Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter (A) November 29, 2016

Sumerograms and Akkadograms in Hittite: Ideograms, Logograms, Allograms, or Heterograms?

Maksim Kudrinski and Ilya Yakubovich

Abstract

The goal of this paper is to compare various designations that have been offered for the Sumerian and Akkadian elements that occur in Hittite written texts but were presumably absent from the spoken Hittite language. We suggest that the most appropriate cover term in this case is heterogram, which represents the established designation for Aramaeograms in Middle Iranian texts, whereas the other terms offered thus far are either descriptively inadequate or evoke false associations. With regard to the function of heterograms in Hittite texts, it is concluded that they were not systematically used as markers of the elevated style but sometimes could serve for the expression of semantic distinctions that had no counterpart in colloquial Hittite.

Acknowledgements

Many ideas of this paper were first presented in our joint talk at the Rencontre Assyriologique Internationale 2015 in Bern. We are grateful to the audience of this gathering for its constructive feedback, and also much obliged to Stephen Durnford (Brighton), Joost Hazenbos (Amsterdam / Leipzig / Munich), H. Craig Melchert (Chapel Hill, NC), and Mark Weeden (London), who took pains to correct the style of the present paper and made further valuable remarks on its substance. The research of Ilya Yakubovich was conducted within the framework of the project “Digitales philologisch-etymologisches Wörterbuch der altanatolischen Kleinkorpussprachen (RI 1730/7-1)” funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.

References

Archi, A. (2010): When did the Hittites Begin to Write in Hittite? In: Y. Cohen et al. (ed.), Pax Hethitica: Studies on the Hittites and their Neighbours in Honour of Itamar Singer (StBoT 51), Wiesbaden, 37–46. Search in Google Scholar

Bailey, H.W. (1943): Caucasica, JRAS 75 (1/2), 1–5. Search in Google Scholar

Crisostomo, C.J. (2015): Language, Writing, and Ideologies in Contact: Sumerian and Akkadian in the Early Second Millennium BCE. In: A.M. Butts (ed.), Semitic Languages in Contact (Studies in Semitic Languages and Linguistics 82), Leiden, 158–180. Search in Google Scholar

Diakonoff, I.M. (1967): Jazyki drevnej perednej Azii, Moscow. Search in Google Scholar

Emiliano, A. (2011): Issues in the Typographic Representation of Medieval Primary Sources. In: Y. Kawaguchi et al. (ed.), Corpus-based Analysis in Diachronic Linguistics, Amsterdam, 153–173. Search in Google Scholar

Ferguson, C.A. (1959): Diglossia, Word 15, 325–340. Search in Google Scholar

Fishman, J. (1967): Bilingualism With and Without Diglossia; Diglossia With and Without Bilingualism, Journal of Social Studies 23/2, 29–38. Search in Google Scholar

Friedrich, J. (1940): Hethitisches Elementarbuch. 1. Teil: Kurzgefaßte Grammatik (1st ed.), Heidelberg. Search in Google Scholar

Friedrich, J. / A. Kammenhuber / I. Hoffmann (ed.) (1975–): Hethitisches Wörterbuch (2nd ed.), Heidelberg. Search in Google Scholar

Gelb, I.J. (1963): A Study of Writing (revised ed.), Chicago. Search in Google Scholar

Gerschevitch, I. (1979): The Alloglottography of Old Persian, Transactions of Philological Society 1979, 114–190. Search in Google Scholar

Giusfredi, F. (2012): The Akkadian Medical Text KUB 37.1, AoF 39, 49–63. Search in Google Scholar

Goetze, A. (1928): Madduwattaš (MVAeG 32/1), Leipzig. Search in Google Scholar

Goetze, A. (1933): Die Annalen der Muršiliš (MVAeG 38), Leipzig. Search in Google Scholar

Guy, G.R. (1990): The Sociolinguistic Types of Language Change, Diachronica 7/1, 47–67. Search in Google Scholar

Hawkins, J.D. (1995): The Hieroglyphic Inscription of the Sacred Pool Complex at Hattusa (SÜDBURG) (StBoT Beih. 3), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Henkelman, W.F.M. (2011): Cyrus the Elamite and Darius the Persian: A Case of Mistaken Identity. In: R. Rollinger et al. (ed.), Herodot und das Persische Weltreich – Herodotus and the Persian Empire: Akten des 3. Internationalen Kolloquiums zum Thema „Vorderasien im Spannungsfeld klassischer und altorientalischer Überlieferungen“, Innsbruck, 24.–28. November 2008 (Classica et Orientalia 3), Wiesbaden, 577–634. Search in Google Scholar

Hoffner, H.A. (1997): The Laws of the Hittites: A Critical Edition (DMOA 23), Leiden. Search in Google Scholar

Hoffner, H.A. / H.C. Melchert (2008): A Grammar of the Hittite Language. Part 1: Reference Grammar, Winona Lake, Indiana. Search in Google Scholar

Holland, G.B. / M. Zorman (2007): The Tale of Zalpa: Myth, Morality and Coherence in a Hittite Narrative (Studia Mediterranea 19), Pavia. Search in Google Scholar

Hrozný, F. (1917): Die Sprache der Hethiter (BoSt. 1–2), Leipzig. Search in Google Scholar

Jarceva, V.N. (ed.). (1990): Lingvisticheskij enciklopedicheskij slovar’, Moscow. Search in Google Scholar

Johanson, L. (2013): Written Language Intertwining. In: P. Bakker / Y. Matras (ed.), Contact Languages: A Comprehensive Guide (Language Contact and Bilingualism 6), Berlin, 273–331. Search in Google Scholar

Kloekhorst, A. (2008): Etymological Dictionary of the Hittite Inherited Lexicon, Leiden. Search in Google Scholar

Košak, S. (1982): Hittite Inventory Texts (THeth. 10), Heidelberg. Search in Google Scholar

Kudrinski, M. (forthcoming): Hittite Heterographic Writings and Their Interpretation: The Evidence of Sentential Clitics, IF. Search in Google Scholar

Laroche E. (1978): Problèmes de l’écriture cunéiforme hittite, Annali della Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa. Classe di Lettere e Filosofia, Serie III, 8, 3, 739–753. Search in Google Scholar

Langslow, D.R. (2002): Approaching Bilingualism in Corpus Languages. In: J.N. Adams et al. (ed.), Bilingualism in Ancient Society: Language Contact and the Written Text, New York, 23–51. Search in Google Scholar

Miller, J. (2013): Royal Hittite Instructions and Related Administrative Texts (SBL WAW 31), Atlanta. Search in Google Scholar

Neu, E. (1980): Althethitische Ritualtexte in Umschrift (StBoT 25), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Otten, H, (1981): Die Apologie Hattušiliš III: Das Bild der Überlieferung (StBoT 24), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Patri, S. (2007): L’alignement syntaxique dans les langues indo-européennes d’Anatolie (StBoT 49), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Popko, M. (2007): Althethitisch? Zu den Datierungsfragen in der Hethitologie. In: D. Groddek / M. Zorman (ed.), Tabularia Hethaeorum: Hethitologische Beiträge Silbin Košak zum 65. Geburtstag (DBH 25), Wiesbaden, 575–581. Search in Google Scholar

Rieken, E. (2006): Zum hethitisch-luwischen Sprachkontakt in historischer Zeit, AoF 33, 271–285. Search in Google Scholar

Ross, M.D. (1991): Refining Guy’s Sociolinguistic Types of Language Change, Diachronica 8/1, 119–129. Search in Google Scholar

Rubio, G. (2007): Writing in Another Tongue: Alloglottography in the Ancient Near East. In: S.L. Sanders (ed.), Margins of Writing, Origins of Cultures (OIS 2) (2nd printing), Chicago, 33–70. Search in Google Scholar

Rüstel, C. / G. Wilhelm (2012): Landschenkungsurkunden hethitischer Könige (StBoT Beih. 4), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Skjaervø, P.O. (1995): Aramaic in Iran, Aram 7, 283–318. Search in Google Scholar

Starke, F. (1977): Die Funktionen der dimensionalen Kasus und Adverbien im Althethitischen (StBoT 23), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Starke, F. (1985): Die keilschrift-luwischen Texte in Umschrift (StBoT 30), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Stolper, M.W. / J. Tavernier (2007): An Old Persian Administrative Tablet from the Persepolis Fortification, Arta 2007.001. Search in Google Scholar

Testen, D. (2012): Ideographic Writing, Encyclopedia Iranica. Last updated 27.03.2012. http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/ideographic-writing. Search in Google Scholar

Thomason, S.G. (2001): Language Contact: An Introduction, Edinburgh – Washington, DC. Search in Google Scholar

van den Hout, T. (1998): The Purity of Kingship: An Edition of CTH 569 and Related Hittite Oracle Inquiries of Tutḫaliya IV (DMOA 25), Leiden. Search in Google Scholar

van den Hout, T. (2007): Institutions, Vernaculars, Publics: The Case of Second-Millennium Anatolia. In: S.L. Sanders (ed.), Margins of Writing, Origins of Cultures (OIS 2) (2nd printing), Chicago, 221–262. Search in Google Scholar

van den Hout, T. (2009): Reflections on the Origin and Development of the Hittite Tablet Collections in Hattuša and Their Consequences for the Rise of Hittite Literacy. In: F. Peccholi-Daddi et al. (ed.), Central-North Anatolia in the Hittite Period: New Perspectives in the Light of Recent Research. Actes of the International Conference Held at the University of Florence (7–9 February 2007) (Studia Asiana 5), Rome, 71–96. Search in Google Scholar

von Soden, W. (1995): Grundriß der akkadischen Grammatik (3rd ed.). In collaboration with W.R. Mayer (AnOr. 33), Rome. Search in Google Scholar

Waal, W. (2011): They Wrote on Wood: The Case for a Hieroglyphic Scribal Tradition on Wooden Writing Boards in Hittite Anatolia, AnSt. 61, 21–34. Search in Google Scholar

Weeden, M. (2011): Hittite Logograms and Hittite Scholarship (StBoT 54), Wiesbaden. Search in Google Scholar

Yakubovich, I. (2006): Free-standing Genitive and Hypostasis in Hittite, JNES 65/1, 39–49. Search in Google Scholar

Yakubovich, I. (2008a): Hittite-Luwian Bilingualism and the Origin of Anatolian Hieroglyphs, Acta Linguistica Petropolitana 4, 9–26. Search in Google Scholar

Yakubovich, I. (2008b): Review of S.L. Sanders (ed.), Margins of Writing, Origins of Cultures (OIS 2), JIES 36, 202–211. Search in Google Scholar

Yakubovich, I. (2010): Sociolinguistics of the Luvian Language, Leiden. Search in Google Scholar

Yakubovich, I. (2012): Review of Patri (2007), JNES 71/2, 390–392. Search in Google Scholar

Zorman, M. (2010): Über die Gründe für die Verwendung von Glossenkeilen im Hethitischen. In: A. Süel (ed.), Acts of the VIIth International Congress of Hittitology, Çorum, August 25–31, 2008, Ankara, 1029–1038. Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2016-11-29
Published in Print: 2016-12-1

© 2016 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston