All the Fish in the Sea: Maximum Sustainable Yield and the Failure of Fisheries Management

Carmel Finley

Published by University of Chicago Press 2011

All the Fish in the Sea

Maximum Sustainable Yield and the Failure of Fisheries Management

Carmel Finley

https://doi.org/10.7208/9780226249681

Overview
Contents

About this book

Between 1949 and 1955, the State Department pushed for an international fisheries policy grounded in maximum sustainable yield (MSY). The concept is based on a confidence that scientists can predict, theoretically, the largest catch that can be taken from a species’ stock over an indefinite period. And while it was modified in 1996 with passage of the Sustained Fisheries Act, MSY is still at the heart of modern American fisheries management. As fish populations continue to crash, however, it is clear that MSY is itself not sustainable. Indeed, the concept has been widely criticized by scientists for ignoring several key factors in fisheries management and has led to the devastating collapse of many fisheries.

Carmel Finley reveals that the fallibility of MSY lies at its very inception—as a tool of government rather than science. The foundational doctrine of the MSY emerged at a time when the US government was using science to promote and transfer Western knowledge and technology, and to ensure that American ships and planes would have free passage through the world’s seas and skies. Finley charts the history of US fisheries science using MSY as her focus, and in particular its application to halibut, tuna, and salmon fisheries. Fish populations the world over are threatened, and All the Fish in the Sea will help sound warnings of the effect of any management policies divested from science itself.

Author information

Carmel Finley teaches in the Department of History at Oregon State University. She is coeditor of Two Paths toward Sustainable Forests: Public Values in Canada and the United States.

Reviews

“Fisheries science and management are ripe for study by professional historians skilled in archival research and analysis. Here Carmel Finley applies both of these skills in abundance, focusing them on the great salmon and tuna fisheries of the North Pacific, and particularly the events surrounding the negotiations of the post–World War II peace treaty between Japan and the United States and the trilateral International Convention for the North Pacific Fisheries. She demonstrates how the ideas of the time percolated the 1958 conference on the Law of the Sea and, eventually, came to reside in the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea. As a true historian, Finley also reaches back to the origins of the concepts of fisheries science in the research and politics of the 1930s in Europe and North America, and relates the personalities of the major players with the institutional and political framework within which they were operating. A tour de force indeed.”

— Sidney J. Holt, coauthor of On the Dynamics of Exploited Fish Populations

“While its title sounds harmless enough, this book explodes the myths surrounding MSY, which we learn began its career supporting the commercial interests of the US tuna and salmon fisheries against their competitors—long before scientists anywhere knew how to calculate anything resembling maximum sustainable yield. It is fascinating, although it does demonstrate how ignorant we are of the strange origins of what is still a controversial concept. There is a stark lesson to be learned in an era in which a similar new term, ‘ecosystem-based fisheries management,’ is bandied about as if people know what it is.”

— Daniel Pauly, University of British Columbia

“The decline and collapse of world fisheries is repeatedly cited as exemplary of the ‘tragedy of the commons’—the dilemma whereby individuals, acting in their own rational, individual self-interest, destroy a common good. Using extensive primary sources, Carmel Finley shows that this view is incorrect, and that the decline of fisheries had little to do with the inadvertent adverse impacts of individual action, and everything to do with deliberate governmental and international policy. Since the end of World War II, the United States has consciously pursued a policy of encouraging more and more and more fishing, a policy that had little to do with the needs or interests of fishermen (much less fish) and everything to do with U.S. strategic and economic interests. Not surprisingly, fishermen and fish suffered the consequences. It was a tragedy, but not of the commons. It was a tragedy of attempted enclosure. This is a very important book, one that no environmentalist can afford to ignore.”

— Naomi Oreskes, University of California, San Diego

“This little book, if read by key decision makers, should help to galvanize a reaction against the continuation of the fishery policy currently followed by most seafaring nations. . . . [Finley’s] account of an important topic will be of value to students as well as professional biologists, politicians, and economists.”

— J. C. Briggs, Choice

“This smart little book has all the trappings of a historical account, with endnotes, an extensive bibliography, and a comprehensive index, but it can also be read as a whodunit. The crime scene is the Pacific Ocean, and the motive was access to the fish resources that both Japan and the US were exploiting and/or eyeing, especially salmon in Alaska and tuna in the Pacific, the latter also requiring small bait fishes from coastal waters in Central America. The victim was good faith—the use of argument based on scientific evidence to articulate legitimate positions. The villain is US foreign policy, specifically its fisheries branch . . . [and] the weapon used for the deed, and the main theme of this book, was the concept of ‘maximum sustainable yield’ (MSY), used by Latin American politicians who objected to the expansion of US tuna fisheries into what later became their exclusive economic zones (EEZs), long before MSY became quantifiable.”

— Quarterly Review of Biology

“Finley’s monograph is a brilliant exploration of Cold War international politics and scientific intrigue.”

— Rodolfo John Alaniz, University of California, San Diego, Journal of the History of Biology

Topics

General Interest

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	vii
Abbreviations Publicly Available Download PDF	ix
Acknowledgments Publicly Available Download PDF	xi
Introduction Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	1
1. The Quest for Rational Fishing Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	11
2. The Confrontation at Bristol Bay Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	27
3. The Pacific Fisheries Frontier Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	45
4. The Fish War with Japan Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	67
5. Shaping Fisheries Science Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	82
6. The Line in the Water Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	100
7. The Road to Rome Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	117
8. The Meeting in Rome Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	134
Conclusion: Fishing “Up” to MSY Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	154
Notes Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	169
Index Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	197

Language: English
Publisher: University of Chicago Press
Audience: Professional and scholarly;
Pages
- Main content: 224
Illustrations
- Other: 16 halftones, 3 line drawings
Keywords: sustainable; sustainability; fishing; management; yield; academic; scholarly; research; textbook; agriculture; marine life; aquatic; msy; fisheries; educational; higher education; college; university; species; legal; laws; 1990s; population; theory; government; science; technology; history; historical; policy; bristol bay; pacific; oceans; japan; rome; geographic; myths; commercial; economic; international; cold war; alaska; salmon; political

eBook

Published: August 22, 2011
ISBN: 9780226249681