Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter Oldenbourg November 20, 2023

Framing the Market: The Unexpected Commonalities between Karl Polanyi and the Ordoliberals

  • Erwin Dekker EMAIL logo
From the journal ORDO

Abstract

There has been a resurgence in scholarship on Karl Polanyi in recent years, against the backdrop of rising populism and critiques of globalization and financialization. In these works, Polanyi is typically portrayed as critic of the contested notion of ‘neoliberalism’. In this paper I demonstrate that, to the contrary, Polanyi’s Great Transformation (1944) shares many of the themes central to the contributions of the early neoliberals, specifically the ordoliberal thinkers. Polanyi and the ordoliberals did not only seek to analyze the origins of the same social crisis of the 1930 s and 40 s, but their analysis of the deficiencies of nineteenth-century liberalism as well as the subsequent disintegration through rapidly growing interventions in favor of powerful groups in society has much in common. This paper explores these similarities and demonstrates that they also extended to the way they perceived the responsibility of scientists as well as the interdependence of the various orders in society. It is argued that the ordoliberals, their fellow-traveler F. A. Hayek and Karl Polanyi all perceived the interdependence between the state, civil society and the market somewhat differently, but agreed on the need to conceptualize the relationship between the three. Finally, it is suggested that even the normative ideal of Karl Polanyi, the realization of ‘freedom in a complex society’, has important commonalities with the ordoliberal program: the protection of individual freedom from concentrated forms of power in society.

JEL Codes: A12; A13; B25; P48

Bibliography

Aulenbacher, Brigitte, Richard Bärnthaler, and Andreas Novy. 2019. “Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation, and Contemporary Capitalism.” Österreichische Zeitschrift für Soziologie 44 (2): 105–13. 10.1007/s11614-019-00341-8Search in Google Scholar

Becchio, Giandomenica. 2007. “The Early Debate on Economic Calculation in Vienna (1919–1925). The Heterodox Point of View: Neurath, Mises and Polanyi.” Storia Del Pensiero Economico 2 (November): 133–44.Search in Google Scholar

Beckert, Jens. 2009. “The Great Transformation of Embeddedness: Karl Polanyi and the New Economic Sociology.” In Market and Society, edited by Chris Hann and Keith Hart, 38–55. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511581380.003Search in Google Scholar

Berman, Sheri. 1997. “Civil Society and the Collapse of the Weimar Republic.” World Politics 49 (3): 401–29.10.1353/wp.1997.0008Search in Google Scholar

Block, Fred, and Margaret Somers. 2015. The Power of Market Fundamentalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Blyth, Mark, and Matthias Matthijs. 2017. “Black Swans, Lame Ducks, and the Mystery of IPE’s Missing Macroeconomy.” Review of International Political Economy 24 (2): 203–31. 10.1080/09692290.2017.1308417Search in Google Scholar

Bockman, Johanna, Ariane Fischer, David Woodruff, and Karl Polanyi. 2016. “‘Socialist Accounting’ by Karl Polanyi: With Preface ‘Socialism and the Embedded Economy.’” Theory and Society 45: 385–427. 10.1007/s11186-016-9276-9Search in Google Scholar

Böhm, Franz. 1937. Die Ordnung der Wirtschaft als geschichtliche Aufgabe und rechtschöpferische Leistung. Stuttgart: Verlag von W. Kohlhammer.Search in Google Scholar

Böhm, Franz, Walter Eucken, and Hans Grossmann-Doerth. 1989. “The Ordo Manifesto of 1936.” In Germany’s Social Market Economy, edited by Alan Peacock and Hans Wilgerodt, 15–26. London: Trade Policy Research Centre.10.1007/978-1-349-20145-7_2Search in Google Scholar

Brie, Michael. 2017. Karl Polanyi in Dialogue: A Socialist Thinker for Our Time. Berlin: Black Rose Books.Search in Google Scholar

Buğra, Ayşe, and Kaan Ağartan. 2007. Reading Karl Polanyi for the Twenty-First Century. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.10.1057/9780230607187Search in Google Scholar

Commun, Patricia, and Stefan Kolev. 2018. Wilhelm Röpke (1899–1966): A Liberal Political Economist and Conservative Social Philosopher. Springer.10.1007/978-3-319-68357-7Search in Google Scholar

Dale, Gareth. 2010. Karl Polanyi: Limits of the Market. London: John Wiley & Sons.Search in Google Scholar

. 2016. Karl Polanyi: A Life on the Left. New York: Columbia University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Dekker, Erwin. 2016. The Viennese Students of Civilization: The Meaning and Context of Austrian Economics Reconsidered. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781316411162Search in Google Scholar

Desan, Mathieu, and Gareth Dale. 2019. “Karl Polanyis Faschismustheorie.” In Die Soziologie und der Nationalsozialismus in Österreich, edited by Andreas Kranebitter and Christoph Reinprecht, 301–28. Bielefeld: Transcript Verlag.10.1515/9783839447338-014Search in Google Scholar

Dürr, Ernst-Wolfram. 1954. Wesen und Ziele des Ordoliberalismus. Winterthur: Verlag P. G. Keller.Search in Google Scholar

Dyson, Kenneth. 2021. Conservative Liberalism, Ordo-Liberalism, and the State. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. 10.1093/oso/9780198854289.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Eucken, Walter. 1932. “Staatliche Strukturwandlungen und die Krisis des Kapitalismus.” Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv 36: 297–321.Search in Google Scholar

. 1940. Die Grundlagen der Nationalökonomie. Jena: Verlag von Gustav Fischer.Search in Google Scholar

. 1989. “What Kind of Economic and Social System?” In Germany’s Social Market Economy: Origins and Evolution, 27–45. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Search in Google Scholar

Eucken, Walter, and Franz Böhm. 1948. “Vorwort: Die Aufgabe des Jahrbuchs.” Ordo: Jahrbuch für die Ordnung von Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft 1: vii-xi.Search in Google Scholar

Feld, Lars P., Ekkehard A. Köhler, and Daniel Nientiedt. 2021. “Ordoliberalism and the Social Market Economy,” Freiburger Diskussionspapiere zur Ordnungsökonomik 21/05, 23.Search in Google Scholar

Fèvre, Raphaël. 2021. A Political Economy of Power: Ordoliberalism in Context, 1932-1950. Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780197607800.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Goldschmidt, Nils, and Michael Wohlgemuth. 2008. “Social Market Economy: Origins, Meanings and Interpretations.” Constitutional Political Economy 19 (3): 261–76. 10.1007/s10602-008-9047-3Search in Google Scholar

Gray, John. 2000. Two Faces of Liberalism. New York: Polity Press.Search in Google Scholar

Grossekettler, Heinz G. 1994. “On Designing an Institutional Infrastructure for Economies: The Freiburg Legacy after 50 Years.” Journal of Economic Studies 21: 9–24. 10.1108/01443589410070761Search in Google Scholar

Hayek, Friedrich A. 1948. Individualism and Economic Order. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Search in Google Scholar

. 1988. The Collected Works of Friedrich August Hayek Vol I, The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism. Edited by W. W. Bartley III. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Horn, Karen. 2020. “Perpetuating Prejudice: The Difficult Relationship between German Ordoliberalism and Adam Smith.” History of Economic Ideas 28 (2): 97–133.Search in Google Scholar

Iber, Patrick and Mike Konczal. 2016. “Karl Polanyi for President.” Dissent, May 23.Search in Google Scholar

Kolev, Stefan. 2018. “Paleo- and Neoliberals: Ludwig von Mises and the ‘Ordo-Interventionists.’” In Wilhelm Röpke (1899–1966), edited by Patricia Commun and Stefan Kolev, 20:65–90. Cham: Springer International Publishing.10.1007/978-3-319-68357-7_5Search in Google Scholar

. 2021. “When Liberty Presupposes Order: F. A. Hayek’s Learning Ordoliberalism.” Freiburger Diskussionspapiere zur Ordnungsökonomik, no. 21/02.Search in Google Scholar

Kolev, Stefan, and Joachim Zweynert. 2019. “Approaches to Transformation in Economics.” In The Handbook of Political, Social, and Economic Transformation, edited by Wolfgang Merkel, Raj Kollmorgen, and Hans-Jürgen Wagener, 115–23. Oxford University Press.10.1093/oso/9780198829911.003.0011Search in Google Scholar

Kukathas, Chandran. 2003. The Liberal Archipelago: A Theory of Diversity and Freedom. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/019925754X.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Lacher, Hannes. 2019. “Karl Polanyi, the ‘Always-Embedded Market Economy,’ and the Re-Writing of The Great Transformation.” Theory and Society 48 (5): 671–707. 10.1007/s11186-019-09359-zSearch in Google Scholar

Mises, Ludwig von. 1977. A Critique of Interventionism. New York: Arlington House. Search in Google Scholar

Müller-Armack, Alfred. 1949. Diagnose unserer Gegenwart. Güterloh: C. Bertelsmann Verlag.Search in Google Scholar

North, Douglass C. 1977. “Markets and Other Allocation Systems in History: The Challenge of Karl Polanyi.” The Journal of European Economic History 6: 703–16.Search in Google Scholar

Oliver, Henry M. 1960. “German Neoliberalism.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 74 (1): 117–49.10.2307/1884137Search in Google Scholar

Polanyi, Karl. 1945. Origins of Our Time: The Great Transformation. London: Victor Gollancz.Search in Google Scholar

. 1947. “Our Obsolete Market Mentality: Civilization Must Find a New Thought Pattern.” Commentary 3: 109–17.Search in Google Scholar

. 1971. “Carl Menger’s Two Meanings of ‘Economic.’” Studies in Economic Anthropology 7: 16–24.Search in Google Scholar

. 2014. “Economics and the Freedom to Shape Our Social Destiny.” In For A New West: Essays, edited by Giorgio Resta and Mariavittoria Catanzariti, 33–38. Cambridge, UK: Polity.Search in Google Scholar

. 2016. Karl Polanyi: The Hungarian Writings. Edited by Gareth Dale. Manchester University Press.Search in Google Scholar

. 2018 a. Economy and Society: Selected Writings. Edited by Michele Cangiani and Thomas Thomasberger. Cambridge, UK: Polity. Search in Google Scholar

. 2018 b. “The Economy as Instituted Process.” In The Sociology of Economic Life, edited by Mark Granovetter and Richard Swedberg, 3–21. London: Routledge.Search in Google Scholar

Polanyi, Michael. 1958. Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.Search in Google Scholar

Polanyi-Levitt, Kari, and Marguerite Mendell. 1987 a. “Karl Polanyi: His Life and Times.” Studies in Political Economy 22: 7–39.Search in Google Scholar

. 1987 b. “Karl Polanyi: His Life and Times.” Studies in Political Economy 22: 7–39.10.1080/19187033.1987.11675572Search in Google Scholar

Rieter, Heinz, and Matthias Schmolz. 1993. “The Ideas of German Ordo-Liberalism 1938-45: Pointing the Way to a New Economic Order.” The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought 1 (1): 87–114.10.1080/10427719300000064Search in Google Scholar

Rodrigues, João. 2013. “Between Rules and Incentives: Uncovering Hayek’s Moral Economy.” American Journal of Economics and Sociology 72: 565–92. 10.1111/ajes.12018Search in Google Scholar

Röpke, Wilhelm. 1942. “A Value Judgment on Value Judgments.” Revue de la Faculte des Sciences economiques d’Istanbul 3 (1–2): 1–19.Search in Google Scholar

. 1947. Das Kulturideal des Liberalismus. Frankfurt am Mainz: Verlag G. Schulte-Bulmke.Search in Google Scholar

. 1948. Die Gesellschftskrisis der Gegenwart. Erlenbach: Rentsch.Search in Google Scholar

. 1950. The Social Crisis of Our Time. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.Search in Google Scholar

. 1960. A Humane Economy: The Social Framework of the Free Market. Chicago: Henry Regnery Company.Search in Google Scholar

Rothbard, Murray N. 1961. “Down With Primitivism: A Thorough Critique of Polanyi.” New York.Search in Google Scholar

Rüstow, Alexander. 1945. Das Versagen des Wirtschaftsliberalismus als religiongeschichtes Problem. Zürich: Europa Verlag.Search in Google Scholar

Sally, Razeen. 1996. “Ordoliberalism and the Social Market: Classical Political Economy from Germany.” New Political Economy 1 (2): 233–57. 10.1080/13563469608406254Search in Google Scholar

Sayer, Andrew. 2007. “Foreword.” In Reading Karl Polanyi for the Twenty-First Century, edited by Ayşe Buğran and Kaan Ağartan, ix-xi. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.Search in Google Scholar

Somers, Margaret, and Fred Block. 2014. “The Return of Karl Polanyi.” Dissent 61 (2): 30–33.10.1353/dss.2014.0027Search in Google Scholar

Streeck, Wolfgang. 2016. How Will Capitalism End? London: Verso Books.Search in Google Scholar

Streissler, Erich. 1972. “To What Extent Was the Austrian School Marginalist?” History of Political Economy 4: 426–41.10.1215/00182702-4-2-426Search in Google Scholar

Thomasberger, Claus, and Michael Brie. 2019. “Karl Polanyi’s Search for Freedom in a Complex Society.” Österreichische Zeitschrift für Soziologie 44 (2): 169–82. 10.1007/s11614-019-00333-8Search in Google Scholar

Vanberg, Viktor J. 2015. “Ordoliberalism, Ordnungspolitik, and the Reason of Rules.” European Review of International Studies 2 (3): 27–36.10.3224/eris.v2i3.23446Search in Google Scholar

Woodruff, David M. 2017. “Ordoliberalism, Polanyi, and the Theodicy of Markets.” In Ordoliberalism, Law and the Rule of Economics, edited by J. Hien and Christian Joerges, 215–27. London: Hart Publishing.Search in Google Scholar

Zweig, Konrad. 1980. The Origins of The German Social Market Economy: The Leading Ideas and Their Intellectual Roots. London: Adam Smith Institute.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2023-11-20
Published in Print: 2023-11-01

© 2023 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Downloaded on 23.2.2024 from https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/ordo-2023-2003/html
Scroll to top button