Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter Mouton November 22, 2017

Argumentation in participant-driven photo interviews: A case in ICT for development in Mozambique

Silvia De Ascaniis, Sara Vannini and Lorenzo Cantoni
From the journal Semiotica

Abstract

Argumentation is essentially dialogical, hence based on verbal disputation. Nonetheless, other semiotic resources than language may play a substantial role in argumentative circumstances. In this article, different argumentative functions played by photographs are explored, based on an unusual corpus for the field. People working in Mozambican Community Multimedia Centers (CMCs) were interviewed, in order to reconstruct the social meaning they confer to such places. To facilitate the exchange of meanings between interviewees and interviewers, who had different cultural and experiential backgrounds, interviewees were requested to take pictures of something they liked, something they didn’t like, and something they perceived as particularly representative of their CMC. Pictures were then presented and commented by participants during their interview. By means of analytical reconstructions, the major argumentative roles played by photographs in the interviews were identified, as well as their semiotic function in respect to interviewees’ words. Argumentative analysis also broadened and enriched the method of photo-driven interviews, and added a further interpretative access to analysis of social representations.

References

Aakhus, M. 2003. Neither naïve nor critical reconstruction: Dispute mediators, impasse, and the design of argumentation. Argumentation 17(3). 265–290. Search in Google Scholar

Aakhus, M. 2007. Communication as design. Communication Monographs 74(1). 112–117. Search in Google Scholar

Avgerou, C. & G. Walsham. 2000. Information technology in context: Studies from the perspective of developing countries. London: Ashgate. Search in Google Scholar

Barceló Aspeitia, A. A. 2012. Words and images in argumentation. Argumentation 26(3). 355–368. Search in Google Scholar

Barthes, Roland. 1964. Rhétorique de l’image. Communications 4. 40–51. Search in Google Scholar

Berger, A. 1989. Seeing is believing: An introduction to visual communication. Mountain View, CA: Mayfield. Search in Google Scholar

Bignante, E. 2010. The use of photo-elicitation in field research. EchoGéo 11. http://echogeo.revues.org/11622 (accessed 19 October 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Billig, M. 1996. Arguing and thinking: A rhetorical approach to social psychology (New ed.). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Brunello, P. 2010. ICT for education projects: A look from behind the scenes. Information Technology for Development 16(3). 232–239. Search in Google Scholar

Byford, J. 2002. Anchoring and objectifying “neocortical warfare”: Representation of a biological metaphor in Serbian conspiracy literature. Papers on Social Representations 11(3). 1–14. Search in Google Scholar

Coffin, C. 2009. Contemporary educational argumentation: A multimodal perspective. Argumentation 23(4). 513–530. Search in Google Scholar

Collier, J. 1967. Visual anthropology: Photography as a research method. New York: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston. Search in Google Scholar

Creech, H. 2006. Evaluation of UNESCO’s Community Multimedia Centers. United Nations Organization for Education Science and Culture. http://portal.unesco.org/pv_obj_cache/pv_obj_id_BE7A0D92CAAF9399898BB8BE86A10234676C0500/filename/CMC+Evaluation_Final.pdf (accessed 19 October 2017). Search in Google Scholar

De Ascaniis, S. 2013. Destination online travel reviews. An argumentative and textual genre perspective. Unpublished doctoral thesis. Università della Svizzera italiana, Lugano (Switzerland). http://doc.rero.ch/record/31482?ln=it Search in Google Scholar

Dodman, D. R. 2003. Shooting in the city: An autophotographic exploration of the urban environment in Kingston, Jamaica. Area 35(3). 293–304. Search in Google Scholar

Gaster, P., C. Cumbana, G. Macueve, L. N. Cabral Domingos & F. Mabila. 2009. Digital inclusion in Mozambique: A challenge for all. Maputo: CIUEM. http://www.ngopulse.org/sites/default/files/FinalMozambiqueReport10July2009-English.pdf (accessed 19 October 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Gould, E. A., R. Gómez & K. Camacho. 2010. Information needs in developing countries: How are they being served by public access venues? In Proceedings of the sixteenth Americas conference on information systems, 1–12. Lima: ScholarONE. Search in Google Scholar

Groarke, L. 1996. Logic, art, and argument. Informal Logic 18(2). 105–129. Search in Google Scholar

Groarke, L. 1999. The pragma-dialectics of visual argument. In F. H. van Eemeren, R. Grootendorst, A. Blair & C. A. Willard (eds.), Proceedings of the fourth international society for the study of argumentation, 276–280. Amsterdam: Kluwer. Search in Google Scholar

Harper, D. 2002. Talking about pictures: A case for photo elicitation. Visual Studies 17(1). 13–26. Search in Google Scholar

Heeks, R. 2002. Information systems and developing countries: Failure, success, and local improvisations. Information Society 18(2). 101–112. Search in Google Scholar

Hitchcock, D. & B. Verheij. 2006. Arguing on the Toulmin model. Dordrecht: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Howarth, C. 2006. A social representation is not a quiet thing: Exploring the critical potential of social representations theory. British Journal of Social Psychology 45(1). 65–86. Search in Google Scholar

Lewiński, M. 2010. Internet political discussion forums as an argumentative activity type: A pragma-dialectical analysis of online forms of strategic maneuvering with critical reactions. Amsterdam: SicSat. Search in Google Scholar

Lindekens, R. 1971. Éléments pour une sémiotique de la photographie. Brussels: AIMAV. Search in Google Scholar

Mabila, F., J. M. Nhabinda Mboane & A. I. Mondlane. 2010. Mozambique sector performance review 2009/2010 (No. Volume 2, Number 16, 1–28). IDRC Study/Acacia Initiative. http://www.researchictafrica.net/publications.php (accessed 19 October 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Mazzali Lurati, S. & L. Cantoni. 2005. Photography, semiotics of. In K. Brown (ed.), Encyclopedia of language & linguistics, 2nd edn., vol. 9, 569–571. Oxford: Elsevier. Search in Google Scholar

Mazzali Lurati, S. & C. Pollaroli. 2014. A pragma-semiotic analysis of advertisements as multimodal texts: A case study. In A. Maiorani & C. Christie (eds.), Multimodal epistemologies: Towards an integrated framework, 66–82. London: Routledge. Search in Google Scholar

Mitchell, W. J. T. 1995. Picture theory: Essays on verbal and visual representation. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Search in Google Scholar

Moscovici, S. 1961. La psychanalyse, son image et son public. Paris: PUF. Search in Google Scholar

Moscovici, S. 1988. Notes towards a description of social representations. European Journal of Social Psychology 18(3). 211–250. Search in Google Scholar

Perelman, C. & L. Olbrechts-Tyteca. 1969. The new rhetoric, John Wilkinson & Purcell Weaver (trans.). Notre Dame: The University of Notre Dame Press Search in Google Scholar

Rega, I. 2010. What do local people think about teleCenters? A key issue for sustainability. Lugano: Università della Svizzera Italiana dissertation. Search in Google Scholar

Rega, I., S. Vannini, E. Fino & L. Cantoni. 2013. Exploring the meanings of community multimedia centers in Mozambique: A social representation perspective. Information Technologies & International Development 9(4). 35–54. Search in Google Scholar

Rocci, A. 2008. Analyzing and evaluating persuasive media discourse in context. In M. Burger (ed.), L’analyse linguistique des discours des médias: Théories, méthodes et enjeux, 247–284. Québec: Nota Bene. Search in Google Scholar

Rocci, A. 2009. Maneuvering with voices: The polyphonic framing of arguments in an institutional advertisement. In F. H. van Eemeren (ed.), Examining argumentation in context: Fifteen studies on strategic maneuvering, 257–283. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Search in Google Scholar

Rose, G. 2007. Visual methodologies an introduction to the interpretation of visual materials. Los Angeles: SAGE. Search in Google Scholar

Samuels, J. 2004. Breaking the ethnographer’s frames reflections on the use of photo elicitation in understanding Sri Lankan monastic culture. American Behavioral Scientist 47(12). 1528–1550. Search in Google Scholar

Sclavi, M. 2003. Arte di ascoltare e mondi possibili: Come si esce dalle cornici di cui siamo parte. Milan: Bruno Mondadori. Search in Google Scholar

Slade, C. 2003. Seeing reasons: Visual argumentation in advertisements. Argumentation 17(2). 145–160. Search in Google Scholar

Snoek Henkemans, A. F. 2001. Argumentation structures. In F. H. van Eemeren (ed.), Crucial concepts in argumentation theory, 101–134. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Tedre, M., E. Sutinen, E. Kähkönen & P. Kommers. 2006. Ethnocomputing: ICT in cultural and social context. Communications of the ACM 49(1). 126–130. Search in Google Scholar

Toulmin, S. 1958. The uses of argument. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

UNESCO. 2004. Scale up initiative for Community Multimedia Centers in Mozambique. http://portal.unesco.org/ci/en/ev.php-URL_ID=17568&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html (accessed 19 October 2017). Search in Google Scholar

Unwin, T. (ed.). 2009. ICT4D: Information and communication technology for development. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

van Eemeren, F. H. 2001. Crucial concepts in argumentation theory. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. Search in Google Scholar

van Eemeren, F. H., B. Garssen, E. C. W. Krabbe, A. S. Henkemans, B. Verheij & J. H. M. Wagemans. 2014. Handbook of argumentation theory. Berlin: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

van Eemeren, F. H. & R. Grootendorst. 2004. A systematic theory of argumentation: The pragma-dialectical Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

van Eemeren, F. H., R. Grootendorst & A. F. Snoek Henkemans. 2002. Argumentation: Analysis, evaluation, presentation. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Search in Google Scholar

Vannini, S. 2014. Social representations of Community Multimedia Centers in Mozambique. Lugano: Università della Svizzera Italiana dissertation. Search in Google Scholar

Vannini, S., I. Rega, S. Sala & L. Cantoni. 2015. Using photo-elicitation to explore social representations of Community Multimedia Centers in Mozambique. Electronic Journal of Information Systems in Developing Countries 67(8). 1–23. Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2017-11-22
Published in Print: 2018-01-26

© 2018 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston