The Birth of Conservative Judaism

Michael Cohen

Michael Cohen

The Birth of Conservative Judaism

Solomon Schechter's Disciples and the Creation of an American Religious Movement

Columbia University Press | 2012

https://doi.org/10.7312/cohe15635

Overview
Contents

About this book

Solomon Schechter (1847–1915), the charismatic leader of New York's Jewish Theological Seminary (JTS), came to America in 1902 intent on revitalizing traditional Judaism. While he advocated a return to traditional practices, Schechter articulated no clear position on divisive issues, instead preferring to focus on similarities that could unite American Jewry under a broad message. Michael R. Cohen demonstrates how Schechter, unable to implement his vision on his own, turned to his disciples, rabbinical students and alumni of JTS, to shape his movement. By midcentury, Conservative Judaism had become the largest American Jewish grouping in the United States, guided by Schechter's disciples and their continuing efforts to embrace diversity while eschewing divisive debates.

Yet Conservative Judaism's fluid boundaries also proved problematic for the movement, frustrating many rabbis who wanted a single platform to define their beliefs. Cohen demonstrates how a legacy of tension between diversity and boundaries now lies at the heart of Conservative Judaism's modern struggle for relevance. His analysis explicates four key claims: that Conservative Judaism's clergy, not its laity or Seminary, created and shaped the movement; that diversity was—and still is—a crucial component of the success and failure of new American religions; that the Conservative movement's contemporary struggle for self-definition is tied to its origins; and that the porous boundaries between Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Judaism reflect the complexity of the American Jewish landscape—a fact that Schechter and his disciples keenly understood. Rectifying misconceptions in previous accounts of Conservative Judaism's emergence, Cohen's study enables a fresh encounter with a unique religious phenomenon.

Author information

Michael R. Cohen is director of Jewish Studies at Tulane University in New Orleans. He received his Ph.D. in Near Eastern and Judaic studies from Brandeis University and his A.B. with honors from Brown University. A recipient of the American Jewish Historical Society's Ruth B. Fein Prize and a Bernard and Audre Rapoport Fellowship at the American Jewish Archives, he is also a Monroe Fellow at the New Orleans Gulf South Center at Tulane University.

Reviews

Cohen's arguments are complex, subtle, and based on a careful reading of the sources.

Jonathan B. Krasner:
In this first book, Cohen distinguishes himself as an innovative and significant young scholar of American Judaism.

Matthew Lagrone:
...should quickly become the standard work on the emergence of the movement.

Lawrence Grossman:
A fascinating new history

Pamela S. Nadell, American University:
Conservative Judaism has found its historian for the twenty-first century. In The Birth of Conservative Judaism, Michael R. Cohen has written a boldly argued, lucid history of the origins of what he rightly calls a new American religious movement. Repudiating earlier historians who retrojected Conservatism's origins to nineteenth-century Europe or to acculturating immigrants, Cohen turns our gaze to where it should have been all along—to the charismatic teacher Solomon Schechter and the generation of rabbis he trained to perpetuate his vision and forge a new path into the future of American Judaism.

Jeffrey S. Gurock, Yeshiva University:
An insightful work of social history grounded in diligent archival research. Michael R. Cohen explores the mission, trials, achievements, and frustrations of the rabbis who gave birth to the Conservative Movement in American Judaism. He exposes the challenges a Jewish religious group faced in molding a faith community, respectful of tradition yet attuned to the demands of modern society.

Jonathan D. Sarna, Brandeis University, author of American Judaism: A History:
This path-breaking and provocative volume challenges Conservative Judaism's founding myth and rewrites its subsequent history. The most important study of early Conservative Judaism in more than half-a-century, it should be required reading for all students of American Judaism and for anyone who cares about the Conservative movement's past, present, and future.

Frontmatter Free access PDF PDF	i
Contents Free access PDF PDF	v
Acknowledgments Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	vii
Introduction Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	1
1. Solomon Schechter and the Charismatic Bond Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	15
2. The United Synagogue and the Transition to Postcharismatic Authority Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	44
3. A “Heretic,” a “Maverick,” and the Challenge to Inclusivity Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	69
4. On the Brink of Irrelevance Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	85
5. The Platform of Discipleship Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	101
6. A Task Left Unfinished Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	123
Conclusion Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	138
Epilogue Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	156
Abbreviations Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	165
Notes Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	167
Index Access restricted Content is available PDF PDF	201

The Birth of Conservative Judaism

Solomon Schechter's Disciples and the Creation of an American Religious Movement

Details

Formats