Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
Weitere Optionen …

Communication and Medicine

Weitere Optionen …

Structure and variation in end-of-life discussions in the Surgical Intensive Care Unit

Ellen Barton / Matthew Aldridge / Thomas Trimble / Justin Vidovic
Online erschienen: 27.07.2005 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/come.2005.2.1.3


The research reported here is an exploratory discourse analysis of a corpus of six end-of-life discussions in a Surgical Intensive Care Unit (SICU), describing the structure and variations of the four phases of an end-of-life discussion in terms of the function of each of these phases: the Opening (Phase 1), Description of Current Status (Phase 2), Holistic Decision Making (Phase 3), and Logistics of Dying (Phase 4). Of particular interest is Phase 2, in which the presentation of medical information culminates in an inferential summary statement that functions to establish the patient's status as terminal. We argue that it is Phase 2 that is crucial in the functional progression of an end-of-life discussion toward a decision to move from therapeutic to palliative care, since it is in Phase 2 that physicians and families interactionally achieve a consensus that allows a decision to withdraw or withhold further treatment, including life support, which would be futile and only prolong the patient's suffering. We show how two of the end-of-life discussions in the corpus that did not establish the terminal status of the patient in Phase 2 did not move to decision making in Phase 3.

Keywords: physician–patient interaction; end-of-life care; decision making; intensive care; bad news; palliative care; discourse analysis


Ellen Barton is a Professor in the Linguistics Program at Wayne State University. Her work on the discourse of medicine has appeared in the Journal of Pragmatics, Narrative Inquiry, Discourse Studies, and Discourse and Society. Her current projects are on end-of-life discussions and invitations to participate in medical research. Address for correspondence: Linguistics Program, Department of English, Wayne State University, Detroit, MI 48202, USA.

Online erschienen: 27.07.2005

Erschienen im Druck: 01.01.2005

Quellenangabe: Communication & Medicine, Band 2, Heft 1, Seiten 3–20, ISSN (Online) 1613-3625, ISSN (Print) 1612-1783, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/come.2005.2.1.3.

Zitat exportieren

Zitierende Artikel

Hier finden Sie eine Übersicht über alle Crossref-gelisteten Publikationen, in denen dieser Artikel zitiert wird. Um automatisch über neue Zitierungen dieses Artikels informiert zu werden, aktivieren Sie einfach oben auf dieser Seite den „E-Mail-Alert: Neu zitiert“.

Rebecca J Anderson, Steven Bloch, Megan Armstrong, Patrick C Stone, and Joseph TS Low
Palliative Medicine, 2019, Jahrgang 33, Nummer 8, Seite 926
Eun Kyoung Choe, Marisa E Duarte, Hyewon Suh, Wanda Pratt, and Julie A Kientz
JMIR Human Factors, 2019, Jahrgang 6, Nummer 2, Seite e8885
Ciarán T. Bradley and Karen J. Brasel
American Journal of Hospice and Palliative Medicine®, 2008, Jahrgang 24, Nummer 6, Seite 499
Richard H. Savel, Simon Lavotshkin, Ariel L. Shiloh, Anthony J. Carlese, and Michael A. Gropper
ICU Director, 2010, Jahrgang 1, Nummer 4, Seite 214
Matthew Aldridge and Ellen Barton
Qualitative Health Research, 2007, Jahrgang 17, Nummer 7, Seite 908
Aleksandra Sokalska-Bennett
Journal of Language and Sexuality, 2017, Jahrgang 6, Nummer 1, Seite 61
Valerie Schulz and Richard J. Novick
Seminars in Cardiothoracic and Vascular Anesthesia, 2013, Jahrgang 17, Nummer 4, Seite 240
Elizabeth Perkins, Maureen Gambles, Rachel Houten, Sheila Harper, Alan Haycox, Terri O’Brien, Sarah Richards, Hong Chen, Kate Nolan, and John E Ellershaw
Health Services and Delivery Research, 2016, Jahrgang 4, Nummer 20, Seite 1
Karen M. Gutierrez
Critical Care Nursing Quarterly, 2012, Jahrgang 35, Nummer 3, Seite 299
Mary Lay Schuster, Ann La Bree Russell, Dianne M. Bartels, and Holli Kelly-Trombley
Technical Communication Quarterly, 2013, Jahrgang 22, Nummer 3, Seite 195
Ros Sorensen and Rick Iedema
Death Studies, 2011, Jahrgang 35, Nummer 6, Seite 481
Journal of Nursing Management, 2008, Jahrgang 16, Nummer 5, Seite 535
Ellen Barton
Communication, 2007, Jahrgang 4, Nummer 1

Kommentare (0)