Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter December 1, 2020

Aristotle on the Soul as Harmony

Melpomeni Vogiatzi
From the journal Elenchos

Abstract

A topic common to both Plato’s and Aristotle’s discussions of theories of the soul is the doctrine of the soul as a harmony of the parts of the body. Plato’s Phaedo as well as Aristotle’s De anima and Eudemus present this theory and argue against the identification of the soul as a harmony. This paper has two focuses, one philosophical and one historical. First, I will focus on the argumentation used by Aristotle in his dialogue Eudemus, which is often associated with Aristotle’s early attachment to Plato. On the basis of the argumentation against the harmonia theory, I will try to show that the Eudemus is not a dialogue that depicts Aristotle’s Platonic phase. Instead, by comparing the arguments of the Eudemus with both Plato and Aristotle’s mature thought, I will argue that the argumentation of the Eudemus seems to be an indirect attack on Plato’s view on the Forms and on the nature of the soul, and that it seems to be consistent with Aristotle’s mature work On the Soul. Second, given that Aristotle discusses this topic twice, I will try, also on the basis of conclusions about the Eudemus and on later reception of Aristotle’s arguments, to show why this is the case.


Corresponding author: Melpomeni Vogiatzi, Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München, Munich, Germany, E-mail:

Acknowledgments

I would like to thank Munich School of Ancient Philosophy, especially Prof. Peter Adamson and Prof. Christof Rapp for their suggestions and support. I am also indepted to Dr. Bethany Somma for their feedback.

References

Baltussen, H. 2015. “Strato of Lampsacus as a Reader of Plato’s Phaedo: His Critique of the Soul’s Immortality.” In Ancient Readings of Plato’s Phaedo, edited by S. Delcomminette, P. d’Hoine, and M. Gavray, 37–62. Leiden: Brill.10.1163/9789004289543_004Search in Google Scholar

Baltussen, H. 2016. The Peripatetics: Aristotle’s Heirs 322 BCE–200 CE. New York: Routledge.10.4324/9781315719092Search in Google Scholar

Barnes, J., ed. 1995. The Cambridge Companion to Aristotle. Cambridge: CUP.Search in Google Scholar

Bernays, J. 1863. Die Dialoge des Aristoteles in ihrem Verhältnis zu seinem übrigen Werken. Berlin: W. Hertz.Search in Google Scholar

Betegh, G. 2020. “Thinking with Empedocles: Aristotle on Soul as Harmonia.” Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 59 (forthcoming).10.1093/oso/9780198859000.003.0001Search in Google Scholar

Bonitz, H. 1873. “Zur Erklärung einiger Stellen aus Aristoteles Schrift Über die Seele.” Hermes 7: 422–8.Search in Google Scholar

Bos, A. P. 1984. “Aristotle’s Eudemus and Protrepticus: Are They Really Two Different Works?” Dionysius 8: 19–51.Search in Google Scholar

Bos, A. P. 1989. Cosmic and Meta–cosmic Theology in Aristotle’s Lost Dialogues. Leiden: Brill.10.1163/9789004246652Search in Google Scholar

Bostock, D. 1986. Plato’s Phaedo. Oxford: Clarendon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Carter, J. 2019. Aristotle on Earlier Greek Psychology. Cambridge: CUP.10.1017/9781108646321Search in Google Scholar

Caston, V. 1997. “Epiphenomenalism, Ancient and Modern.” Philosophical Review 106: 309–64, https://doi.org/10.2307/2998397.Search in Google Scholar

Charlton, W. 1985. “Aristotle and the Harmonia Theory.” In Aristotle on Nature and Living Things, edited by A. Gotthelf, 13150. Pittsburgh: Mathesis Publications.Search in Google Scholar

Chroust, A. H. 1966a. “Eudemus or on the Soul: An Aristotelian Dialogue on the Immortality of the Soul.” Mnemosyne 19 (1): 17–30, https://doi.org/10.1163/156852566x00943.Search in Google Scholar

Chroust, A. H. 1966b. “The Psychology in Aristotle’s Lost Dialogue Eudemus or On the Soul.” Acta Classica 9: 49–62.Search in Google Scholar

Chroust, A. H. 1973. Aristotle: New Light in his Life and of Some of his Lost Works, I: Some Novel Interpretations of the Man and his Life, II: Observations on Some of Aristotle’s Lost Works. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Delcomminette, S., P. d’Hoine, and M. Gavray (eds.) 2015. Ancient Readings of Plato’s Phaedo. Leiden: Brill.10.1163/9789004289543Search in Google Scholar

Della Valle, G. 1905. “La teoria dell’anima–armonia di Aristosseno e l’epifenomenismo contemporaneo.” Rivista di Filosofia 8: 210–31.Search in Google Scholar

Düring, I. 1966. Aristoteles. Darstellung und Interpretation seines Denkens. Heidelberg: Universitätsverlag Winter.Search in Google Scholar

Fortenbaugh, W., and E. Schütrumpf (eds.) 2001. Dicaearchus of Messana: Text, Translation, and Discussion. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Gaiser, K. 1985. “Ein Gespräch mit König Philipp: Zum Eudemus des Aristoteles.” In Aristoteles Werk und Wirkung, P. Moraux gewidmet, I, edited by J. Wiesner, 456–84. Berlin: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110859720.457Search in Google Scholar

Gallop, D. 1975. Plato: Phaedo. Oxford: OUP.Search in Google Scholar

Gigon, O. 1960. “Prolegomena to an Edition of the Eudemus.” In Aristotle and Plato in the Mid–fourth Century, edited by I. Düring, and G. E. L. Owen, 19–73. Göteborg: Almqvist & Wiksell.Search in Google Scholar

Gigon, O. 1987. Aristotelis Opera. Volumen tertium: Librorum deperditorum Fragmanta, collegit et annotationibus instruxit. Berlin: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110826661Search in Google Scholar

Gottschalk, H. B. 1971. “Soul as Harmonia.” Phronesis 16 (2): 179–98, https://doi.org/10.1163/156852871x00124.Search in Google Scholar

Grube, G. M. A. 1997. “Phaedo.” In Plato Complete Works, edited by J. Cooper. Indianapolis, Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company.Search in Google Scholar

Guthrie, W. K. C. 1981. A History of Greek Philosophy, VI: Aristotle, An Encounter. Cambridge: CUP.10.1017/CBO9780511518447Search in Google Scholar

Hackforth, R. F. B. A. 1972. Plato’s Phaedo. Cambridge: CUP.Search in Google Scholar

Hicks, R. D. 1976 (19071). Aristotle De anima. With Translation, Introduction, and Notes. Cambridge: CUP.Search in Google Scholar

Huffmann, C. 1993. Philolaus of Croton, Pythagorean and Presocratic: A Commentary on the Fragments and Testimonia with Interpretative Essays. Cambridge: CUP.10.1017/CBO9780511597367Search in Google Scholar

Huffmann, C. 2009. “The Pythagorean Conception of the Soul from Pythagoras to Philolaus.” In Body and Soul in Ancient Philosophy, edited by D. Frede, and B. Reis. Berlin: De Gruyter.10.1515/9783110216523.1.21Search in Google Scholar

Huffmann, C. 2012. Aristoxenus of Tarentum: Texts and Discussions. New Brunswick, London: Transaction Publishers.Search in Google Scholar

Jaeger, W. 1978 (19231). Aristoteles. Grundlegung einer Geschichte seiner Entwicklung. Berlin: Weidmann.Search in Google Scholar

McKirahan, R. 2016. “Philolaus on the Soul.” In Pythagorean Knowledge from the Ancient to the Modern World, edited by A. B. Renger, and A. Stavru, 63–76. Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz Verlag.10.2307/j.ctvc770xm.8Search in Google Scholar

Moraux, P. 1960. “From the Protrepticus to the Dialogue On Justice.” In Aristotle and Plato in the Mid–fourth Century, edited by I. Düring and G. E. L. Owen, 113–32. Göteborg: Almqvist & Wiksell.Search in Google Scholar

Nuyens, F. J. 1948. L’évolution de la psychologie d’Aristote. Louvain: Éditions de l’Institut supérieur de philosophie.Search in Google Scholar

Owen, G. E. L. 1975. “Kategorien und Ideen im Eudemus.” In Frühschriften des Aristoteles, edited by P. Moraux, 270–75. Darmstadt: Wissensschaftliche Buchgesellschaft.Search in Google Scholar

Rees, D. A. 1960. “Theories of the Soul in the Early Aristotle.” In Aristotle and Plato in the Mid-fourth Century, edited by I. Düring, and G. E. L. Owen, 191–200. Göteborg: Almqvist & Wiksell.Search in Google Scholar

Repici, L. 2011. “Strato’s Aporiae in Plato’s Phaedo.” In Strato of Lampsacus: Text, Translation, and Discussion, edited by M. L. Desclos, and W. Fortenbaugh, 413–42. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Rose, V. 1886. Aristotelis qui ferebatur librorum fragmenta. Leipzig: Teubner.Search in Google Scholar

Ross, W. D. 1955. Aristotelis fragmenta selecta. Oxford: OUP.10.1093/actrade/9780198145127.book.1Search in Google Scholar

Ross, W. D. 1961. Aristotle, De anima. Edited with Introduction and Commentary. Oxford: OUP.10.1093/actrade/9780198141556.book.1Search in Google Scholar

Rowe, C. J. 1993. Plato: Phaedo. Cambridge: CUP.Search in Google Scholar

Smith, J. A. (trans.) 1984. “On the Soul.” In The Complete Works of Aristotle, edited by J. Barnes. Princeton: PUP.Search in Google Scholar

Trabattoni, F. 1988. “La dottrina dell’anima–armonia del Fedone.” Elenchos 9: 53–74.Search in Google Scholar

Trabattoni, F. 2015. “La théorie de l’âme–harmonie chez les commentateurs anciens.” In Ancient Readings of Plato’s Phaedo, edited by S. Delcomminette, P. d’Hoine, and M. Gavray, 256–69. Leiden: Brill.10.1163/9789004289543_013Search in Google Scholar

Walzer, R. 1934. Aristotelis dialogorum fragmenta selecta. Firenze: Sansoni.Search in Google Scholar

Wehrli, F. (ed.) 1967–1978. Die Schule des Aristoteles: Texte und Kommentar, Vols. 1–10. Basel, Stuttgart: Schwabe.Search in Google Scholar

Westerink, L. G. 1976–1977. The Greek Commentaries on Plato’s Phaedo, vol. II [Damascius]. Amsterdam: The Prometheus Trust.Search in Google Scholar

Young, D. J. 2013. “Does Aristotle Refute the Harmonia Theory of the Soul?”. Open Journal of Philosophy 3 (1): 47–54, https://doi.org/10.4236/ojpp.2013.31008.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2020-12-01
Published in Print: 2020-12-16

© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston