Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter August 28, 2019

Decriminalizing People Smuggling

Mollie Gerver

Abstract

Since 2015 millions of migrants have paid smugglers to take them across borders. In response, states have increasingly arrested smugglers, hoping to morally condemn smuggling, and to decrease the rate of inward migration. This article argues that, even if a state is justified in morally condemning smuggling, and justified in decreasing inward migration, arresting smugglers is a disproportionate response for reaching these ends.

References

1951 Convention and 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, URL=http://www.unhcr.org/3b66c2aa10.html (accessed on March 23, 2016).Search in Google Scholar

Achilli, L. (2018). ‘The “Good” Smuggler: The Ethics and Morals of Human Smuggling among Syrians’, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 676 (1): 77–96.Search in Google Scholar

Aloyo, E. and Cusumano, E. (forthcoming). ‘Morally Evaluating Human Smuggling Smuggling: The Case of Migration to Europe’, Critical Review of Social and Political Philosophy.Search in Google Scholar

Anti-people Smuggling and other Measures Act. (2010). URL=https://www.legislation.gov.au/Details/C2010A00050 (accessed on January 13, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

Arboleda, E. (1991). ‘Refugee Definition in Africa and Latin America: The Lessons of Pragmatism’, International Journal of Refugee Law 3 (2): 185–207.Search in Google Scholar

Barry, C. and Øverland, G. (2012). ‘How Much for the Child?’, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 16 (1): 189–204.Search in Google Scholar

Betts, A. (2010). ‘Survival Migration: A New Protection Framework’, Global Governance 16 (3): 361–382.Search in Google Scholar

Braithwaite, J. and Pettit, P. (1990). Not Just Deserts (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Carens, J. (1987). ‘Aliens and Citizens: The Case for Open Borders’, The Review of Politics 49 (2): 251–273.Search in Google Scholar

Carens, J. (1992). ‘Refugees and the Limits of Obligations’, Public Affairs Quarterly 6 (1): 31–44.Search in Google Scholar

Carens, J. (1997). ‘The Philosopher and the Policy Maker: Two Perspectives on the Ethics of Immigration with Special Attention to the Problem of Restricting Asylum’, in K. Hailbronner, D.A. Martin and H. Motomura (eds.). Immigration Admissions: The Search for Workable Policies in Germany and the United States (Providence, RI and Oxford: Berghahn), pp. 3–50.Search in Google Scholar

Carens, J. (2013). The Ethics of Immigration (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Cherem, M. (2016). ‘Refugee Rights: Against Expanding the Definition of “Refugees” and Unilateral Protection Elsewhere’, Journal of Political Philosophy 24 (2): 183–205.Search in Google Scholar

Del Valle, H., Ben Ali, R., and Turner, W. (2016). ‘Search and Rescue in the Central Mediterranean’, Forced Migration Review 51: 25–26.Search in Google Scholar

Duff, A. (2013). ‘Theories of Criminal Law’, in E.N. Zalta (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Summer 2013 Edition, URL=http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2013/entries/criminal-law/ (accessed on January 13, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

Dummett, M. (2001). On Immigration and Refugees (London: Routledge).Search in Google Scholar

Eurostat. (2016). ‘Asylum and First Time Asylum Applicants by Citizenship, Age and Sex: Annual Aggregated Data’, 13 December, URL=http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/en/web/products-datasets/-/MIGR_ASYAPPCTZA (accessed on December 20, 2017)Search in Google Scholar

Fabre, C. (2006). Whose Body Is It Anyway? Justice and the Integrity of the Person (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Feinberg, J. (1988). Harmless Wrongdoing (New York: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Fekete, L. (2009). ‘Europe’s Shame: A Report on 105 Deaths Linked to Racism or Government Migration and Asylum Policies’, European Race Bulletin (London: Institute of Race Relations).Search in Google Scholar

Fish, M.J. (2008). ‘An Eye for an Eye: Proportionality as a Moral Principle of Punishment’, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 28 (1): :57–71.Search in Google Scholar

Gardner, J. (2007). Offences and Defences (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Gerver, M. (2018). The Ethics and Practice of Refugee Repatriation (Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Gibney, M. (2004). The Ethics and Politics of Asylum: Liberal Democracy and the Response to Refugees (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Hidalgo, J. (2016). ‘The Ethics of People Smuggling’, The Journal of Global Ethics 12 (3): 311–326.Search in Google Scholar

Hitchcock, C. (2016). ‘Probabilistic Causation’, in E.N. Zalta (ed.). The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy:Winter 2012 Edition, URL=http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/win2012/entries/causation-probabilistic/ (accessed on November 22, 2016).Search in Google Scholar

Horwood, C. and Malakoot, A. (2014). ‘From Sub-Saharan Africa through North Africa: Tracking Deaths along the Way’, in T. Brian and F. Laczko (eds.). Fatal Journeys Tracking Lives Lost During Migration (Geneva: International Organization of Migration).Search in Google Scholar

Igunza, E. (2015) ‘How Ethiopia Has Cracked down on People Smuggling’, BBC Africa, 1 October 2015, URL=from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-34404249 (accessed on 18 December, 2016).Search in Google Scholar

Immigration Act 1971, Part III Section 25A, URL=http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1971/77/section/25 (accessed on 13 January, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

Kingsley, P. (2015). ‘On the Road to Agadez: Desperation and Death along a Saharan Smuggling Route’, The Guardian 9 November. URL=https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/09/on-the-road-in-agadez-desperation-and-death-along-a-saharan-smuggling-route (accessed on December 9, 2016).Search in Google Scholar

Kukathas, C. (2013). ‘In Praise of the Strange Virtue of People Smuggling’, Global Policy Journal, 3 May, URL=http://www.globalpolicyjournal.com/blog/03/05/2013/praise-strange-virtue-people-smuggling (accessed on January 2, 2017).Search in Google Scholar

Landry, R. (2016). ‘The “Humanitarian Smuggling” of Refugees: Criminal Offence or Moral Obligation?’, Refugee Studies Centre Working Paper Series No. 119, URL=https://www.rsc.ox.ac.uk/publications/the-humanitarian-smuggling-of-refugees-criminal-offence-or-moral-obligation (accessed on July 1, 2018).Search in Google Scholar

Lijnders, L. and Robinson, S. (2013). ‘From the Horn of Africa to the Middle East: Human Trafficking of Eritrean Asylum Seekers across Borders’, Anti-Trafficking Review 2: 137–154.Search in Google Scholar

Lister, M. (2013). ‘Who Are Refugees?’, Law and Philosophy 32 (5): 645–671.Search in Google Scholar

Long, K. (2013). The Point of No Return: Refugees: Refugees, Rights, and Repatriation (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Matthew, P. (2009). Rethinking Asylum: History, Purpose and Limits (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Search in Google Scholar

May, L. (2007). War Crimes and Just War (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).Search in Google Scholar

McMahan, J. (2014). ‘Proportionate Defense’, Journal of Transnational Law and Policy 23 (1): 1–35.Search in Google Scholar

MHub. (2015). ‘Mixed Migration Trend Report for September 2015 Covering Mixed Migration Events in: Algeria, Egypt, Ethiopia, Libya, Mali, Morocco, Nigeria, Sudan, Tunisia, Greece and Italy’, Bulletin, September 2015.Search in Google Scholar

Miller, D. (2005). ‘Immigration: The Case for Its Limits’, in A.I. Cohen and C.H. Wellman (eds.). Contemporary Debates in Applied Ethics (Malden, MA: Blackwell Publishing), pp. 193–204.Search in Google Scholar

Miller, D. (2016). Strangers in Our Midst: The Political Philosophy of Immigration (Cambridge: Harvard University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Millum, J. (2014). ‘Consent under Pressure: The Puzzle of Third Party Coercion’, Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 17 (1): 113–127.Search in Google Scholar

Moore, M.S. (1997). Placing Blame: A Theory of Criminal Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Muller, J.F. (forthcoming). ‘The Ethics of Commercial Human Smuggling’, European Journal of Political Theory.Search in Google Scholar

Nelkin, D.K. (2015). ‘Friendship, Freedom, and Special Obligations’, in A. Buckareff, C. Moya and S. Rosell (eds.). Agency, Freedom and Moral Responsibility (London: Palgrave).Search in Google Scholar

Oberman, K. (2016). ‘Immigration as a Human Right’, in S. Fine and L. Ypi (eds.). Migration in Political Theory: The Ethics of Movement and Membership (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Parekh, S. (2017). The Ethics of Forced Displacement (New York: Routledge).Search in Google Scholar

Robinson, D. (2016). ‘EU Border Force Accuses Charities of Collusion with Migrant Smugglers’, Financial Times, 15 December, URL=https://www.ft.com/content/3e6b6450-c1f7-11e6-9bca-2b93a6856354 (accessed on May 12, 2017)Search in Google Scholar

Roemer, J. (1982). A General Theory of Exploitation and Class (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Safdar, A. (2016). ‘NGOs Decry Charges against NGOs in Greece’, Al Jazeera, 16 January, URL=https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/01/ngos-decry-arrests-volunteer-lifeguards-greece-160116193522648.html (accessed on January 13, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

Sanchez, G. (2017). ‘Critical Perspectives on Clandestine Migration Facilities: An Overview of the Migrant Smuggling Research’, Journal on Migration and Human Security 5 (1): 9–27.Search in Google Scholar

Singer, P. (1972). ‘Famine, Affluence, and Morality’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 1 (3): 229–243.Search in Google Scholar

Smith, H. (2016). ‘Tracing Cases of Culpable Ignorance’, in R. Peels (ed.). Perspectives on Ignorance from Moral and Social Philosophy (New York and Abingdon: Taylor and Francis), ch. 6.Search in Google Scholar

Steiner, H. (1984). ‘A Liberal Theory of Exploitation’, Ethics 94 (2): 225–241.Search in Google Scholar

Steiner, H. (2013). ‘Liberalism, Neutrality, and Exploitation’, Politics, Philosophy, and Economics 12 (4): 335–344.Search in Google Scholar

Tardy, T. (2015). ‘Operation Sophia Tackling the Refugee Crisis with Military Means’, Brief, SSUE, URL=https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/193999/Brief_30_Operation_Sophia.pdf (accessed on December 15, 2017).Search in Google Scholar

UK National Crime Agency. (2016). ‘Suspected Head of Smuggling Network Arrested in Derby’, URL=http://www.nationalcrimeagency.gov.uk/news/858-suspected-head-of-people-smuggling-network-arrested-in-derby (accessed on December 19, 2018).Search in Google Scholar

UNODC. (2018). ‘Global Study on Smuggling of Migrants’, United Nations, Vienna, URL=https://www.unodc.org/documents/data-and-analysis/glosom/GLOSOM_2018_web_small.pdf (accessed on January 16, 2019).Search in Google Scholar

Valdman, M. (2009). ‘A Theory of Wrongful Exploitation’, Philosophers’ Imprint 9 (6): 1–14.Search in Google Scholar

van Reisen, M., Estafanos, M., and Rijken, C. (2013). Human Trafficking in the Sinai: Refugees between Life and Death (Oisterwijk: Wolf Legal Publishers).Search in Google Scholar

van Reisen, M. and Rijken, C. (2015). ‘Sinai Trafficking: Origin and Definition of a New Form of Human Trafficking’, Social Inclusion 3 (1): 113–124.Search in Google Scholar

Von Hirsch, A. (2005). ‘Criteria for Proportionality: A Review’, in A. von Hirsch and A. Ashworth (eds.). Proportionate Sentencing: Exploring the Principles (Oxford: Oxford University Press), pp. 131–162.Search in Google Scholar

Waldron, J. (2000). ‘On the Road: Good Samaritans and Compelling Duties’, Santa Clara Law Review 40 (4): 1053–1103.Search in Google Scholar

Walzer, M. (1983). Spheres of Justice (New York: Basic Books).Search in Google Scholar

Weber, L. and Pickering, S. (2013). ‘Exporting Risks, Deporting Non-Citizens’, in F. Pakes (ed.). Globalization and the Challenge to Criminology (Abingdon, UK: Routledge), pp. 110–128.Search in Google Scholar

Wellman, C.H. (2005). ‘Samaritanism and the Duty to Obey the Law’, in C.H. Wellman and A.J. Simmons, Is There a Duty to Obey the Law? (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), pp. 1–90.Search in Google Scholar

Wellman, C.H. (2008). ‘Immigration and Freedom of Association’, Ethics 119 (1): 109–141.Search in Google Scholar

Wolff, J. and De Shalit, A. (2007). Disadvantage (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2019-08-28
Published in Print: 2021-04-27

© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston