Accessible Unlicensed Requires Authentication Published by De Gruyter October 1, 2020

Startup Competitions and their Role in Entrepreneurial Ecosystems: A Conceptual Attempt

Lennard Stolz

Abstract

Research on entrepreneurial ecosystems (EEs) is still advancing as a concept that both practitioners and scholars claim has advanced beyond other approaches to fostering or explaining regional entrepreneurship. However, criticism of the concept centers on a lack of understanding of causes and effects and the importance of single instruments for its functionality. While practitioners and policy makers are jumping on the bandwagon and trying to aim policies directly at entrepreneurial ecosystems, investigation of the role of single instruments and their impact on entrepreneurial ecosystems remains insufficient. Fostering entrepreneurship through startup competitions (SUCs) is a decades-old policy instrument. Today, both scholars and practitioners mention SUCs as an element of entrepreneurial ecosystems, but analyzing them from that perspective remains undone. Building on a regional understanding of entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial ecosystems, this paper provides a novel framework for the role of startup competitions in entrepreneurial ecosystems. Following on previous studies of SUCs, this study identifies core mechanisms and benefits of the competitions and presents a general framework for SUCs. Then, the study results are synthesized with mechanisms central to entrepreneurial ecosystems, e.g., entrepreneurial learning, networks of entrepreneurial-related actors in the region, and financing entrepreneurship. It is argued that startup competitions work as network hubs in entrepreneurial ecosystems because they connect: a) entrepreneurs with each other, b) entrepreneurs with relevant actors (e.g., financiers, experts, entrepreneurship support organizations), c) those actors among themselves. Therefore, the competitions are “anchor events” and strengthen the overall quality of the EE in which they occur. The study also argues that SUCs benefit from a functioning EE’s positive climate for entrepreneurship and the availability of resources. The study is theoretical, and its findings lead to an agenda for further research.

JEL Classification: L26; R11; R58

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Lower Saxony Ministry of Science and Culture (Germany) under Grant number 76202-17-3/17. The Author would like to thank Rolf Sternberg and two anonymous reviewers for their helpful comment on an earlier version of this paper.

References

Ács, Z. J./Autio, E./Szerb, L. (2014): National Systems of Entrepreneurship: Measurement issues and policy implications. In: Research Policy, (43)3, 476–494. Search in Google Scholar

Adamczyk, S./Bullinger, A. C./Möslein, K. M. (2012): Innovation Contests: A Review, Classification and Outlook. In: Creativity and Innovation Management, (21)4, 335–360. Search in Google Scholar

Aldrich, H. E./Yang, T. (2014): How do entrepreneurs know what to do? learning and organizing in new ventures. In: Journal of Evolutionary Economics, (24)1, 59–82. Search in Google Scholar

Alvedalen, J./Boschma, R. (2017): A critical review of entrepreneurial ecosystems research: towards a future research agenda. In: European Planning Studies, (25)6, 887–903. Search in Google Scholar

Anderson, A. R./Miller, C. J. (2003): “Class matters”: human and social capital in the entrepreneurial process. In: The Journal of Socio-Economics, (32)1, 17–36. Search in Google Scholar

Auerswald, P. (2015): Enabling Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. Insights from Ecology to Inform Effective Entrepreneurship Policy (=Kauffman Foundation Research Series on City, Metro, and Regional Entrepreneurship). Source: https://www.kauffman.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/enabling_entrepreneurial_ecosystems.pdf (25.06.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Autio, E./Kenney, M./Mustar, P./Siegel, D./Wright, M. (2014): Entrepreneurial innovation: The importance of context. In: Research Policy, (43)7, 1097–1108. Search in Google Scholar

BarNir, A./Watson, W. E./Hutchins, H. M. (2011): Mediation and Moderated Mediation in the Relationship Among Role Models, Self-Efficacy, Entrepreneurial Career Intention, and Gender. In: Journal of Applied Social Psychology, (41)2, 270–297. Search in Google Scholar

