Accessible Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter April 7, 2017

Is Capitalist Utopia Noncompetitive? Jason Brennan’s Why Not Capitalism?

Stephen Hood


Jason Brennan’s Why Not Capitalism? provides a direct response to G.A. Cohen’s moral defence of the value of socialism, arguing that, even under the utopian conditions Cohen specifies, capitalism would be recognized as the most attractive form of social organization. Yet, in one respect, Brennan’s account of utopia seems oddly out of keeping with the capitalist system it is taken to represent: the freedom of the characters within it seems almost totally untouched by the pressure of competitive market forces. I argue that this absence cannot be explained simply by an appeal to the positive intentions of utopian individuals as, even with such motivations in place, competition would still be unavoidable. This means that, even if we agree with Brennan that people would want a utopia in which they had the greatest possible scope to pursue their own personal plans, they may still have good reason to reject his capitalist ideal in favour of a system that would secure for them fair terms on which to compete.


I would like to thank Miriam Ronzoni and two anonymous referees for comments on previous versions of this article.


Brennan, J. (2014). Why Not Capitalism? (New York: Routledge).Search in Google Scholar

Brighouse, H. and A. Swift. (2006). ‘Equality, Priority and Positional Goods.’ Ethics 116 (3): 471–497.Search in Google Scholar

Brown, A. (2015). ‘Principles of Stakes Fairness in Sport.’ Politics, Philosophy & Economics 14 (2): 152–186.Search in Google Scholar

Cohen, G.A. (2009). Why Not Socialism? (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Gilabert, P. (2012). ‘Cohen on Socialism, Equality and Community.’ Socialist Studies/Études Socialistes 8 (1): 101–121.Search in Google Scholar

Goodin, R. (2010). ‘Temporal Justice.’ Journal of Social Policy 39 (1): 1–16.Search in Google Scholar

Halliday, D. (2015). ‘Private Education, Positional Goods, and the Arms Race Problem.’ Politics, Philosophy & Economics. Epub ahead of print. DOI: 10.1177/1470594X15603717.Search in Google Scholar

Hayek, F.A. (1945). ‘The Use of Knowledge in Society.’ The American Economic Review 35 (4): 519–530.Search in Google Scholar

Hayek, F.A. (2002 [1968]). ‘Competition as a Discovery Procedure.’ Trans. M.S. Snow, Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics 5 (3): 9–23.Search in Google Scholar

Heath, J. (2014). ‘The History of the Invisible Hand’. In his Morality, Competition and the Firm: The Market Failures Approach to Business Ethics, pp. 205–229. (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Jacobs, L. (2004). Pursuing Equal Opportunities: The Theory and Practice of Egalitarian Justice. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Kahneman, D., P. Slovic and A. Tversky. (1982). Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Nozick, R. (1974). Anarchy State and Utopia. (New York: Basic Books).Search in Google Scholar

O‘Neill, M. and T. Williamson (eds.) (2012). Property-Owning Democracy: Rawls and Beyond. (Oxford: Wiley).Search in Google Scholar

Ostrom, E. (2015). Governing the Commons. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Rawls, J. (2005). Political Liberalism: Expanded Edition. (New York: Columbia UP).Search in Google Scholar

Roemer, J. (2010). ‘Jerry Cohen’s Why Not Socialism? Some Thoughts.’ The Journal of Ethics 14 (3–4): 255–262.Search in Google Scholar

Ronzoni, M. (2012). ‘Life is Not a Camping Trip – On the Desirability of Cohenite Socialism.’ Politics, Philosophy & Economics 11 (2): 171–185.Search in Google Scholar

Rose, J.L. (2014). ‘Money Does Not Guarantee Time: Discretionary Time as a Distinct Object of Distributive Justice.’ Journal of Political Philosophy 22 (4): 438–457.Search in Google Scholar

Smith, A. (1993 [1776]). The Wealth of Nations. (Oxford: Oxford UP).Search in Google Scholar

Steiner, H. (2014). ‘Greed and Fear.’ Politics, Philosophy & Economics 13 (2): 140–150.Search in Google Scholar

Stilz, A. (2014). ‘Is The Free Market Fair?’ Critical Review 26 (3–4): 423–438.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2017-04-07
Published in Print: 2017-06-27

© 2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston