Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter Mouton March 3, 2018

A comparison of the effects of extensive and intensive reading approaches on the vocabulary development of Korean secondary EFL learners

A Young Park, Talia Isaacs and Helen Woodfield

Abstract

Although language experts have long advocated the use of Extensive Reading (ER) to enhance vocabulary acquisition, the widespread use of the more traditional Intensive Reading (IR) approach prevails in English as Foreign Language (EFL) settings. Many experimental studies have attempted to demonstrate the benefits of using ER over IR in classroom contexts; however, none have demonstrated significant differences in learning gains. This quasi-experimental study involved the measurement of partial vocabulary knowledge of specific words encountered through reading to compare the effects of ER and conventional IR instruction on EFL learners’ vocabulary knowledge development. Two intact classes of 72 Korean secondary students (36/class) received either ER or IR instructional treatments over a 12-week timespan, with pre- and post- performance differences examined by proficiency level. ANCOVA results showed that students benefited significantly more from the ER than from the IR treatment in terms of their knowledge of the meanings and uses of target words. With regard to proficiency, advanced and intermediate level learners benefited more from ER, while low level learners benefited more from IR. These findings suggest that EFL practitioners should carefully consider their learners’ proficiency level when selecting a reading approach, in order to optimize learners’ vocabulary development.

References

Alavinia, P. & S. Farhady. 2012. Using differentiated instruction to teach vocabulary in mixed ability classes with a focus on multiple intelligences and learning styles. International Journal of Applied Science and Technology 2(4). 72–82. Search in Google Scholar

Al-Homoud, F. & N. Schmitt. 2009. Extensive reading in a challenging environment: A comparison of extensive and intensive reading approaches in Saudi Arabia. Language Teaching Research 13(4). 383–401. 10.1177/1362168809341508 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Bruton, A. 2009. The vocabulary knowledge scale: A critical analysis. Language Assessment Quarterly 6(4). 288–297. 10.1080/15434300902801909 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Cha, J. E. 2009. The effects of extensive reading on enhancing vocational high school students’ L2 vocabulary and reading rates. English Teaching 64(3). 3–30. 10.15858/engtea.64.3.200909.3 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Coady, J. 1997. L2 vocabulary acquisition through extensive reading. In J. Coady & T. Huckin (eds.), Second language vocabulary acquisition: A rationale for pedagogy, 225–237. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Cobb, T. (2004). The compleat lexical tutor. Retrieved from http://www.lextutor.ca/ Search in Google Scholar

Coxhead, A. 2000. A new academic word list. TESOL Quarterly 34(2). 213–238. 10.2307/3587951 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Daller, M. & D. Phelan. 2013. Predicting international student study success. Applied Linguistics Review 4(1). 173–193. Search in Google Scholar

Daller, M. & W. Yixin. 2016. Predicting study success of international students. Applied Linguistics Reviewhttps://doi.org (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Day, R. & N. Prentice. 2016. Extensive reading into the classroom. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Eckerth, J. & P. Tavakoli. 2012. The effects of word exposure frequency and elaboration of word processing on incidental L2 vocabulary acquisition through reading. Language Teaching Research 16(2). 227–252. 10.1177/1362168811431377 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Elgort, I. & P. Warren. 2014. L2 vocabulary learning from reading: Explicit and tacit lexical knowledge and the role of learner and item variables. Language Learning 64(2). 365–414. 10.1111/lang.12052 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Glew, P. J. 2013. Embedding international benchmarks of proficiency in English in undergraduate nursing programs: Challenges and strategies in equipping culturally and linguistically diverse students with English as an additional language for nursing in Australia. Collegian 20(2). 101–108. 10.1016/j.colegn.2012.04.002 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Grabe, W. 2009. Reading in a second language: Moving from theory to practice. New York: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Grabe, W. & F. L. Stoller. 2009. Teaching and researching: Reading. London: Routledge. Search in Google Scholar

Haahr, M. & S. Haahr (2010). List randomizer (Version 0.1) [Computer Software]. Dublin: Randomness and Integrity Services Ltd Retrieved from http://www.random.org./lists/ Search in Google Scholar

Horst, M. 2005. Learning L2 vocabulary through extensive reading: A measurement study. Canadian Modern Language Review 61(3). 355–382. 10.3138/cmlr.61.3.355 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Hudson, T. 2007. Teaching second language reading. New York: Oxford University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Huffman, J. 2014. Reading rate gains during a one-semester extensive reading course. Reading in a Foreign Language 26(2). 17–33. Search in Google Scholar

Hulstijn, J. H. 1992. Retention of inferred and given word meanings: Experiments in incidental vocabulary leaning. In P. J. Amaud & H. Bejoint (eds.), Vocabulary and applied linguistics, 113–125. London: Macmillan. Search in Google Scholar

Ireson, J. & S. Hallam. 2001. Ability grouping in education. London: Sage. Search in Google Scholar

Jacobs, G. M. & T. S. Farrell. 2012. Teachers’ Sourcebook for Extensive Reading. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing. Search in Google Scholar

Kim, I. 2010. Finalizing English reading I. Seoul. South Korea: Pung-ga Kyo-yook. Search in Google Scholar

Kim, Y. 2008. The contribution of collaborative and individual tasks to the acquisition of L2 vocabulary. The Modern Language Journal 92(1). 114–130. 10.1111/j.1540-4781.2008.00690.x (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Kweon, S.-O. & H.-R. Kim. 2008. Beyond raw frequency: Incidental vocabulary acquisition in extensive reading. Reading in a Foreign Language 20(2). 191–215. Search in Google Scholar

Laufer, B. & G.C. Ravenhorst-Kalovski. 2010. Lexical threshold revisited: Lexical text coverage, learners’ vocabulary size and reading comprehension. Reading in a Foreign Language 22(1). 15–30. Search in Google Scholar

Lee, J. & D. L. Schallert. 1997. The relative contribution of L2 language proficiency and L1 reading ability to L2 reading performance: A test of the threshold hypothesis in an EFL context. TESOL Quarterly 31(4). 713–739. 10.2307/3587757 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Millett, S., E. Quinn & P. Nation. 2007. Asian and Pacific speed readings for ESL learners. Wellington: English Language Institute Occasional Publication. Search in Google Scholar

Milton, J. 2013. Measuring the contribution of vocabulary knowledge to proficiency in the four skills. In C. Bardel, C. Lindqvist & B. Laufer (eds.), L2 vocabulary acquisition, knowledge and use: New perspectives on assessment and corpus analysis, 57–78. Modena, Italy: European Second Language Association. Search in Google Scholar

Nakanishi, T. 2015. A meta‐analysis of extensive reading research. TESOL Quarterly 49(1). 6–37.10.1002/tesq.157 Search in Google Scholar

Nation, P. 2013. What should every ESL teacher know?. Seoul: Compass Publishing. Search in Google Scholar

Nation, P. 2015. Principles guiding vocabulary learning through extensive reading. Reading in a Foreign Language 27(1). 136–145. Search in Google Scholar

Nation, P. & A. Heatley. 1996. Vocabprofile, word and range: Programs for processing text. Wellington, New Zealand: LALS. Search in Google Scholar

Negi, J. S. (2010). Teaching English to multilevel EFL learners in a large classroom: A pedagogical discussion. Paper presented at the NELTA Conference, Nepal. Search in Google Scholar

Paribakht, T. S. & M. Wesche. 1997. Vocabulary enhancement activities and reading for meaning in second language vocabulary acquisition. In J. Coady & T. Huckin (eds.), Second language vocabulary acquisition: A rationale for pedagogy, 174–200. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Park, A Young. 2017. A comparison of the impact of extensive and intensive reading approaches on the Korean EFL learners’ reading rate and reading comprehension development. International Journal of Applied Linguistics & English Literature 6(3). 131–142. Search in Google Scholar

Pigada, M. & N. Schmitt. 2006. Vocabulary acquisition from extensive reading: A case study. Reading in a Foreign Language 18(1). 1–28. Search in Google Scholar

Rashidi, N. & M. Piran. 2011. The effect of extensive and intensive reading on Iranian EFL learners’ vocabulary size and depth. Journal of Language Teaching and Research 2(2). 471–482. 10.4304/jltr.2.2.471-482 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Read, J. 1993. The development of a new measure of L2 vocabulary knowledge. Language Testing 10(3). 355–371. 10.1177/026553229301000308 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Read, J. 2000. Assessing vocabulary. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Renandya, W. A. & T. S. C. Farrell. 2011. “Teacher, the tape is too fast!’ extensive listening in ELT. ELT Journal 65(1). 52–59. 10.1093/elt/ccq015 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Reynolds, B. L. 2015. The effects of word form variation and frequency on second language incidental vocabulary acquisition through reading. Applied Linguistics Review 6(4). 467–497. Search in Google Scholar

Roche, T. & M. Harrington. 2013. Recognition vocabulary knowledge as a predictor of academic performance in an English as a foreign language setting. Language Testing in Asia 3(1). 1–13. Search in Google Scholar

Schmitt, N., X. Jiang & W. Grabe. 2011. The percentage of words known in a text and reading comprehension. Modern Language Journal 95(1). 26–43. 10.1111/j.1540-4781.2011.01146.x (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Senoo, Y. & K. Yonemoto. 2014. Vocabulary learning through extensive reading: A case study. Canadian Journal of Applied Linguistics 17(2). 1–22. Search in Google Scholar

Shin, D., Y. Chon & H. Kim. 2011. Receptive and productive vocabulary sizes of high school learners: What next for the basic word list. English Teaching 66(3). 123–148. 10.15858/engtea.66.3.201109.123 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Song, J. & V. G. Sardegna. 2014. EFL learners’ incidental acquisition of English prepositions through enhanced extensive reading instruction. RELC Journal 45(1). 67–84.10.1177/0033688214522623 Search in Google Scholar

Stephens, M. 2016. Response to Sakurai: The influence of translation on reading amount, proficiency and speed in extensive reading. Reading in a Foreign Language 28(1). 151. Search in Google Scholar

Tekmen, E. & A. Daloǧlu. 2006. An investigation of incidental vocabulary acquisition in relation to learner proficiency level and word frequency. Foreign Language Annals 39(2). 220–243. 10.1111/j.1944-9720.2006.tb02263.x (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Treffers-Daller, J. & J. Milton. 2013. Vocabulary size revisited: The link between vocabulary size and academic achievement. Applied Linguistics Review 4(1). 151–172. Search in Google Scholar

Vidal, K. 2011. A comparison of the effects of reading and listening on incidental vocabulary acquisition. Language Learning 61(1). 219–258.10.1111/j.1467-9922.2010.00593.x Search in Google Scholar

Waring, R. & M. Takaki. 2003. At what rate do learners learn and retain new vocabulary from reading a graded reader. Reading in a Foreign Language 15(2). 130–163. Search in Google Scholar

Webb, S. 2005. Receptive and productive vocabulary learning: The effects of reading and writing on word knowledge. Studies in Second Language Acquisition 27(1). 33–52. Search in Google Scholar

Webb, S. & A. C. Chang. 2015. Second language vocabulary learning through extensive reading with audio support: How do frequency and distribution of occurrence affect learning?. Language Teaching Research 19(6). 667–686.10.1177/1362168814559800 Search in Google Scholar

Webb, S. & J. Macalister. 2013. Is text written for children useful for L2 extensive reading?. TESOL Quarterly 47(2). 300–322. 10.1002/tesq.70 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

West, M. 1953. A general service list of English words. London: Longman. Search in Google Scholar

Yamashita, J. 2015. In search of the nature of extensive reading in L2: Cognitive, affective, and pedagogical perspectives. Reading in a Foreign Language 27(1). 168–181. Search in Google Scholar

Zahar, R., T. Cobb & N. Spada. 2001. Acquiring vocabulary through reading: Effects of frequency and contextual richness. Canadian Modern Language Review 57(4). 541–572. 10.3138/cmlr.57.4.541 (accessed 2 January 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Zhang, L. J. & S. B. Anual. 2008. The role of vocabulary in reading comprehension: The case of secondary school students learning English in Singapore. RELC Journal 39(1). 51–76.10.1177/0033688208091140 Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2018-3-3
Published in Print: 2018-3-26

© 2018 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston