Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter September 27, 2016

The Early Modern Subject Revisited – Responses to Barth, Lenz, Renz and Wunderlich

Udo Thiel
From the journal Kant-Studien


Responding to comments on The Early Modern Subject, this paper focuses on a strictly limited range of issues: methodology, Descartes on consciousness, and Locke and Hume on personal identity. 1) Ursula Renz’s comments prompt an explanation of the notion of development in historical studies of philosophy. 2) Contra Christian Barth, although it is difficult to determine what kind of self-relation consciousness is for Descartes on the basis of the texts, it is argued that a higher-order reading is a more plausible interpretation than a first-order reading. 3) It is shown that Locke’s account of personal identity can usefully be characterized as ‘subjectivist’, in spite of Martin Lenz’s objections. 4) And finally, in consideration of Falk Wunderlich’s comments, the paper argues against both a traditional ‘ontological’ reading and a ‘sceptical realist’ interpretation of Hume’s bundle theory of the mind.


Cottingham, John (1976), ‘Introduction’, in Descartes’ Conversation with Burman, ed. and transl. by J. Cottingham, Oxford: Oxford University Press 1976. Search in Google Scholar

Davies, Catherine Glyn (1990), Conscience as Consciousness. The Idea of Self-Awareness in French Philosophical Thought from Descartes to Diderot, Oxford: Voltaire Foundation. Search in Google Scholar

Descartes, René, Œuvres de Descartes, ed. and transl. Ch. Adam and P. Tannery, 13 vols, (revised edn.), Paris: Vrin 1964–1976 [AT]. Search in Google Scholar

Descartes, René, Philosophical Writings, ed. and transl. J. Cottingham, R. Stoothoff, D. Murdoch, and A. Kenny, 3 vols., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1984–1991 [CSM]. Search in Google Scholar

Hume, David, A Treatise of Human Nature, ed. by David F. Norton and Mary J. Norton, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2000 [Treatise]. References are to the Selby-Bigge pagination, provided in the margins. Search in Google Scholar

Hume, David, ‘An Abstract of A Treatise of Human Nature’, in Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, ed. by David F. Norton and Mary J. Norton, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2000, 403–417 [Norton and Norton]. Search in Google Scholar

Locke, John, An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, ed. P. H. Nidditch, Oxford: Oxford University Press 1975 [Essay]. Search in Google Scholar

Renz, Ursula (2010), Die Erklärbarkeit von Erfahrung. Realismus und Subjektivität in Spinozas Theorie des menschlichen Geistes, Frankfurt a. M.: Klostermann. Search in Google Scholar

Strawson, Galen (2011), The Evident Connexion. Hume on Personal Identity, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Thiel, Udo, The Early Modern Subject. Self-Consciousness and Personal Identity from Descartes to Hume, Oxford: Oxford University Press 2011, Paperback Edition 2014 [EMS]. Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2016-9-27
Published in Print: 2016-9-27

© De Gruyter