Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter August 20, 2021

Burckhardt’s Silence and Nietzsche

  • Manfred Posani Löwenstein EMAIL logo
From the journal Nietzsche-Studien


The first part of this article questions the authenticity of one of the most quoted and allegedly reliable sources in the Burckhardt-Nietzsche debate. After having pointed out who was interested in manipulating this source and why, it will go back to the original issue of Burckhardt’s “silence.” This time, though, the question is going to be tackled from a different angle: not what Burckhardt thought about Nietzsche; rather, what did Nietzsche think about Burckhardt’s silence. The claims I will raise in this respect are two: 1) Nietzsche is the first interpreter of Burckhardt’s silence; 2) Burckhardt’s silence, far from being a mere private issue, became an elaborate theme of Nietzsche’s mature philosophy.


Bernoulli, Carl Albrecht: Franz Overbeck und Friedrich Nietzsche: Eine Freundschaft, 2 vols., Jena 1908Search in Google Scholar

Bertrand, Joseph: “Blaise Pascal: Les Provinciales,” Revue des Deux Mondes 101 (1890), 5–56Search in Google Scholar

Diethe, Carol: Nietzsche’s Sister and The Will to Power: A Biography of Elisabeth Förster-Nietzsche, Urbana, IL 2003Search in Google Scholar

Gossman, Lionel: Basel in the Age of Burckhardt: A Study in Unseasonable Ideas, Chicago 2000Search in Google Scholar

Heller, Erich: “Burckhardt and Nietzsche,” in The Importance of Nietzsche: Ten Essays, Chicago 1988, 39–54Search in Google Scholar

Heller, Erich: The Disinherited Mind, London 1952Search in Google Scholar

Hinde, John R.: Jacob Burckhardt and the Crisis of Modernity, Montreal 2000Search in Google Scholar

Jensen, Anthony K.: An Interpretation of Nietzsche’s “On the Uses and Disadvantage of History for Life”, New York 201610.4324/9781315746074Search in Google Scholar

Large, Duncan: “‘Our Greatest Teacher’: Nietzsche, Burckhardt, and the Concept of Culture,” International Studies in Philosophy 32/3 (2000), 3–2310.5840/intstudphil200032337Search in Google Scholar

Löwith, Karl: “Jacob Burckhardt: Der Mensch inmitten der Geschichte,” in Sämtliche Schriften, vol. 7, ed. Klaus Stichweh, Stuttgart 1984, 39–36210.1007/978-3-476-03168-6_2Search in Google Scholar

Marmor, Max: “Altered States: A Bibliographical Note on Censorship in the Nietzsche Archive,” The Yale University Library Gazette 72/1.2 (1997), 54–67Search in Google Scholar

Martin, Alfred von: Nietzsche und Burckhardt: Zwei geistige Welten im Dialog, Munich 1947Search in Google Scholar

Montinari, Mazzino: “Die geschwärzten Stellen in C. A. Bernoulli: Friedrich Nietzsche und Franz Overbeck: Eine Freundschaft,Nietzsche-Studien 6 (1977), 300–2810.1515/9783112418987-016Search in Google Scholar

Montinari, Mazzino: Su Nietzsche, Rome 1981Search in Google Scholar

Müller, Enrico: Die Griechen im Denken Nietzsches, Berlin 200510.1515/9783110921939Search in Google Scholar

Ponton, Olivier: Nietzsche: Philosophie de la légèreté, Berlin 200810.1515/9783110204322Search in Google Scholar

Posani Löwenstein, Manfred: Burckhardt e Nietzsche: Cinque Studi, Pisa 2017Search in Google Scholar

Regent, Nikola: “A ‘Wondrous Echo’: Burckhardt, Renaissance and Nietzsche’s Political Thought,” in Herman W. Siemens / Vasti Roodt (eds.),Nietzsche, Power and Politics: Rethinking Nietzsche’s Legacy for Political Thought, Berlin 2008, 629–6510.1515/9783110217339.7.629Search in Google Scholar

Ruehl, Martin A.: “‘An Uncanny Re-Awakening’. Nietzsche’s Renascence of the Renaissance out of the Spirit of Jacob Burckhardt,” in Manuel Dries (ed.), Nietzsche on Time and History, Berlin 2008, 231–7110.1515/9783110210460.4.231Search in Google Scholar

Salin, Edgar: Jacob Burckhardt und Nietzsche, Basel 1938Search in Google Scholar

Sigurdson, Richard: Jacob Burckhardt’s Social and Political Thought, Toronto 200410.3138/9781442676367Search in Google Scholar

Walter-Busch, Emil: Burckhardt und Nietzsche im Revolutionszeitalter, Munich 201210.30965/9783846753330_015Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2021-08-20
Published in Print: 2021-08-18

© 2021 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 23.3.2023 from
Scroll Up Arrow