Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter Mouton November 9, 2017

On the production of a multimodal news item: An argumentative approach

Marta Zampa and Marina Bletsas
From the journal Semiotica

Abstract

The present paper deals with the production of a multimodal news item from an ethnographic perspective, aiming at fully understanding the role played by news values, i.e. shared criteria for news selection, in newsroom argumentation. The news item we consider is the picture news from Corriere del Ticino, the main Italian-language newspaper in Switzerland. As the Italian name fototesto says, this news item combines a verbal and a photographical component, presenting the journalists with particular challenges in its selection. To shed light on this production process, we take as a case study a picture news on eco-friendly heat distribution and the editorial conference leading to its choice, which took place on January 24, 2013. We analyze the interaction from the viewpoint of argumentation theory, combining Pragma-Dialectics (van Eemeren and Grootendorst) and the Argumentum Model of Topics (Rigotti and Greco Morasso 2009, 2010, under review), and unravel the reasons behind choices in content and form taken collaboratively by the journalists.

References

Agliati, Mario 2003. La storia del “Corriere del Ticino.” Muzzano: Edizioni San Giorgio. Search in Google Scholar

Aristotle. 1960. Aristotle’s posterior analytics: Topica (Loeb classical library 391), Hugh Tredennick & Edward S. Forster (eds.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Barthes, Roland. 1983 [1961]. The photographic message. In Susan Sontag (ed.), A Barthes reader, 194–201. New York: Hill and Wang. Search in Google Scholar

Bednarek, Monika & Helen Caple. 2012. News discourse. London: Continuum. Search in Google Scholar

Bell, Allan. 1991. The language of news media (Language in society 16). Oxford: Blackwell. Search in Google Scholar

Breed, Warren. 1955. Social control in the newsroom: A functional analysis. Social Forces 33(4). 326–335. Search in Google Scholar

Cotter, Colleen. 2010. News talk: Investigating the language of journalism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Eemeren, Frans H. van & Rob Grootendorst. 2004. A systematic theory of argumentation: The pragma-dialectical approach. New York: Cambridge University Press. Search in Google Scholar

Fondazione Corriere del Ticino. 1941. Statutes of corriere del Ticino. In Mario Agliati (ed.), La storia del “Corriere del Ticino.” Muzzano: Edizioni San Giorgio. Search in Google Scholar

Galtung, Johan & Mari H. Ruge. 1965. The structure of foreign news. Journal of Peace Research 2(1). 64–91. Search in Google Scholar

Greco Morasso, Sara. 2011. Argumentation in dispute mediation: A reasonable way to handle conflict (Argumentation in context 3). Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Search in Google Scholar

Groarke, Leo. 2002. Towards a pragma-dialectics of visual argument. In Frans H. van Eemeren (ed.), Advances in pragma-dialectics, 137–151. Amsterdam: Sic Sat; Newport News, VA: Vale Press. Search in Google Scholar

Kjeldsen, Jens E. 2012. Pictorial argumentation in advertising: Visual tropes and figure as a way of creating visual argumentation. In Frans H. van Eemeren & Bart Garssen (eds.), Topical themes in argumentation theory: Twenty exploratory studies (Argumentation Library 22), 239–255. Dordrecht, NY: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Knox, John. 2007. Visual-verbal communication on online newspaper home pages. Visual Communication 6(1). 19–53. Search in Google Scholar

Kress, Gunther R. & Theo van Leeuwen. 1998. Front pages: (The critical) analysis of newspaper layout. In Allan Bell & Peter Garrett (eds.), Approaches to media discourse, 186–219. Oxford: Blackwell. Search in Google Scholar

Kress, Gunther R. & Theo van Leeuwen. 2010 [1996]. Reading images: The grammar of visual design, 2nd edn. London: Routledge. Search in Google Scholar

Lippmann, Walter. 1922. Public opinion. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction. Search in Google Scholar

Mann, William C. & Sandra A. Thompson. 1988. Rhetorical structure theory: Towards a functional theory of text organization. Text 3(8). 243–281. Search in Google Scholar

Mazzali-Lurati, Sabrina & Chiara Pollaroli. 2014 A pragma-semiotic analysis of advertisements as multimodal texts: A case study. In Arianna Maiorani & Christine Christie (eds.), Multimodal epistemologies: Towards an integrated framework, 66–82. New York & London: Routledge. Search in Google Scholar

Musi, Elena. 2014. Evidential modals at the semantic-argumentative interface: Appearance verbs as indicators of defeasible argumentation. Informal Logic 34(4). 417–442. Search in Google Scholar

Perrin, Daniel. 2003. Progression analysis (PA): Investigating writing strategies at the workplace. Journal of Pragmatics 35(6). 907–921. Search in Google Scholar

Perrin, Daniel. 2013. The linguistics of newswriting. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Search in Google Scholar

Rigotti, Eddo. 2006. Relevance of context-bound loci to topical potential in the argumentation stage. Argumentation 20. 519–540. Search in Google Scholar

Rigotti, Eddo & Sara Greco Morasso. 2009. Argumentation as an object of interest and as a social and cultural resource. In Nathalie Muller Mirza & Anne-Nelly Perret-Clermont (eds.), Argumentation and education: Theoretical foundations and practices, 9–66. Boston, MA: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Rigotti, Eddo & Sara Greco Morasso. 2010. Comparing the Argumentum Model of Topics to other contemporary approaches to argument schemes: The procedural and material components. Argumentation 24(4). 489–512. Search in Google Scholar

Rigotti, Eddo & Sara Greco under review. Inference in argumentation: A topics-based approach to argument schemes. Dordrecht: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Rigotti, Eddo & Andrea Rocci. 2006. Towards a definition of communication context: Foundations of an interdisciplinary approach to communication. Studies in Communication Sciences 6(2). 155–180. Search in Google Scholar

Rocci, Andrea. 2017. Modality in argumentation. A semantic investigation of the role of modalities in the structure of arguments with an application to Italian Modal Expressions. Dordrecht: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Rocci, Andrea, Sabrina Mazzali-Lurati & Chiara Pollaroli. 2013. Is this the Italy we like? Multimodal argumentation in a Fiat Panda TV commercial. In Barry Pennock-Speck & María Milagros del Saz-Rubio (eds.), The multimodal analysis of television commercials, 157–187. Valencia: Universitat de València. Search in Google Scholar

Taboada, Maite & Christopher Habel. 2013. Rhetorical relations in multimodal documents. Discourse Studies 1(15). 65–89. Search in Google Scholar

Zampa, Marta. 2015. News values as endoxa of newsmaking: An investigation of argumentative practices in the newsroom. Lugano: Università della Svizzera italiana dissertation. Search in Google Scholar

Zampa, Marta. in press. Argumentation in the newsroom. Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John Benjamins. Search in Google Scholar

Zampa, Marta & Daniel Perrin. 2016 Arguing with oneself: The writing process as an argumentative soliloquy. Journal of Argumentation in Context 5 (1).9–28. Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2017-11-09
Published in Print: 2018-01-26

© 2018 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston