Accessible Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter June 14, 2017

Detecting capital market convergence clubs

Fuat C. Beylunioglu, Thanasis Stengos and M. Ege Yazgan


In this study, we propose a new method to find convergence clubs that combine pairwise method of testing convergence with maximal clique algorithm. Unlike many of those already developed in the literature, this new method aims to find convergence clubs endogenously without depending on priori classifications. We use our method to study convergence among different capital markets as captured by their respective indices. Stock market convergence would indicate the absence of arbitrage opportunities in moving between the different markets as they would all present investors with similar risks. Furthermore, stock market convergence would be a precursor to GDP convergence as these economies would be bound by similar (possibly unobservable) common factors that affect long run macroeconomic performance.

JEL Classification: C32; O47


Abbott, A., and G. De Vita. 2013. “Testing for Long-run Convergence Across Regional House Prices in the UK: A Pairwise Approach.” Applied Economics 45 (10): 1227–1238. Search in Google Scholar

Abbott, A., G. De Vita, and L. Altinay. 2012. “Revisiting the Convergence Hypothesis for Tourism Markets: Evidence from Turkey Using the Pairwise Approach.” Tourism Management 33 (3): 537–544. Search in Google Scholar

Apergis, N., C. Christou, and J. Payne. 2011. “Political and Institutional Factors in the Convergence of International Equity Markets: Evidence from the Club Convergence and Clustering Procedure.” Atlantic Economic Journal 39 (1): 7–18. Search in Google Scholar

Apergis, N., and P. Padhi. 2013. “Health Expenses and Economic Growth: Convergence Dynamics Across the Indian States.” International Journal of Health Care Finance and Economics 13 (3–4): 261–277. Search in Google Scholar

Awokuse, T. O., A. Chopra, and D. A. Bessler. 2009. “Structural Change and International Stock Market Interdependence: Evidence from Asian Emerging Markets.” Economic Modelling 26 (3): 549–559. Search in Google Scholar

Baumol, W. J 1986. “Productivity Growth, Convergence, and Welfare: What the Long-run Data Show.” The American Economic Review 76: 1072–1085. Search in Google Scholar

Bekaert, G., and C. R. Harvey. 1997. “Emerging Equity Market Volatility.” Journal of Financial Economics 43 (1): 29–77. Search in Google Scholar

Beylunioğlu, F. C., T. Stengos, and M. E. Yazgan. (2016). Detecting Convergence Clubs. Discussion Paper, Department of Economics and Finance, University of Guelph. Search in Google Scholar

Black, F 1974. “International Capital Market Equilibrium with Investment Barriers.” Journal of Financial Economics 1 (4): 337–352. Search in Google Scholar

Bley, J 2009. “European Stock Market Integration: Fact or Fiction?” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 19 (5): 759–776. Search in Google Scholar

Bron, C., and J. Kerbosch. 1973. “Algorithm 457: Finding All Cliques of an Undirected Graph.” Communications of the ACM 16 (9): 575–577. Search in Google Scholar

Bruno, G., R. De Bonis, and A. Silvestrini. 2012. “Do Financial Systems Converge? New Evidence from Financial Assets in OECD Countries.” Journal of Comparative Economics 40 (1): 141–155. Search in Google Scholar

Caporale, G. M., and N. Spagnolo. 2011. “Stock Market Integration Between Three CEECs, Russia, and the UK.” Review of International Economics 19 (1): 158–169. Search in Google Scholar

Chelley-Steeley, P. L 2005. “Modeling Equity Market Integration Using Smooth Transition Analysis: A Study of Eastern European Stock Markets.” Journal of International Money and Finance 24 (5): 818–831. Search in Google Scholar

Chortareas, G., and G. Kapetanios. 2009. “Getting PPP Right: Identifying Mean-Reverting Real Exchange Rates in Panels.” Journal of Banking & Finance 33 (2): 390–404. Search in Google Scholar

Corrado, L., R. Martin, and M. Weeks. 2005. “Identifying and Interpreting Regional Convergence Clusters Across Europe.” The Economic Journal 115 (502): C133–C160. Search in Google Scholar

Corrado, L., and M. Weekds. 2011. Testing for Convergence Clubs, University of Cambridge, CWPE 1110. Search in Google Scholar

Demian, C.-V 2011. “Cointegration in Central and East European Markets in Light of EU Accession.” Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 21 (1): 144–155. Search in Google Scholar

Dufrénot, G., V. Mignon, and T. Naccache. 2012. “Testing Catching-Up Between the Developing Countries: “Growth Resistance” and Sometimes “Growth Tragedy”.” Bulletin of Economic Research 64 (4): 470–508. Search in Google Scholar

Dumas, B., and B. Solnik. 1993. “The World Price of Foreign Exchange Risk.” Technical report, National Bureau of Economic Research. Search in Google Scholar

Égert, B., and E. Kočenda. 2007. “Interdependence Between Eastern and Western European Stock Markets: Evidence from Intraday Data.” Economic Systems 31 (2): 184–203. Search in Google Scholar

Eppstein, D., M. Löffler, and D. Strash. 2010. “Listing All Maximal Cliques in Sparse Graphs in Near-Optimal Time.” In International Symposium on Algorithms and Computation. editor by O. Cheong, K.-Y. Chwa, K. Park, 403–414. Berlin: Springer. Search in Google Scholar

Errunza, V., and E. Losq. 1985. “International Asset Pricing Under Mild Segmentation: Theory and Test.” The Journal of Finance 40 (1): 105–124. Search in Google Scholar

Eun, C. S., and S. Janakiramanan. 1986. “A Model of International Asset Pricing with a Constraint on the Foreign Equity Ownership.” The Journal of Finance 41 (4): 897–914. Search in Google Scholar

Eun, C. S., and J. Lee. 2010. “Mean–Variance Convergence Around the World.” Journal of Banking & Finance 34 (4): 856–870. Search in Google Scholar

Ferson, W. E., and C. R. Harvey. 1993. “The Risk and Predictability of International Equity Returns.” Review of financial Studies 6 (3): 527–566. Search in Google Scholar

Ferson, W. E., and C. R. Harvey. 1994. “Sources of Risk and Expected Returns in Global Equity Markets.” Journal of Banking & Finance 18 (4): 775–803. Search in Google Scholar

Fratzscher, M 2002. “Financial Market Integration in Europe: On the Effects of EMU on Stock Markets.” International Journal of Finance & Economics 7 (3): 165–193. Search in Google Scholar

Fritsche, U., and V. Kuzin. 2011. “Analysing Convergence in Europe Using the Non-linear Single Factor Model.” Empirical Economics 41 (2): 343–369. Search in Google Scholar

Gilmore, C. G., B. M. Lucey, and G. M. McManus. 2008. “The Dynamics of Central European Equity Market Comovements.” The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 48 (3): 605–622. Search in Google Scholar

Grauer, F. L., R. H. Litzenberger, and R. E. Stehle. 1976. “Sharing Rules and Equilibrium in an International Capital Market Under Uncertainty.” Journal of Financial Economics 3 (3): 233–256. Search in Google Scholar

Hansen, H. and S. Johenasen. 1999. “Some tests for parameter constancy in cointegrated VAR-models” Econometrics Journal2: 306–333 Search in Google Scholar

Harvey, C. R 1989. “Time-varying Conditional Covariances in Tests of Asset Pricing Models.” Journal of Financial Economics 24 (2): 289–317. Search in Google Scholar

Hobijin, B., and P. H. Franses. 2000. “Asymptotically Perfect and Relative Convergence of Productivity.” Journal of Applied Econometrics 15 (1): 59–81. Search in Google Scholar

Ikeno, H 2014. “Pairwise Tests of Convergence of Japanese Local Price Levels.” International Review of Economics & Finance 31: 232–248. Search in Google Scholar

Kapetanios, G 2003. “Determining the Stationarity Properties of Individual Series in Panel Datasets.” University of London Queen Mary Economics, Working Paper, 495. Search in Google Scholar

Kim, S. J., F. Moshirian, and E. Wu. 2005. “Dynamic Stock Market Integration Driven by the European Monetary Union: An Empirical Analysis.” Journal of Banking & Finance 29 (10): 2475–2502. Search in Google Scholar

Kim, Y. S., and J. J. Rous. 2012. “House Price Convergence: Evidence from US State and Metropolitan Area Panels.” Journal of Housing Economics 21 (2): 169–186. Search in Google Scholar

Konc, J., and D. Janezic. 2007. “An Improved Branch and Bound Algorithm for the Maximum Clique Problem.” Proteins 4: 5. Search in Google Scholar

Maneschiöld, P.-O 2006. “Integration Between the Baltic and International Stock Markets.” Emerging Markets Finance and Trade 42 (6): 25–45. Search in Google Scholar

Mankiw, N. G., D. Romer, and D. N. Weil. (1990). A Contribution to the Empirics of Economic GrowthTechnical report, National Bureau of Economic Research. Search in Google Scholar

Morana, C 2008. “International Stock Markets Comovements: The Role of Economic and Financial Integration.” Empirical Economics 35 (2): 333–359. Search in Google Scholar

Mylonidis, N., and C. Kollias. 2010. “Dynamic European Stock Market Convergence: Evidence from Rolling Cointegration Analysis in the First Euro-Decade.” Journal of Banking & Finance 34 (9): 2056–2064. Search in Google Scholar

Narayan, P. K., S. Mishra, and S. Narayan. 2011. “Do Market Capitalization and Stocks Traded Converge? New Global Evidence.” Journal of Banking & Finance 35 (10): 2771–2781. Search in Google Scholar

Onay, C 2006. “A Co-integration Analysis Approach to European Union Integration: The Case of Acceding and Candidate Countries.” European Integration Online Papers (EIoP) 10 (7): 1–11. Search in Google Scholar

Özkan, H., T. Stengons, and M. E. Yazgan. 2016. “Persistence and Convergence: Some Further Results.” Unpublished Manuscript, Department of Economics and Finance, University of Guelph. Search in Google Scholar

Pascual, A. G 2003. “Assessing European Stock Markets (co) Integration.” Economics Letters 78 (2): 197–203. Search in Google Scholar

Pesaran, H. M 2007. “A Pair-Wise Approach to Testing for Output and Growth Convergence.” Journal of Econometrics 138 (1): 312–355. Search in Google Scholar

Phillips, P. C., and D. Sul. 2007. “Transition Modeling and Econometric Convergence Tests.” Econometrica 75 (6): 1771–1855. Search in Google Scholar

Quah, D. T 1996. “Empirics for Economic Growth and Convergence.” European Economic Review 40 (6): 1353–1375. Search in Google Scholar

Rockinger, M., and G. Urga. 2000. “The Evolution of Stock Markets in Transition Economies.” Journal of Comparative Economics 28 (3): 456–472. Search in Google Scholar

Sala-i Martin, X. X 1996. “Regional Cohesion: Evidence and Theories of Regional Growth and Convergence.” European Economic Review 40 (6): 1325–1352. Search in Google Scholar

Scheicher, M 2001. “The Comovements of Stock Markets in Hungary, Poland and the Czech Republic.” International Journal of Finance & Economics 6 (1): 27–39. Search in Google Scholar

Stengos, T., and M. Yazgan. 2014a. “Persistence in Real Exchange Rate Convergence.” Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics and Econometrics 18 (1): 73–88. Search in Google Scholar

Stengos, T., and M. E. Yazgan. 2014b. “Persistence in Convergence.” Macroeconomic Dynamics 18 (04): 753–782. Search in Google Scholar

Stengos, T., M. E. Yazgan, and H. Ozkan. 2016. “Persistence in Convergence and Club Formation.” Discussion Paper, Department of Economics and Finance, University of Guelph. Search in Google Scholar

Stulz, R. M 1981. “On the Effects of Barriers to International Investment.” The Journal of Finance 36 (4): 923–934. Search in Google Scholar

Yilmazkuday, H 2013. “Inflation Targeting, Flexible Exchange Rates and Inflation Convergence.” Applied Economics 45 (5): 593–603. Search in Google Scholar

Yunus, N 2013. “Contagion in International Financial Markets: A Recursive Cointegration Approach.” Journal of Multinational Financial Management 23 (4): 327–337. Search in Google Scholar

Supplemental Material:

The online version of this article (DOI: offers supplementary material, available to authorized users.

Published Online: 2017-6-14

©2017 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston