Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter April 30, 2018

Public Budget Contributions to the European Rail Sector

An in Depth Analysis for Eight Countries
Jan Thomas Schäfer and Georg Götz ORCID logo

Abstract

This paper provides an analysis of the funding structure of the railways in eight European countries. It updates and expands the well-known database on public contributions to rail, which has initially been published by [NERA (2004) Study of the Financing of and Public Budget Contributions to Railways: A Final Report for European Commission, DG TREN. London: NERA National Economic Research Associates.]. The analysis shows that there are large differences concerning the focus of granted funds which can be explained by different policy objectives, differences in the level and degree of network access charges and different cost coverage ratios of public transport services. We identify a tendency towards two main financing models. In our data-set countries either focus their support payments on the operation of the infrastructure, which implies lower network charges and thus a lower amount of necessary Public Service Compensations, or they focus on the support of transport services with a higher degree of cost coverage of network charges and thus a lower amount of operating contributions paid to the infrastructure manager. The structure of funds, different approaches of infrastructure financing and differences in the treatment of historical debt are likely to have an influence on the performance of the investigated railway systems.

JEL Classification: R42; R48; L92; H54

Corresponding author: Georg Götz, Professor, Justus Liebig University Giessen, Giessen, Germany

  1. Funding: Jan Schäfer thanks Deutsche Bahn AG for funding a PhD fellowship.

References

Arrigo, U. and G. Di Foggia (2013) “Schemes and Levels of State Aid to Rail Industry in Europe: Evidences from a Cross-Country Comparison,” European Journal of Business and Economics, 8(3):14–20.10.12955/ejbe.v8i3.410Search in Google Scholar

Arrigo, U. and G. Di Foggia (2014) “Policy-Oriented Insights to Enhance Effectiveness and Efficiency of Public Spending: Comparing the Determinants of Subsidies to Railways in Key European Countries,” International Journal of Managerial Studies and Research (IJMSR), 2(11):23–35.Search in Google Scholar

Banverket (2008) Swedish Rail Sector Development: Banverket’s sector report.Search in Google Scholar

Beck, A., H. Bente and M. Schilling (2013) “Railway Efficiency – An Overview and a Look at Opportunities for Improvement,” International Transport Forum, Discussion Paper (2013–2012).Search in Google Scholar

Best, A., B. Görlach, H. van Essen, A. Schroten, U. Becker and R. Gerike (2006) “Size, Structure and Distribution of Transport Subsidies in Europe: A Report to the European Environment Agency,” Final Report, 11 December 2006.Search in Google Scholar

Bundesamt für Statistik BFS (2013) Schweizerische Eisenbahnrechnung 2011.Search in Google Scholar

Dehornoy, J. (2011) The Evolution of Public Funding to the Rail Sector in 5 European Countries – A Comparison. In: Fourth Annual Competition and Regulation in Network Industries (CRNI) Conference. Brussels.Search in Google Scholar

Deville, X. and F. Verduyn (2012) Implementation of EU Legislation on Rail Liberalisation in Belgium, France, Germany and The Netherlands: NBB Working Paper No 221. Brussels: National Bank of Belgium.Search in Google Scholar

ECORYS Nederland BV (2006) Analysis of the financial situation of railway undertakings in the European Union: Report to the European Commission DG-TREN. Rotterdam: ECORYS Nederland BV.Search in Google Scholar

Engel, E., R. Fischer and A. Galetovic (2010) “The Economics of Infrastructure Finance: Public-Private Partnerships Versus Public Provision,” EIB Papers, 15(1):40–69.Search in Google Scholar

European Commission (2007) Annexes to the Communication on Monitoring Development of the Rail Market: Commission Staff Working Document, COM (2007) 609. Brussels.Search in Google Scholar

European Commission (2008a) Community Guidelines on State Aid for Railway Undertakings, Communication from the Commission 2008/C 184/07. Official Journal of the European Union, C 184/13. Brussels, 22.07.2008.Search in Google Scholar

European Commission (2008b) Multi-annual Contracts for Rail Infrastructure Quality: Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament, COM(2008) 54 final. Brussels.Search in Google Scholar

European Commission (2014) Fourth report on monitoring development of the rail market: Report from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament, COM(2014) 353 final, Brussels, 13.06.2014.Search in Google Scholar

Eurostat (2005) Three decisions on Italy: SCIP, ISPA and Concessionari d’imposta: Euro-Indicators News Release 65/2005. Luxembourg: Eurostat Press Office.Search in Google Scholar

Eurostat (2008) Methodological Treatment of the Capital Injections into RENFE-Operadora in 2006: Letter to Instituto Nacional de Estadistica Madrid. Luxembourg: European Commission, Eurostat Directorate C: National and European Accounts.Search in Google Scholar

Finger, M., Y. Putallaz and D. van de Velde (2015) Solid Infrastructure Financing for Efficient Rail Systems: Results of an Workshop Organized by SNCF Group’s Strategy Team.Search in Google Scholar

Instituto Nacional de Estadistica (2007) Methodological Treatment of the Capital Injections into ADIF: Letter from the National Statistics Office to Eurostat. Madrid, Spain.Search in Google Scholar

Laurino, A., F. Ramella and P. Beria (2015) “The Economic Regulation of Railway Networks: A Worldwide Survey,” Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 77:202–212.10.1016/j.tra.2015.04.011Search in Google Scholar

Nash, C. (2008) “Passenger Railway Reform in the Last 20 years–European Experience Reconsidered,” Research in Transportation Economics, 22(1):61–70.10.1016/j.retrec.2008.05.020Search in Google Scholar

Nash, C. (2010) “European Rail Reform and Passenger Services – The Next Steps,” Research in Transportation Economics, 29(1):204–211.10.1016/j.retrec.2010.07.025Search in Google Scholar

Nash, C., J.-E. Nilsson and H. Link (2011) Comparing Three Models for Introduction of Competition into Railways – Is a Big Wolf so Bad After All? CTS Working Paper 2011:19, Centre for Transport Studies Stockholm.Search in Google Scholar

NERA (2004) Study of the Financing of and Public Budget Contributions to Railways: A Final Report for European Commission, DG TREN. London: NERA National Economic Research Associates.Search in Google Scholar

NERA (2005) Public Budget Contributions to the Railways: A Report to Deutsche Bahn AG. London: NERA National Economic Research Associates.Search in Google Scholar

OECD (2010) The PSE Manual – OECD’s Producer Support Estimate and Related Indicators of Agricultural Support. Paris: OECD Trade and Agriculture Directorat.Search in Google Scholar

Perkins, S. (2005) The Role of Government in European Railway Investment and Funding. China Railway Investment and Finance Reform Forum, Beijing, China.Search in Google Scholar

RGL Forensics, Frontier Economics and Aecom (2009) Study on Separation of Accounts of Railway Undertakings and Rail Infrastructure Managers: Final Report for the European Commission.Search in Google Scholar

Steer Davis Gleave (2005) RAILIMPLEMENT – Implementation of EU Directives 2001/12/EC, 2001/13/EC and 2001/14/EC: Final Report for the European Commission, Directorate General for Energy and Transport. Steer Davies Gleave, Bologna, Italy.Search in Google Scholar

Valsecchi, C., P. ten Brink, S. Bassi, S. Withana, M. Lewis, A. Best, F. Oosterhuis, C. Dias Soares, H. Rogers-Ganter and T. Kapenhengst (2009) Environmentally Harmful Subsidies: Identification and Assesment: Final report for the European Commission’s DG Environment. Institute for European Environmental Policy (IEEP), London and Brussels.Search in Google Scholar

van de Velde, D., C. Nash, A. Smith, F. Mizutani, S. Uranishi, M. Lijesen and F. Zschoche (2012) EVES-Rail, Economic Effects of Vertical Separation in the Railway Sector: Full Technical Report for CER, Community of European Railways and Infrastructure Companies, by inno-V (Amsterdam) in Cooperation with University of Leeds – ITS, Kobe University, VU Amsterdam University and Civity Management Consultants.Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2018-04-30
Published in Print: 2017-06-26

©2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Scroll Up Arrow