Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
More options …

The International Journal of Biostatistics

Ed. by Chambaz, Antoine / Hubbard, Alan E. / van der Laan, Mark J.


IMPACT FACTOR 2018: 1.309

CiteScore 2018: 1.11

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 1.325
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.715

Mathematical Citation Quotient (MCQ) 2018: 0.03

Online
ISSN
1557-4679
See all formats and pricing
More options …

Preference-Based Instrumental Variable Methods for the Estimation of Treatment Effects: Assessing Validity and Interpreting Results

M. Alan Brookhart / Sebastian Schneeweiss
Published Online: 2007-12-28 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.2202/1557-4679.1072

Observational studies of prescription medications and other medical interventions based on administrative data are increasingly used to inform regulatory and clinical decision making. The validity of such studies is often questioned, however, because the available data may not contain measurements of important prognostic variables that guide treatment decisions. Recently, approaches to this problem have been proposed that use instrumental variables (IV) defined at the level of an individual health care provider or aggregation of providers. Implicitly, these approaches attempt to estimate causal effects by using differences in medical practice patterns as a quasi-experiment. Although preference-based IV methods may usefully complement standard statistical approaches, they make assumptions that are unfamiliar to most biomedical researchers and therefore the validity of such an analysis can be hard to evaluate. Here, we describe a simple framework based on a single unobserved dichotomous variable that can be used to explore how violations of IV assumptions and treatment effect heterogeneity may bias the standard IV estimator with respect to the average treatment effect in the population. This framework suggests various ways to anticipate the likely direction of bias using both empirical data and commonly available subject matter knowledge, such as whether medications or medical procedures tend to be overused, underused, or often misused. This approach is described in the context of a study comparing the gastrointestinal bleeding risk attributable to different non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.

Keywords: outcomes research; pharmacoepidemiology; instrumental variables methods

About the article

Published Online: 2007-12-28


Citation Information: The International Journal of Biostatistics, Volume 3, Issue 1, ISSN (Online) 1557-4679, DOI: https://doi.org/10.2202/1557-4679.1072.

Export Citation

©2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston.Get Permission

Citing Articles

Here you can find all Crossref-listed publications in which this article is cited. If you would like to receive automatic email messages as soon as this article is cited in other publications, simply activate the “Citation Alert” on the top of this page.

[1]
Andrew Prouse, Elise Gunzburger, Fan Yang, Justin Morrison, Javier A. Valle, Ehrin J. Armstrong, and Stephen W.  Waldo
Journal of the American Heart Association, 2020, Volume 9, Number 4
[2]
Ellicott C. Matthay, Erin Hagan, Laura M. Gottlieb, May Lynn Tan, David Vlahov, Nancy Adler, and M. Maria Glymour
SSM - Population Health, 2019, Page 100526
[3]
E. R. John, K. R. Abrams, C. E. Brightling, and N. A. Sheehan
BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2019, Volume 19, Number 1
[4]
[5]
Ramy Behman, Avery B. Nathens, Barbara Haas, Nicole Look Hong, Petros Pechlivanoglou, and Paul Karanicolas
Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery, 2019, Volume 87, Number 3, Page 636
[7]
Brian J. Potter, Colin Dormuth, and Jacques Le Lorier
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2019
[8]
James William Bales, Robert H. Bonow, Robert T. Buckley, Jason Barber, Nancy Temkin, and Randall M. Chesnut
Neurocritical Care, 2019, Volume 31, Number 1, Page 11
[9]
Raluca Ionescu-Ittu, Joseph A.C. Delaney, and Michal Abrahamowicz
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2009, Volume 18, Number 7, Page 562
[10]
Luke Keele, Qingyuan Zhao, Rachel R. Kelz, and Dylan Small
Medical Care, 2018, Page 1
[11]
Lakshmi Venkitachalam, Yang Lei, Elizabeth A. Magnuson, Paul S. Chan, Joshua M. Stolker, Kevin F. Kennedy, Neal S. Kleiman, and David J. Cohen
Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, 2011, Volume 4, Number 6, Page 587
[12]
Joanna Chikwe, Timothy Lee, Shinobu Itagaki, David H. Adams, and Natalia N. Egorova
Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 2018, Volume 72, Number 13, Page 1478
[13]
Babagnidé François Koladjo, Sylvie Escolano, and Pascale Tubert-Bitter
BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2018, Volume 18, Number 1
[14]
Jing Cheng and Winston Lin
American Journal of Epidemiology, 2018, Volume 187, Number 3, Page 614
[15]
Sonja A. Swanson and Miguel A. Hernán
International Journal of Epidemiology, 2017
[16]
Neil M Davies, Kyla H Thomas, Amy E Taylor, Gemma MJ Taylor, Richard M Martin, Marcus R Munafò, and Frank Windmeijer
International Journal of Epidemiology, 2017, Volume 46, Number 6, Page 2067
[17]
Ashkan Ertefaie, James H Flory, Sean Hennessy, and Dylan S Small
American Journal of Epidemiology, 2017, Volume 185, Number 12, Page 1233
[18]
Michael S. Schechter, Donald R. VanDevanter, David J. Pasta, Sarah A. Short, Wayne J. Morgan, and Michael W. Konstan
Annals of the American Thoracic Society, 2018, Volume 15, Number 2, Page 225
[19]
Jonathan D. Cogen and Margaret Rosenfeld
Annals of the American Thoracic Society, 2018, Volume 15, Number 2, Page 169
[20]
Alexis A Krumme, Ajinkya Pawar, Sebastian Schneeweiss, Robert J Glynn, Niteesh K Choudhry, Martin Kulldorff, Adrian Santiago Ortiz, Jerome Avorn, and Joshua J Gagne
Journal of Comparative Effectiveness Research, 2017
[21]
Maxine Sun and Stuart R. Lipsitz
Urologic Oncology: Seminars and Original Investigations, 2017
[22]
Jessica M. Franklin and Sebastian Schneeweiss
Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 2017
[23]
Yusuke Tsutsumi, Shingo Fukuma, Asuka Tsuchiya, Tatsuyoshi Ikenoue, Yosuke Yamamoto, Sayaka Shimizu, Miho Kimachi, and Shunichi Fukuhara
Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine, 2017, Volume 25, Number 1
[24]
Lea Rossi, Denise Stevens, Jean-Yves Pierga, Florence Lerebours, Fabien Reyal, Mathieu Robain, Bernard Asselain, Roman Rouzier, and Tone Frost Bathen
PLOS ONE, 2015, Volume 10, Number 7, Page e0132853
[25]
Robert Carroll, Chris Metcalfe, Sarah Steeg, Neil M. Davies, Jayne Cooper, Nav Kapur, David Gunnell, and Roberto Furlan
PLOS ONE, 2016, Volume 11, Number 2, Page e0149713
[26]
M. Bilal Iqbal, Simon D. Robinson, Lillian Ding, Anthony Fung, Eve Aymong, Albert W. Chan, Steven Hodge, Anthony Della Siega, Imad J. Nadra, and Andreas Schäfer
PLOS ONE, 2016, Volume 11, Number 2, Page e0148931
[27]
Asuka Tsuchiya, Yusuke Tsutsumi, and Hideo Yasunaga
Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine, 2016, Volume 24, Number 1
[28]
Branko Miladinovic, Ambuj Kumar, Iztok Hozo, and Benjamin Djulbegovic
BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2011, Volume 11, Number 1
[29]
Romain Pirracchio, Charles Sprung, Didier Payen, and Sylvie Chevret
BMC Medical Research Methodology, 2011, Volume 11, Number 1
[30]
Lynn L DeBar, Charles Elder, Cheryl Ritenbaugh, Mikel Aickin, Rick Deyo, Richard Meenan, John Dickerson, Jennifer A Webster, and Bobbi Jo Yarborough
BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2011, Volume 11, Number 1
[31]
Sophie Stamenkovic, Anne Solesse, Laura Zanetti, Pascale Zagury, Muriel Vray, Pascal Auquier, Elisabeth Baumelou, Frédéric de Bels, Marie-Christine Bene, Alain Bernard, Jean-Pierre Boissel, Marie-Odile Carrere, Pierre Czernichow, Benoit Dervaux, Eveline Eschwege, Pascale Fabbro-Peray, Bruno Falissard, Annie Fourrier, Didier Guillemot, François Lacoin, Maryse Lapeyre-Mestre, Patrick Maison, Jacques Massol, Emmanuel Oger, Françoise Roudot-Thoraval, Patrice Trouiller, Muriel Vray, and Mahmoud Zureik
Thérapie, 2012, Volume 67, Number 5, Page 409
[32]
Amy Richardson, Michael G. Hudgens, Jason P. Fine, and M. Alan Brookhart
Biostatistics, 2017, Volume 18, Number 1, Page 48
[33]
Jaeun Choi and A. James O'Malley
Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series C (Applied Statistics), 2017, Volume 66, Number 1, Page 159
[34]
R. Carroll, P. Corcoran, E. Griffin, I. Perry, E. Arensman, D. Gunnell, and C. Metcalfe
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 2016, Volume 51, Number 11, Page 1485
[35]
Douglas Lehmann, Yun Li, Rajiv Saran, and Yi Li
Statistics in Biosciences, 2016
[36]
David M. Safley, Lakshmi Venkitachalam, Kevin F. Kennedy, and David J. Cohen
JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions, 2015, Volume 8, Number 12, Page 1574
[37]
M. Bilal Iqbal, Imad J. Nadra, Jehangir N. Din, Cara Hendry, Lillian Ding, Anthony Fung, Eve Aymong, Albert W. Chan, Steven Hodge, Simon D. Robinson, and Anthony Della Siega
The American Journal of Cardiology, 2016, Volume 117, Number 5, Page 735
[38]
Michal Abrahamowicz, Lise M. Bjerre, Marie-Eve Beauchamp, Jacques LeLorier, and Rebecca Burne
Statistics in Medicine, 2016, Volume 35, Number 7, Page 1001
[40]
Sonja A. Swanson and Miguel A. Hernán
Epidemiology, 2013, Volume 24, Number 3, Page 370
[41]
Steven M. Brunelli and Jeremy A. Rassen
American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2013, Volume 61, Number 1, Page 13
[42]
Moniek W.M. van de Luijtgaarden, Kitty J. Jager, Mårten Segelmark, Julio Pascual, Frederic Collart, Aline C. Hemke, César Remón, Wendy Metcalfe, Alfonso Miguel, Reinhard Kramar, Knut Aasarød, Ameen Abu Hanna, Raymond T. Krediet, Staffan Schön, Pietro Ravani, Fergus J. Caskey, Cecile Couchoud, Runolfur Palsson, Christoph Wanner, Patrik Finne, and Marlies Noordzij
Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 2016, Volume 31, Number 1, Page 120
[43]
Chanelle J. Howe, Lauren E. Cain, and Joseph W. Hogan
Current Epidemiology Reports, 2015, Volume 2, Number 3, Page 162
[44]
Sonja A. Swanson, Sonia Hernandez-Diaz, Kristin Palmsten, Helen Mogun, Mark Olfson, and Krista F. Huybrechts
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2015, Volume 24, Number 9, Page 934
[45]
Richard E. Nelson, Jonathan R. Nebeker, Candace Hayden, Larry Reimer, Karen Kone, and Joanne LaFleur
AIDS and Behavior, 2013, Volume 17, Number 1, Page 160
[46]
Michel Rossignol, Bernard Begaud, Pierre Engel, Bernard Avouac, France Lert, Frederic Rouillon, Jacques Bénichou, Jacques Massol, Gerard Duru, Anne-Marie Magnier, Didier Guillemot, Lamiae Grimaldi-Bensouda, and Lucien Abenhaim
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2012, Volume 21, Number 10, Page 1093
[47]
Jesse Yenchih Hsu, Scott A. Lorch, and Dylan S. Small
Health Services and Outcomes Research Methodology, 2012, Volume 12, Number 2-3, Page 119
[48]
S Schneeweiss, J J Gagne, R J Glynn, M Ruhl, and J A Rassen
Clinical Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 2011, Volume 90, Number 6, Page 777
[50]
Brian D. Bradbury, M. Alan Brookhart, Wolfgang C. Winkelmayer, Cathy W. Critchlow, Ryan D. Kilpatrick, Marshall M. Joffe, Harold I. Feldman, John F. Acquavella, Ouhong Wang, and Kenneth J. Rothman
American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 2009, Volume 54, Number 3, Page 554
[51]
Jaclyn L.F. Bosco, Rebecca A. Silliman, Soe Soe Thwin, Ann M. Geiger, Diana S.M. Buist, Marianne N. Prout, Marianne Ulcickas Yood, Reina Haque, Feifei Wei, and Timothy L. Lash
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2010, Volume 63, Number 1, Page 64
[52]
Bing Cai, Sean Hennessy, James H. Flory, Daohang Sha, Thomas R. Ten Have, and Dylan S. Small
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2012, Volume 21, Page 114
[53]
Neil M. Davies, David Gunnell, Kyla H. Thomas, Chris Metcalfe, Frank Windmeijer, and Richard M. Martin
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2013, Volume 66, Number 12, Page 1386
[54]
Jeffrey R. Curtis, Lang Chen, Leslie R. Harrold, Pongthorn Narongroeknawin, George Reed, and Daniel H. Solomon
Arthritis Care & Research, 2010, Volume 62, Number 1, Page 101
[55]
Yun Li, Yoonseok Lee, Robert A. Wolfe, Hal Morgenstern, Jinyao Zhang, Friedrich K. Port, and Bruce M. Robinson
Statistics in Medicine, 2015, Volume 34, Number 7, Page 1150
[56]
Fan Yang, José R. Zubizarreta, Dylan S. Small, Scott Lorch, and Paul R. Rosenbaum
The American Statistician, 2014, Volume 68, Number 4, Page 253
[57]
Jialiang Li, Jason Fine, and Alan Brookhart
Biometrics, 2015, Volume 71, Number 1, Page 122
[58]
Zijian Guo, Jing Cheng, Scott A. Lorch, and Dylan S. Small
Statistics in Medicine, 2014, Volume 33, Number 20, Page 3528
[59]
Julia J. Scialla, Jiannong Liu, Deidra C. Crews, Haifeng Guo, Karen Bandeen-Roche, Patti L. Ephraim, Navdeep Tangri, Stephen M. Sozio, Tariq Shafi, Dana C. Miskulin, Wieneke M. Michels, Bernard G. Jaar, Albert W. Wu, Neil R. Powe, and L Ebony Boulware
Kidney International, 2014, Volume 86, Number 4, Page 798
[60]
Krista F. Huybrechts, Tobias Gerhard, Jessica M. Franklin, Raisa Levin, Stephen Crystal, and Sebastian Schneeweiss
Pharmacoepidemiology and Drug Safety, 2014, Page n/a
[61]
Xinglei Shen, Nicholas G Zaorsky, Mark V Mishra, Kathleen A Foley, Terry Hyslop, Sarah Hegarty, Laura T Pizzi, Adam P Dicker, and Timothy N Showalter
Future Oncology, 2012, Volume 8, Number 1, Page 37
[62]
Anirban Basu and Kwun Chuen Gary Chan
Health Economics, 2014, Volume 23, Number 4, Page 462
[63]
Anirban Basu, Anupam B. Jena, Dana P. Goldman, Tomas J. Philipson, and Robert Dubois
Health Economics, 2014, Volume 23, Number 3, Page 359
[65]
G. Fang, J. M. Brooks, and E. A. Chrischilles
American Journal of Epidemiology, 2012, Volume 175, Number 1, Page 60
[66]
Michal Abrahamowicz, Marie-Eve Beauchamp, Raluca Ionescu-Ittu, Joseph A. C. Delaney, and Louise Pilote
American Journal of Epidemiology, 2011, Volume 174, Number 4, Page 494
[67]
Thomas R. Ten Have, Sharon-Lise T. Normand, Sue M. Marcus, C. Hendricks Brown, Philip Lavori, and Naihua Duan
Psychiatric Annals, 2008, Volume 38, Number 12, Page 772

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Log in