Visualizing the invisible with the human body
Physiognomy and ekphrasis in the ancient world
Ed. by Johnson, J. Cale / Stavru, Alessandro
- eBook (PDF)
- Publication Date:
- November 2019
- Copyright year:
1. Demarcating ekphrasis in Mesopotamia
Johnson, J. Cale
In its original Graeco-Roman context, the term ekphrasis (ex- ‘out’ + phrazein ‘to explain’) was quickly narrowed down to its usual present-day definition, as “a vivid description of a work of art,” but in this contribution I argue that older definitions involving vividness and emotional involvement with the object of description are ideally suited for an extension of the concept to Mesopotamian literary practice. Vividness can already be identified, obliquely, in Irene Winter’s contrast between Western “representation” as opposed to Mesopotamian “manifestation,” where manifestation necessarily involves direct interaction between a worshiper or ritual specialist and the statue that acts in the stead of the king. I argue here that this kind of vividness can be redefined, in largely formal terms, as a rhetorical practice in which a typically third person description (aka “representation”) is altered so as to give the impression of first or second person direct participation (aka “manifestation”). In Mesopotamia this rhetorical phenomenon is most clearly visible in the so-called Tigi Hymns, particularly when a votive object is directly addressed in the second person (and the ritual contextualization of these acts of direct address in well-defined sections of the hymnic genre). As part of a broader effort to define the different “descriptive paradigms” that operated within early Mesopotamian scientific thought, the carefully circumscribed type of ekphrastic description that we find in the Tigi Hymns can be contrasted with other descriptive paradigms in cuneiform literature such as physiognomic descriptions and the late šikinšu texts. Within these several varieties of descriptivism, however, the particulars of ekphrastic description in the Tigi Hymns and similar materials are distinctive, and this paper concludes with a brief catalogue of ekphrastic descriptions in Classical Sumerian literature.
J. Cale Johnson (2019). 1. Demarcating ekphrasis in Mesopotamia. In J. Cale Johnson, Alessandro Stavru (Eds.), Visualizing the invisible with the human body: Physiognomy and ekphrasis in the ancient world (pp. 11–40). Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110642698-002
Book DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110642698
Online ISBN: 9783110642698
© 2019 Walter de Gruyter GmbH, Berlin/Munich/Boston. BY-NC-ND 4.0 This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 License.