Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter Mouton November 18, 2020

Saussure’s “anagrams”: A case of acousmatic mistaken identity?

Fionn Bennett
From the journal Semiotica

Abstract

In the course of his painstaking study of ancient verse, Ferdinand de Saussure came up with an intriguing theory about the phonetics of the poetry he scrutinised. He postulated that the “jeux phoniques” he detected in the texts he analysed was proof that their authors were attempting to “parasite” the surface level meaning of their verse with a “hypotexte.” This hypotexte consisted of “anagrams” of “mots thèmes” whose phonetic properties were “isosyllabically diffracted” throughout the rest of the host text. Today it is generally accepted that Saussure was wrong about this. Few however maintain that what he discerned in the phonetic depths of the verse he auscultated was no more than the figment of a fertile imagination. But if this be so, what exactly had he detected? This paper maintains that what Saussure stumbled upon was the trace of a contribution made to ancient verse by melodically and metrically organised sounds. This was inevitable. Virtually all the texts he probed were “carmina sacra” that were composed to be sung and accompanied by music. This musical accompaniment had a decisive impact on the phonetics of the “lexemic” words in the Poetry that has survived. This is so because sung verse cannot “euphoniously” accommodate a musical accompaniment unless its phonetics constituents are selected, concatenated and intoned in such a way as to follow the melodic contours and rhythm patterns that modulate their articulation. In addition, the point of making verse consist both of melodically organised arrangements of sound and of organisations of sound in which one can recognise ordinary words was not simply ornamental. The real point was to bi-nature what one was hearing. In other words, the goal was to “over-signify” the usual meanings of the “logocentric” words in the verse with a separate but complementary meaning and narrative encoded in melodised tones and metered rhythms. Why qualify the accompanying music as “acousmatic voices”? Because the music in question was added to song to give a voice to whichever tutelary divinity the song was performed to honour. That’s what makes “acousmatic voices” an especially apt epithet for characterising the melodically and rhythmically structured bodies of sound Saussure so presciently discerned in the phonetic depths of the poésie phonisante he probed. The point of their being in poetry was to give a voice to the agencies to whom the object or occasion of verse is beholden for its Being-in-the-world.


Corresponding author: Fionn Bennett, Universite de Reims, Reims, France, E-mail:

References

Babich, Babette. 2006. Words in blood, like flowers: Poetry and eros music and philosophy. Albany: State University of New York Press.Search in Google Scholar

Bader, Françoise. 1989. La langue des dieux ou l’hermétisme des poètes Indo-Européens. Pisa: Giardini.Search in Google Scholar

Barker, Andrew. 1995. Heterophonia and poikilia: Accompaniments to Greek melody. In B. Gentili & F. Perusino (eds.), Mousike: Metrica, ritmica e musica greca in memoria di Giovanni Comotti, 41–60. Pisa: Istituti Editoriali e Poligrafici Internazionali.Search in Google Scholar

Beck, Guy. 1993. Sonic theology: Hinduism and sacred sound. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press.Search in Google Scholar

Bennett, Fionn. 2016. Music and language in ancient verse: The dynamics of an antagonistic concord. Special issue. Humanities 5(1). 1–14. https://doi.org/10.3390/h5010008.Search in Google Scholar

Bennett, Fionn. 2020. The psychoacoustics of enthousiasmόs: How to hear a cosmopoietic cantata in a chorus of atmospheric whistlers. Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 103(3). 229–246.10.3917/rmm.193.0229Search in Google Scholar

Bouché-Leclercq, Auguste. 1880. Histoire de la divination dans l’antiquité. Paris: E. Leroux.Search in Google Scholar

Boyancé, Pierre. 1936. Le culte des muses chez les philosophes grecs. Paris: E. de Boccard.Search in Google Scholar

Boykan, Martin. 2000. Reflections on words and music. Musical Quarterly 84(1). 123–136.10.1093/mq/84.1.123Search in Google Scholar

Brancacci, Aldo. 2007. Democritus’ Mousika. In Aldo Brancacci & Pierre-Marie Morel (eds.), Democritus: Science, the arts, and the care of the soul, 181–205. Leiden & Boston: Brill.10.1163/ej.9789004151604.i-352.41Search in Google Scholar

Bundy, Elroy T. 1962. Studia Pindarica. Berkeley: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar

Cavarero, Adriana. 2005. For more than one voice. Stanford: Stanford University Press.10.1515/9780804767309Search in Google Scholar

David, Amirthanayagam P. 2006. The dance of the muses: Choral theory and ancient Greek poetics. Oxford: Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199292400.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Davies, David. 2013. The dialogue between words and music in the composition and comprehension of song. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 71(1). 13–22.10.1111/j.1540-6245.2012.01537.xSearch in Google Scholar

D’Alessio, Giovan-Battista. 2005. Ordered from the catalogue: Pindar, Bacchylides, and Hesiodic genealogical poetry. In Richard Hunter (ed.), The Hesiodic catalogue of women: Constructions and reconstructions, 217–238. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511482243.010Search in Google Scholar

Detienne, Marcel. 1990. Maîtres de la vérité dans la Grèce archaïque. Paris: La Découverte.Search in Google Scholar

Francotte, Auguste. 1985. Le genre de vie parménidien et les techniques de l’extase dans la Grèce archaïque. In Philippe Marçais (ed.), Mélanges à la mémoire de Philippe Marçais, 15–66. Paris: Maisonneuve.Search in Google Scholar

Frontisi-Ducroux, Françoise. 2002. Avec son diaphragme visionnaire: Ἰδυίῃσι πραπίδεσσι, Iliade XVIII, 481. À propos du bouclier d’Achille. Revue des Etudes Grecques 115(2). 463–484.10.3406/reg.2002.4502Search in Google Scholar

Gandon, Francis. 2002. De dangereux édifices. Louvain: Peeters.Search in Google Scholar

Gandon, Francis. 2006. Le nom de l’absent. Limoges: Lambert-Lucas.Search in Google Scholar

Georgiades, Thrasybulos. 1958. Musik und Rhythmus bei den Griechen. Hamburg: Rowohlt.Search in Google Scholar

Hagel, Stefan. 2017. Language and dance: A non-Platonizing view. In L. Gianvittorio (ed.), Choreutika: Performing dance in archaic and classical Greece, 198–214. Pisa & Roma: Fabrizio Serra.Search in Google Scholar

Kingsley, Peter. 1999. In the dark places of wisdom. London: Duckworth.Search in Google Scholar

Koller, Hermann. 1954. Mimesis, Die Mimesis in der Antike. Berne: A. Francke.Search in Google Scholar

Koller, Hermann. 1955. Stoicheion. Glotta 34(3/4). 161–174.Search in Google Scholar

Koller, Hermann. 1963. Musik und Dichtung im alten Griechenland. Berne: A. Francke.Search in Google Scholar

Lonsdale, Steven H. 1993. Dance and ritual play in Greek religion. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Manetti, Giovanni. 1993. Theories of the sign in classical antiquity. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Mowitt, John. 2015. Sounds: The ambient humanities. Oakland: University of California Press.10.1525/california/9780520284623.001.0001Search in Google Scholar

Nagy, Gregory. 1990. Pindar’s Homer. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Nagy, Gregory. 2010. Language and meter. In Egbert J. Bakker (ed.), A companion to the ancient Greek language, 370–387. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.10.1002/9781444317398.ch25Search in Google Scholar

Nagy, Joseph. 1985. The wisdom of the outlaw: The boyhood deeds of Finn in the Gaelic narrative tradition. Berkeley: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar

Nettl, Bruno. 1956. Music in primitive culture. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.10.4159/harvard.9780674863408Search in Google Scholar

Onians, Richard B. 1988. The origins of European thought. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9780511552724Search in Google Scholar

Otto, Walter F. 1987. Der Mythos und das Wort. In Pascal David (ed.), Essais sur le mythe, 16–43. Mauvezin: Trans-Europ-Repress.Search in Google Scholar

Padoux, André. 1994. L’énergie de la parole: Cosmogonies de la parole tantrique. Montpellier: Fata Morgana.Search in Google Scholar

Power, Timothy. 2010. The culture of Kitharôidia. Washington and Cambridge: Harvard University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Prauscello, Lucia. 2014. Performing citizenship in Plato’s Laws. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139680882Search in Google Scholar

Probert, Philomen. 2003. A new short guide to the accentuation of ancient Greek. London: Bristol Classical Press.Search in Google Scholar

Rocconi, Eleonora. 2012. Aristoxenus and musical ethos. In Carl Huffman (ed.), Aristoxenus of Tarentum: Discussion, 65–90. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.10.4324/9781315082158-3Search in Google Scholar

Rocconi, Eleonora. 2015. Music and dance in Greece and Rome. In P. Destrée & P. Murray (eds.), A companion to ancient aesthetics, 81–93. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.10.1002/9781119009795.ch5Search in Google Scholar

Rouget, Gilbert. 1990. La musique et la transe. Paris: Editions Gallimard.Search in Google Scholar

Schneider, Marius. 1960. Le rôle de la musique dans la mythologie et les rites des civilisations non européennes. In Rolland Manuel (ed.), Histoire de la musique, vol. 1. Paris: Gallimard.Search in Google Scholar

Schneider, Marius. 1964. Die Natur der Lobgesangs. Basel: Bärenreiter.Search in Google Scholar

Seaford, Richard. 1996. Euripides: Bacchae. Warminster: Aris & Phillips.Search in Google Scholar

Stanford, William Bedell. 1967. The sound of Greek: Studies in the Greek theory and practice of euphony. Berkeley: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar

Testenoire, Pierre-Yves. 2009. Des anagrammes chez Homère? De Saussure aux commentateurs anciens. Lalies 30. 215–230.Search in Google Scholar

Testenoire, Pierre-Yves. 2013. Ferdinand de Saussure, à la recherche des anagrammes. Limoges: Éditions Lambert-Lucas.Search in Google Scholar

Toporov, Viktor. 1981. Die Ursprünge der indogermanische Poetik. Poetica 13. 189–251.10.30965/25890530-0130304001Search in Google Scholar

Utaker, Arild. 2002. La philosophie du langage: Une archéologie saussurienne. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.Search in Google Scholar

Valéry, Paul. 1957. Œuvres. Paris: Gallimard.Search in Google Scholar

Vernant, Jean-Pierre. 1996. Mythe et pensée chez les Grecs. Paris: La Découverte.10.3917/dec.verna.1996.01Search in Google Scholar

Watkins, Calvert. 1970. Language of Gods and language of men. In J. Puhvel (ed.), Myth and law among the Indo-Europeans, 1–18. Berkeley: University of California Press.Search in Google Scholar

Watkins, Calvert. 1995. How to kill a dragon. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

West, Martin L. 1992. Ancient Greek music. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar

Wunderli, Peter. 2004. Saussure’s anagrams and the analysis of literary texts. In Carol Sanders (ed.), The Cambridge companion to Saussure, 174–185. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CCOL052180051X.012Search in Google Scholar

Yelle, Robert A. 2003. Explaining mantras. New York: Routledge.10.4324/9780203483381Search in Google Scholar

Published Online: 2020-11-18
Published in Print: 2021-01-27

© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston

Scroll Up Arrow