Published by De Gruyter Oldenbourg

Volume 36 Issue 2

Issue of Analyse & Kritik

Contents
Journal Overview

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Page range: i-i

Download PDF

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Editorial: Environmental Justice as Empirical and Normative

Gordon Walker

Page range: 221-228

Download PDF

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Ghettos in Slovakia. Confronting Roma Social and Enviromental Exclusion

Richard Filčák, Tamara Stager

Page range: 229-250

More Download PDF

Abstract

More than half of the Roma population in Slovakia lives in spaces that are segregated or separated from dominant non-Roma communities. The socio-spatial marginalization of Roma is both generated and reinforced through open and discrete social processes and measures largely orchestrated by local governments, enabled by an ineffective state; and reinforced by the general socio-economic policy framework. This article builds on extensive field research on predominantly Roma-occupied spaces (i.e., ‘settlements’) in Slovakia and focuses on the nature and function of Roma segregation and separation in Slovakia from an ecological socio-political, and economic standpoint. Based on Loi’c Wacquant’s work on ethno-racial segregation and the concept of environmental justice, we discuss social and environmental discrimination as one of the constituent elements in understanding Roma socio-spatial marginalization and its functions, and employ the neologism, ‘hyper-osada’ as a tool to conceptually and analytically investigate the; new impetus and recent trajectory of Roma segregation and separation.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Environmental Inequality in France: A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Perspective

Éloi Laurent

Page range: 251-262

More Download PDF

Abstract

This article highlights the challenge of environmental inequality in France within the framework of social-ecology, an approach relating ecological crises to social issues, especially inequality. It starts by defining the notions of environmental inequality and environmental justice within the framework of the; ‘capability approach’ and then reviews recent empirical studies that show how air pollution, chemical and noise pollutions, access to environmental resources and exposure to social-ecological disasters are socially differentiated in France and can be understood, under the definition adopted in this article, as a form of injustice. It concludes by reviewing issues raised by environmental inequality in France and exploring policy solutions able to address this challenge.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

When Is ‘Yes to the Mill’ Environmental Justice? Interrogating Sites of Acceptance in Response to Energy Development

Stephanie Malin

Page range: 263-286

More Download PDF

Abstract

Though grassroots organizations have mobilized against US environmental injustices since; the 1980s, academic definitions of environmental justice (EJ) remain limited in important ways, including: a tendency to privilege cases where activists achieve a successful, ‘tidy’ outcome; inattention to roles natural resource dependence and free market systems play in structuring environmental inequality; and a tendency to under-analyze alternative notions of EJ that result, utilized by activists who prioritize local autonomy and procedural justice in land-use decision making. Here, I argue that these alternative notions of EJ help mobilize divergent forms of EJ activism-‘sites of resistance’ to industrial production systems and their risks, and ‘sites of acceptance’ to those same practices. To illustrate, I explore extensive mixed method data in the context of energy development and sites of acceptance related to uranium production in the southwestern United States. I show how alternative notions of EJ are shaped by identification with uranium production, persistent poverty and economic insecurity, and faith that increased uranium production will fuel US nuclear power production and help combat global climate change.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

No Environmental Justice Movement in France? Controversy about Pollution in Two Southern French Industrial Towns

Christelle Gramaglia

Page range: 287-314

More Download PDF

Abstract

This paper describes the emergence of a controversy concerning pollution and environmental and health risks in two southern French towns, Viviez and Salindres, which are both known for their long industrial history. It explores some of the reasons why the majority of the local populations resented the fact that the; issues raised were addressed publicly. It also examines some of the coping strategies residents may have developed to avoid talking about risks and to distance themselves from them. It goes on to discuss the differences and similarities in the development of concerns for environmental inequalities in the North American and French contexts, asking, in the manner of Werner Sombart on socialism in the USA at the end of the nineteenth century, why environmental justice is not a strong concern (either as a social movement or frame of analysis) this side of the Atlantic.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Climate Change, Energy Policy and Justice: A Systematic Review

Jason Byrne, Chloe Portanger

Page range: 315-344

More Download PDF

Abstract

Energy efficiency and energy security are emerging concerns in climate change policy. But. there is little acknowledgment of energy justice issues. Marginalised and vulnerable communities may be disproportionately exposed to both climate change impacts (e.g. heat, flooding) and costs associated with energy transitions related to climate change mitigation and adaptation (e.g. particulate exposure from biofuel combustion). Climate change is producing energy-related impacts such as increased cooling costs. In some cases it threatens energy security. Higher electricity costs associated with ‘climate proofing’ energy network infrastructure may exacerbate ‘fuel poverty’ - itself a form of injustice. In this paper we critically review the literature about multiple interrelations between energy policy, justice and climate change. We identify key issues, illuminate knowledge gaps, and synthesise findings to develop a conceptual model. We chart a research agenda and highlight policy implications.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Environmental Inequalities and Democratic Citizenship: Linking Normative Theory with Empirical Research

Fabian Schuppert, Ivo Wallimann-Helmer

Page range: 345-366

More Download PDF

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to link empirical findings concerning environmental inequalities with different normative yard-sticks for assessing whether these inequalities should be deemed unjust, or not. We argue that such an inquiry must necessarily take into account some caveats regarding both empirical research and normative theory. We suggest that empirical results must be contextualised by establishing geographies of risk. As a normative yard-stick we propose a moderately demanding social-egalitarian account of justice and democratic citizenship, which we take to be best suited to identify unjust as well as legitimate instances of socio-environmental inequality.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Water Justice: A Multilayer Term and Its Role in Cooperation

Angela Kallhoff

Page range: 367-382

More Download PDF

Abstract

In discussing water justice, this paper distinguishes four concepts of water justice: Distributive justice claims a fair share of water, ecological justice focuses on the integrity of water as a vulnerable resource, cultural justice addresses values attached to water reservoirs, and procedural justice explicates fair procedures in negotiating water conflicts. After having given an overview over recent contributions to the various meanings of water justice, the paper tries to answer the question of how standards of justice can be integrated into an approach that overcomes the alleged tragedies of the commons. It focuses on the example of a water reservoir whose access conditions provoke conflicts among neighbors.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Individual Moral Responsibility and the Problem of Climate Change

Richard Galvin, John R. Harris

Page range: 383-396

More Download PDF

Abstract

The problems caused by anthropogenic climate change threaten the lives and well-being of millions, yet it seems that we, as individuals, are powerless to prevent or worsen these problems. In this essay we consider the difficulty of assigning moral responsibility in cases of collective action problems like the problem of anthropogentic climate change. We consider two promising solutions, the expected utility and rights based solution, and argue that both are incapable of explaining why individuals have moral obligations to address collective action problems. We believe, however, that this result does not justify inaction, instead it reveals a failure of moral philosophy to adequately address collective action problems. More work must be done to address the moral responsibilities that arise in cases of collective action problems and we close by pointing in the direction of some promising work in this area.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Why Participate in Pro-Environmental Action? Individual Responsibility in Unstructured Collectives

Anton Leist

Page range: 397-416

More Download PDF

Abstract

The degradation of natural resources in the environment is, technically speaking, a form of depleting a public good. Public goods are notorious for free-riding among egoists, but the marginality of individual contributions provides no less an obstacle, both to moral duty and motivation. This article discusses the problems of minimized and missing causal involvement on the empirical side; and, in the applicability of classical moral arguments, on the ethical side. It. suggests that individual responsibility is derived on the basis of implicit advantage-taking from participation in collective action.

Publicly Available February 11, 2016

Authors

Page range: 417-420

Download PDF

About this journal

ANALYSE & KRITIK

is devoted to the fundamental issues of empirical and normative social theory
is directed at social scientists and social philosophers who combine commitment to political and moral enlightenment with argumentative rigour and conceptual clarity
develops social theorizing in connection with analytical philosophy and philosophy of science
promotes the dialogue between Anglo-American and Continental traditions in the social sciences and ethics
publishes articles in English

Volume 36 Issue 2

Issue of Analyse & Kritik

Contents

Editorial: Environmental Justice as Empirical and Normative

Ghettos in Slovakia. Confronting Roma Social and Enviromental Exclusion

Abstract

Environmental Inequality in France: A Theoretical, Empirical and Policy Perspective

Abstract

When Is ‘Yes to the Mill’ Environmental Justice? Interrogating Sites of Acceptance in Response to Energy Development

Abstract

No Environmental Justice Movement in France? Controversy about Pollution in Two Southern French Industrial Towns

Abstract

Climate Change, Energy Policy and Justice: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Environmental Inequalities and Democratic Citizenship: Linking Normative Theory with Empirical Research

Abstract

Water Justice: A Multilayer Term and Its Role in Cooperation

Abstract

Individual Moral Responsibility and the Problem of Climate Change

Abstract

Why Participate in Pro-Environmental Action? Individual Responsibility in Unstructured Collectives

Abstract

Authors