Accessible Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter October 11, 2014

Territory Lost – Climate Change and the Violation of Self-determination Rights

Frank Dietrich and Joachim Wündisch

Abstract

Inhabitants of low-lying islands flooded due to anthropogenic climate change will lose their territory and thereby their ability to exercise their right to political self-determination. This paper addresses the normative questions which arise when climate change threatens territorial rights. It explores whether the loss of statehood supports a claim to territorial compensation, and if so, how it can be satisfied. The paper concludes that such claims are well founded and that they should be met by providing compensatory territories. After introducing a differentiation between land rights and territorial rights, previous theoretical responses to the problem of sinking islands are criticized. It is argued that states may be required to give up parts of their territory as compensation. The paper develops criteria of sufficiency for compensatory territories and proposes to base their selection process on a negative auction. Since it is unlikely that unsettled compensatory territories that meet the specified requirements are available, the rights of their original inhabitants are discussed.

Correction Statement

Correction added after ahead-of-print publication on mopp-2013-0005: The DOI of this article has been corrected to: 10.1515/mopp-2013-0005.

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank Helder de Schutter, Fabian Schuppert, Alexa Zellentin, the participants of the conference “Intergenerational Justice and Natural Resources” at Graz University, audiences at Münster University and Zürich University, as well as two anonymous reviewers of Moral Philosophy and Politics for their helpful comments.

Bibliography

Brennan, Jason: The Ethic of Voting, Princeton, Oxford: Princeton University Press, 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Byravan, Sujatha; Rajan, Sudhir Chella: The Ethical Implications of Sea-Level Rise Due to Climate Change, Ethics & International Affairs, 24 (2010), 239–260.Search in Google Scholar

Caney, Simon: Cosmopolitan Justice, Responsibility, and Global Climate Change, Leiden Journal of International Law, 18 (2005), 747–775.Search in Google Scholar

Cassese, Antonio: Self-Determination of Peoples. A Legal Reappraisal, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.Search in Google Scholar

Dietrich, Frank: Changing Borders by Secession: Normative Assessment of Territorial Claims. In: Pavković, A.; Radan, P. (eds.): The Ashgate Research Companion on Secession, Aldershot: Ashgate, 2011, 81–95.Search in Google Scholar

Dietrich, Frank: Territorial Rights and Demographic Change, International Theory, 6 (2014), 174–190.Search in Google Scholar

Hiller, Avram: Climate Change and Individual Responsibility, The Monist, 94 (2011), 349–368.Search in Google Scholar

Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth Assessment Report 2007, available on http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_dataSearch in Google Scholar

Kagan, Shelly: Do I Make a Difference? Philosophy & Public Affairs, 39 (2011), 105–141.Search in Google Scholar

Kolers, Avery: Land, Conflict, and Justice, New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009.Search in Google Scholar

Kolers, Avery: Floating Provisos and Sinking Islands, Journal of Applied Philosophy, 29 (2012), 333–343.Search in Google Scholar

Lefkowitz, David: On the Foundation of Rights to Political Self-Determination: Secession, Nonintervention and Democratic Governance, Journal of Social Philosophy, 39 (2008), 492–511.Search in Google Scholar

Locke, John: Two Treatise of Government, ed. Peter Laslett, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, [1689] 1988.Search in Google Scholar

Meisels, Tamar: A Land Without a People’: An Evaluation of Nations’ Efficiency-Based Territorial Claims, Political Studies, 50 (2002), 959–973.Search in Google Scholar

Miller, David: On Nationality, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1995.Search in Google Scholar

Miller, David: Territorial Rights: Concept and Justification, Political Studies, 60 (2012), 252–268.Search in Google Scholar

Nine, Cara: Ecological Refugees, States Borders, and the Lockean Proviso, Journal of Applied Philosophy, 27 (2010), 359–375.Search in Google Scholar

Nine, Cara: Global Justice and Territory, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012.Search in Google Scholar

Oliver, Selma: A New Challenge to International Law: The Disappearance of the Entire Territory of a State, International Journal on Minority and Group Rights, 16 (2009), 209–243.Search in Google Scholar

Risse, Mathias: The Right to Relocation: Disappearing Island Nations and Common Ownership of the Earth, Ethics & International Affairs, 23 (2009), 281–300.Search in Google Scholar

Risse, Mathias: On Global Justice, Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2012.Search in Google Scholar

Sandler, Ronald: Ethical Theory and the Problem of Inconsequentialism: Why Environmental Ethicists Should be Virtue-Oriented Ethicists, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 23 (2010), 167–183.Search in Google Scholar

Shue, Henry: Global Environment and International Inequality, International Affairs, 75 (1999), 533–537.Search in Google Scholar

Simmons, A. John: On the Territorial Rights of States, Philosophical Issues, 11 (2001), 300–326.Search in Google Scholar

Sinnott-Armstrong, Walter: It’s Not My Fault: Global Warming and Individual Moral Obligations. In: Sinnott-Armstrong, W.; Howarth, R. B. (eds.): Perspectives on Climate Change: Science, Economics, Politics, Ethics, Amsterdam: Emerald Group Publishing Limited, 2005, 285–307.Search in Google Scholar

Steiner, Hillel: Territorial Justice. In: Lehning, Percy B. (ed.): Theories of Secession, London, New York: Routledge, 1998, 61–70.Search in Google Scholar

Steiner, Hillel: May Lockean Doughnuts Have Holes? The Geometry of Territorial Jurisdiction: A Response to Nine, Political Studies, 56 (2008), 949–956.Search in Google Scholar

Stilz, Anna: Why Do States Have Territorial Rights, International Theory, 1 (2009), 185–213.Search in Google Scholar

Stilz, Anna: Nations, States, and Territory, Ethics, 121 (2011), 572–601.Search in Google Scholar

Terminski, Bogumil: Mining-Induced Displacement and Resettlement: Social Problem and Human Rights Issue (A Global Perspective) (August 10, 2012). Available at SSRN: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2028490http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2028490Search in Google Scholar

United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change 1992, available on http://unfccc.intSearch in Google Scholar

Wellman, Christopher Heath: A Theory of Secession. The Case for Political Self-Determination, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.Search in Google Scholar

Yamamoto, Lilian; Esteban, Miguel: Vanishing Island States and Sovereignty, Ocean & Coastal Management, 53 (2010), 1–9.Search in Google Scholar

Zellentin, Alexa: Climate Migration. Cultural Aspects of Climate Change, Analyse & Kritik, 32 (2010), 63–86.Search in Google Scholar

Note

The ahead-of-print-version of this article was published under the DOI jmpp-2013-0005.

Published Online: 2014-10-11
Published in Print: 2015-05-01

© 2015 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston