Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter February 7, 2014

Assessing the Effect of the Consumer-Voter Sentiment on Tiebout-Like Migration: The EU 27 Case

Christos Kallandranis and Socrates Karidis
From the journal Global Economy Journal

Abstract

The paper revisits the determinants of intra-European migration using a conditional logit model for the period 2000–2010. With all moving restrictions lifted, a substantial Union enlargement in 2004, and a severe economic crisis in progress, new evidence is being revealed regarding the decision making process of individuals who choose to relocate. We examine Tiebout’s proposition of voting with one’s feet in the context of the Union, and we show that fiscal policies in the form of fiscal packages offered to a country’s residents as well as consumer confidence indicators play a decisive role in affecting that process. With 26 alternative destinations over a period of 11 years, we find that people will choose to move to a country that offers them a better fiscal surplus, higher confidence as economic agents and higher potential earnings. In light of our results, and after establishing the migration patterns, we believe that a new discussion should open regarding efficiency concerns and government policy implications.

JEL Classification: E62; E690; F22; F60

Acknowledgments

We benefited from the helpful comments of an anonymous referee. We would also like to thank George Koutsoudis of Tesco Bank for his assistance during the data manipulation process. Responsibility for any remaining errors is our own.

References

Acemoglu, D., and A.Scott. 1994. “Consumer Confidence and Rational Expectations: Are Agents’ Beliefs Consistent with the Theory?The Economic Journal104:119.10.2307/2234671Search in Google Scholar

Berg, L., and R.Bergstrom. 1996. “Consumer Confidence and Consumption in Sweden.” Uppsala University, Department of Economics Working Papers Series 1996:7.Search in Google Scholar

Bram, J., and S.Ludvigson. 1998. “Does Consumer Confidence Forecast Household Expenditure? A Sentiment Index Horse Race.” Economic Policy Review4:5979.Search in Google Scholar

Brucker, H., and P. J. H.Schroder. 2007. “International Migration with Heterogeneous Agents: Theory and Evidence.” Institute for Employment Research Discussion Paper 2007:27.Search in Google Scholar

Buchanan, J. M., and C. J.Goetz. 1972. “Efficiency Limits of Fiscal Mobility: An Assessment of the Tiebout Model.” Journal of Public Economics1:2543.10.1016/0047-2727(72)90018-7Search in Google Scholar

Carroll, C. D., J. C.Fuhrer, and D. W.Wilcox. 1994. “Does Consumer Sentiment Forecast Household Spending? If So, Why?The American Economic Review84:1397408.Search in Google Scholar

Cebula, R. J. 2005. “Internal Migration Determinants: Recent Evidence.” International Advances in Economic Research11:26774.10.1007/s11294-005-6656-8Search in Google Scholar

Cebula, R. J. 2009. “Migration and the Tiebout–Tullock Hypothesis Revisited.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology68:54151.10.1111/j.1536-7150.2009.00638.xSearch in Google Scholar

Cebula, R. J., and M. Z.Kafoglis. 1986. “A Note on the Tiebout–Tullock Hypothesis: The Period 1975–1980.” Public Choice48:659.10.1007/BF00239561Search in Google Scholar

Celik, S., E.Aslanoglu, and S.Uzun. 2010. “Determinants of Consumer Confidence in Emerging Economies: A Panel Cointegration Analysis.” Paper presented at the 30th annual meeting of the Middle East Economic Association, Allied Social Sciences Association, Atlanta, GA, January 3–6.Search in Google Scholar

Clark, X., T. J.Hatton, and J. G.Williamson. 2002. “Where Do US Immigrants Come from, and Why?”NBER Working Paper 8998.Search in Google Scholar

Cushing, B. J. 1993. “The Effect of the Social Welfare System on Metropolitan Migration in the US, by Income Group, Gender and Family Structure.” Urban Studies30:32537.10.1080/00420989320080321Search in Google Scholar

Cuthbertson, K., J.Foreman-Peck, and P.Gripaios. 1982. “The Effects of Local Authority Fiscal Decisions on Population Levels in Urban Areas.” Regional Studies16:16570.10.1080/09595238200185191Search in Google Scholar

Davies, P. S., M. J.Greenwood, and H.Li. 2001. “A Conditional Logit Approach to US State to State Migration.” Journal of Regional Science41:33760.10.1111/0022-4146.00220Search in Google Scholar

Day, K. M. 1992. “Interprovincial Migration and Local Public Goods.” Canadian Journal of Economics25:12344.10.2307/135714Search in Google Scholar

Day, K. M., and S.Winer. 2001. “Policy-Induced Migration in Canada: An Empirical Study”, Human Resources Development Canada, Applied Research Branch.Search in Google Scholar

Day, K. M., and S.Winer. 2012. Interregional Migration and Public Policy in Canada: An Empirical Study, Vol. 223. Montreal, Canada: McGill-Queen’s Press-MQUP.Search in Google Scholar

Dowding, K., P.John, and S.Biggs. 1994. “Tiebout: A Survey of the Empirical Literature.” Urban Studies31:76797.10.1080/00420989420080671Search in Google Scholar

Drakos, K. 2006. “A Note on Uncertainty and Investment across the Spectrum of Irreversibility.” Applied Economics Letters13:87376.10.1080/13504850500425451Search in Google Scholar

Drakos, K., and C.Kallandranis. 2005. “Investment and Cash Flow: Evidence from Greek Listed Companies.” Applied Economics Quarterly51:38796.Search in Google Scholar

Drakos, K., and C.Kallandranis. 2007. “Investment and Cash Flow: Evidence for Asymmetries in European Manufacturing.” Applied Financial Economics17:1191200.10.1080/09603100600843890Search in Google Scholar

Dunn, L. F., and I. A.Mirzaie. 2006. “Turns in Consumer Confidence: An Information Advantage Linked to Manufacturing.” Economic Inquiry44:34351.10.1093/ei/cbj018Search in Google Scholar

Easaw, J. Z., D.Garratt, and S. M.Heravi. 2005. “Does Consumer Sentiment Accurately Forecast UK Household Consumption? Are There Any Comparisons To Be Made with the US?Journal of Macroeconomics27:51732.10.1016/j.jmacro.2004.03.001Search in Google Scholar

Easaw, J. Z., and S. M.Heravi. 2004. “Evaluating Consumer Sentiments as Predictors of UK Household Consumption Behavior: Are They Accurate and Useful?International Journal of Forecasting20:67181.10.1016/j.ijforecast.2003.12.006Search in Google Scholar

Edel, M., and E.Sclar. 1974. “Taxes, Spending, and Property Values: Supply Adjustment in a Tiebout–Oates Model.” The Journal of Political Economy82:94154.10.1086/260248Search in Google Scholar

Emerson, R. A., and D.Hendry. 1994. “An Evaluation of Forecasting Using Leading Indicators.” Journal of Forecasting15:27191.10.1002/(SICI)1099-131X(199607)15:4<271::AID-FOR623>3.0.CO;2-7Search in Google Scholar

Epple, D., A.Zelenitz, and M.Visscher. 1978. “A Search for Testable Implications of the Tiebout Hypothesis.” The Journal of Political Economy86:40525.10.1086/260679Search in Google Scholar

Fan, C. S., and P.Wong. 1998. “Does Consumer Sentiment Forecast Household Spending?: The Hong Kong Case.” Economics Letters58:7784.10.1016/S0165-1765(97)00247-4Search in Google Scholar

Farnham, M., and P.Sevak. 2006. “State Fiscal Institutions and Empty-Nest Migration: Are Tiebout Voters Hobbled?Journal of Public Economics90:40727.10.1016/j.jpubeco.2005.07.005Search in Google Scholar

Fertig, M. 2001. “The Economic Impact of EU-Enlargement: Assessing the Migration Potential.” Empirical Economics26:70720.10.1007/s001810100078Search in Google Scholar

Flatters, F., V.Henderson, and P.Mieszkowski. 1974. “Public Goods, Efficiency, and Regional Fiscal Equalization.” Journal of Public Economics3:99112.10.1016/0047-2727(74)90028-0Search in Google Scholar

Fox, W. F., H. W.Herzog, and A. M.Schlottman. 1989. “Metropolitan Fiscal Structure and Migration.” Journal of Regional Science29:52336.10.1111/j.1467-9787.1989.tb01242.xSearch in Google Scholar

Gabriel, S. A., J.Shack-Marquez, and W. L.Wascher. 1992. “Regional House-Price Dispersion and Interregional Migration.” Journal of Housing Economics2:23556.10.1016/1051-1377(92)90002-8Search in Google Scholar

Greenwood, M. J., and G. L.Hunt. 1984. “Migration and Interregional Employment Redistribution in the United States.” The American Economic Review74:95769.Search in Google Scholar

Greenwood, M. J., and J. M.McDowell. 1991. “Differential Economic Opportunity, Transferability of Skills, and Immigration to the United States and Canada.” The Review of Economics and Statistics73:61223.10.2307/2109400Search in Google Scholar

Hatton, T. J. 1995. “A Model of UK Emigration, 1870–1913.” The Review of Economics and Statistics77:40715.10.2307/2109903Search in Google Scholar

Houtenville, A., and K. S.Conway. 2001. “Elderly Migration and State Fiscal Policy: Evidence from the 1990 Census Migration Flows.” National Tax Journal54:10323.10.17310/ntj.2001.1.05Search in Google Scholar

Howrey, P. E. 2001. “The Predictive Power of the Index of Consumer Sentiment.” Brookings Papers on Economic Activity1:175216.10.1353/eca.2001.0010Search in Google Scholar

Hüfner, F. P., and M.Schröder. 2002. “Forecasting Economic Activity in Germany-How Useful Are Sentiment Indicators?”ZEW Discussion Paper 2:56.10.2139/ssrn.339141Search in Google Scholar

Hunt, G. L., and R. E.Mueller. 2004. “North American Migration: Returns to Skill, Border Effects, and Mobility Costs.” Review of Economics and Statistics86:9881007.10.1162/0034653043125130Search in Google Scholar

Huth, W. L., D. R.Eppright, and P. M.Taube. 1994. “The Indexes of Consumer Sentiment and Confidence: Leading or Misleading Guides to Future Buyer Behavior.” Journal of Business Research29:199206.10.1016/0148-2963(94)90004-3Search in Google Scholar

Islam, M. N. 1989. “Tiebout Hypothesis and Migration-Impact of Local Fiscal Policies.” Public Finance44:40618.Search in Google Scholar

Jackson, A. L., D. L.Ortmeyer, and M. A.Quinn. 2013. “Are Immigrants Really Attracted to the Welfare State? Evidence from OECD Countries.” International Economics and Economic Policy10:129.10.1007/s10368-012-0219-2Search in Google Scholar

Kallandranis, C. 2007. “Topics on the Dynamics of Capital and Labour Demand: An Empirical Analysis.” PhD diss., Department of Economics, University of Patras.Search in Google Scholar

Karidis, S., and M. A.Quinn. 2006. “Fiscal Harmonization and Migration in the European Union.” Brussels Economic Review49:33352.Search in Google Scholar

Kennan, J., and J. R.Walker. 2011. “The Effect of Expected Income on Individual Migration Decisions.” Econometrica79:21151.10.3982/ECTA4657Search in Google Scholar

Koven, S. G., and M. C.Shelley. 1989. “Public Policy Effects on Net Urban Migration.” Policy Studies Journal17:70518.10.1111/j.1541-0072.1989.tb00814.xSearch in Google Scholar

Liebig, T., and A.Sousa-Poza. 2006. “The Influence of Taxes on Migration: Evidence from Switzerland.” Cambridge Journal of Economics30:23552.10.1093/cje/bei057Search in Google Scholar

Lovell, M. C., and P.-L.Tien. 2000. “Economic Discomfort and Consumer Sentiment.” Eastern Economic Journal26:18.10.2139/ssrn.222510Search in Google Scholar

Maddala, G. S. 1983. Limited-Dependent and Qualitative Variables in Econometrics, Vol. 3. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511810176Search in Google Scholar

Matsusaka, J. G., and A. M.Sbordone. 1995. “Consumer Confidence and Economic Fluctuations.” Economic Inquiry33:296318.10.1111/j.1465-7295.1995.tb01864.xSearch in Google Scholar

McFadden, D. 1974. “Conditional Logit Analysis of Qualitative Choice behavior.” In Frontier in Econometrics, edited by Paul Zarembka, 10542. New York and London: Academic Press.Search in Google Scholar

McFadden, D. L. 1984. “Econometric Analysis of Qualitative Response Models.” Handbook of Econometrics2:1395457.10.1016/S1573-4412(84)02016-XSearch in Google Scholar

Mourougane, A., and M.Roma. 2003. “Can Confidence Indicators Be Useful to Predict Short Term Real GDP Growth?Applied Economics Letters10:51922.10.1080/1350485032000100305Search in Google Scholar

Musgrave, R. 1939. “The Voluntary Exchange Theory of Public Economy.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics53:21337.10.2307/1882886Search in Google Scholar

