Accessible Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter June 20, 2020

The Ethics of Police Body-Worn Cameras

Frej Klem Thomsen

Abstract

Over the past decade, police departments in many countries have experimented with and increasingly adopted the use of police body-worn cameras (PBWCs). This article aims to examine the moral issues raised by the use of PBWCs, and to provide an overall assessment of the conditions under which the use of PBWCs is morally permissible. It first reviews the current evidence for the effects of using PBWCs. On the basis of this review the article sets out a teleological argument for the use of PBWCs. The final two sections of the article review two deontological objections to the use of PBWCs: the idea that use of PBWCs is based on or expresses disrespectful mistrust, and the idea that the use of PBWCs violates a right to privacy. The article argues that neither of these objections is persuasive, and concludes that we should conditionally accept and support the use of PBWCs.

Acknowledgements

I have presented drafts of this paper at a 2018 Roskilde University Moral Philosophy seminar, a 2019 conference on mass state surveillance at Karlsruhe Institut für Technologie, and the 2019 Braga Meetings in Ethics and Political Philosophy. I am grateful for helpful comments on these and other occasions from William Bülow, Matthew Hall, Sean Kaplan, Rune Klingenberg Hansen, Kristian Kragh, Peter Königs, Sune Lægaard, Chris Nathan, Nora Ni Loideain, Kevin Macnish, Ingmar Persson, Scott Robbins, Christian Seidel, Patrick Smith, Thomas Søbirk Petersen, Jørn Sønderholm, Jakob Thrane Mainz, and Anette Zimmerman. I am further grateful for many helpful comments from two anonymous reviewers for the journal and the guest editor of this special issue. Finally, the article owes a great debt above all to Jesper Ryberg, not merely for his invaluable comments on this specific article, but for his style of argument, long exposure to which I suspect has led me to inadvertently (if perhaps not quite successfully) imitate.

References

Adams, I. and Mastracci, S. (2017). ‘Visibility is a Trap: The Ethics of Police Body-Worn Cameras and Control’, Administrative Theory & Praxis 39 (4): 313–328.Search in Google Scholar

Alfino, M. and Mayes, G.R. (2003). ‘Reconstructing the Right to Privacy’, Social Theory & Practice 29 (1): 1–18.Search in Google Scholar

American Civil Liberties Union. (2018). ‘A Model Act for Regulating the Use of Body Worn Cameras by Law Enforcement (Version 2.1)’, American Civil Liberties Union. URL: (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B. (2016). ‘Police Body Cameras in Large Police Departments’, Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology 106 (4): 729–768.Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B., Farrar, W.A., and Sutherland, A. (2015). ‘The Effect of Police Body-Worn Cameras on Use of Force and Citizens’ Complaints against the Police: A Randomized Controlled Trial’, Journal of Quantitative Criminology 31 (3): 509–535.Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Magicks, S., and Henderson, R. (2016). ‘Wearing Body Cameras Increases Assaults against Officers and Does Not Reduce Police Use of Force: Results from a Global Multi-site Experiment’, European Journal of Criminology 13 (6): 744–755.Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Megicks, S., and Henderson, R. (2016a). ‘“Contagious accountability”: A Global Multisite Randomized Controlled Trial on the Effect of Police Body-Worn Cameras on Citizens’ Complaints against the Police’, Criminal Justice and Behavior 44 (2): 293–316.Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., Drover, P., Sykes, J., Megicks, S., and Henderson, R. (2016b). ‘Report: Increases in Police Use of Force in the Presence of Body-worn Cameras are Driven by Officer Discretion: A Protocol-based Subgroup Analysis of Ten Randomized Experiments’, Journal of Experimental Criminology 12 (3): 453–463.Search in Google Scholar

Ariel, B., Sutherland, A., Henstock, D., Young, J., and Sosinski, G. (2018). ‘The Deterrence Spectrum: Explaining Why Police Body-Worn Cameras ‘Work’ or ‘Backfire’ in Aggressive Police–Public Encounters’, Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 12 (1): 6–26.Search in Google Scholar

Armacost, B.E. (2004). ‘Organizational Culture and Police Misconduct’, George Washington University Law Review 72 (3): 453–546.Search in Google Scholar

Brown, C. (2011). ‘Consequentialise This’, Ethics 121 (4): 749–771.Search in Google Scholar

Corlett, J.A. (2002). ‘The Nature and Value of the Moral Right to Privacy’, Public Affairs Quarterly 16 (4): 329–350.Search in Google Scholar

Coudert, F., Butin, D., and Le Métayer, D. (2015). ‘Body-worn Cameras for Police Accountability: Opportunities and Risks’, Computer Law & Security Review 31 (6): 749–762.Search in Google Scholar

Cubitt, T.I., Lesic, R., Myers, G.L., and Corry, R. (2017). ‘Body-worn Video: A Systematic Review of Literature’, Australian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology 50 (3): 379–396.Search in Google Scholar

Darwall, S.L. (1977). ‘Two Kinds of Respect’, Ethics 88 (1): 36–49.Search in Google Scholar

Darwall, S.L. (2006). The Second-Person Standpoint: Morality, Respect, and Accountability (Cambridge: Harvard University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Davis, S. (2009). ‘Is There a Right to Privacy?’, Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 90 (4): 450–475.Search in Google Scholar

Doyle, T. (2009). ‘Privacy and Perfect Voyeurism’, Ethics and Information Technology 11 (3): 181–189.Search in Google Scholar

Eidelson, B. (2015). Discrimination and Disrespect (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Eitle, D., D’Alessio, S.J., and Stolzenberg, L. (2014). ‘The Effect of Organizational and Environmental Factors on Police Misconduct’, Police Quarterly 17 (2): 103–126.Search in Google Scholar

Frankfurt, H. (1997). ‘Equality and Respect’, Social Research 64 (1): 3–15.Search in Google Scholar

Gabriel, I. (2016). ‘Effective Altruism and Its Critics’, Journal of Applied Philosophy 34 (4): 457–473.Search in Google Scholar

Griffin, J. (2007). ‘The Human Right to Privacy’, San Diego Law Review 44 (4): 697–721.Search in Google Scholar

Grossmith, L., Owens, C., Finn, W., Mann, D., Davies, T., and Baika, L. (2015). ‘police, camera, Evidence: London’s Cluster Randomised Controlled Trial of Body Worn video’, College of Policing Limited & Mayor’s Office for Policing and Crime, (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Harris, C.J. (2009). ‘Police Use of Improper Force: A Systematic Review of the Evidence’, Victims & Offenders 4 (1): 25–41.Search in Google Scholar

Hedberg, E.C., Katz, C.M., and Choate, D.E. (2017). ‘Body-Worn Cameras and Citizen Interactions with Police Officers: Estimating Plausible Effects Given Varying Compliance Levels’, Justice Quarterly 34 (4): 627–651.Search in Google Scholar

Hellman, D. (2008). When Is Discrimination Wrong? (Cambridge: Harvard University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Hohfeld, W.N. (1913). ‘Some Fundamental Legal Conceptions as Applied in Judicial Reasoning’, The Yale Law Journal 23 (1): 16–59.Search in Google Scholar

Jennings, W.G., Lynch, M.D., and Fridell, L.A. (2015). ‘Evaluating the Impact of Police Officer Body-worn Cameras (Bwcs) on Response-to-resistance and Serious External Complaints: Evidence from the Orlando Police Department (OPD) Experience Utilizing a Randomized Controlled Experiment’, Journal of Criminal Justice 43 (6): 480–486.Search in Google Scholar

Kane, R.J. and White, M.D. (2009). ‘Bad Cops’, Criminology & Public Policy 8 (4): 737–769.Search in Google Scholar

Lippert-Rasmussen, K. (2013). Born Free and Equal? A Philosophical Inquiry into the Nature of Discrimination (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Lum, C., Koper, C., Merola, L., Scherer, A., and Reioux, A. (2015). ‘Existing and Ongoing Body Worn Camera Research: Knowledge Gaps and Opportunities’, Laura and John Arnold Foundation. (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Lum, C., Stoltz, M., Koper, C.S., and Scherer, J.A. (2019). ‘Research on Body-worn Cameras’, Criminology & Public Policy 18 (1): 93–118.Search in Google Scholar

MacAskill, W. (2015). Doing Good Better: How Effective Altruism Can Help You Make a Difference (New York: Random House).Search in Google Scholar

Macnish, K. (2018). ‘Government Surveillance and Why Defining Privacy Matters in a Post-Snowden World’, Journal of Applied Philosophy 35 (2): 417–432.Search in Google Scholar

Marmor, A. (2015). ‘What is the Right to Privacy?’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 43 (1): 3–26.Search in Google Scholar

Marthews, A. and Tucker, C.E. (2017). ‘Government Surveillance and Internet Search Behavior’, SSRN. (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Maskaly, J., Donner, C., Jennings, W.G., Ariel, B., and Sutherland, A. (2017). ‘The Effects of Body-worn Cameras (Bwcs) on Police and Citizen Outcomes: A State-of-the-art Review’, Policing: An International Journal 40 (4): 672–688.Search in Google Scholar

McCloskey, H.J. (1980). ‘Privacy and the Right to Privacy’, Philosophy 55 (211): 17–38.Search in Google Scholar

Morgan, J. and Silverstone, D. (2017). ‘Trialling Body-Worn Video Cameras for City of London Police: Officer Perceptions and Justice outcomes’, City of London Police, (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Nagel, T. (1998). ‘Concealment and Exposure’, Philosophy and Public Affairs 27 (1): 3–30.Search in Google Scholar

Oberdiek, J. (2008). ‘Specifying Rights Out of Necessity’, Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 28 (1): 127–146.Search in Google Scholar

Pelfrey, W.V. and Keener, S. (2018). ‘Body-worn Cameras and Officer Perceptions: A Mixed-method Pretest Posttest of Patrol Officers and Supervisors’, Journal of Crime and Justice 41 (5): 1–18.Search in Google Scholar

Penney, J.W. (2016). ‘Chilling Effects: Online Surveillance and Wikipedia Use’, Berkeley Technology & Law Journal 31 (1): 118–182.Search in Google Scholar

Penney, J.W. (2017). ‘Internet surveillance, regulation, and Chilling Effects Online: A Comparative Case Study’, Internet Policy Review 6 (2): 1–39.Search in Google Scholar

Pettit, P. (1989). ‘Consequentialism and Respect for Persons’, Ethics 100 (1): 116–126.Search in Google Scholar

Rachels, J. (1975). ‘Why Privacy is Important’, Philosophy & Public Affairs 4 (4): 323–333.Search in Google Scholar

Ready, J.T. and Young, J.T.N. (2015). ‘The Impact of On-officer Video Cameras on Police–citizen Contacts: Findings from a Controlled Experiment in mesa, AZ’, Journal of Experimental Criminology 11 (3): 445–458.Search in Google Scholar

Richards, P., Roberts, D., Britton, M., and Roberts, N. (2018). ‘The Exploration of Body-Worn Video to Accelerate the Decision Making Skills of Police Officers within an Experiential Learning Environment’, Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 12 (1): 43–49.Search in Google Scholar

Rickless, S.C. (2007). ‘The Right to Privacy Unveiled’, San Diego Law Review 44 (1): 773–799.Search in Google Scholar

Ryberg, J. (2007). ‘Privacy rights, Crime prevention, CCTV, and the Life of Mrs Aremac’, Res Publica 13 (2): 127–143.Search in Google Scholar

Schauer, F. (1978). ‘Fear, Risk and the First Amendment: Unravelling the Chilling Effect’, Boston University Law Review 58 (5): 685–732.Search in Google Scholar

Singer, P. (2009). The Life You Can Save (London: Picador).Search in Google Scholar

Stalcup, M. and Hahn, C. (2016). ‘Cops, Cameras, and the Policing of Ethics’, Theoretical Criminology 20 (4): 482–501.Search in Google Scholar

Stanley, J. (2015). ‘Police Body-Mounted Cameras: with Right Policies in place, a Win for All (V2.0)’, American Civil Liberties Union, (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Stoycheff, E., Liu, J., Xu, K., and Wibowo, K. (2019). ‘Privacy and the Panopticon: Online Mass Surveillance’s Deterrence and Chilling Effects’, New Media & Society 21 (3): 602–619.Search in Google Scholar

Thomson, J.J. (1975). ‘The Right to Privacy’, Philosophy & Public Affairs 4 (4): 295–314.Search in Google Scholar

Unger, P. (1996). Living High and Letting Die (Oxford: Oxford University Press).Search in Google Scholar

Wall, E. (2011). ‘Privacy and the Moral Right to Personal Autonomy’, International Journal of Applied Philosophy 25 (1): 69–85.Search in Google Scholar

White, M.D., Gaub, J.E., and Todak, N. (2018). ‘Exploring the Potential for Body-Worn Cameras to Reduce Violence in Police–Citizen Encounters’, Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 12 (1): 66–76.Search in Google Scholar

Yokum, D., Ravishankar, A., and Coppock, A. (2017). ‘Evaluating the Effects of Police Body-Worn Cameras: A Randomized Controlled Trial’, Office of the City Administrator. (accessed on January 10, 2020)Search in Google Scholar

Yokum, D., Ravishankar, A., and Coppock, A. (2019). ‘A Randomized Control Trial Evaluating the Effects of Police Body-worn Cameras’, PNAS 116 (21): 10329–10332.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2020-06-20
Published in Print: 2020-05-26

© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston