Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published online by De Gruyter November 29, 2022

The Irrationality of Stand Your Ground: Game Theory on Self-Defense

  • Carlos Santana ORCID logo EMAIL logo , Adam C. Smith , Kathryn Petrozzo and Derek Halm

Abstract

US law continues its historical trend of growing more permissive towards actors who engage in violent action in purported self-defense. We draw on some informal game theory to show why this is strategically irrational and suggest rolling back self-defense doctrines like stand your ground to earlier historical precedents like duty to retreat.


Corresponding author: Carlos Santana, Department of Philosophy, University of Utah, 215 S Central Campus Dr., 4th Floor, Salt Lake City, UT 84112, USA, E-mail:

References

ACLED. 2020. Demonstrations & Political Violence in America: New Data for Summer 2020. Armed Conflict Location and Event Data Project. Also available at https://acleddata.com/2020/09/03/demonstrations-political-violence-in-america-new-data-for-summer-2020/.Search in Google Scholar

Alvarez, L. 2013. “In Zimmerman Case, Self-Defense Was Hard to Topple.” New York Times. July 14, 2013. Also available at https://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/15/us/in-zimmerman-case-self-defense-was-hard-to-topple.html.Search in Google Scholar

Associated Press (AP). 1985. “Goetz Pulled Gun on Muggers Before, Lawyer Says.” Associated Press. Feb 8, 1985. Also available at https://www.nytimes.com/1985/02/08/nyregion/goetz-pulled-gun-on-muggers-before-lawyer-says.html.Search in Google Scholar

Bailey, A. 2021. “‘Stand Your Ground’ Bill Clears Senate.” Arkansas Times. Also available at https://arktimes.com/arkansas-blog/2021/01/19/stand-your-ground-bill-clears-senate.Search in Google Scholar

Benbaji, Y. 2005. “Culpable Bystanders, Innocents Threats, and the Ethics of Self-Defense.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 585: 623–40, https://doi.org/10.1080/00455091.2005.10716603.Search in Google Scholar

Blackstone, W. 1979. Commentaries on the Laws of England, Volume 4: A Facsimile of the First Edition of 1765–1769, Vol. 4. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.10.7208/chicago/9780226163277.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Brown, R. M. 1994. No Duty to Retreat: Violence and Values in American History and Society. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press.Search in Google Scholar

Brown-Long, C. 2019. “Opinion: I Was Jailed for My Trafficker’s Death. I’m Free Now—But Other Women Languish.” The Washington Post. Also available at https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/i-was-jailed-for-my-traffickers-death-im-free-now–but-other-women-languish/2019/12/24/78583142-25aa-11ea-9c21-2c2a4d2c2166_story.html.Search in Google Scholar

Capehart, J. 2013. “Five Myths about the Killing of Trayvon Martin.” The Washington Post. July 3, 2013. Also available at https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-the-killing-of-trayvon-martin/2013/07/03/0d76c176-e368-11e2-80eb-3145e2994a55_story.html.Search in Google Scholar

Coates, T. 2012. “Stand Your Ground and Vigilante Justice.” The Atlantic. March 22, 2012. Also available at https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/stand-your-ground-and-vigilante-justice/254900/.Search in Google Scholar

Condon, B. 2020. “Kenosha Shooter’s Defense Portrays Him as ‘American Patriot’.” Associated Press. 24 September 2020. Also available at https://www.denverpost.com/2020/09/24/kenosha-kyle-rittenhouse-american-patriot-defense/.Search in Google Scholar

Crisafi, D. 2016. “No Ground to Stand upon? Exploring the Legal, Gender, and Racial Implications of Stand Your Ground Laws in Cases of Intimate Partner Violence.” PhD diss., University of Central Florida. Also available at http://purl.fcla.edu/fcla/etd/CFE0006090.Search in Google Scholar

DeMillo, A. 2021. “Arkansas Governor Signs Stand Your Ground Bill into Law.” AP. March 3, 2021. Also available at https://apnews.com/article/arkansas-legislature-asa-hutchinson-770d5d3402e0075501042c1bb1a571a0.Search in Google Scholar

Dixit, A. K., S. Skeath, and D. H. Reiley. 2015. Games of Strategy, 4th ed. New York: W. W. Norton.Search in Google Scholar

Draper, K. 2009. “Defense.” Philosophical Studies 145: 69–88, https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-009-9387-5.Search in Google Scholar

Farrington, B. 2020. “Florida Governor Seeks New Penalties for Violent Protesters.” AP. Sep 21, 2020. Also available at https://apnews.com/article/florida-legislation-archive-ron-desantis-2ab026883ef33198db71f7057d367baa.Search in Google Scholar

Fearnow, B. 2021. “Republicans Push Anti-protest Laws in 25 States, Protect Drivers Who Hit Demonstrators.” Newsweek. February 20, 2021. Also available at https://www.newsweek.com/republicans-push-anti-protest-laws-25-states-protect-drivers-who-hit-demonstrators-1570767.Search in Google Scholar

Fein, E. 1985. “Angry Citizens in Many Cities Supporting Goetz.” New York Times. Jan 7, 1985. Also available at https://www.nytimes.com/1985/01/07/nyregion/angry-citizens-in-many-cities-supporting-goetz.html.Search in Google Scholar

Ferzan, K. 2019. “Stand Your Ground.” In The Palgrave Handbook of Applied Ethics and the Criminal Law, edited by L. Alexander, and K. K. Ferzan, 731–49. New York: Springer.10.1007/978-3-030-22811-8_31Search in Google Scholar

Finkelstein, C. 2001. “A Puzzle about Hobbes on Self-Defense.” Pacific Philosophical Quarterly 82 (3–4): 332–61, https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0114.00131.Search in Google Scholar

Franks, M. A. 2013. “Real Men Advance, Real Women Retreat: Stand Your Ground, Battered Women’s Syndrome, and Violence as Male Privilege.” University of Miami Law Review 68: 1099.Search in Google Scholar

Giffords Law Center. 2021. “Stand Your Ground.” Also available at https://giffords.org/lawcenter/gun-laws/policy-areas/guns-in-public/stand-your-ground-laws/.Search in Google Scholar

Golosov, M., M. Troshkin, A. Tsyvinski, and M. Weinzierl. 2013. “Preference Heterogeneity and Optimal Capital Income Taxation.” Journal of Public Economics 97: 160–75, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2012.10.006.Search in Google Scholar

Guettabi, M., and A. Munasib. 2018. “Stand Your Ground Laws, Homicides and Gun Deaths.” Regional Studies 52 (9): 1250–60, https://doi.org/10.1080/00343404.2017.1371846.Search in Google Scholar

Gueth, W. 2017. “Mechanism Design and the Law.” In The Oxford Handbook of Law and Economics: Methodology and Concepts, Vol. 1, edited by F. Parisi, 483–93. New York: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Heller, K. J. 1998. “Beyond the Reasonable Man – A Sympathetic but Critical Assessment of the Use of Subjective Standards of Reasonableness in Self-Defense and Provocation Cases.” American Journal of Criminal Law 26: 1.Search in Google Scholar

Hereth, B. 2018. “Why It’s Wrong to Stand Your Ground.” Philosophy in the Contemporary World 24 (1): 40–50, https://doi.org/10.5840/pcw20172414.Search in Google Scholar

Hobbes, T. [1651] 1996. Leviathan, edited by R. Tuck. New York: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Hurd, H. 2016. “Stand Your Ground.” In The Ethics of Self-Defense, edited by C. Coons, and M. Weber, 254–73. New York: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780190206086.003.0013Search in Google Scholar

Jackson, B. L. 2015. “No Ground on Which to Stand: Revise Stand Your Ground Laws So Survivors of Domestic Violence Are No Longer Incarcerated for Defending Their Lives.” Berkeley Journal of Gender Law and Justice 30: 154.Search in Google Scholar

Kotowitz, Y. 1989. “Moral Hazard.” In Allocation, Information and Markets, edited by P. Newman, J. Eatwell, and M. Milgate, 207–13. London: Palgrave Macmillan.10.1007/978-1-349-20215-7_21Search in Google Scholar

Lagstein, A. 2014. “Beyond the George Zimmerman Trial: The Duty to Retreat and Those Who Contribute to Their Own Need to Use Deadly Self-Defense.” Harvard Journal of Racial and Ethnic Justice 30: 367.Search in Google Scholar

Lave, T. 2013. “Shoot to Kill: Critical Look at Stand Your Ground Laws.” University of Miami Law Review 67 (4): 827–60.Search in Google Scholar

Lee, J. S., R. O’Harrow, and E. Samuels. 2020. “Kenosha: How Two Men’s Paths Crossed in an Encounter that Has Divided the Nation.” The Washington Post. Nov 19, 2020. Also available at https://www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2020/11/19/kenosha-shooting-kyle-rittenhouse-interview/.Search in Google Scholar

Leverick, F. 2006. Killing in Self-Defence. New York: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199283460.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Light, C. E. 2017. Stand Your Ground: A History of America’s Love Affair with Lethal Self-Defense. Boston: Beacon Press.Search in Google Scholar

Locke, J. [1689] 1980. Second Treatise on Civil Government, edited by C. B. Macpherson. Indianapolis: Hackett.Search in Google Scholar

Mack, T. 2016. “Elbow Room for Self-Defense.” Social Philosophy and Policy 322: 18–39, https://doi.org/10.1017/S0265052516000091.Search in Google Scholar

McClellan, C., and E. Tekin. 2017. “Stand Your Ground Laws, Homicides, and Injuries.” Journal of Human Resources 52 (3): 621–53, https://doi.org/10.3368/jhr.52.3.0613-5723r2.Search in Google Scholar

Myerson, R. B. 2008. “Mechanism Design.” In The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, edited by M. Vernengo, E. P. Caldentey, and B. J. Rosser London: Palgrave Macmillan.10.1057/978-1-349-95121-5_2675-1Search in Google Scholar

People v. Goetz. 1986. Court of Appeals of New York, 497 N.E.2d 41 (N.Y. 1986).Search in Google Scholar

Rodgers, B. 2020. “Utah Bill Would Create Criminal Defense for Drivers Who Hit, Kill Protesters During a Riot.” Salt Lake Tribune. Nov 17, 2020. Also avilable at https://www.sltrib.com/news/politics/2020/11/17/utah-bill-would-create/.Search in Google Scholar

Rodin, D. 2002. War and Self-Defense. New York: Oxford University Press.10.1093/0199257744.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Rosen, R. A. 1992. “On Self-Defense, Imminence, and Women Who Kill Their Batterers.” North Carolina Law Review 71: 371.Search in Google Scholar

Rosenberg, G. 2021. “Ohio Governor Signs ‘Stand Your Ground’ Law After Suggesting He’d Veto It.” NPR. Also available at https://www.npr.org/2021/01/04/953405793/ohio-governor-signs-stand-your-ground-law-after-suggesting-hed-veto-it.Search in Google Scholar

Ross, L. P. 2007. “Transmogrification of Self-Defense by National Rifle Association-Inspired Statutes: From the Doctrine of Retreat to the Right to Stand Your Ground.” Southern University Law Review 35: 1.Search in Google Scholar

Sanchirico, C. W. 1997. “The Burden of Proof in Civil Litigation: A Simple Model of Mechanism Design.” International Review of Law and Economics 17 (3): 431–47, https://doi.org/10.1016/s0144-8188(97)00020-3.Search in Google Scholar

Shivaram, D. 2021. “Rittenhouse’s Defense Renews Focus on the Case of a 17-Year-Old Who Killed Her Abuser.” NPR. Also available at https://www.npr.org/2021/11/22/1057976496/rittenhouse-verdict-chrystul-kizer-self-defense.Search in Google Scholar

Sreedhar, S. 2008. “Defending the Hobbesian Right to Self-Defense.” Political Theory 36 (6): 781–802, https://doi.org/10.1177/0090591708323366.Search in Google Scholar

Steinbuch, Y. 2020. “Attorney for Accused Killer Kyle Rittenhouse Releases Video in Self-Defense Claim.” New York Post. Sep 23, 2020. Also available at https://nypost.com/2020/09/23/kyle-rittenhouse-attorney-releases-video-in-self-defense-claim/.Search in Google Scholar

Sweeney, D. 2015. “Standing Up to Stand Your Ground Laws: How the Modern NRA-Inspired Self-Defense Statutes Destroy the Principle of Necessity, Disrupt the Criminal Justice System and Increase Overall Violence.” Cleveland State Law Review 64: 715.Search in Google Scholar

Tarm, M., S. Bauer, and A. Forliti. 2021. “Jury Finds Rittenhouse Not Guilty in Kenosha Shootings.” Associated Press. November 19, 2021. Also available at https://apnews.com/article/jury-finds-kyle-rittenhouse-not-guilty-in-kenosha-shootings-27f812ba532d65c044617483c915e4de.Search in Google Scholar

Thompson, A. C. 2008a. “Conyers Responds to Revelations on Katrina Crimes.” ProPublica. Also available at https://www.propublica.org/article/conyers-responds-to-revelations-on-katrina-crimes-1218.Search in Google Scholar

Thompson, A. C. 2008b. “Post-Katrina, White Vigilantes Shot African-Americans with Impunity.” ProPublica. Also available at https://www.propublica.org/article/post-katrina-white-vigilantes-shot-african-americans-with-impunity.Search in Google Scholar

Thomson, J. J. 1991. “Self-Defense.” Philosophy and Public Affairs 20: 283–310.Search in Google Scholar

Tunick, M. 2014. “John Locke and the Right to Bear Arms.” History of Political Thought 35 (1): 50–69.Search in Google Scholar

Uniacke, S. 1994. Permissible Killing. New York: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511554483Search in Google Scholar

Uniacke, S. 2000. “In Defence of Permissible Killing.” Law and Philosophy 19: 627–33, https://doi.org/10.2307/3505214.Search in Google Scholar

Weaver, Z. L. 2008. “Florida’s Stand Your Ground Law: The Actual Effects and the Need for Clarification.” University of Miami Law Review 63 (1): 395–430.Search in Google Scholar

Wheatcroft, M. 1998. “Duty to Retreat for Cohabitants—In New Jersey a Battered Spouse’s Home is Not Her Castle.” Rutgers Law Journal 30: 539.Search in Google Scholar

Zhu, M. 2014. “College Admissions in China: A Mechanism Design Perspective.” China Economic Review 30: 618–31, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chieco.2013.08.006.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2022-11-29

© 2022 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 3.2.2023 from https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/mopp-2022-0007/html
Scroll Up Arrow