Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
More options …

International Journal of Legal Discourse

Editor-in-Chief: Cheng, Le

Managing Editor: Sun, Yuxiu

Online
ISSN
2364-883X
See all formats and pricing
More options …

Justice, fairness and juridical perfectibility

Susan Petrilli
Published Online: 2016-05-19 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ijld-2016-0011

Abstract

Aristotle had already underlined the importance of the relationship between justice and equity (a term I interpret as synonomous to fairness), which he analysed in great detail. Equity is the term which in the English translation of Aristotle’s works corresponds to epiekes (Greek). A starting point for my paper will be Aristotle’s considerations on the relationship between equity and justice. In English we have “equity,” “impartiality,” “fairness,” “equitableness”. Do we distinguish between these terms? is there any difference? In what follows I discuss equity, or better the relation between equity and justice, treating equity and fairness as the same thing. According to Aristotle equity and justice are neither completely the same nor generically different. If they are different either the just or the equitable is not good; or, if they are both good, they are the same (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Bk. V, Ch. 9, 10, p. 1019). Briefly, we could make the claim that equity (fairness) corrects the tendency that characterizes justice towards abstraction, impartiality and indifference, which in fact constitute the condition of possibility for justice to obtain. Equity opens to singularity, to unreplaceability, to uniqueness, shifting justice from the relation of indifference to the other, to the relation of unindifference to the other, to each and every other considered in his or her absolute unrepeatability.

Keywords: firstness; equity; justice; mercy; otherness; responsibility; semioethics

References

  • Aristotle. 1957. Etica Nicomachea, ed. by Armando Plebe. Laterza: Bari-Rome.

  • Aristotle. 2000. Etica Nicomachea, Introd., trans. and notes by Claudio Mazzarelli, Milan: Bompiani. Testi a fronte.Google Scholar

  • Aristotle. 2011. Nicomachean ethics, ed. by Robert C. Bartlett and Susan D. Collins (Trans. Interpretive Essay, Notes, Glossary), Chicago: University of Chicago Press.Google Scholar

  • Bonfantini, Massimo A. 1987. La semiosi e l’abduzione. Milan: Bompiani.

  • Carroll, Lewis. 1871. Through the looking glass, and what Alice found there. Illustrator John Tenniel, London, UK: Macmillan.Google Scholar

  • Chomsky, Noam & Michel Foucault. 1974. Human nature: Justice versus power. In Fons Eiders (ed.), Reflexive Water – The Basic Concerns of Mankind. London: Souvenir Press, 1974; It. trans., Giustizia e natura umana, Intro. by Salvo Vaccaro, Palermo and São Paulo, Ila Palma & Edizioni Associate, 1994.Google Scholar

  • Deely, John, Augusto Ponzio & Susan Petrilli. 2005. The semiotic animal. Ottawa, Toronto, New York: Legas.Google Scholar

  • Eco, Umberto & Thomas A. Sebeok (eds.). 1983. The sign of three. Holmes, Dupin, Peirce. Bloomington, Ind.: Indiana University Press.Google Scholar

  • Diamantides, M. (ed.). 2007. Levinas, law, politics. London: Routledge.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1972. Humanisme de l’autre homme. Montpellier: Fata Morgana.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1983a. “La conscience non intentionnelle,” Eng. trans. in Id. 1998.

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1983b. “Philosophie, justice et amour”. Eng. trans., in Id. 1998, pp. 103–121.

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1987. Collected philosophical papers, Eng. trans. Alphonso Lingis, Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1991[1961]. Totality and infinity, Eng. trans. A. Lingis, Intro. J. Wild, Dordrecht: Kluwer.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1993[1987]. Outside the subject, Eng. trans. M. B. Smith. London: The Athlone Press.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1994. Les imprévus de l’histoire. Montpellier: Fata Morgana.Google Scholar

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 1998[1991]. Entre nous. On thinking-of-the-other, Eng. trans. M. B. Smith and B. Harshav. London: The Athlone Press.

  • Levinas, Emmanuel. 2000[1974]. Otherwise than being or beyond essence, Eng. trans. A. Lingis, Pittsburgh: Duquesne University Press.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2010. Sign crossroads global perspectives. Semioethics and responsibility, John Deely editor, Preface, “In her own voice,” pp. vii–ix, & “The Seventh Sebeok Fellow,” pp. xi–xiii, by J. Deely, New Brunswick (U.S.A.) and London (U.K.), Transaction Publishers, 2010. (This volume presents in monograph form, indexed, the first Sebeok Fellow Special Issue of The American Journal of Semiotics 24.4 (2008), published on the occasion of Dr. Petrilli’s installation as the 7 SSA Sebeok Fellow at the 2008 33 Annual Meeting of the Semiotic Society of America).

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2012. Expression and interpretation in language. New Brunswick (U.S.A.) and London (U.K.): Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2014a. Sign studies and semioethics. Communication, translation and values [= Semiotics, Communication and Cognition, editors Paul Cobley and Kalevi Kull, Vol. 13], Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter Mouton.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan (ed.). 2014b. Semioetica e comunicazione globale [= Athanor. Semiotica, Filosofia, Arte, Letteratura, Anno XXIV, ns n. 17, 2013–2014], Milan: Mimesis.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2015a. Victoria Welby and the science of signs. Significs, semiotics, philosophy of language. Foreword by Frank Nuessel, pp. xii–xv, New Brunswick (U.S.A.) and London (U.K.): Transaction Publishers.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2015b. Nella vita dei segni. Percorsi della semiotica. Milan: Mimesis.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan. 2016. The global world and its manifold faces. Otherness as the basis of communication [= Reflections on Signs and Language, editors Susan Petrilli and Augusto Ponzio, Vol. 1]. Berne, Zurigo: Peter Lang.Google Scholar

  • Petrilli, Susan and Augusto Ponzio. 2003. Semioetica. Rome: Meltemi.

  • Petrilli, Susan and Augusto Ponzio. 2010. “Semioethics”. 2010. In Paul Cobley, The Routledge Companion to Semiotics, Intro., 3–12. London: Routledge, 150–162.

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 1993. Signs, dialogue and ideology, Eng. trans. S. Petrilli, Amsterdam: John Benjamins.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 1996. Sujet et altérité. Sur Emmanuel Lévinas, Paris: L’Harmattan.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 1998. (et alii) Levinas Vivant. Bari: Edizioni dal Sud.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2004. “La obra, el cuerpo y la sombra. Levinas y el otro modo communicación global,” in Barosso et alii, Aproximaciones al pensamiento de Emmanuel, Madrid, Editorial Trotta, pp. 295–315.

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2006. “The I questioned: Emmanuel Levinas and the critique of occidental reason,” Subject Matters 3, 1, 2006, pp. 1–42, with A. Z. Newton, M. B. Smith, R. Bernasconi, G. Ward, R. Burggraeve, B. Bergo, W. P. Simmons, A. Aronowicz, pp. 43–127.

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2008a. Tra Bachtin e Levinas. Scrittura, dialogo, alterità. Bari: Palomar.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2008b. Signification and alterity in Emmanuel Levinas. Semiotica 121–1/4. 115–130.Web of ScienceGoogle Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2009a. Emmanuel Levinas, globalization, and preventive peace. Ottawa: Legas.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2009b. L’écoute de l’autre. Paris: L’Harmattan.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Augusto. 2009c. La scelta degli scrigni nel Mercante di Venezia di Shakespeare”. In Globalizzazione e infunzionalità [= Athanor. Semiotica, Filosofia, Arte, Letteratura, XIX, 12 n.s], 209–222. Rome, Meltemi, now Milan: Mimesis.

  • Ponzio, Augusto, Susan Petrilli & Julia Ponzio. 2005. Reasoning with Emmanuel Levinas. Ottawa: Legas.Google Scholar

  • Ponzio, Julia. 2007. Politics not left to itself: Recognition and forgiveness in Levinas’s philosophy, in M. Diamantides (ed.), 35–48.

  • Pope Francis. 2016. Il nome di Dio è misericordia. Una conversazione con Andrea Tornielli. Milan: Piemme.Google Scholar

  • Rossi-Landi, Ferruccio. 1975. Linguistics and economics. The Hague: Mouton, 1977.Google Scholar

  • Rossi-Landi, Ferruccio. 1978. Ideologia. Milan: ISEDI; Eng. trans. R. Griffin, Marxism and Ideology. Oxford: Clarendon, 1990.Google Scholar

  • Rossi-Landi, Ferruccio. 1985. Metodica filosofica e scienza dei segni. Milan: Bompiani.

  • Sebeok, Thomas A. 2001. Global Semiotics. Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University Press.

  • Sebeok, Thomas A. & Marcel Danesi. 2000. The forms of meanings. Modeling systems theory and semiotic analysis. Berlin: Walter de Gruyer.Google Scholar

  • Shakespeare, William. 1990[1598]. Il mercante di Venezia, intr. by Tommaso Pisanti, It. trans. Paola Ojetti. Milan: Newton Edizioni.Google Scholar

  • Shakespeare, William. 1999 [1598]. Il mercante di Venezia, with the original text, trans. and ed. by Alessandro Serpieri. Milan: Garzanti.Google Scholar

  • Shakespeare, William. 2008 [1598]. The merchant of venice, ed. by Jay L. Halio, Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

About the article

Received: 2015-06-13

Accepted: 2016-02-26

Published Online: 2016-05-19

Published in Print: 2016-04-01


Citation Information: International Journal of Legal Discourse, Volume 1, Issue 1, Pages 1–22, ISSN (Online) 2364-883X, ISSN (Print) 2364-8821, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/ijld-2016-0011.

Export Citation

©2016 by De Gruyter Mouton.Get Permission

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Log in