Evidence of the Law

Gary Lawson

Published by University of Chicago Press 2017

Evidence of the Law

Proving Legal Claims

Gary Lawson

https://doi.org/10.7208/9780226432199

Overview
Contents

About this book

How does one prove the law? If your neighbor breaks your window, the law regulates how you can show your claim to be true or false; but how do you prove that in breaking your window your neighbor has broken the law? American jurisprudence devotes an elaborate body of doctrine—and an equally elaborate body of accompanying scholarly commentary—to worrying about how to prove facts. It establishes rules for the admissibility of evidence, creates varying standards of proof, and assigns burdens of proof that determine who wins or loses when the facts are unclear. But the law is shockingly inexplicit when addressing these issues with respect to the proof of legal claims. Indeed, the entire language of evidentiary proof, so sophisticated when it comes to questions of fact, is largely absent from the American legal system with respect to questions of law.

As Gary Lawson shows, legal claims are inherently objects of proof, and whether or not the law acknowledges the point openly, proof of legal claims is just a special case of the more general norms governing proof of any claim. As a result, similar principles of evidentiary admissibility, standards of proof, and burdens of proof operate, and must operate, in the background of claims about the law. This book brings these evidentiary principles for proving law out of the shadows so that they can be analyzed, clarified, and discussed. Viewing legal problems through this lens of proof illuminates debates about everything from constitutional interpretation to the role of stipulations in litigation. Rather than prescribe resolutions to any of those debates, Evidence of the Law instead provides a set of tools that can be used to make those debates more fruitful, whatever one’s substantive views may be. As lawyers, judges, and legal subjects confront uncertainty about what the law is, they can, should, and must, Lawson argues, be guided by the same kinds of abstract considerations, structures, and doctrines long used to make determinations about questions of fact.

Author information

Gary Lawson is the Philip S. Beck Professor at the Boston University School of Law. He is coauthor of The Origins of the Necessary and Proper Clause and The Constitution of Empire: Territorial Expansion and American Legal History and the author of seven editions of Federal Administrative Law. He lives in Acton, MA.

Reviews

“Twenty years ago, Lawson wrote an extremely good and potentially highly influential article titled 'Proving the Law.' As lawyers and judges and legal subjects confront uncertainty about what the law is, they can and should, Lawson argued, be guided by the same kinds of considerations and structures and doctrines long used to make determinations about uncertain questions of fact. This idea is novel, important, and right, but it has not penetrated legal thought nearly as much as it should have. Adding detail, applications, embellishments, and implementation to the idea, Evidence of the Law will increase the influence and visibility and usefulness of Lawson’s important argument.”

— Frederick Schauer, University of Virginia School of Law, author of "Thinking Like a Lawyer" and "The Force of Law"

“Evidence of the Law illuminates how many of the issues that are treated explicitly for factual disputes (for example, admissibility rules and burdens and standards of proof) are also present in disputes about questions of law—however, they are typically presupposed or left implicit in legal doctrine, reasoning, and decision making. Those who specialize in any doctrinal area of law will see how these epistemological issues apply in their domains, and those who specialize in areas of evidence, proof, and procedure will see ways in which their conceptual tools may have broader applicability throughout the law. This is a book that should be read by every law professor, and probably every judge and litigator, as well.”

— Michael S. Pardo, University of Alabama School of Law, coauthor of "Minds, Brains, and Law: The Conceptual Foundations of Law and Neuroscience"

“This is a very, very good book. Evidence of the Law is original, smart, careful, and extremely well-written, and makes a genuinely valuable contribution on a topic of major significance to virtually every field of law. It strikes just the right balance between high theory and the discussion of real-world legal examples and practical problems; between backward-looking analysis and forward-looking suggestions; and between seriousness and lighthearted humor. As Lawson says in his conclusion, ‘This book was not written in order to argue. It was written in order to help start a conversation. I believe that there is value in talking about evidence of the law. What say you?’ Speaking for myself, I will be delighted to join that conversation.”

— Joseph L. Hoffmann, Indiana University Maurer School of Law

Topics

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	v
Introduction Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	1
Chapter One. The Formal Structure of Proof Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	16
Chapter Two. Proving the Law Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	45
Chapter Three. Proof in Interpretation Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	83
Chapter Four. Understanding Indeterminacy Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	108
Chapter Five. Building the Imperfect Evidence Set Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	133
Chapter Six. Stipulating the Law Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	147
Chapter Seven. Selecting Standards of Proof Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	193
Acknowledgments Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	209
Notes Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	211
Index Requires Authentication Unlicensed Licensed Download PDF	247

Language: English
Publisher: University of Chicago Press
Audience: Professional and scholarly;
Pages
- Main content: 264
Keywords: proof; proof of law; standards of proof; evidence; evidence sets; legal epistemology; legal claims

eBook

Published: February 21, 2017
ISBN: 9780226432199