Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter September 27, 2016

Consciousness in Early Modern Philosophy

Remarks on Udo Thiel’s Account

Christian Barth
From the journal Kant-Studien

Abstract:

This commentary on Udo Thiel’s rich and inspiring book The Early Modern Subject consists of three parts. The first part expresses agreement with Thiel’s claim that the early modern philosophers use terms such as “conscientia”, “conscience”, “consciousness”, and “Bewusstsein” in order to refer to forms of “relating to one’s own self”. However, Thiel’s additional claim that the early modern philosophers were not much concerned with object consciousness is found wanting. The second part takes issue with Thiel’s understanding of the way in which René Descartes’s psychological usage of the term “conscientia” is innovative. It is argued that Descartes does not arrive at the psychological meaning of the term by abstraction from its moral meaning. Instead, Descartes only widens the application of the term in one of its established ancient meanings. The third part presents objections to Thiel’s higher-order reading of Cartesian conscientia.

References

Barth, C. (2011) “Apperception in the Essays Concerning Human Understanding: A Critique of the Reflective Account and a Sketch of an alternative Proposal”. In: IX. Internationaler Leibniz Kongress. Natur und Subjekt. Vorträge 1. Teil. Ed. by H. Breger / J. Herbst / S. Erdner. Hannover, 37‒43. Search in Google Scholar

Cottingham, J. (1976) “Introduction”. In: Descartes’ Conversation with Burman. Ed. and transl. by J. Cottingham. Oxford. Search in Google Scholar

Davies, C. G. (1990) ‘Conscience’ as Consciousness: The Idea of Self-Awareness in French Philosophical Writing from Descartes to Diderot. Oxford. Search in Google Scholar

Descartes, R. Œuvres de Descartes. Ed. by C. Adam and P. Tannery. 13 vols. 1964–1976. Paris. [= AT] Search in Google Scholar

Descartes, R. The Philosophical Writings of Descartes. 3 vols. Ed. by J. Cottingham / R. Stoothoff / D. Murdoch / A. Kenny (only vol. 3). 1984–1991. Cambridge. [= CSM] Search in Google Scholar

Faber, B. (1612) Thesaurus Eruditionis Scholasticae. Heidelberg/Leipzig. Search in Google Scholar

Faber, B. (1696) Thesaurus Eruditionis Scholasticae. Leipzig. Search in Google Scholar

Hobbes. T. (1994) Leviathan (with selected variants from the Latin edition of 1668). Ed. by E. Curley. Indianapolis/Cambridge. Search in Google Scholar

Perler, D. / Schierbaum, S. (2014) Selbstbezug und Selbstwissen: Texte zur mittelalterlichen Debatte. Frankfurt a. M. Search in Google Scholar

Ritter, J. / Gründer K. / Gabriel, G. Historisches Wörterbuch der Philosophie. 13 vols. 1971 ff. Basel. [= HWPh] Search in Google Scholar

Simmons, A. (2012) “Cartesian Consciousness Reconsidered”. In: Philosopher’s Imprint 12/2. Search in Google Scholar

Theologische Realenzyclopädie. 36 vols. 1977–2004. Berlin [= TRE] Search in Google Scholar

Thesaurus Linguae Latinae. 1900–. Leipzig. [= TLL] Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2016-9-27
Published in Print: 2016-9-27

© De Gruyter