these fine-scale geographic variations in migration patterns and morphology.


[1] Webster M.S., Marra P.P., Haig S.M., Bensch S., Holmes R.T., Links between worlds: unraveling migratory connectivity, Trends Ecol. Evol., 2002, 17, 76–83 10.1016/S0169-5347(01)02380-1Search in Google Scholar

[2] Boulet M., Norris D.R., Introduction: the past and present of migratory connectivity, Ornithol. Monogr., 2006, 61, 1–13 10.2307/40166835Search in Google Scholar

[3] Webster M.S., Marra P.P., in:, Greenberg R, Marra P.P. (Eds.), Birds of Two Worlds: The Ecology and Evolution of Migration, Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, 2005 Search in Google Scholar

[4] Calvert A.M., Walde S.J., Taylor P.D., Nonbreeding-season drivers of population dynamics in seasonal migrants: conservation parallels across taxa, Avian Conserv. Ecol., 2009, 10.5751/ACE-00335-040205Search in Google Scholar

[5] Ruegg K.C., Smith T.B., Not as the crow flies: a historical explanation for circuitous migration in Swainson’s Thrush (Catharus ustulatus), Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B Biol. Sci., 2002, 269, 1375–1381 10.1098/rspb.2002.2032Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[6] Voelker G., Bowie R.C.K., Klicka J., Gene trees, species trees and Earth history combine to shed light on the evolution of migration in a model avian system, Mol. Ecol., 2013, 22, 3333–3344 10.1111/mec.12305Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[7] Alvarado A.H., Fuller T.L., Smith T.B., Integrative tracking methods elucidate the evolutionary dynamics of a migratory divide, Ecol. Evol., 2014, 4, 3456–3469 10.1002/ece3.1205Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[8] Faaborg J., Holmes R.T., Anders A.D., Bildstein K.L., Dugger K. M., Gauthreux, Jr. S. S., et al., Conserving migratory land birds in the New World: do we know enough?, Ecol. Appl., 2010, 20, 398–418 10.1890/09-0397.1Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[9] Bearhop S., Fiedler W., Furness R.W., Votier S.C., Waldron S., Newton J., et al., Assortative mating as a mechanism for rapid evolution of a migratory divide, Science, 2005, 310, 502–504 10.1126/science.1115661Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[10] Berthold P., Helbig A.J., Mohr G., Querner U., Rapid microevolution of migratory behaviour in a wild bird species, Nature, 1992, 360, 668–670 10.1038/360668a0Search in Google Scholar

[11] Jones J., Norris D.R., Girvan M.K., Barg J.J., Kyser T.K., Robertson R.R., Migratory connectivity and rate of population decline in a vulnerable songbird, Condor, 2008, 110, 538–544 10.1525/cond.2008.8563Search in Google Scholar

[12] Phillips A.R., The Known Birds of North and Middle America: Part II, Allan R. Phillips, Denver, 1991 Search in Google Scholar

[13] Pyle P., Identification Guide to North American Birds: Part 1, Slate Creek Press, Bolinas, 1997 Search in Google Scholar

[14] Dellinger R., Wood P.B., Jones P.W., Donovan T.M., Hermit Thrush (Catharus guttatus), Birds North Am. Online, 2012, 10.2173/bna.herthr.02Search in Google Scholar

[15] Aldrich J.W., Population characteristics and nomenclature of the Hermit Thrush, Proc. United States Natl. Museum, Smithson. Inst., 1968, 124, 1–33 10.5479/si.00963801.124-3637.1Search in Google Scholar

[16] Dickerman R.W., Parkes K.C., in:, The Era of Allan R. Phillips: A Festschrift, Horizon Communications Publishers, Albequerque, 1997 Search in Google Scholar

[17] Osgood W.H., New subspecies of North American birds, Auk, 1901, 18, 179–185 10.2307/4069505Search in Google Scholar

[18] Warner B.G., Mathewes R.W., Clague J.J., Ice-free conditions on the Queen Charlotte Islands, British Columbia, at the height of late Wisconsin glaciation, Science, 1982, 218, 675–677 10.1126/science.218.4573.675Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[19] Greenberg R., Danner R., Olsen B., Luther D., High summer temperature explains bill size variation in salt marsh sparrows, Ecography (Cop.)., 2012, 35, 146–152 10.1111/j.1600-0587.2011.07002.xSearch in Google Scholar

[20] Phillips A., Marshall J., Monson G., The Birds of Arizona, The University of Arizona Press, Tucson, 1964 Search in Google Scholar

[21] Storer R.W., Subspecies and the study of geographic variation, Auk, 1982, 99, 599–601 10.2307/4086035Search in Google Scholar

[22] Berthold P., Bird Migration: A General Survey, 2nd ed., Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993 Search in Google Scholar

[23] McCabe T.T., McCabe E.B., Preliminary studies of western Hermit Thrushes, Condor, 1932, 34, 26–40 10.2307/1363789Search in Google Scholar

[24] McCabe T.T., McCabe E.B., From field and study: Hermit Thrushes of northwestern states, Condor, 1933, 35, 122–123 10.2307/1363610Search in Google Scholar

[25] Clement P., Thrushes, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2000 Search in Google Scholar

[26] Stutchbury B.J.M., Tarof S.A., Done T., Gow E., Kramer P.M., Tautin J, et al., Tracking long-distance songbird migration by using geolocators, Science, 2009, 323, 896 10.1126/science.1166664Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[27] Bairlein F., Norris D.R., Nagel R., Bulte M., Voigt C.C., Fox J.W., et al., Cross-hemisphere migration of a 25g songbird, Biol. Lett., 2012, 8, 505–507 10.1098/rsbl.2011.1223Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[28] Stach R., Jakobsson S., Kullberg C., Fransson T., Geolocators reveal three consecutive wintering areas in the thrush nightingale, Anim. Migr., 2013, 1, 1–7 10.2478/ami-2012-0001Search in Google Scholar

[29] Rundel C.W., Wunder M.B., Alvarado A.H., Ruegg K.C., Harrigan R., Schuh A., et al., Novel statistical methods for integrating genetic and stable isotope data to infer individual-level migratory connectivity, Mol. Ecol., 2013, 22, 4163–4176 10.1111/mec.12393Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[30] Hobson K.A., Van Wilgenburg S.L., Faaborg J., Toms J.D., Rengifo C., Sosa A. L., et al., Connecting breeding and wintering grounds of Neotropical migrant songbirds using stable hydrogen isotopes: a call for an isotopic atlas of migratory connectivity, J. Field Ornithol., 2014, 85, 237–257 10.1111/jofo.12065Search in Google Scholar

[31] Porzig E.L., Seavy N.E., Gardali T., Geupel G.R., Holyoak M., Eadie J. M., Habitat suitability through time: using time series and habitat models to understand changes in bird density, Ecosphere, 2014, 5, 1–16 10.1890/ES13-00166.1Search in Google Scholar

[32] Samuels I.A., Gardali T., Humple D.L., Geupel G.R., Winter site fidelity and body condition of three riparian songbird species following a fire, West. N. Am. Nat., 2005, 65, 45–52 Search in Google Scholar

[33] Jaramillo A., Hudson S.E., Strong C.M., Coyote Creek Field Station Ten-Year Report, 1987-1996, San Francisco Bay Bird Observatory, Milpitas, 2003 Search in Google Scholar

[34] Ralph C.J., Geupel G.R., Pyle P., Martin T.E., Desante D.F., Handbook of Field Methods for Monitoring Landbirds, USDA Forest Service, Berkeley, 1993 10.2737/PSW-GTR-144Search in Google Scholar

[35] Lockwood R., Swaddle J.P., Rayner J.M.V, Avian wingtip shape reconsidered: wingtip shape indices and morphological adaptations to migration, J. Avian Biol., 1998, 29, 273–292 10.2307/3677110Search in Google Scholar

[36] Owen J.C., Collecting, processing, and storing avian blood: a review, J. Field Ornithol., 2011, 82, 339–354 10.1111/j.1557-9263.2011.00338.xSearch in Google Scholar

[37] Griffiths R., Double M.C., Orr K., Dawson R.J.G., A DNA test to sex most birds, Mol. Ecol., 1998, 7, 1071–1075 10.1046/j.1365-294x.1998.00389.xSearch in Google Scholar PubMed

[38] Lisovski S., Hahn S., GeoLight - processing and analysing light-based geolocator data in R, Methods Ecol. Evol., 2012, 3, 1055–1059 10.1111/j.2041-210X.2012.00248.xSearch in Google Scholar

[39] Hill R.D., Braun M.J., In:, Sibert JR, Nielsen JL (Eds.), Electronic Tagging and Tracking in Marine Fisheries: Proceedings of the Symposium on Tagging and Tracking Marine Fish with Electronic Devices (7 - 11 Febr. 2000, Honolulu, Hawaii), University of Hawaii, Springer Netherlands, 2001, 315–330 Search in Google Scholar

[40] Worton B.J., Kernel methods for estimating the utilization distribution in home-range studies, Ecology, 1989, 70, 164–168 10.2307/1938423Search in Google Scholar

[41] Fudickar A.M., Wikelski M., Partecke J., Tracking migratory songbirds: accuracy of light-level loggers (geolocators) in forest habitats, Methods Ecol. Evol., 2012, 3, 47–52 10.1111/j.2041-210X.2011.00136.xSearch in Google Scholar

[42] Ambrosini R., Møller A.P., Saino N., A quantitative measure of migratory connectivity, J. Theor. Biol., 2009, 257, 203–211 10.1016/j.jtbi.2008.11.019Search in Google Scholar

[43] Rodríguez-Ruiz J., de la Puente J., Parejo D., Valera F., Calero-Torralbo M.A., Reyes-González J.M., et al., Disentangling migratory routes and wintering grounds of Iberian near-threatened European Rollers Coracias garrulus, PLoS One, 2014, journal.pone.0115615 10.1371/journal.pone.0115615Search in Google Scholar

[44] Bell C.P., Leap-frog migration in the Fox Sparrow: minimizing the cost of spring migration, Condor, 1997, 99, 470–477 10.2307/1369953Search in Google Scholar

[45] Kelly J.F., Ruegg K.C., Smith T.B., Combining isotopic and genetic markers to identify breeding origins of migrant birds, Ecol. Appl., 2005, 15, 1487–1494 10.1890/04-1704Search in Google Scholar

[46] Hallworth M.T., Marra P.P., Miniaturized GPS tags identify non-breeding territories of a small breeding migratory songbird, Sci. Rep., 2015, 5 10.1038/srep11069Search in Google Scholar

[47] Baldwin M.W., Winkler H., Organ C.L., Helm B., Wing pointedness associated with migratory distance in commongarden and comparative studies of stonechats (Saxicola torquata), J. Evol. Biol., 2010, 23, 1050-1056 10.1111/j.1420-9101.2010.01975.xSearch in Google Scholar

[48] Yong W., Moore F.R.., Flight, morphology, energetic condition, and the stopover biology of migrating thrushes, Auk, 1994, 111, 683–692 Search in Google Scholar

[49] Ketterson E.D., Nolan Jr. V., Geographic variation and its climatic correlates in the sex ratio of eastern-wintering Dark-eyed Juncos (Junco hyemalis hyemalis), Ecology, 1976, 57, 679–693 10.2307/1936182Search in Google Scholar

[50] Cristol D.A., Baker M.B., Carbone C., In: Nolan, Jr. V., Ketterson E.D., Thompson C. (Eds.), Current Ornithology, Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York, 1999, 33-88 10.1007/978-1-4757-4901-4_2Search in Google Scholar

[51] Stouffer P.C., Dwyer G.M., Sex-biased winter distribution and timing of migration of Hermit Thrushes (Catharus guttatus) in eastern North America, Auk, 2003, 120, 836–847 10.1642/0004-8038(2003)120[0836:SWDATO]2.0.CO;2Search in Google Scholar

[52] Bowlin M.S., Sex, wingtip shape, and wing-loading predict arrival date at a stopover site in the Swainson’s Thrush (Catharus ustulatus), Auk, 2007, 124, 1388–1396 10.1093/auk/124.4.1388Search in Google Scholar

[53] Delmore K.E., Fox J.W., Irwin, D.E., Dramatic intraspecific differences in migratory routes, stopover sites and wintering areas, revealed using light-level geolocators, Proc. Biol. Sci., 2012, 279, 4582–4589 10.1098/rspb.2012.1229Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[54] Delmore K.E., Irwin D.E., Hybrid songbirds employ intermediate routes in a migratory divide, Ecol. Lett., 2014, 17, 1211–1218 10.1111/ele.12326Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[55] Cormier R.L., Humple D.L., Gardali T., Seavy N.E., Light-level geolocators reveal strong migratory connectivity and withinwinter movements for a coastal California Swainson’s Thrush (Catharus ustulatus) population, Auk, 2013, 130, 283–290 10.1525/auk.2013.12228Search in Google Scholar

[56] Ruegg K.C., Hijmans R.J., Moritz C., Climate change and the origin of migratory pathways in the Swainson’s thrush, Catharus ustulatus, J. Biogeogr., 2006, 33, 1172–1182 10.1111/j.1365-2699.2006.01517.xSearch in Google Scholar

[57] Carrara P.E., Ager T.A., Baichtal J.F., Possible refugia in the Alexander Archipelago of southeastern Alaska during the late Wisconsin glaciation, Can. J. Earth Sci., 2007, 44, 229–244 10.1139/e06-081Search in Google Scholar

[58] Shafer A.B.A., Cullingham C.I., Côté S.D., Coltman D.W., Of glaciers and refugia: a decade of study sheds new light on the phylogeography of northwestern North America. Mol. Ecol., 2010, 19, 4589–4621 10.1111/j.1365-294X.2010.04828.xSearch in Google Scholar PubMed

[59] Swarth H.S., Origins of the fauna of the Sitkan District, Alaska, Proc. Calif. Acad. Sci., 1936, 23, 66–71 Search in Google Scholar

[60] Cook J.A., Dawson N.G., MacDonald S.O., Conservation of highly fragmented systems: the north temperate Alexander Archipelago, Biol. Conserv., 2006, 133, 1–15 10.1016/j.biocon.2006.05.026Search in Google Scholar

[61] Topp C.M., Winker K., Genetic patterns of differentiation among five landbird species from the Queen Charlotte Islands, British Columbia, Auk, 2008, 125, 461–472 10.1525/auk.2008.06254Search in Google Scholar

[62] Atwater B.F., Hedel C.W., Helley E.J., Late Quaternary depositional history, Holocene sea-level changes, and vertical crustal movement, southern San Francisco Bay, California, U.S.G.S. Professional Paper, 1977, 1014, 1–15 10.3133/pp1014Search in Google Scholar

[63] Sillett T.S., Holmes R.T., Variation in survivorship of a migratory songbird throughout its annual cycle, J. Anim. Ecol., 2002, 71, 296–308 10.1046/j.1365-2656.2002.00599.xSearch in Google Scholar

[64] Weir J.T., Schluter D., Ice sheets promote speciation in boreal birds, Proc. Biol. Sci., 2004, 271, 1881–1887 10.1098/rspb.2004.2803Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[65] Outlaw D.C., Voelker G., Mila B., Girman D.J., Evolution of long-distance migration in and historical biogeography of Catharus thrushes: a molecular phylogenetic approach, Auk, 2003, 120, 299–310 10.1093/auk/120.2.299Search in Google Scholar

[66] Winker K., Pruett C.L., Seasonal migration, speciation, and morphological convergence in the genus Catharus (Turdidae), Auk, 2006, 123, 1052-1068 10.1093/auk/123.4.1052Search in Google Scholar

[67] Delmore K.E., Kenyon H.L., Germain R.R., Irwin D.E., Phenotypic divergence during speciation is inversely associated with differences in seasonal migration, Proc. R. Soc. B. Biol. Sci., 2015, 282, 20151921 10.1098/rspb.2015.1921Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[68] Ruegg K., Anderson E.C., Boone J., Pouls J., Smith T.B., A role for migration-linked genes and genomic islands in divergence of a songbird, Mol. Ecol., 2014, 23, 4757–4769 10.1111/mec.12842Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[69] Delmore K.E., Hübner S., Kane N.C., Schuster R., Andrew R.L., Câmara F., et al., Genomic analysis of a migratory divide reveals candidate genes for migration and implicates selective sweeps in generating islands of differentiation, Mol. Ecol., 2015, 24, 1873–1888 10.1111/mec.13150Search in Google Scholar PubMed

[70] Topp C.M., Pruett C.L., McCracken K.G., Winker K., How migratory thrushes conquered northern North America: a comparative phylogeography approach, PeerJ, 2013, https:// 10.7717/peerj.206Search in Google Scholar PubMed PubMed Central

[71] Norris R.D., Marra P.P., Seasonal interactions, habitat quality, and population dynamics in migratory birds, Condor, 2007, 109, 535–547 10.1093/condor/109.3.535Search in Google Scholar

[72] Sauer J.R., Hines J.E., Fallon J.E., Pardieck K.L., Ziolkowski, Jr. D. J., Link W.A., The North American Breeding Bird Survey, Results and Analysis 1966 - 2013, Version 01.30.2015, USGS Patuxent Wildl. Res. Cent., 2015 Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2015-9-9
Accepted: 2016-1-19
Published Online: 2016-2-4

© 2016 Allison R. Nelson et al.

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 3.0 License.

Downloaded on 23.3.2023 from
Scroll Up Arrow