Batjargal, B. (2003): Social Capital and Entrepreneurial Performance in Russia: A Longitudinal Study. In: Organization Studies, (24)4, 535–556. Search in Google Scholar

Bernoster, I./Rietveld, C./Thurik, A./Torrès, O. (2018): Overconfidence, Optimism and Entrepreneurship. In: Sustainability, (10)7, 2233. Search in Google Scholar

Bliemel, M./Flores, R./Klerk, S. de/Miles, M./Costas, B./Monteiro, P. (2016): The role and performance of accelerators in the Australian startup ecosystem. Working Paper of the University New South Wales Business School. Source: http://unsworks.unsw.edu.au/fapi/datastream/unsworks:38003/bin8ca2e40f-1d69-4eb9-8d99-e332794b8f8f?view=true (24.06.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Bosma, N./Hessels, J./Schutjens, V./van Praag, M./Verheul, I. (2012): Entrepreneurship and role models. In: Journal of Economic Psychology, (33)2, 410–424. Search in Google Scholar

Brown, R./Mason, C. (2017): Looking inside the spiky bits: a critical review and conceptualisation of entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Small Business Economics, (49)1, 11–30. Search in Google Scholar

Carbonara, E./Tran, H. T./Santarelli, E. (2019): Determinants of novice, portfolio, and serial entrepreneurship: an occupational choice approach. In: Small Business Economics, (31)3, 219. Search in Google Scholar

Cavallo, A./Ghezzi, A./Balocco, R. (2019): Entrepreneurial ecosystem research: present debates and future directions. In: International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, (15)4, 1291–1321. Search in Google Scholar

Clarysse, B./Wright, M./Bruneel, J./Mahajan, A. (2014): Creating value in ecosystems: Crossing the chasm between knowledge and business ecosystems. In: Research Policy, (43)7, 1164–1176. Search in Google Scholar

Content, J./Bosma, N./Jordaan, J./Sanders, M. (2019): Entrepreneurial ecosystems, entrepreneurial activity and economic growth: new evidence from European regions. In: Regional Studies, (53), 1–13. Search in Google Scholar

Credit, K./Mack, E. A./Mayer, H. (2018): State of the field: Data and metrics for geographic analyses of entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Geography Compass, (12)9, e12380. Search in Google Scholar

Cukier, D./Kon, F. (2018): A maturity model for software startup ecosystems. In: Journal of Innovation and Entrepreneurship, (7)1. Search in Google Scholar

Davidsson, P./Honig, B. (2003): The role of social and human capital among nascent entrepreneurs. In: Journal of Business Venturing, (18)3, 301–331. Search in Google Scholar

Delgado, M./Porter, M. E./Stern, S. (2010): Clusters and entrepreneurship. In: Journal of Economic Geography, (10)4, 495–518. Search in Google Scholar

Dubini, P. (1989): The influence of motivations and environment on business start-ups: Some hints for public policies. In: Journal of Business Venturing, (4)1, 11–26. Search in Google Scholar

Eickelpasch, A./Fritsch, M. (2005): Contests for cooperation—A new approach in German innovation policy. In: Research Policy, (34)8, 1269–1282. Search in Google Scholar

Esteve-Pérez, S./Mañez-Castillejo, J. A. (2008): The Resource-Based Theory of the Firm and Firm Survival. In: Small Business Economics, (30)3, 231–249. Search in Google Scholar

Feld, B. (2012): Startup Communities – Building an Entrepreneurial Ecosystem in your City. John Wiley & Sons, Inc.: Hoboken, NJ, USA. Search in Google Scholar

Feldman, M. P. (2001): The Entrepreneurial Event Revisited: Firm Formation in a Regional Context. In: Industrial and Corporate Change, (10)4, 861–891. Search in Google Scholar

Feldman, M. P./Francis, J./Bercovitz, J. (2005): Creating a Cluster While Building a Firm: Entrepreneurs and the Formation of Industrial Clusters. In: Regional Studies, (39)1, 129–141. Search in Google Scholar

Feldman, M. P./Siegel, D. S./Wright, M. (2019): New developments in innovation and entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Industrial and Corporate Change, (28)4, 817–826. Search in Google Scholar

Foo, M. D./Wong, P. K./Ong, A. (2005): Do others think you have a viable business idea? Team diversity and judges’ evaluation of ideas in a business plan competition. In: Journal of Business Venturing, (20)3, 385–402. Search in Google Scholar

Forbes, D. P. (2005): Are some entrepreneurs more overconfident than others? In: Journal of Business Venturing, (20)5, 623–640. Search in Google Scholar

Fotopoulos, G./Louri, H. (2000): Determinants of Hazard Confronting New Entry: Does Financial Structure Matter? In: Review of Industrial Organization, (17)3, 285–300. Search in Google Scholar

Fotopoulos, G./Storey, D. J. (2019): Public policies to enhance regional entrepreneurship: another programme failing to deliver? In: Small Business Economics, (53)1, 189–209. Search in Google Scholar

Gailly, B. (2006): Can You Teach Entrepreneurs to Write their Business Plan? An Empirical Evaluation of Business Plan Competitions. In: Fayolle, A./Klandt, H. (Eds.): International entrepreneurship education. Issues and newness. Edward Elgar: Cheltenham, U.K, Northampton, Mass., 133–154. Search in Google Scholar

Garud, R./Gehman, J./Giuliani, A. P. (2014): Contextualizing entrepreneurial innovation: A narrative perspective. In: Research Policy, (43)7, 1177–1188. Search in Google Scholar

Gonzalez-Uribe, J./Leatherbee, M. (2018): The Effects of Business Accelerators on Venture Performance: Evidence from Start-Up Chile. In: The Review of Financial Studies, (31)4, 1566–1603. Search in Google Scholar

Guerrero, M./Urbano, D./Fayolle, A./Klofsten, M./Mian, S. (2016): Entrepreneurial universities: emerging models in the new social and economic landscape. In: Small Business Economics, (47)3, 551–563. Search in Google Scholar

Harrington, K. (2016): In Your Entrepreneurial Ecosystem Scaling? In: Innovations: Technology, Governance, Globalization, (11)1, 126–142. Search in Google Scholar

Hechavarría, D. M./Ingram, A. E. (2019): Entrepreneurial ecosystem conditions and gendered national-level entrepreneurial activity: a 14-year panel study of GEM. In: Small Business Economics, (53)2, 431–458. Search in Google Scholar

Honig, B. (2001): Learning Strategies and Resources for Entrepreneurs and Intrapreneurs. In: Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, (26)1, 21–34. Search in Google Scholar

Honig, B. (2004): Entrepreneurship Education: Toward a Model of Contingency-Based Business Planning. In: Academy of Management Learning & Education, (3)3, 258–273. Search in Google Scholar

Invernizzi, A. C./Menozzi, A./Passarani, D. A./Patton, D./Viglia, G. (2017): Entrepreneurial overconfidence and its impact upon performance. In: International Small Business Journal, (116)1, 709–728. Search in Google Scholar

Isenberg, D. J. (2010): The big idea: How to start an entrepreneurial revolution. In: Harvard Business Review, (88)6. Search in Google Scholar

Isenberg, D. J. (2011): Introducing the Entrepreneurship Ecosystem: Four Defining Characteristics. Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/danisenberg/2011/05/25/introducing-the-entrepreneurship-ecosystem-four-defining-characteristics/ (25.02.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Katz, J. A. (2003): The chronology and intellectual trajectory of American entrepreneurship education. In: Journal of Business Venturing, (18)2, 283–300. Search in Google Scholar

Kerr, W. R./Lerner, J./Schoar, A. (2014): The Consequences of Entrepreneurial Finance: Evidence from Angel Financings. In: Review of Financial Studies, (27)1, 20–55. Search in Google Scholar

Kiese, M./Kahl, J. (2017): Competitive funding in North Rhine-Westphalia. In: Competitiveness Review, (27)5, 495–515. Search in Google Scholar

Klinger, B./Schündeln, M. (2011): Can Entrepreneurial Activity be Taught? Quasi-Experimental Evidence from Central America. In: World Development, (39)9, 1592–1610. Search in Google Scholar

Koellinger, P./Minniti, M./Schade, C. (2007): “I think I can, I think I can”: Overconfidence and entrepreneurial behavior. In: Journal of Economic Psychology, (28)4, 502–527. Search in Google Scholar

Kuebart, A./Ibert, O. (2019): Beyond territorial conceptions of entrepreneurial ecosystems: The dynamic spatiality of knowledge brokering in seed accelerators. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, (63)2–4, 118–133. Search in Google Scholar

Lovgren, A./Ross, R. B./Leschewski, A./Peterson, H. C. (2020): Do Entrepreneurial Assistance Programs Create Value for Agri-Food Entrepreneurs? In: Entrepreneurship Research Journal, (10)1, 377. Search in Google Scholar

Lundström, A./Stevenson, L. A. (2005): Entrepreneurship Policy: Theory and Practice. (=International Studies in Entrepreneurship, Band 9). Springer: Boston, MA. Search in Google Scholar

Lutz, E./Bender, M./Achleitner, A.-K./Kaserer, C. (2013): Importance of spatial proximity between venture capital investors and investees in Germany. In: Journal of Business Research, (66)11, 2346–2354. Search in Google Scholar

Mack, E./Mayer, H. (2016): The evolutionary dynamics of entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Urban Studies, (53)10, 2118–2133. Search in Google Scholar

Malecki, E. J. (2018): Entrepreneurship and entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Geography Compass, (12)3, e12359. Search in Google Scholar

Maskell, P./Bathelt, H./Malmberg, A. (2004): Temporary Clusters and Knowledge Creation: The Effects of International Trade Fairs, Conventions and Other Professional Gatherings. SPACES 2004–4. Source: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.463.8444&rep=rep1&type=pdf (26.06.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Mason, C./Anderson, M./Kessl, T./Hruskova, M. (2020): Promoting student enterprise: Reflections on a university start-up programme. In: Local Economy: The Journal of the Local Economy Policy Unit, (35)1, 68–79. Search in Google Scholar

McKenzie, D. (2017): Identifying and Spurring High-Growth Entrepreneurship: Experimental Evidence from a Business Plan Competition. In: American Economic Review, (107)8, 2278–2307. Search in Google Scholar

McKenzie, D./Sansone, D. (2019): Predicting entrepreneurial success is hard: Evidence from a business plan competition in Nigeria. In: Journal of Development Economics, (141), 102369. Search in Google Scholar

Michelsen, C./Wolf, H./Schwartz, M. (2013): Regional Entrepreneurial Opportunities in the Biotech Industry: Exploring the Transition from Award-Winning Nascent Entrepreneurs to Real Start-Ups. In: European Planning Studies, (21)11, 1708–1734. Search in Google Scholar

Miller, D. J./Ács, Z. J. (2017): The campus as entrepreneurial ecosystem: the University of Chicago. In: Small Business Economics, (49)1, 75–95. Search in Google Scholar

MIT (2020): MIT $100k. Source: https://www.mit100k.org/ (20.02.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Motoyama, Y./Knowlton, K. (2017): Examining the Connections within the Startup Ecosystem: A Case Study of St. Louis. In: Entrepreneurship Research Journal, (7)1. Search in Google Scholar

Neck, H. M./Meyer, G. D./Cohen, B./Corbett, A. C. (2004): An Entrepreneurial System View of New Venture Creation. In: Journal of Small Business Management, (42)2, 190–208. Search in Google Scholar

Parker, S. C. (2013): Do serial entrepreneurs run successively better-performing businesses? In: Journal of Business Venturing, (28)5, 652–666. Search in Google Scholar

Passaro, R./Quinto, I./Thomas, A. (2017): Start-up competitions as learning environment to foster the entrepreneurial process. In: International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research, (23)3, 426–445. Search in Google Scholar

Rasmussen, E./Borch, O. J. (2010): University capabilities in facilitating entrepreneurship: A longitudinal study of spin-off ventures at mid-range universities. In: Research Policy, (39)5, 602–612. Search in Google Scholar

Rice University (2020): RICE Business Plan Competition. Source: https://rbpc.rice.edu/ (20.02.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Ross, L. W./Byrd, K. A. (2011): Business Plan Competitions: Start-up “Idols” and Their Twenty-First Century Launch Pads. In: Journal of Higher Education Theory and Practice, (11)4, 53–64. Search in Google Scholar

Russell, R./Atchison, M./Brooks, R. (2008): Business plan competitions in tertiary institutions: encouraging entrepreneurship education. In: Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management, (30)2, 123–138. Search in Google Scholar

Schäfer, S./Mayer, H. (2019): Entrepreneurial ecosystems: Founding figures and research frontiers in economic geography. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, (63) 2–4, 55–63. Search in Google Scholar

Schwartz, M./Goethner, M./Michelsen, C./Waldmann, N. (2013): Start-up Competitions as an Instrument of Entrepreneurship Policy: The German Experience. In: European Planning Studies, (21)10, 1578–1597. Search in Google Scholar

Sekula, R./Bakhru, S./Zappe, S. (2009): Playing to win. In: Nature Biotechnology, (27)9, 793–796. Search in Google Scholar

Semrau, T./Werner, A. (2014): How Exactly Do Network Relationships Pay Off? The Effects of Network Size and Relationship Quality on Access to Start-Up Resources. In: Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, (38)3, 501–525. Search in Google Scholar

Shane, S./Cable, D. (2002): Network Ties, Reputation, and the Financing of New Ventures. In: Management Science, (48)3, 364–381. Search in Google Scholar

Shane, S./Stuart, T. (2002): Organizational Endowments and the Performance of University Start-ups. In: Management Science, (48)1, 154–170. Search in Google Scholar

Shepherd, D. A./Krueger, N. F. (2002): An Intentions–Based Model of Entrepreneurial Teams’ Social Cognition*. In: Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, (27)2, 167–185. Search in Google Scholar

Silver, J. K./Binder, D. S./Zubcevik, N./Zafonte, R. D. (2016): Healthcare Hackathons Provide Educational and Innovation Opportunities: A Case Study and Best Practice Recommendations. In: Journal of medical systems, (40)7, 177. Search in Google Scholar

Spigel, B. (2016): Developing and governing entrepreneurial ecosystems: the structure of entrepreneurial support programs in Edinburgh, Scotland. In: International Journal of Innovation and Regional Development, (7)2, 141–160. Search in Google Scholar

Spigel, B. (2017): The Relational Organization of Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. In: Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, (41)1, 49–72. Search in Google Scholar

Spigel, B./Harrison, R. (2018): Toward a process theory of entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Strategic Entrepreneurship Journal, (12)1, 151–168. Search in Google Scholar

Spilling, O. R. (1996): The entrepreneurial system: On entrepreneurship in the context of a mega-event. In: Journal of Business Research, (36)1, 91–103. Search in Google Scholar

Stam, E. (2015): Entrepreneurial Ecosystems and Regional Policy: A Sympathetic Critique. In: European Planning Studies, (23)9, 1759–1769. Search in Google Scholar

Stam, E. (2018): Measuring Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. In: O’Connor, A. et al. (Hrsg.): Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. (=International Studies in Entrepreneurship). Springer International Publishing: Cham, 173–197. Search in Google Scholar

Stam, E./Spigel, B. (2018): Entrepreneurial Ecosystems. In: Clercq, D. de et al. (Eds.): The SAGE handbook of small business and entrepreneurship. SAGE: Los Angeles, London, New Delhi, 407–421. Search in Google Scholar

Stam, E./van de Ven, A. (2019): Entrepreneurial ecosystem elements. In: Small Business Economics, . advanced online publication. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11187-019-00270-6. Search in Google Scholar

Sternberg, R. (2007): Entrepreneurship, Proximity and Regional Innovation Systems. In: Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie, (98)5, 652–666. Search in Google Scholar

Sternberg, R./Bloh, J. v./Coduras, A. (2019): A new framework to measure entrepreneurial ecosystems at the regional level. In: Zeitschrift für Wirtschaftsgeographie, (63)2–4, 103–117. Search in Google Scholar

Sternberg, R./Litzenberger, T. (2004): Regional clusters in Germany--their geography and their relevance for entrepreneurial activities. In: European Planning Studies, (12)6, 767–791. Search in Google Scholar

Stuetzer, M./Obschonka, M./Brixy, U./Sternberg, R./Cantner, U. (2014): Regional characteristics, opportunity perception and entrepreneurial activities. In: Small Business Economics, (42)2, 221–244. Search in Google Scholar

van Auken, H./Fry, F. L./Stephens, P. (2006): The Influence of Role Models On Entrepreneurial Intentions. In: Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship, (11)02, 157–167. Search in Google Scholar

van de Ven, H. (1993): The development of an infrastructure for entrepreneurship. In: Journal of Business Venturing, (8)3, 211–230. Search in Google Scholar

van Rijnsoever, F. J. (2020): Meeting, mating, and intermediating: How incubators can overcome weak network problems in entrepreneurial ecosystems. In: Research Policy, (49)1, 103884. Search in Google Scholar

Watson, K. (2019): Stimulating Entrepreneurial Behaviour Through Start-Up Competitions: Current Features of Provision in UK Higher Education Institutions. In: McAdam, M./Cunningham, J. A. (Hrsg.): Entrepreneurial Behaviour. Springer International Publishing: Cham, 121–143. Search in Google Scholar

Watson, K./McGowan, P./Cunningham, J. A. (2018): An exploration of the Business Plan Competition as a methodology for effective nascent entrepreneurial learning. In: International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behavior & Research, (24)1, 121–146. Search in Google Scholar

Watson, K./McGowan, P./Smith, P. (2015): Leveraging Effectual Means through Business Plan Competition Participation. In: Industry and Higher Education, (29)6, 481–492. Search in Google Scholar

Wen, C. T./Chen, Y. W. (2007): The innovation process of entrepreneurial teams in dynamic business plan competition: from sense-making perspective. In: International Journal of Technology Management, (39)3/4, 346. Search in Google Scholar

World Bank (2018): Tech Startup Ecosystem in West Bank and Gaza – Findings and Recommendations. Source: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/715581526049753145/pdf/126144-replacement-WBG-ecosystem-mapping-digital.pdf (25.06.2020). Search in Google Scholar

World Economic Forum (2013): Entrepreneurial Ecosystems Around the Globe and Company Growth Dynamics. Source: http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_EntrepreneurialEcosystems_Report_2013.pdf (25.06.2020). Search in Google Scholar

Wright, M./Siegel, D. S./Mustar, P. (2017): An emerging ecosystem for student start-ups. In: The Journal of Technology Transfer, (42)4, 909–922. Search in Google Scholar

Ylinenpää, H. (2009): Entrepreneurship and Innovation Systems: Towards a Development of the ERIS/IRIS Concept. In: European Planning Studies, (17)8, 1153–1170. Search in Google Scholar

Received: 2020-03-17
Accepted: 2020-09-16
Published Online: 2020-10-01
Published in Print: 2020-11-25

© 2020 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Boston