Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter November 29, 2019

Redistribution in Theory and Practice: A Critique of Rawls and Piketty

Hannes H. Gissurarson


Rawls’ theory is about prudence rather than justice. It is about the kind of political structure on which rational people would agree if they were preparing for the worst. Other strategies, such as confining redistribution to upholding a safety net, might also be plausible. Rawls’ theory is Georgism in persons: the income from individual abilities is regarded as if it is at the disposal of the collective and could be taxed as rent. This goes against the strong moral intuition of self-ownership. However, Rawls’ question, where the worst off are as well off as they can be, is interesting. According to the Index of Economic Freedom, it actually may be under relatively unfettered capitalism. Unlike Rawls, Piketty is chiefly worried about the rich, seeking to impose confiscatory taxes on them. But the rich are not a fixed, unchangeable group of people who can effortlessly watch their capital accumulate. Capital is precarious, as is vividly illustrated in Balzac’s novel Père Goriot which Piketty quotes. Different as the approaches of Rawls and Piketty are, both of them agree that their ideal society has to be closed: It must become ‘socialism in one country.’


Aristotle. 1941 [ca. 340 BC]. The Basic Works, edited by R. McKeon. New York: Random House. Search in Google Scholar

Balzac, Honoré de. 1885 [1834–5]. Père Goriot. Boston: Roberts Brothers. Search in Google Scholar

Becker, Gary S., and Nigel Tomas. 1986. “Human Capital and the Rise and Fall of Families.” Journal of Labor Economics 4 (1): 1–39.10.1086/298118 Search in Google Scholar

Buckley, William F. 1986 [1951]. God and Man at Yale. South Bend IN: Gateway Editions. Search in Google Scholar

Chydenius, Anders. 1931 [1765]. The National Gain. London: Ernest Benn. Search in Google Scholar

Delsol, Jean-Philippe, Nicolas Lecaussin, and Emmanuel Martin. 2017. Anti-Piketty: Capital for the twenty-first Century. Washington DC: Cato Institute. Search in Google Scholar

Dolan, Kerry A., and Louisa Kroll. 2018. “Forbes Billionaires 2018: Meet the Richest People on the Planet.” Forbes 6 March. Search in Google Scholar

Dürrenmatt, Friedrich. 1956. Der Besuch der alten Dame, [The Visit]. Zürich: Arche. Search in Google Scholar

Flew, Antony. 1981. The Politics of Procrustes: Contradictions of Enforced Equality. London: Temple Smith. Search in Google Scholar

Friedman, David. 1973. The Machinery of Freedom. New York: Harper & Row. Search in Google Scholar

George, Henry. 1935 [1879]. Progress and Poverty: An Inquiry into the Cause of Industrial Depressions and of Increase of Want with Increase of Wealth: The Remedy. New York: Robert Schalkenbach Foundation. Search in Google Scholar

Gissurarson, Hannes H. 2017a. Green Capitalism: How to Protect the Environment by Defining Private Property Rights. Brussels: New Direction. Search in Google Scholar

Gissurarson, Hannes H. 2017b. Lessons for Europe from the 2008 Icelandic Bank Collapse. Brussels: New Direction. Search in Google Scholar

Gissurarson, Hannes H. 2018. Spending Other People’s Money: A Critique of Rawls, Piketty and Other Redistributionists. Brussels: New Direction. Search in Google Scholar

Grossman, Vasily. 2006 [1960]. Life and Fate, translated by Robert Chandler. New York: New York Review Books Classics. Search in Google Scholar

Gwartney, James, Robert Lawson, Joshua Hall, and Ryan Murphy. 2018. Economic Freedom of the World: 2018 Annual Report. Vancouver BC: Fraser Institute. Search in Google Scholar

Hayek, Friedrich A. von. 1983. “The Muddle of the Middle.” In Philosophical and Economic Foundations of Capitalism, edited by S. Pejovich, 89–101. Lexington MA: D. C. Heath and Company. Search in Google Scholar

Kay, John. 2015. Other People’s Money: Masters of the Universe or Servants of the People. London: Profile Books. Search in Google Scholar

Kroll, Luisa. 2018. “The Forbes 400 Self-Made Score: From Silver Spooners to Bootstrappers.” Forbes 3 October. Search in Google Scholar

Locke, John. 1960 [1689]. Two Treatises of Government, edited by P. Laslett. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Lucas, John R. 1980. On Justice. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Search in Google Scholar

Max Planck Institute. 2019. Human Mortality Database. Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research and University of California, Berkeley and INED, Paris. Search in Google Scholar

Mises, Ludwig von. 1922. Die Gemeinwirtschaft, [Socialism]. Jena: Gustav Fischer. Search in Google Scholar

Norberg, Johan. 1998. Den svenska liberalismens historia, [History of Swedish Liberalism]. Stockholm: Timbro. Search in Google Scholar

Nozick, Robert. 1974. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. New York: Basic Books. Search in Google Scholar

Perry, M. J. 2016. Blog 13 June 2016. Search in Google Scholar

Piketty, Thomas. 2014. Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Cambridge MA: Belknap Press. Search in Google Scholar

Plato. 1961 [ca. 380 BC]. The Collected Dialogues, edited by E. Hamilton and H. Cairns. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Rawls, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge MA: Belknap Press. Search in Google Scholar

Ridley, Matt. 2010. The Rational Optimist. London: Fourth Estate. Search in Google Scholar

Rosanoff, M. A. 1932. “Edison in His Laboratory.” Harper’s Magazine 165 (September): 402–17. Search in Google Scholar

Rothbard, Murray. 1973. “A Future of Peace and Capitalism.” In Modern Political Economy, edited by James H. Weaver, 419–30. Boston: Allyn and Bacon. Search in Google Scholar

Sachs, Jeffrey D. 2006. “Welfare States beyond Ideology.” Scientific American 295 (5): 42.10.1038/scientificamerican1106-42 Search in Google Scholar

Sanandaji, Nima. 2015. Scandinavian Unexceptionalism. London: Institute of Economic Affairs. Search in Google Scholar

Smith, Adam. 1981 [1776]. An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, edited by R. H. Campbell and A. S. Skinner. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund. Search in Google Scholar

Smith, Adam. 1982 [1759]. The Theory of Moral Sentiments, edited by D. D. Raphael and A. I Macfie. Indianapolis: Liberty Fund. Search in Google Scholar

Sowell, Thomas. 2019. Discrimination and Disparities. New York: Basic Books. Search in Google Scholar

Stigler, George J. 1970. “Director’s Law of Public Income Distribution.” The Journal of Law and Economics 13 (1): 1–10.10.1086/466680 Search in Google Scholar

Watts, Robert. 2018. “The Rich List: At Last, the Self-made Triumph over Old Money.” Sunday Times 13 May. Search in Google Scholar

World Bank. 2018. Poverty and Shared Prosperity 2018: Piecing Together the Poverty Puzzle. Washington DC: World Bank. Search in Google Scholar

World Bank. 2019. “GDP per capita, current US$.” Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2019-11-29

© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston