Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter July 26, 2014

What Can Be Expected from International Frameworks to Regulate Large-Scale Land and Water Acquisitions in Sub-Saharan Africa?

Michael Brüntrup, Waltina Scheumann, Axel Berger, Lidija Christmann and Clara Brandi

Abstract

This paper explores the use of international governance frameworks as being one of the ways to regulate large-scale land acquisitions (LSLAs). LSLAs are currently flourishing in both developed and developing countries, in particular in the sub-Saharan Africa region. Although they can potentially have many positive impacts in rural areas, many LSLAs have been shown to mainly produce negative impacts in poor countries with weak national policy and institutional frameworks and poorly defined rights for rural people. To successfully regulate the occurrence of LSLAs and their impacts, it needs to be understood that LSLAs are more complex than they are usually portrayed as being. Some of the complexities pertain to water issues; provenience of investors; legality and legitimacy of acquisitions; as well as the diversity of actors and the people affected. Against this background, five international frameworks are looked at: human rights, voluntary international guidelines, international global water governance regimes and bi-/multilateral river treaties, and voluntary private standards and codes. The paper concludes that the frameworks reviewed provide valuable guidance regarding LSLAs, but no single approach can help in dealing with the multitude of actors, situations, and impacts of LSLAs. Even if they are considered collectively, they can tackle many but not all challenges. Yet, their implementation could substantially improve the process and the impact of LSLAs, including their refusal. A key question is how these frameworks are deployed at the local level. Some rely on translation into national laws and on their implementation, others try to establish a direct linkage between the international and the local level. It is of great interest to study how international frameworks trickle down to local policy arenas, how they are used by stakeholders, and how they are finally shaping conflicts at the local level and affecting their results. In particular, their potential for empowering poor stakeholders should be of interest for research and development.

Literature

Acharya, A., How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localisation and Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism, 58International Organisation (2004). Search in Google Scholar

ActionAid, A Brief Introduction to the “Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests in the Context of National Food Security (June 2012), available at: <http://landportal.info/sites/default/files/actionaid_voluntaryguidelines_guide.pdf>, accessed 9 February 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Alden Wily, L., Governance and Land Relations: A Review of Decentralisation of Land Administration and Management in Africa (London: IIED, 2003). Search in Google Scholar

Alden Wily, L., Looking Back to See Forward: The Legal Niceties of Land Theft in Land Rushes, 39Journal of Peasant Studies, no. 3–4 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Alden Wily, L., The Law and Land Grabbing: Friend or Foe, presentation at the 2013 Law and Development Conference “Legal and Development Implications of International Land Acquisitions” (Kyoto, Japan, 31 May 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Anseeuw, W., M. Boche, T. Breu, M. Giger, J. Lay, P. Messerli and K. Nolte, Transnational Land Deals for Agriculture in the Global South, analytical report based on the Land Matrix Database (Bern/Montpellier/Hamburg: CDE/CIRAD/GIGA, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

Askew, K., F. Maganga and R. Odgaard, Of Land and Legitimacy: A Tale of Two Lawsuits, 83Africa: The Journal of the International African Institute, no. 1 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Baietti, A., A. Shlyakhtenko, R. La Rocca and Urvaksh D. Patel, Green Infrastructure Finance: Leading Initiatives and Research (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

Berger, A., Do We Really Need a Multilateral Investment Agreement? German Development Institute/Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE) Briefing Paper 9/2013 (Bonn, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Berger, A., M. Busse, P. Nunnenkamp and M. Roy, Do Trade and Investment Agreements Lead to More FDI? Accounting for Key Provisions Inside the Black Box, 10International Economics and Economic Policy, no. 2 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Berger, A., M. Busse, P. Nunnenkamp and M. RoyBerger, More Stringent BITs, Less Ambiguous Effects on FDI? Not a Bit!112Economic Letters (2011). Search in Google Scholar

Berger, A. and J. Harten, What Opportunities Do the New EU International Investment Agreements Offer for Developing Countries?, German Development Institute/Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE), Briefing Paper 12/2012 (Bonn, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

Berry, S., Questions of Ownership: Proprietorship and Control in a Changing Rural Terrain – A Case Study from Ghana, 83Africa, no. 1 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Boon, J., How Developing Countries Can Adapt Current Bilateral Investment Treaties to Provide Benefits to Their Domestic Economies, 187Global Business Law Review, no. 1 (2011). Search in Google Scholar

Bromley, D.W., Formalising Property Relations in the Developing World: The Wrong Prescription for the Wrong Malady, 26Land Use Policy, no. 1 (2009). Search in Google Scholar

Brüntrup, M., Detrimental Land Grabbing or Growth Poles? Determinants and Potential Development Effects of Foreign Direct Land Investments, 20Technikfolgenabschätzung – Theorie und Praxis, no. 1 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Burnod, P., M. Gingembre and R. Andrianirina, Competition over Authority and Access: International Land Deals in Madagascar, 44Development and Change, no. 2 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

CFS (Committee on World Food Security), available at: <http://www.fao.org/cfs/cfs-home/resaginv/en/>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Cernic, J.L., Corporate Human Rights Obligations under Stabilization Clauses, 11German Law Journal, no. 2 (2010). Search in Google Scholar

Chaisse, J., Promises and Pitfalls of the European Union Policy on Foreign Investment. How Will the New EU Competence on FDI Affect the Emerging Global Regime?15Journal of International Economic Law, no. 1 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Checkel, J.T., International Norms and Domestic Politics: Bridging the Rationalist-Constructivist Divide, 3European Journal of International Relations, no. 4 (1997). Search in Google Scholar

Chu, J, Gender and “Land Grabbing” in Sub-Saharan Africa: Women’s Land Rights and Customary Land Tenure, 54Development, no. 1 (2011). Search in Google Scholar

Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Substantive Issues Arising in the Implementation of the ICESCR (General Comment 15: The Right to Water, arts. 11 and 12 of the International Covenant) (20 January 2003). Search in Google Scholar

Cotula, L., Land Deals in Africa: What Is in the Contracts? (London: IIED, 2011). Search in Google Scholar

Cotula, L., “‘Land Grabbing’ in the Shadow of the Law: Legal Frameworks Regulating the Global Land Rush”, in R. Rayfuse and NicoleWeisfelt (eds.), The Challenge of Food Security (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

Cotula, L., The Great African Land Grab? Agricultural Investments and the Global Food System (London/New York: Zed Books, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Cotula, L., S.Vermeulen, R.Leonard and J.Keeley, Land Grab or Development Opportunity? Agricultural Investment and International Land Deals in Africa (London/Rome: IIED/FAO/IFAD, 2009). Search in Google Scholar

Cuffaro, N. and D. Hallam, “Land Grabbing” in Developing Countries: Foreign Investors, Regulation and Codes of Conduct (January 2011), available at: <http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm/SSRN_ID1750047_code904191.pdf?abstractid=1744204&mirid=1>, accessed 12 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

De Schutter, O., Large-scale Land Acquisitions and Leases: A Set of Core Principles and Measures to Address the Human Rights Challenge (June 2009), available at: <http://www.srfood.org/images/stories/pdf/otherdocuments/20090611_large-scale-land-acquisitions_en.pdf>, accessed 9 February 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Deininger, K. and D. Byerlee, Rising Global Interest in Farmland: Can It Yield Sustainable and Equitable Benefits? (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2010). Search in Google Scholar

Deininger, K. and G. Feder, Land Registration, Governance, and Development: Evidence and Implications for Policy, 24The World Bank Research Observer, no. 2 (2009). Search in Google Scholar

Dolzer, R., The Impact of International Investment Treaties on Domestic Administrative Law, 37International Law and Politics, no. 4 (2006). Search in Google Scholar

Dolzer, R. and C. Schreuer, Principles of International Investment Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008). Search in Google Scholar

Donnelly, J., Universal Human Rights in Theory and Practice (2nd ed., Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2003). Search in Google Scholar

Dwyer, M.B., Building the Politics Machine: Tools for ‘Resolving’ the Global Land Grab, 44Development and Change, no. 2 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Edelman, M., Messy Hectares: Questions about the Epistemology of Land Grabbing Data, 40Journal of Peasant Studies, no. 3 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, Voluntary Guidelines to Support the Progressive Realization of the Right to Adequate Food in the Context of National Food Security (Rome, 2005). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, From Land Grab to Win-Win. Seizing the Opportunities of International Investments in Agriculture (Rome, 2009a). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, Guide on Legislating for the Right to Food (Rome, 2009b). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, Voluntary Guidelines on the Responsible Governance of Tenure of Land, Fisheries and Forests in the Context of National Food Security (Rome, 2012a). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, Governance of Land Tenure. Making It Happen (Rome, 2012b). Search in Google Scholar

FAO, Trends and Impacts of Foreign Investment in Developing Country Agriculture – Evidence from Case Studies (Rome, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Falkner,R., Global Governance – The Rise of Non-state Actors, EAA Technical Report 4/2011 (Copenhagen: European Environment Agency, 2011). Search in Google Scholar

Friis, C. and A. Reenberg, Land Grab in Africa: Emerging Land System Drivers in a Teleconnected World, Global Land Project-International Project Office (GLP-IPO), GLP Report no. 1 (University of Copenhagen, 2010). Search in Google Scholar

Gallagher, K., Losing Control: Policy Space to Prevent and Mitigate Financial Crises in Trade and Investment Agreements, 29Development Policy Review, no. 4 (2011). Search in Google Scholar

German, L., G. Schoneveld and E. Mwangi, Contemporary Processes of Large-scale Land Acquisition by Investors: Case Studies from sub-Saharan Africa, Occasional Paper 68 (Bogor/Indonesia: CIFOR, 2011). Search in Google Scholar

Global Reporting Initiative, available at: <https://www.globalreporting.org/Pages/default.aspx>, accessed 12 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

GRAIN, Seized: The 2008 Landgrab For Food And Financial Security (October 2008), available at: <http://www.grain.org/article/entries/93-seized-the-2008-landgrab-for-food-and-financial-security>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

GRAIN, Squeezing Africa Dry: Behind Every Land Grab Is a Water Grab (Barcelona, June 2012), available at: <http://www.grain.org/article/entries/4516-squeezing-africa-dry-behind-every-land-grab-is-a-water-grab>, accessed 21 August 2012. Search in Google Scholar

GRAIN, available at: <http://farmlandgrab.org/>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Hafner-Burton, E. and K. Tsutsui, Human Rights in a Globalizing World: The Paradox of Empty Promises, 110American Journal of Sociology, no. 5 (2005). Search in Google Scholar

Hampel-Milagrosa, A. and M. Brüntrup, Land Grabbing and its Gender Implications – What Do We Know So Far, presentation at the 2013 Law and Development Conference “Legal and Development Implications of International Land Acquisitions” (Kyoto, Japan, 31 May 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Henson, S. and J. Humphrey, Understanding the Complexities of Private Standards in Global Agri-food Chains As They Impact Developing Countries, 46The Journal of Development Studies, no. 9 (2010). Search in Google Scholar

Herrmann, R., U. Grote and M. Brüntrup, Household Welfare Outcomes of Large-scale Agricultural Investments: Insights from Sugarcane Outgrower Schemes and Estate Employment in Malawi, paper presented at the Annual World Bank Conference on Land and Poverty (Washington, DC, 8–11 April 2013), available at: <http://www.conftool.com/landandpoverty2013/index.php/Herrmann-368_paper.pdf?page=downloadPaper&filename=Herrmann-368_paper.pdf&form_id=368&form_version=final>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Hertzog, T. et al., Ostrich-Like Strategies in Sahelian Sands? Land and Water Grabbing in the Office du Niger, Mali, 5Water Alternatives, no. 2 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Hilhorst, T., J. Nelen and N. Traoré, Agrarian Change below the Radar Screen: Rising Farmland Acquisitions by Domestic Investors in West Africa. Results from a Survey in Benin, Burkina Faso and Niger, unpublished paper by the Royal Tropical Institute and SNV (April 2011), available at: <http://m.snvworld.org/sites/www.snvworld.org/files/publications/agrarian_change_under_radar_screen_kit_snv.pdf>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Hodgson, S., Land and Water – The Rights Interface, LSP Working Paper 10 (Rome: FAO, 2004). Search in Google Scholar

Hofmann, R., C. Tams and S. Schill (eds.), Preferential Trade and Investment Agreements: From Recalibration to Reintegration (Baden-Baden: Nomos, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Huggins, C., Rural Water Tenure in East Africa. A Comparative Study of Legal Regimes and Community Responses to Changing Tenure Patterns in Tanzania and Kenya (May 2000). Search in Google Scholar

IEA, Recommendations for Improvement of Sustainability Certified Markets, Strategic Inter-Task Study: Monitoring Sustainability Certification of Bioenergy (February 2013), available at: <http://www.bioenergytrade.org/downloads/iea-sust-cert-task-4-final2013.pdf>, accessed 12 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Jägerskog, A., A. Cascão, M. Hårsmar and K. Kim, Land Acquisitions: How Will They Impact Transboundary Waters?, Report no. 30 (Stockholm: SIWI, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

Kennedy, E.T., The Effects of Sugarcane Production on Food Security, Health, and Nutrition in Kenya: A Longitudinal Analysis (Washington, DC: IFPRI, 1989). Search in Google Scholar

Knörich, J. and A. Berger, Friends or Foes? Interactions between Indonesia’s International Investment Agreements and National Investment Law, German Development Institute/Deutsches Institut für Entwicklungspolitik (DIE), Study (Bonn, 2014, Study No. 82). Search in Google Scholar

Land Matrix, available at: <http://landportal.info/landmatrix>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Maertens, M. and J.F. Swinnen, Trade, Standards, and Poverty: Evidence from Senegal, 37World Development, no. 1 (2009). Search in Google Scholar

McCulloch, N. and M. Ota, Export Horticulture and Poverty in Kenya, Institute of Development Studies Working Paper 174 (Sussex, 2002). Search in Google Scholar

Mehta, L., G.J. Veldwisch and J. Franco, Introduction to the Special Issue: Water Grabbing? Focus on the (re)Appropriation of Finite Water Resources, 5Water Alternatives, no. 2 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Minot, N. and M. Ngigi, Are Horticultural Exports a Replicable Success Story? Evidence from Kenya and Côte d’Ivoire, Conferences Paper no. 7, presented at the InWEnt, IFPRI, NEPAD, CTA conference Successes in African Agriculture (Pretoria, 2003). Search in Google Scholar

Newcombe, A. and L. Paradell, Law and Practice of Investment Treaties: Standards of Treatment (Alphen aan den Rijn: Kluwer Law International, 2009). Search in Google Scholar

Nolte, K., Large-scale Agricultural Investments under Poor Land Governance Systems: Actors and Institutions in the Case of Zambia, GIGA Working Papers no. 221 (Hamburg: GIGA German Institute of Global and Area Studies, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Open Contracting, available at: <http://www.open-contracting.org>, accessed 12 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Oxfam, A Sweeter Future? The potential for EU sugar reform to contribute to poverty reduction in southern Africa (London, 2004). Search in Google Scholar

Oxfam, Land and Power: The Growing Scandal Surrounding the New Wave of Investments in Land (Oxford, 2011). Search in Google Scholar

O’Rourke, D., Multi-Stakeholder Regulation: Privatizing or Socializing Global Labor Standards?34World Development, no. 5 (May 2006). Search in Google Scholar

Pearce, F., Splash and Grab: The Global Scramble for Water, New Scientist (4 March 2013), available at: <http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21729066.400-splash-and-grab-theglobal-scramble-for-water.html>, accessed 19 April 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Peters, P.E., Conflicts Over Land and Threats to Customary Tenure in Africa, African Affairs (2013). Herr Görlt, ich schicke Ihnen den Link, da ich mir nicht sicher bin: http://afraf.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2013/08/07/afraf.adt047.abstract. Search in Google Scholar

Platteau, J.P., The Evolutionary Theory of Land Rights as Applied to sub‐Saharan Africa: A Critical Assessment, 27Development and Change, no. 1 (2008). Search in Google Scholar

RAI, available at: <http://www.responsibleagroinvestment.org/rai/>, accessed 12 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Ramazzotti, M., Customary Water Rights and Contemporary Water Legislation, FAO Legal Papers Online 76 (Rome: FAO, 2008). Search in Google Scholar

Richards, M., Social and Environmental Impacts of Agricultural Large-scale Land Acquisitions in Africa – With a Focus on West and Central Africa, Rights and Resources Initiative (Washington, DC, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Sauvant, K. and L. Sachs (eds.), The Effect of Treaties on Foreign Direct Investment: Bilateral Investment Treaties, Double Taxation Treaties, and Investment Flows (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009). Search in Google Scholar

Schaffnit-Chatterjee, C., Foreign Investment in Farmland. No Low-Hanging Fruit, Deutsche Bank research (Frankfurt a. M., November 2012), available at: <http://www.dbresearch.com/PROD/DBR_INTERNET_EN-PROD/PROD0000000000296807/Foreign±investment±in±farmlandpercent3A±No±low-hanging±fruit.PDF>, accessed 9 February 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Schlegel, S., T. Kaphengst and S. Cavallieri, Options to Develop a Global Standard-Setting Scheme for Products Derived from Natural Resources (NRS) (Frankfurt/Berlin: WWF Germany and Ecologic, 2008). Search in Google Scholar

Schoneveld, G.C., L.A. German and E. Nukator, Towards Sustainable Biofuel Development: Assessing the Local Impacts of Large-scale Foreign Land Acquisitions in Ghana, paper prepared for the World Bank Annual Conference on Land Policy and Administration (Washington, DC, 26–27 April 2010). Search in Google Scholar

Scoones, I., R. Hall, S.M. Borras, B. White and W. Wolford, The Politics of Evidence: Methodologies for Understanding the Global Land Rush, 40Journal of Peasant Studies, no. 3 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Sierra Leone Network on the Right to Food, Study Reveals Alarming Facts about Plantation of Addax Bioenergy in Sierra Leone (June 2011), available at: <http://farmlandgrab.org/post/view/18809>, accessed 21 April 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Smaller, C. and H. Mann, A Thirst for Distant Lands: Foreign Investment in Agricultural Land and Water, Foreign Investment for Sustainable Development Program, International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) (Winnipeg, Canada 2009). Search in Google Scholar

United Nations, Treaty Series, vol. 993, depositary notification C.N.781.2001.TREATIES-6 of 5 October 2001. Search in Google Scholar

United Nations, Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights: Implementing the United Nations “Protect, Respect and Remedy” Framework, UN Document A/HRC/17/31 (March 2011). Search in Google Scholar

U.N. Human Rights Council (HRC), Promotion and Protection of All Human Rights, Civil, Political, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Including the Right to Development: Protect, Respect and Remedy: A Framework for Business and Human Rights, U.N. Doc. A/HRC/11/13/ (22 April 2009). Search in Google Scholar

UN Global Compact SABPs (Sustainable Agriculture Business Principles), available at: <http://www.fairlabor.org/blog/entry/developing-sustainable-agriculture-business-principles-un-global-compact>, accessed 6 May 2013. Search in Google Scholar

UNCTAD, The Role of International Investment Agreements in Attracting Foreign Direct Investment to Developing Countries (New York/Geneva: United Nations, 2009). Search in Google Scholar

UNCTAD, World Investment Report 2012. Towards a New Generation of Investment Policies (New York/Geneva: United Nations, 2012). Search in Google Scholar

UNCTAD, World Investment Report 2013. Global Value Chains: Investment and Trade for Development (New York/Geneva: United Nations, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Väth, S., Gaining Neighbours or Disruptive Factors – What Happened When Large-scale Land-based Investment in the Ghanaian Oil Palm Sector Met the Local Population on the Ground?, paper presented at the International Conference on Global Land Grabbing II (Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 17–19 October 2012), available at: <http://www.cornell-landproject.org/download/landgrab2012papers/Vath.pdf>, accessed 31 October 2013. Search in Google Scholar

Vermeulen, S. and L. Cotula, Over the Heads of Local People: Consultation, Consent, and Recompense in Large-Scale Land Deals for Biofuels Projects in Africa, 37The Journal of Peasant Studies, no. 4 (2010). Search in Google Scholar

Von Braun, J. and R.S. Meinzen-Dick, “Land Grabbing” by Foreign Investors in Developing Countries: Risks and Opportunities (Washington, DC: IFPRI, 2009). Search in Google Scholar

Von Lossow, T., Machtverschiebung am Nil. Äthiopien und Ägypten begegnen sich im Wasserkonflikt auf Augenhöhe (SWP-Aktuell 11, Februar, 2013). Search in Google Scholar

Williams, T.O., et al., Water Implications of Large-scale Land Acquisitions in Ghana, 5Water Alternatives, no. 2 (2012). Search in Google Scholar

Wolford, W., et al., Governing Global Land Deals: The Role of the State in the Rush for Land, 44Development and Change, no. 2 (2013). Search in Google Scholar

Yackee, J., Bilateral Investment Treaties, Credible Commitment, and the Rule of (International) Law: Do BITs Promote Foreign Direct Investment?42Law & Society Review, no. 4 (2008). Search in Google Scholar

Yackee, J., Do Bilateral Investment Treaties Promote Foreign Direct Investment? Some Hints from Alternative Sources of Evidence, 51Virginia Journal of International Law, no. 2 (2010). Search in Google Scholar

Note:

The assessments in this paper represent the authors’ own opinions and not necessarily those of their organizations.

Published Online: 2014-7-26
Published in Print: 2014-12-1

©2014 Law and Development Review