Skip to content
Licensed Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter January 26, 2018

Producer organizations and contract farming: a comparative study of smallholders’ market strategies in South India

Inka Gersch

Abstract

The fundamental restructuring processes of agri-food networks in developing and emerging markets have intensified the debate on how to improve the integration of smallholders into so called modern value chains. In this context, the company-driven contract farming model and the member-based model of producer organizations are discussed by practitioners and in the scholarly literature as alternatives to traditional market systems. This study compares the models’ abilities to address economic challenges of highly fragmented and small-scale dominated agriculture on a household as well as on an aggregate level. It analyzes empirical data from the Indian floriculture sector with the global value chain approach. The study reveals that the smallholders perceive both contract farming and producer organization to be beneficial for their households’ economic risk situation, while only the producer organization has a positive effect on the households’ income. The contract farming benefits production and value chain efficiency, whereas the producer organization does not show an impact in these respects. We thus observe that the contract farming model increases value creation in the overall chain, but it does not raise the producer’s value capture; while the producer organization model does not heighten value creation in the overall chain, but it lifts the producers’ value capture. The organization’s individual capabilities determine how each model addresses the economic challenges. Overall, the author argues that contract farming and producer organizations are supplementing, not competitive, strategies and should be applied in combination.

Acknowledgement

The author would like to thank Martina Fuchs and Martin Franz for their support and the anonymous referees for their comments on earlier versions of this paper.

References

Agricultural Census India (2015): Agricultural census 2010–11. agcensus.nic.in/document/agcensus2010/allindia201011H.pdf (accessed 21.04.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA) (2017): Floriculture. apeda.in/apedawebsite/SubHead_Products/Floriculture.htm (accessed 21.11.2017).Search in Google Scholar

Agriculture Division Planning Commission Government Of India (2011): Report of the Working Group on Agricultural Marketing Infrastructure, Secondary Agriculture and Policy Required for Internal and External Trade for the Twelfth Five Year Plan. www.esocialsciences.org/Download/repecDownload.aspx?fname=A2015527145117_39.pdf&fcategory=Articles&AId=6873&fref=repec (accessed 11.10.2016).Search in Google Scholar

Altenburg, T./Weller, J. (1991): Kontraktproduktion – ein Instrument zur Verbesserung der wirtschaftlichen Lage von Kleinbauern? In: Nord-Süd aktuell, (5)3, 387–404.Search in Google Scholar

Arias, P./Hallam, D./Krivonos, E./Morrison, J. (2013): Smallholder integration in changing food markets. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations/ Rome.Search in Google Scholar

Artiuch, P./Kornstein, S. (2012): Thoughts on food waste solutions. MIT Independent Activities Period Research Project. http://mitpsc.mit.edu/blog/archivepage/iap12-sam-kornstein/ (accessed 13.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

AVT Natural Products Ltd. (2014): Post harvest processing centers. www.avtnatural.com/post_harvest_processing_centers.html (accessed 19.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Barrett, C.B./Bachke, M./Bellemare, M.F./Michelson, H.C./Narayanan, S./Walker, T.F. (2011): Smallholder Participation in Contract Farming: Comparative Evidence from Five Countries. In: World Development (40)4, 715–730.10.1016/j.worlddev.2011.09.006Search in Google Scholar

Bijman, J. (2008): Contract farming in developing countries: an overview. www.wageningenur.nl/upload_mm/5/c/b/79333121-6f4b-4f86-9e8e-0a1782e784d6_ReviewContractFarming.pdf (accessed 04.01.2015).Search in Google Scholar

Bijman, J./Ton, G. (2008): Producer organizations in agriculture development. Producer organizations and value chains. In: Capacity.Org, 34, 4–6.Search in Google Scholar

Census Organization of India (2011): Tamil Nadu population census data 2011. www.census2011.co.in/census/state/tamil+nadu.html (accessed 8.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Dannenberg, P./Nduru, G.M. (2013): Practices in international value chains: the case of the Kenyan fruit and vegetable chain beyond the exclusion debate. In: Tijdschrift voor economische en sociale geografie, (104)1, 41–56.10.1111/j.1467-9663.2012.00719.xSearch in Google Scholar

DAC – Department of Agriculture and Cooperation (2011a): Agricultural census 2010/2011 Complete report. www.agcensus.nic.in/document/agcensus2010/completereport.pdf (accessed 18.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

DAC – Department of Agriculture and Cooperation (2011b): Agricultural census. Graphs. www.agcensus.nic.in/document/agcensus2010/agcen2010rep.htm (accessed 25.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

DAC – Department of Agriculture and Cooperation (2013): Policy and progress guidelines for farmer producer organizations. www.nhm.nic.in/Archive/FPO-Policy&Process-GuidelinesDAC2013.pdf (accessed 13.11.2014)Search in Google Scholar

Debajit, M./Ghosh, S. (2016): Growth and export status of Indian floriculture: A review. Agricultural Reviews, (37)1, 77–80.Search in Google Scholar

Department Of Agriculture, Cooperation & Farmers Welfare, Ministry Of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare (2015): All India report on agriculture census 2010-1. agcensus.nic.in/document/ac1011/reports/air2010-11complete.pdf (accessed 23.11.2017).Search in Google Scholar

Eaton, C./Shepherd, A.W. (2001): Contract farming. Partnership for growth. Rom. (=FAO Agricultural Bulletin Services No. 145).Search in Google Scholar

Fan, S./Brzeska, J./Keyzer, M./Halsema, A. (2013): From subsistence to profit: transforming smallholder farms. Food Policy Report. International Food Policy Research Institute/ Washington, DC.10.2499/9780896295582Search in Google Scholar

FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2011): Annual report on FAO activities in support of producers’ organizations and agricultural cooperatives. www.fao-ilo.org/fileadmin/user_upload/fao_ilo/pdf/2010_COPACreport.pdf (accessed 09.10.2016).Search in Google Scholar

FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2012): Statistical Yearbook 2012: World Food and Agriculture. www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/fao%20statistical%20yearbook2012.pdf (accessed 13.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2013a): Contract farming for inclusive market access. www.fao.org/3/a-i3526e.pdf (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

FAO (2013b): Food wastage footprint. Impacts on natural resources. www.fao.org/docrep/018/i3347e/i3347e.pdf (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (2016): Cooperatives and producers organizations. www.fao.org/partnerships/cooperatives/en/ (accessed 08.10.2016).Search in Google Scholar

FAO – Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, IFAD – International Fund for Agricultural Development, WFP –, World Food Programme (2012): Agricultural cooperatives: paving the way for food security and rural development. www.fao.org/docrep/016/ap088e/ap088e00.pdf (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Franz, M./Felix, M./Trebbin, A. (2014): Framing smallholder inclusion in global value chains – case studies from India and West Africa. In: Geographica Helvetica 69, 4, 239–247.10.5194/gh-69-239-2014Search in Google Scholar

Gangwar, R.K./Swati, T./Kumar, V./Singh, K./Singh, G. (2014): Food oroduction and post-harvest losses of food grains in India. In: Food Science and Quality Management 31, 48–52.Search in Google Scholar

Gereffi, G./Humphrey, J./Sturgeon, T. (2005) The governance of global value chains. In: Review of International Policy Economy, (12)1, 78–104.10.1080/09692290500049805Search in Google Scholar

Ghee, L.T./Dorral, R. (1992): Contract farming in Malaysia: with special reference to FELDA schemes. In: Glover, D./Teck, L./Ghee, L.T. (eds.): Contract farming in Southeast Asia: three country case studies. Kuala Lumpur, 71–114. Search in Google Scholar

Government of Tamil Nadu (2003): Tamil Nadu. Human Development Report. www.hdr.undp.org/en/content/tamil-nadu-human-development-report-2003 (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Gorton, M./Davidova, S. (2004): Farm productivity and efficiency in the CEE applicant countries: a synthesis of results. In: Agricultural Economics, (30)1, 1–6.10.1111/j.1574-0862.2004.tb00172.xSearch in Google Scholar

Gupta, H. (2007): The role of insurance in health care management in India”. In: International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance, 20(5), 379–391.10.1108/09526860710763307Search in Google Scholar

Gupta, R./Sankhe, S./Dobbs, R./Woetzel, J./Madgavkar, A./Hasyagar, A. (2014): From poverty to empowerment. India’s imperative for jobs, growth and effective basic services. www.mckinsey.com/insights/asia-pacific/indias_path_from_poverty_to_empowerment (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Haller, A. (2014): The “sowing of concrete”: Peri-urban smallholder perceptions of rural–urban land change in the Central Peruvian Andes. In: Land use policy 38: 239–247.10.1016/j.landusepol.2013.11.010Search in Google Scholar

Hegde, N.G (2010): Development of value chain for sustainable agriculture. Background paper for first round table discussion on farmers’ producer organization. Finance Corporation Ltd./ New Delhi.Search in Google Scholar

Henderson, J./Dicken, P./Hess, M./Coe, N./Yeung, H.W-c. (2002): Global production networks and the analysis of economic development. In: Review of International Policy Economy, (9)3, 436–464.10.1080/09692290210150842Search in Google Scholar

Hooper, D.U./Adair, E.C./Cardinale, B.J./Byrnes, J.E.K./Hungate, B.A./Matulich, K.L./Gonzalez, A./Duffy, J.E./Gamfeldt, L./O’Connor, M.I. (2012): A global synthesis reveals biodiversity loss as a major driver of ecosystem change. In: Nature, 486, 105–108.10.1038/nature11118Search in Google Scholar PubMed

Hughes, A. (2001): Global commodity networks, ethical trade and governmentality: Organizing business responsibility in the Kenyan cut flower industry. In: Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, (26)4, 390–406.10.1111/1475-5661.00031Search in Google Scholar

IFC – International Finance Corporation (2011): Accelerating inclusive business opportunities. Business models that make a difference. www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/12216300487cbe85bbddff51e3a7223f/InclusiveBusinessReport2011.pdf?MOD=AJPERES (accessed 28.01.2013).Search in Google Scholar

Kalungu, J.W./ Harris, D. (2013): Smallholder farmers’ perception of the impacts of climate change and variability on rain-fed agricultural practices in semi-arid and sub-humid regions of Kenya. Journal of Environment and Earth Science, 3(7), 129–140.Search in Google Scholar

Kumar, V./Patwari, Y./Ayush, H.N. (2008): Organised food retailing: a blessing or a curse? In: Economic and Political Weekly, (43)20, 67–75.Search in Google Scholar

Kumar Swain, P./ Kumar, C./ Kumar, P.R. (2012): Corporate farming vis-a-vis contract farming in India: a critical perspective. International Journal of Management and Social Sciences Research (IJMSSR), (1)3, 60–70.Search in Google Scholar

Little, P./Watts, M. (1994): Living under contract: contract farming and agrarian transformation in Sub-Saharan Africa. University of Wisconsin Press/ Wisconsin.Search in Google Scholar

Mayring, P. (2000): Qualitative content analysis. Forum: Qualitative Social Research, (1) 2, Art. 20. Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. Grundlagen und Techniken (7. Auflage). Deutscher Studien Verlag/ Weinheim.Search in Google Scholar

Markelova, H./Meinzen-Dick, R./Hellin, J./Dohrn, S. (2009): Collective action for smallholder market access. In: Food Policy, (34)1, 1–7.10.1016/j.foodpol.2008.10.001Search in Google Scholar

Memedovic, O./Shepherd, A. (2009): Agri-food value chains and poverty reduction: Overview of main issues, trend and experiences. Vienna. (=UNIDO Working Paper 12).Search in Google Scholar

Ministry of Commerce & Industry – Govt. of India (2017): Floriculture. www.apeda.gov.in/apedawebsite/SubHead_Products/Floriculture.htm (accessed 21.11.2017).Search in Google Scholar

Mitra, S.D./Mookherjee, M./Torero, M./Visaria, S. (2017): Asymmetric information and middleman margins: An Experiment with Indian Potato Farmers, CEPR Discussion Paper 11548. voxdev.org/topic/firms-trade/middleman-margins-and-market-structure-west-bengal-potato-supply-chains (accessed 20.11.2017).10.1596/29657Search in Google Scholar

Mohan, V. (2016): Flower fascination: India set to be floriculture trade leader. timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Flower-fascination-India-set-to-be-floriculture-trade-leader/articleshow/50979808.cms (accessed 21.11.2017).Search in Google Scholar

Muthukumaran, K. (2010): Indian floriculture industry. Opportunities and challenges. www.cab.org.in/CAB%20Calling%20Content/Financial%20Services%20to%20Indian%20Agriculture/Indian%20Floriculture%20Industry%20-%20Opportunities%20and%20Challenges.pdf (accessed 13.01.2015).Search in Google Scholar

National Horticulture Board (2015): Indian horticulture database – 2014. nhb.gov.in/PDFViwer.aspx?enc=3ZOO8K5CzcdC/Yq6HcdIxC0U1kZZenFuNVXacDLxz28= (accessed 21.11.2017).Search in Google Scholar

Ouma, S. (2015): Assembling export markets. The making and unmaking of global food Connections in West Africa. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell (RGS-IBG book series).10.1002/9781118632567Search in Google Scholar

Pachori, A. (2012): Economic inefficiencies in farm-market linkages in agriculture value chain in India: Problems and Solutions. Singapore. (=ISAS Working Paper No. 163).Search in Google Scholar

Pinto, A.C. (2009): Agricultural cooperatives and farmer organizations – role in rural development and poverty reduction. www.un.org/esa/socdev/egms/docs/2009/cooperatives/Pinto.pdf (accessed 26.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Ponte, S./Gibbon, P. (2005): Trading down: Africa, value chains and the global economy. Temple University Press, Philadelphia. Search in Google Scholar

Prasad, V. (2013): Contract farming through farmer producer organizations (FPOs) in India. New Delhi. (=CCS working Paper No. 293). Search in Google Scholar

Pritchard, B./Connell, J. (2011): Contract farming and the remaking of agrarian landscapes: Insights from South India’s chilli belt. In: Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography, (32)2, 236–252.10.1111/j.1467-9493.2011.00424.xSearch in Google Scholar

Prowse, M. (2007): Making contract farming work with cooperatives. London. (=ODI Opinion 87).Search in Google Scholar

Prowse, M. (2012): Contract farming in developing countries. A review. Paris. (=AFD – Research Department A Savoir 12).Search in Google Scholar

Rauch, T. (2014): New ruralities in the context of global economic and environmental change–are small-scale farmers bound to disappear? In: Geographica Helvetica, 69, 227–237.10.5194/gh-69-227-2014Search in Google Scholar

Riisgaard, L. (2009): Global value chains, labor organization and private social standards: lessons from East African cut flower industries. In: World Development,(37)2, 326–340.10.1016/j.worlddev.2008.03.003Search in Google Scholar

Rondot, P./Collion, M.-H. (eds.) (2001): Producer organizations. Their contribution to rural capacity building and poverty reduction. Washington, DC. (=World Bank Agriculture Technology Notes No. 28.).Search in Google Scholar

Setboonsarng, S. (2008): Global partnership in poverty reduction: contract farming and regional cooperation. ADB Institute Discussion Paper 89. Tokyo, Asian Development Bank Institute.Search in Google Scholar

Schamp, E. W. (2008): Globale Wertschöpfungsketten. In: Geographische Rundschau (60)9, 4–11.Search in Google Scholar

Schöttli, J./Pauli, M. (2011): Indien zwischen Subsistenzwirtschaft und Weltmarktführung. Heidelberg. (=RBZ Schwerpunkt Nr. 51/52). Search in Google Scholar

Singh, S. (2002): Multi-national corporations and agricultural development: a study of contract farming in the Indian Punjab. In: Journal of International Development (14)2, 181–194.10.1002/jid.858Search in Google Scholar

Spoor, M. (2015): Rural development and the future of small-scale family farms. Rome. (=FAO Rural Transformations – Technical Papers Series No 3).Search in Google Scholar

Stamm, A. (2004): Wertschöpfungsketten entwicklungspolitisch gestalten. Anforderungen an Handelspolitik und Wirtschaftsförderung. Deutsche Gesellschaft für technische Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH/ Eschborn.Search in Google Scholar

Swinnen, J. (2015): Value chains, agricultural markets and food security. In: State of agricultural commodity markets. Food and agriculture organization of the United Nations (FAO)/ Rome.Search in Google Scholar

TNFGA – Tamil Nadu Flower Growers Association (2007): Success story- Flower Growers Association. unpublished.Search in Google Scholar

The World Bank (2007): World development report 2008. Agriculture for development. www.siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDRS/Resources/477365-1327599046334/WDR_00_book.pdf (accessed 18.11.2014).Search in Google Scholar

Trebbin, A./Franz, M. (2010): Exclusivity of private governance structures in agro-food networks: Bayer and the food retailing and processing sector in India. Environment and Planning A, (42)9, 2043–2057.10.1068/a42504Search in Google Scholar

Trebbin, A./Hassler, M. (2012): Farmers’ producer companies in India: a new concept for collective action? In: Environment and Planning A, (44)2, 411–427.10.1068/a44143Search in Google Scholar

Wiggins, S./Kirsten, J./Llambi, L. (eds.) (2010): The future of small farms. In: World Development, (38)10, 1341–1348.10.1016/j.worlddev.2009.06.013Search in Google Scholar

Wrigley, N. (2003): Globalizing retail: conceptualizing the distribution-based transnational corporation. In Clark, G.J./Gertler, M.S./Feldman, M.P (eds.): Oxford handbook of economic geography. Oxford, 292–313.Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2017-7-11
Accepted: 2017-12-10
Published Online: 2018-1-26
Published in Print: 2018-3-26

© 2018 by De Gruyter