Accessible Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter June 28, 2019

Moral Conviction and Immigration Attitudes in America

Maura McDonald and Timothy J. Ryan
From the journal The Forum

Abstract

Past work finds that political attitudes vary in the extent to which they are held with moral conviction – a distinctive facet of attitude intensity associated with animosity toward political opponents and resistance to compromise. We examine moral conviction as it arises on a timely political issue: immigration. Our approach is distinctive in that we measure attitudes about immigration in general, but also several subcomponents of the issue (e.g. attitudes toward building a border wall and making English the official language of the US). We find that attention to moral conviction reveals a face of public opinion that other measures do not. Opinions on the conservative side of immigration topics tend to be more strongly held and more consistent across issues. But those with opinions on the liberal side of the issue exhibit greater moral conviction, suggesting that they might be easier to mobilize and more resistant to compromise. We also assess the extent to which morally convicted attitudes can be traced to specific values and aspects of socialization.

References

Abelson, Robert P. 1988. “Conviction (1987 APA Award Address).” American Psychologist 43 (4): 267–275. Search in Google Scholar

Brandt, Mark J., Daniel C. Wisneski, and Linda J. Skitka. 2015. “Moralization and the 2012 U.S. Presidential Election Campaign.” Journal of Social and Political Psychology 3 (2): 211–237. Search in Google Scholar

Ciuk, David J., and Joshua D. Rottman. 2017. “Manipulating Moral Conviction in a Survey Experimental Setting.” Paper presented at the 2017 meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, Chicago, IL. Search in Google Scholar

Clifford, Scott. 2019. “How Emotional Frames Moralize and Polarize Political Attitudes.” Political Psychology 40 (1): 75–91. Search in Google Scholar

Conover, Pamela Johnston, and Patrick R Miller. 2017. “How Republicans Won on Voter Identification Laws: the Roles of Strategic Reasoning and Moral Conviction.” Social Science Quarterly 28 (2): 1–22. Search in Google Scholar

Converse, Philip E. 1964. “The Nature of Belief Systems in Mass Publics.” In Ideology and Discontent, edited by David E. Apter, 206–261. New York: Free Press. Search in Google Scholar

Delton, Andrew W., Peter DeScioli, and Timothy J. Ryan. “Moral Obstinacy in Political Negotiations.” Paper presented at the 2019 NYU-CESS Experimental Political Science Conference, New York, NY. Search in Google Scholar

DeScioli, Peter, and Robert Kurzban. 2013. “A Solution to the Mysteries of Morality.” Psychological Bulletin 139 (2): 477–496. Search in Google Scholar

Dickerson, Caitlin. 2018. “The Price Tag of Migrant Family Separation: $80 Million and Rising.” New York Times, November 20, 2018. www.nytimes.com. Search in Google Scholar

Duckworth, Tammy. 2018. “Duckworth Statement on Inhumane Trump Administration Policy of Family Separation.” June 19, 2018. www.duckworth.senate.gov. Search in Google Scholar

Farrington, Dana. 2019. “Transcript: Trump’s Address On Border Security And Democratic Response.” NPR.org, January 8, 2019. Search in Google Scholar

Frimer, Jeremy A., Caitlin E. Tell, and Jonathan Haidt. 2015. “Liberals Condemn Sacrilege Too: the Harmless Desecration of Cerro Torre.” Social Psychological and Personality Science. 6 (8): 878–886. Search in Google Scholar

“Full Transcripts: ‘Trump’s Speech on Immigration.’” 2019. New York Times. January 8, 2019. www.nytimes.com. Search in Google Scholar

Garrett, Kristin N. 2018. “Fired Up by Morality: the Unique Physiological Response Tied to Moral Conviction in Politics.” Political Psychology 40 (1): 75–91. Search in Google Scholar

Garrett, Kristin N., and Alexa Bankert. 2018. “The Moral Roots of Partisan Division: How Moral Conviction Heightens Affective Polarization.” British Journal of Political Science 95: 1–20. Search in Google Scholar

Graham, Jesse, Jonathan Haidt, and Brian A. Nosek. 2009. “Liberals and Conservatives Rely on Different Sets of Moral Foundations.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 96 (5): 1029–1046. Search in Google Scholar

Haidt, Jonathan. 2001. “The Emotional Dog and Its Rational Tail: a Social Intuitionist Approach to Moral Judgment.” Psychological Review 108 (4): 814–834. Search in Google Scholar

Haidt, Jonathan. 2012a. “Forget the Money, Follow the Sacredness.” The New York Times, March 17, 2012. Available online at campaignstops.blogs.nytimes.com. Search in Google Scholar

Haidt, Jonathan. 2012b. The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. New York: Pantheon. Search in Google Scholar

Haidt, Jonathan, and Craig Joseph. 2011. “How Moral Foundations Theory Succeeded in Building on Sand: a Response to Suhler and Churchland.” Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 23 (9): 2117–2122. Search in Google Scholar

Hetherington, Marc J., and Thomas J. Rudolph. 2015. Why Washington Won’t Work: Polarization, Political Trust, and the Governing Crisis. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Search in Google Scholar

Koleva, Spassena P., Jesse Graham, Ravi Iyer, Peter H. Ditto, and Jonathan Haidt. 2012. “Tracing the Threads: How Five Moral Concerns (Especially Purity) Help Explain Culture War Attitudes.” Journal of Research in Personality 46 (2): 184–194. Search in Google Scholar

Krosnick, Jon A., David S. Boninger, Yao C. Chuang, Matthew K. Berent, and Catherine G. Carnot. 1993. “Attitude Strength: One Construct or Many Related Constructs?” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 65 (6): 1132–1151. Search in Google Scholar

Layman, Geoffrey C. 2001. The Great Divide: Religious and Cultural Confict in American Party Politics. New York: Columbia University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Leal, David L., and Jerod Patterson. 2013. “House Divided? Evangelical Catholics, Mainstream Catholics, and Attitudes Toward Immigration and Life Policies.” The Forum 11 (4): 561–587. Search in Google Scholar

Lee, Frances E. 2016. Insecure Majorities: Congress and the Perpetual Campaign. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Search in Google Scholar

Magid, Rachel W., and Laura E. Schulz. 2017. “Moral Alchemy: How Love Changes Norms.” Cognition 167: 135–150. Search in Google Scholar

Martinez, Michael D., Stephen C. Craig, and James G. Kane. 2005. “Ambivalence and Public Opinion.” In Ambivalence and the Structure of Political Opinion, edited by Stephen C. Craig and Michael D. Martinez, 1–14. New York: Palgrave MacMillan. Search in Google Scholar

Morgan, G. Scott, Linda J. Skitka, and Daniel C. Wisneski. 2010. “Moral and Religious Convictions and Intentions to Vote in the 2008 Presidential Election.” Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 10 (1): 307–320. Search in Google Scholar

Office of Management and Budget. 2018. “An American Budget.” Available online at www.whitehouse.gov. Search in Google Scholar

Pizarro, David A., and Paul Bloom. 2003. “The Intelligence of the Moral Intuitions: Comment on Haidt (2001).” Psychological Review 110 (1): 193–196. Search in Google Scholar

Rozin, Paul. 1999. “The Process of Moralization.” Psychological Science 10 (3): 218–221. Search in Google Scholar

Ryan, Timothy J. 2014. “Reconsidering Moral Issues in Politics.” The Journal of Politics 76 (2): 380–397. Search in Google Scholar

Ryan, Timothy J. 2017. “No Compromise: Political Consequences of Moralized Attitudes.” American Journal of Political Science 61 (2): 409–423. Search in Google Scholar

Ryan, Timothy J. 2019. “Actions Versus Consequences in Political Arguments: Insights From Moral Psychology.” Journal of Politics 81 (2): 426–440. Search in Google Scholar

Shweder, Richard. 2012. “Relativism and Universalism.” In Companion to Moral Anthropology, edited by Didier Fassin, 85–102. New York: Wiley. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J. 2014. “The Psychological Foundations of Moral Conviction.” In Advances in Experimental Moral Psychology, edited by Jennifer Wright and Hagop Sarkissian, 148–166. New York: Bloomsbury Academic Press. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., and Christopher W. Bauman. 2008. “Moral Conviction and Political Engagement.” Political Psychology 29 (1): 29–54. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., and Daniel C. Wisneski. 2011. “Moral Conviction and Emotion.” Emotion Review 3 (3): 328–330. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., Christopher W. Bauman, and Edward G. Sargis. 2005. “Moral Conviction: Another Contributor to Attitude Strength or Something More?.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 88 (6): 895–917. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., Anthony N. Washburn, and Timothy S. Carsel. 2015. “The Psychological Foundations and Consequences of Moral Conviction.” Current Opinion in Psychology 6: 41–44. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., Brittany E. Hanson, Anthony N. Washburn, and Allison B. Mueller. 2018a. Moral and religious convictions: Are they the same or different things? PLoS One 13 (6): e0199311. Search in Google Scholar

Skitka, Linda J., Daniel C. Wisneski, and Mark J. Brandt. 2018b. “Attitude Moralization: Probably Not Intuitive or Rooted in Perceptions of Harm.” Current Directions in Psychological Science 27 (1): 9–13. Search in Google Scholar

Smith, Kevin B., John R. Alford, John R. Hibbing, Nicholas G. Martin, and Peter K. Hatemi. 2016. “Intuitive Ethics and Political Orientations: Testing Moral Foundations as a Theory of Political Ideology.” American Journal of Political Science 61 (2): 424–437. Search in Google Scholar

Tankersley, Jim. 2019. “Strain of Shutdown is Spreading as Hot Economy Loses its Steam.” New York Times, January 16, 2019, P. A1. Search in Google Scholar

Tetlock, Philip E. 2003. “Thinking the Unthinkable: Sacred Values and Taboo Cognitions.” TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences 7 (7): 320–324. Search in Google Scholar

Tetlock, Philip E., O. V. Kristel, S. B. Elson, M. C. Green, and J. S. Lerner. 2000. “The Psychology of the Unthinkable: Taboo Trade-Offs, Forbidden Base Rates, and Heretical Counterfactuals.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 78 (5): 853–870. Search in Google Scholar

Valentino, Nicholas A., Ted Brader, and Ashley E. Jardina. 2012. “Immigration Opposition Among U.S. Whites: General Ethnocentrism or Media Priming of Attitudes About Latinos?” Political Psychology 34 (2): 149–166. Search in Google Scholar

Visser, Penny S., George Y. Bizer, and Jon A. Krosnick. 2006. “Exploring the Latent Structure of Strength-Related Attitude Attributes.” Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 38: 1–67. Search in Google Scholar

Wegener, Duane T., John Downing, Jon A. Krosnick, and Richard E. Petty. 1995. “Measures and Manipulations.” In Attitude Strength, edited by Richard E. Petty and Jon A. Krosnick, 455–488. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Search in Google Scholar

Wisneski, Daniel C., and Linda J. Skitka. 2017. “Moralization Through Moral Shock: Exploring Emotional Antecedents to Moral Conviction.” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 43 (2): 139–150. Search in Google Scholar

Zorn, Eric. 2019. “Pelosi says Border Walls are ‘Immoral.’ But that’s not the Conversation we need to be having Right Now.” The Chicago Tribune, February 19, 2019. Search in Google Scholar

Supplementary Material

The online version of this article offers supplementary material (https://doi.org/10.1515/for-2019-0006).

Published Online: 2019-06-28

©2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston