Skip to content
BY 4.0 license Open Access Published by De Gruyter Open Access March 5, 2019

Productivity, nutrient balance, and economics of monsoon rice under different nutrient management practices in two agro-ecological zones of Bangladesh

  • M.A.H.S. Jahan , Akbar Hossain EMAIL logo , Jagadish Timsina , M.A.R. Sarkar , M. Salim , M. Farooq , Shilpi Das , A.K. Chaki and M.M. Hossain
From the journal Open Agriculture


Inherently poor soil fertility and non-adoption of fertilizer recommendations based on soil test and yield targets by farmers limit the productivity and profitability from monsoon rice in Bangladesh and much of South Asia. In the Level Barind Tract (LBT; AEZ-25) and the High Ganges River Floodplain (HGR; AEZ-11) agro-ecological zones (AEZs) of Bangladesh, monsoon (aman/kharif) season transplanted rainfed rice (known as T. aman rice) is grown in large areas after maize, wheat and/or mungbeans, with residues of each crop removed from the field after grain harvest. This results in lower grain yield and lower profits in these AEZs as compared with other AEZs. Nutrient management, based on soil test, yield targets, or integrated use of inorganics and organics for each AEZ together with retention of crop residue, has the potential to increase rice yield, reduce production cost and increase income. With this hypothesis, this study was conducted to determine the optimum nutrient management practices for achieving higher yield, maintaining apparent soil nutrient balance, and obtaining high profits from monsoon rice. Twelve nutrient management options were evaluated, of which the first six were: (i) 80-16-44-12-2 kg ha-1 of N, P, K, S, Zn respectively for a high yield goal (T1; ‘HYG’); (ii) 56-12-32-8- 1.5 kg ha-1 respectively for a medium yield goal (T2; ‘MYG’); (iii) 65-13-32-9-2 kg ha-1 respectively plus 5 t ha-1 cowdung as integrated plant nutrient management system (T3, ‘IPNS’); (iv) 67-14-41-9-2 kg ha-1 respectively as a soil test-based fertilizer management strategy (T4; ‘STB’); (v) 40-9-11-0-0 kg ha-1 respectively as per farmers’ practice (T5; ‘FP’) and (vi) 0-0-0-0-0 kg ha-1 as a control (T6; ‘CON’). The remaining six treatments were the same as above but each also included the crop residue incorporation (CRI), i.e., (vii) T7, ‘HYG+CRI’; (viii) T8, ‘MYG+CRI’; (ix) T9, ‘IPNS+CRI’; (x) T10, ‘STB+CRI’; (xi) T11 ‘FP’+CRI’; and (xii) T12, ‘CON+CRI’. In both AEZs, STB plus CRI resulted in the highest rice yield (p≤0.05) followed by ‘STB’ and ‘IPNS+CRI’. In comparison with ‘FP’ and ‘CON’, each without CRI, balances were positive (p≤0.05) for P, S, Zn and B but were negative for N and K in ‘HYG’, ‘MYG’, ‘IPNS’ and ‘STB’ with or without CRI. In both AEZS, STB nutrient management had the highest (p≤0.05) net returns (526 & 487 US$ ha-1, respectively), highest benefit cost ratio (BCR; 3.54 & 3.36) and highest marginal benefit cost ratio (MBCR; 10.47 & 10.19). These were followed by STB+CRI’ and ‘IPNS’, while they were lowest (p≤0.05) for CON and FP. We recommend that nutrient application, based on soil test with incorporation of mungbean residue, followed by IPNS, could be the best strategies for achieving high yield, improving soil fertility and for fetching a higher profit from monsoon rice in Bangladesh and similar soils and growing environments of South Asia.


Akhteruzzaman M., Mondal N.A., Ahammad K.U., Mahmud J.A., Jahan M.A.H.S., Integrated nutrient management for Wheat-Mungbean-T. aman rice cropping pattern in high Ganges river floodplain soil. Eco-friendly Agril. J., 2009, 2(1), 322-326Search in Google Scholar

Alam M.J., Humphreys E., Sarkar M.A.R., Yadav S., Intensification and diversification increase land and water productivity and profitability of rice-based cropping systems on the High Ganges River Floodplain of Bangladesh. Field Crops Res., 2017, 209, 10-26, in Google Scholar

Ali M.R., Costa D.J., Sayed M.A., Khan M.A.H., Abedin J.A., Development of fertilizer recommendation for the cropping pattern potato-boro-T. aman in irrigated medium high land condition under AEZ-9. Bangladesh J. Agril. Res., 2009, 34(1), 41-49, doi: 10.3329/bjar.v34i1.5751Search in Google Scholar

Awal M.A., Bhuiyan M.A.H., Rahman M.S., Ali M.R., Profitability of recommended fertilizer on Wheat-Jute-T. aman cropping pattern under irrigated condition. Bangladesh J. Agric. Environ., 2007, 3(1), 47-55Search in Google Scholar

Baruah A., Baruah K.K., Organic manures and crop residues as fertilizer substitutes: impact on nitrous oxide emission, plant growth and grain yield in pre-monsoon rice cropping system. J. Environ. Protect., 2015, 6, 755-770, doi: 10.4236/ jep.2015.67069Search in Google Scholar

Basak N.C., Quayyum M.A., Asaduzzaman S.M., Sultana N., Khan M.A.H., Integrated nutrient management in the Mustard-Boro rice-T. aman rice cropping system. Bangladesh J. Agril. Res., 2008, 33(1), 135-143Search in Google Scholar

Bhuiyan M.A.H., Evaluation of introducing mungbean into cereal based cropping pattern for sustainable soil fertility and productivity. Ph D Thesis. Dept. of Soil Science, Bangladesh Agricultural University, Mymensingh, 2004Search in Google Scholar

Chauhan B.S., Mahajan G., Sardana V., Timsina J., Jat M.L., Productivity and sustainability of the rice-wheat cropping system in the Indo-Gangetic Plains of the Indian subcontinent: problems, opportunities, and strategies. Adv. Agron., 2012, 117, 316-355, doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-394278-4.00006-4Search in Google Scholar

Damodar R.D., Subba Rao A., Sammi K.R., Takkar P.N., Yield sustainability and phosphorus utilization in soybean-wheat system on Vertisols in response to integrated use of manure and fertilizer phosphorus. Field Crops Res., 1999, 62, 181-19010.1016/S0378-4290(99)00019-2Search in Google Scholar

Das S., Ali M.M., Rahman M.H., Khan M.R., Hossain A., El Sabagh A., Barutcular C., Vasileva V., Soil test based with additional nutrients increased the fertility and productivity of Wheat─Mungbean─T.Aman rice cropping pattern in the High Ganges River Floodplain of Bangladesh. Bulgarian J. Agric. Sci., 2018, (6) (in press)Search in Google Scholar

Devi S., Gupta C., Jat S.L., Parmar M.S., Crop residue recycling for economic and environmental sustainability: The case of India. Open Agric., 2017, 2(1), 486-494, opag-2017-005310.1515/opag-2017-0053Search in Google Scholar

Dinkins C.P., Jones C., McVay K., Olson-Rutz R.O., Nutrient management in no-till and minimum till system. The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), Montana State University and Montana State University Extension, EB0182 revised, December 2014, < AgandNaturalResources/EB0182.pdf> (Accessed on 07 December 2018)Search in Google Scholar

Dobermann A., Witt C., Abdulrachman S., Gines H.C., Nagarajan R., Son T.T., Tan P.S., Wang G.H., Chien N.V., Thoa V.Y.K., Phung C.V., Stalin P., Muthukrishnan P., Ravi V., Babu M., Simbahan G.C., Adviento M.A.A., Soil fertility and indigenous nutrient supply in irrigated rice domains of Asia. Agron. J., 2003a, 95, 913-923, doi: 10.2134/agronj2003.9130Search in Google Scholar

Dobermann A., Witt C., Abdulrachman S., Gines H.C., Nagarajan R., Son T.T., Tan P.S., Wang G.H., Chien N.V., Thoa V.T.K., Phung C.V., Stalin P., Muthukrishnan P., Ravi V., Babu M., Simbahan G.C., Adviento M.A., Bartolome V., Estimating indigenous nutrient supplies for site specific nutrient management in irrigated rice. Agron. J., 2003b, 95, 924-935, doi: 10.2134/ agronj2003.9240Search in Google Scholar

Dobermann A., Nelson R., Beever D., Bergvinson D., Crowley E., Denning G., Giller K., Hughes J., d’Arros Jahn M., Lynam J., Masters W., Naylor R., Neath G., Onyido I., Remington T., Wright I., Zhang F., Solutions for sustainable agriculture and food systems. Technical report for the post-2015 development agenda, Sustainable Development Solutions Network, New York, 2013, pp-1-99, <’CON’tent/ uploads/2014/02/130919-TG07-Agriculture-Report-WEB.pdf> (Accessed on 07 December 2018)Search in Google Scholar

Fahad S., Ahmad K.M., Anjum M.A., Hussain S., The effect of micronutrients (B, Zn and Fe) foliar application on the growth, flowering and corm production of gladiolus (Gladiolus grandiflorus L.) in calcareous soils. J. Agr. Sci. Tech., 2014(16), 1671-1682Search in Google Scholar

Freeman K., Boron: A Key consideration in High Yield Systems, 2013, <’CON’siderationin- high-yield-systems> (Accessed on 07 December 2018)Search in Google Scholar

FRG (Fertilizer Recommendation Guide), Fertilizer Recommendation Guide-2012, Bangladesh Agricultural Research Council, Farmgate, Dhaka 1215, 2012, p. 274Search in Google Scholar

Hellevang K.J., Grain moisture content effects and management. Department of Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering, North Dakota State University, 1995, < plantsci/crops/ae905w.htm> (Accessed on 07 December 2018).Search in Google Scholar

Hossain M.S., Hossain A., Sarkar M.A.R., Jahiruddin M., Teixeira da Silva J.A., Israil Hossain M., Productivity and soil fertility of the rice-wheat system in the high Ganges River floodplain of Bangladesh is influenced by the inclusion of legumes and manure. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ., 2016, 218, 40-52, doi: 10.1016/j.agee.2015.11.017Search in Google Scholar

Hua K., Zhang W., Guo Z., Wanga D., Oenema O., Evaluating crop response and environmental impact of the accumulation of phosphorus due to long-term manuring of vertisol soil in northern China. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ., 2015, 219, 101-110, doi: 10.1016/j.agee.2015.12.008Search in Google Scholar

Jahan M.A.H.S., Sarkar M.A.R., Salim M., Nutrient management on leaf area index of potato-mungbean-T. aman rice cropping pattern. Bangladesh J. Agric. Res., 2014a, 39(3), 515-527, doi: 10.3329/bjar.v39i3.21994Search in Google Scholar

Jahan M.A.H.S., Sarkar M.A.R., Salim M., Islam N, Tiwari T.P., Total dry matter production of potato, mungbean and T. aman rice as influenced by nutrient management of potato-mungbean-T. aman rice cropping pattern. Bangladesh J. Agric. Res., 2014b, 39(2), 211-225, doi: 10.3329/bjar.v39i2.20416Search in Google Scholar

Jahan M.A.H.S., Hossain A., Sarkar M.A.R., Teixeira da Silva J.A., Ferdousi M.N.S., Productivity impacts and nutrient balances of an intensive potato-mungbean-rice crop rotation in multiple environments of Bangladesh. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ, 2016, 231(1), 79-97, in Google Scholar

Kavimadan S.K., Gupta J.P., Mahapatra I.C., Studies on residue management and biofertilizers in Rice-Wheat sequence. Indian J. Agron., 1987, 32(3), 278-279Search in Google Scholar

Khan M.A.H., Quayyum M.A., Choudhury D.A., Nazrul M.I., Ali M.R., Integrated nutrient management for Potato-T. Aus-T. aman rice cropping system. Bangladesh Agron. J., 2005, 11(1&2), 89-96Search in Google Scholar

Ladha J.K., Rao A.N., Raman A.K., Padre A.T., Dobermann A., Gathala M., Kumar V., Saharawat Y., Sharma S., Piepho H.P., Alam M.M., Liak R., Rajendran R., Reddy C.K., Parsad R., Sharma P.C., Singh S.S., Saha A., Noor S., Agronomic improvements can make future cereal systems in South Asia far more productive and result in a lower environmental footprint. Glob. Change Biol., 2016, 22, 1054-1074, doi: 10.1111/gcb.13143Search in Google Scholar

Lv S., Wang X., Liu G., A simple and reasonable calculation equation of balanced fertilization. Agron., 2015, 5(2), 180-187, doi:10.3390/agronomy5020180Search in Google Scholar

Mahajan A., Gupta R.D. (eds.), Balanced Use of Plant Nutrients: Integrated Nutrient Management (INM) in a Sustainable Rice-Wheat Cropping System. Springer, Dordrecht, 2009, doi. org/10.1007/978-1-4020-9875-8_810.1007/978-1-4020-9875-8_8Search in Google Scholar

Naser H.M., Basak N.C., Islam M.F., Effect of rice straw and chemical fertilizers on the productivity and economics of Boro rice-Transplanted Aman rice system. Online J. Biol. Sci., 2001, 1(9), 831-83410.3923/jbs.2001.831.834Search in Google Scholar

Noor M.A., Nitrogen management and regulation for optimum NUE in maize - A mini review. Cogent Food Agric., 2017, 3(1), 1348214, in Google Scholar

Panaullah G.M., Timsina J., Saleque M.A., Ishaque M., Pathan A.B.M.B.U., Connor D.J., Saha P.K., Quayyum M.A., Humphreys E., Meisner C.A., Nutrient uptake and apparent balances for rice-wheat sequences. III. Potassium. J. Plant Nutr., 2006, 29, 173-187, doi: 10.1080/01904160500416554Search in Google Scholar

R Core Team, R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria, 2013. ISBN 3-900051-07-0Search in Google Scholar

Saha P.K., Ishaque M., Saleque M.A., Miah M.A.M., Panaullah G.M., Bhuiyan N.I., Long-term integrated nutrient management for rice-based cropping pattern: effect on growth, yield, nutrient uptake, nutrient balance sheet, and soil fertility. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal., 2007, 38, 579-610, doi: 10.1080/00103620701215718Search in Google Scholar

Saidy A.R., Relationship between water content and mineralization of carbon and nitrogen in soils varying in physical and chemical characteristics. J. Trop. Soils., 2013, 18(1), 45-52, doi: 10.5400/jts.2012.18.1.45Search in Google Scholar

Saleque M.A., Timsina J., Panaulah G.M., Ishaque M., Pathan A.B.M.B.U., Quayyum M.A., Connor D.J., Saha P.K., Humphreys E., Meisner C.A., Nutrient uptake and balances for rice-wheat systems. II. Phosphorus. J. Plant Nutr., 2006, 28, 157-172, doi: 10.1080/01904160500416547Search in Google Scholar

Sapkota T.B., Jat M.L., Shankar V., Singh L.K., Rai M., Grewal M.S., Stifling C.M., Tillage, residue and nitrogen management effects on methane and nitrous oxide emission from rice-wheat system of Indian Northwest Indo-Gangetic Plains. J. Integr. Environ. Sci., 2015, 12(sup. 1), 31-46, doi: 10.1080/1943815X.2015.1110181Search in Google Scholar

Satapathy S.S., Swain D.K., Pasupalak S., Bhadoria P.B.S., Effect of elevated [CO2] and nutrient management on wet and dry season rice production in subtropical India. The Crop J., 2015, 3(6), 468-480, in Google Scholar

Singh V.K., Dwivedi B.S., Tiwari K.N., Majumdar K., Rani M., SinghSearch in Google Scholar

S.K., Timsina J., Optimizing nutrient management strategies for rice-wheat system in the Indo-Gangetic Plains of India and adjacent region for higher productivity, nutrient use efficiency and profits. Field Crops Res., 2014, 164, 30-44, doi: 10.1016/j. fcr.2014.05.007Search in Google Scholar

Singh Y., Singh B., Timsina J., Crop residue management for nutrient cycling and improving soil productivity in rice-based cropping systems in the tropics. Adv. Agron., 2005, 85, 269-407, doi: 10.1016/S0065-2113(04)85006-5Search in Google Scholar

Swarup A., Wanjari R.H., Three decades of All India Co-ordinated Research Project on Long-term Fertilizer Experiments to Study Changes in soil Quality, Crop Productivity and Sustainability. Bhopal: Indian Institute of Soil Science, 2001, <http://www.> ( on 29 September 2018)Search in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Can organic sources of nutrients increase crop yields to meet global food demand? Agronomy, 2018, 8, 1-20, doi:103390/agronomy8100214Search in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Connor D.J., Productivity and management of rice-wheat cropping systems: issues and challenges. Field Crops Res., 2001, 69, 93-13210.1016/S0378-4290(00)00143-XSearch in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Buresh R.J., Dobermann A., Dixon J., Rice-Maize Systems in Asia: Current Situation and Potential. IRRI and CIMMYT, Los Banos (Philippines), 2011, p.235Search in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Wolf J., Guilpart N., van Bussel L.G.J., Grassini P., van Wart J., Hossain A., Rashid H., Islam S., van Ittersum M.K., Can Bangladesh produce enough cereals to meet future demand? Agric. Syst., 2018, 163, 36-44, doi: 10.1016/j.agsy.2016.11.003Search in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Panaulah G.M., Saleque M.A., Ishaque M., Pathan A.B.M.B.U., Quayyum, M.A., Connor, D.J., Saha, P.K., Humphreys E., Meisner, C.A. (2006b). Nutrient uptake and apparent balances for Rice-Wheat sequences. I. Nitrogen. J. Plant Nutr., 2006b, 29, 137-15510.1080/01904160500416539Search in Google Scholar

Timsina J., Quayyum M.A., Connor D.J., Saleque M., Haq F., Panaullah M.G., Jahan M.A.H.S., Begum R.A., Effect of fertilizer and mungbean residue management on total productivity, soil fertility and N-use efficiency of intensified Rice-Wheat systems. Intl. J. Agric. Res., 2006a, 1(1), 41-52Search in Google Scholar

Whitbread A., Blair G., Naklang K., Lefroy R., Wonprasaid S., Konboon Y., Suriya Arunroj D., The management of rice straw, fertilizers and leaf litters in rice cropping systems in northeast Thailand. Plant Soil, 1999, 209(1), 29-36, doi:10.1023/A:1004519031550Search in Google Scholar

Zhang H., Xu M., Shi X., Li Z., Huang Q., Wang X., Rice yield, potassium uptake and balance under long-term fertilization in rice-based cropping systems in southern China. Nutr. Cycl. Agroecosyst., 2010, 88, 341-349, doi: 10.1007/s10705-010- 9359-3Search in Google Scholar

Zaman S.M., Amin M.R., Ali M.Y., Hossain M.A., Aktar S., Nutrient management in Boro-T. aman cropping system under high Ganges river floodplain soil. Bangladesh J. Agron. Environ., 2007a, 3(2), 55-63Search in Google Scholar

Zaman S.M., Amin M.R., Naher Q., Aktar S., Uddin M.K., Rahman M.S., Evaluation of different nutrient management packages in Sesame-T. aman cropping system under Ganges tidal floodplain. Intl. J. BioRes., 2007b, 2(4), 1-5Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2018-07-19
Accepted: 2018-12-17
Published Online: 2019-03-05

© by M.A.H.S. Jahan, et al., published by De Gruyter

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Public License.

Downloaded on 28.5.2023 from
Scroll to top button