Abstract
This paper analyzes the determinants of case disposition times in Belgian first instance courts by exploiting a unique dataset of 174 court cases. Unlike previous studies, our analysis focuses mainly on case-level determinants. Regression results show that the use of expert assessments on average prolongs overall disposition time by 902 days. Furthermore, the number of pleadings, as a proxy of case complexity, also significantly impacts the duration of trials. Additionally, results indicate that case outcomes, such as settlements or plaintiff wins, are significant determinants of case duration. In addition to case-level characteristics, our results indicate that two civil procedure reforms aimed at accelerating adjudication led to a major decrease of case duration in Belgian first instance courts.
References
Belgian High Council of Justice. 2010. “Belgische justitiebarometer 2010.” http://www.belgium.be/nl/publicaties/publ_jus titiebarometer-2010.jsp.Search in Google Scholar
Buscaglia, E. , M.Dakolias, W.B.Legal and J.R.Unit. 1999. Comparative International Study of Court Performance Indicators: A Descriptive and Analytical Account. World Bank.Search in Google Scholar
Buscaglia, E., and T.Ulen. 1997. “A Quantitative Assessment of the Efficiency of the Judicial Sector in Latin America,” 17International Review of Law & Economics275.Search in Google Scholar
Christensen, R.K., and J.Szmer. 2012. “Examining the Efficiency of the U.S. Courts of Appeals: Pathologies and Prescriptions,” 32International Review of Law and Economics30–37.Search in Google Scholar
Di Vita, G. 2010. “Production of Laws and Delays in Court Decisions,” 30International Review of Law and Economics276–281.Search in Google Scholar
Di Vita, G. 2012. “Factors Determining the Duration of Legal Disputes: An Empirical Analysis with Micro Data,” 168Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics-Zeitschrift Fur Die Gesamte Staatswissenschaft563–587.Search in Google Scholar
Djankov, S. , R.La Porta, F.Lopez-de-Silanes and A.Shleifer. 2003. “Courts,” 118Quarterly Journal of Economics453–517.Search in Google Scholar
European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice. 2006. “Length of court proceedings in the member states of the Council of Europe based on the case law of the European Court of Human Rights,” Strasbourg.Search in Google Scholar
European Court of Human Rights, statistics, http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Stats_violation_1959_2012_ENG.pdf.Search in Google Scholar
Goerdt, J.A. 1992. Divorce Courts Case Management, Case Characteristics, and the Pace of Litigation in 16 Urban Jurisdictions. Williamsburg, VA: National Center for State Courts.Search in Google Scholar
Heise, M. 2000. “Justice Delayed?: An Empirical Analysis of Civil Case Disposition Time,” 50Case Western Reserve Law Review813–849.Search in Google Scholar
Jiang, Q.-Y. 2006. Court Delay and Law Enforcement in China: Civil Process and Economic Perspective. Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitäts-Verlag.Search in Google Scholar
Lysens, T., and L.Naudts. 2010. Deskundigenonderzoek in Burgerlijke Zaken. Mechelen: Kluwer.Search in Google Scholar
Mitsopoulos, M., and T.Pelagidis. 2007. “Does Staffing Affect the Time to Dispose Cases in Greek Courts?,” 27International Review of Law & Economics219–244.Search in Google Scholar
OECD. 2013. “Judicial Performance and Its Determinants: A Cross-Country Perspective,” OECD Economics Policy Papers.Search in Google Scholar
Spurr, S.J. 1997. “The Duration of Litigation,” 19Law & Policy285–316.Search in Google Scholar
Taelman, P. , P.Orshoven and B.Allemeersch. 2008. De Wet Van 26 April 2007 Tot Wijziging Van Het Gerechtelijk Wetboek Met Het Oog Op Het Bestrijden Van De Gerechtelijke Achterstand Doorgelicht. Brugge: Die Keure.Search in Google Scholar
Vanderkerken, C. , P.Vandermotten and J.Verstappen. 2009. Tien Jaar Nieuwe Fiscale Procedure: Een Evaluatie Voor En Vanuit De Praktijk. Gent: Larcier.Search in Google Scholar
Vereeck, L. and M.Mϋhl. 2000. “An Economic Theory of Court Delay,” 10 European Journal of Law and Economics243–268.Search in Google Scholar
©2015 by De Gruyter