Nakosteen, R. A., and M.Zimmer. 1980. “Migration and Income: The Question of Self-Selection.” Southern Economic Journal46:84051.10.2307/1057152Search in Google Scholar

Oates, W. E. 1969. “The Effects of Property Taxes and Local Public Spending on Property Values: An Empirical Study of Tax Capitalization and the Tiebout Hypothesis.” The Journal of Political Economy77:95771.10.1086/259584Search in Google Scholar

Oates, W. E. 2006. “The Many Faces of the Tiebout Model.” In The Tiebout Model at Fifty: Essays in Public Economics in Honor of Wallace Oates, edited by William A.Fischel, 2145. Cambridge MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.Search in Google Scholar

Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). 2013. “International Migration Database.” Accessed July 2. http://stats.oecd.org/.Search in Google Scholar

Ott, A. F., and R.Shadbegian. 1993. “Fiscally Induced Migration and Public Goods Provision: An Empirical Test of the Buchanan-Goetz Model.” Cahiers D’economie7:3657.Search in Google Scholar

Peridy, N. J. 2006. “Welfare Magnets, Border Effects or Policy Regulations: What Determinants Drive Migration Flows into the EU?Global Economy Journal6:135.Search in Google Scholar

Rubinfeld, D. L. 1987. “The Economics of the Local Public Sector.” Handbook of Public Economics2:571645.10.1016/S1573-4420(87)80006-XSearch in Google Scholar

Samuelson, P. A. 1954. “The Pure Theory of Public Expenditure.” The Review of Economics and Statistics36:38789.10.2307/1925895Search in Google Scholar

Sasser, A. C. 2010. “Voting with Their Feet: Relative Economic Conditions and State Migration Patterns.” Regional Science and Urban Economics40:12235.10.1016/j.regsciurbeco.2010.02.001Search in Google Scholar

Shaw, R. P. 1986. “Fiscal versus Traditional Market Variables in Canadian Migration.” The Journal of Political Economy94:64866.10.1086/261394Search in Google Scholar

Sjaastad, L. A. 1962. “The Costs and Returns of Human Migration.” The Journal of Political Economy70:8093.10.1086/258726Search in Google Scholar

Starrett, D. A. 1980. “On the Method of Taxation and the Provision of Local Public Goods.” The American Economic Review70:38092.Search in Google Scholar

Stock, J. H., and M. W.Watson. 1993. “A Procedure for Predicting Recessions with Leading Indicators: Econometric Issues and Recent Experience.” In Business Cycles, Indicators and Forecasting, edited by James H.Stock and Mark W.Watson, 95156. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.10.3386/w4014Search in Google Scholar

Tiebout, C. M. 1956. “A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures.” The Journal of Political Economy64:41624.10.1086/257839Search in Google Scholar

Tullock, G. 1971. “Public Decisions as Public Goods.” The Journal of Political Economy79:91318.10.1086/259799Search in Google Scholar

Twomey, J. 1987. “Local Authority Fiscal Stance and the Pattern of Residential Migration in the North West of England.” Applied Economics19:1391401.10.1080/00036848700000126Search in Google Scholar

Utaka, A. 2003. “Confidence and the Real Economy-the Japanese Case.” Applied Economics35:33742.10.1080/00036840210135205Search in Google Scholar

Weale, M. 1996. “An Assessment of OECD and UK Leading Indicators.” National Institute Economic Review156:6371.10.1177/002795019615600105Search in Google Scholar

Yinger, J. 1982. “Capitalization and the Theory of Local Public Finance.” The Journal of Political Economy90:91743.10.1086/261101Search in Google Scholar

Yinger, J., H. S.Bloom, A.Boersch-Supan, and H. F.Ladd. 1988. Property Taxes and House Values: The Theory and Estimation of Intrajurisdictional Property Tax Capitalization. Boston, MA: Academic Press.10.1016/B978-0-12-771060-0.50009-2Search in Google Scholar

  1. 1

    For an extensive review, see Dowding, John, and Biggs (1994) and Oates (2006).

  2. 2

    For an extensive review, see Kallandranis (2007).

  3. 3

    For a review on business surveys regarding Economic Sentiment Indicator as a forward looking indicator see Mourougane and Roma (2003), Hüfner and Schröder (2002), Drakos (2006) and Drakos and Kallandranis (2005, 2007).

Published Online: 2014-2-7
Published in Print: 2014-4-1

©2014 by Walter de Gruyter Berlin / Boston