Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
More options …

Journal of Globalization and Development

Ed. by Stiglitz, Joseph / Emran, M. Shahe / Guzman, Martin / Jayadev, Arjun / Ocampo, José Antonio / Rodrik, Dani

2 Issues per year

Online
ISSN
1948-1837
See all formats and pricing
More options …

Sovereign Debt Restructuring: A Model-Law Approach

Steven L. Schwarcz
  • Corresponding author
  • The Stanley A. Star Professor of Law and Business, Duke University School of Law, P.O. Box 90360, Durham, NC 27708-0360, USA
  • The Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI), Waterloo, Canada
  • Email
  • Other articles by this author:
  • De Gruyter OnlineGoogle Scholar
Published Online: 2016-02-04 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/jgd-2015-0031

Abstract

Unlike individuals and corporations, countries indebted beyond their ability to pay cannot use bankruptcy laws to restructure unsustainable debt. The United Nations and the International Monetary Fund have attempted to propose treaties to enable that debt restructuring, but the political difficulties of reaching a worldwide consensus have stymied their efforts. This article argues that a model-law approach to restructuring unsustainable sovereign debt should be feasible and effective because the vast majority of sovereign debt contracts are governed by the laws of either the debtor-state or two other jurisdictions. Those jurisdictions individually could enact a model law to give struggling nations a real prospect of equitably restructuring their debt to sustainable levels. By enabling such debt restructuring, that enactment would also help to foster the norms required to facilitate the development of international treaties.

References

  • Bermann, George A. (1985) Integration through Law: Europe and the American Federal Experience. Berlin: De Gruyter.Google Scholar

  • Black’s Law Dictionary, 4th pocket ed. (2011). West Group.Google Scholar

  • Block-Lieb, Susan and Terence Halliday (2007) “Incrementalisms in Global Lawmaking,” Brookings Journal of International Law, 32:851–903.Google Scholar

  • Bolton, Patrick (2003) “Toward a Statutory Approach to Sovereign Debt Restructuring: Lesson from Corporate Bankruptcy Practice Around the World,” IMF Staff Papers, 50. Available at: https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.cfm?sk=16253.0.

  • Bolton, Patrick and David A. Skeel, Jr. (2004) “Inside the Black Box: How Should a Sovereign Bankruptcy Framework Be Structured?” Emory Law Journal, 53:763–822.Google Scholar

  • Bradley, Michael and Mitu Gulati (2013) “Collective Action Clauses for the Eurozone,” Review of Finance, 1–58.Google Scholar

  • Brooks, Skylar and Domenico Lombardi (2015) “Governing Sovereign Debt Restructuring Through Regulatory Standards.” Journal of Globalization and Development, 6(2):287–318.Google Scholar

  • Brooks, Skylar, Martin Guzman, Domenico Lombardi and Joseph E. Stiglitz (2015) “Identifying and Resolving Inter-Creditor and Debtor-Creditor Equity Issues in Sovereign Debt Restructuring,” CIGI Policy Brief No. 53, January.Google Scholar

  • Clement, Zack (2013) “Restructuring Government Finances – In Public and in Less Than a Year,” Westlaw Insolvency Intelligence, 26:91–93.Google Scholar

  • Clement, Zack and R. Andrew Black (2014) “How City Finances Can Be Restructured: Learning from Both Bankruptcy and Contract Impairment Cases,” American Bankruptcy Law Journal, 88:41–84.Google Scholar

  • Conn, Richard, Principal and Managing Dir., Innovate Partners LLC. (2015) Keynote Address at the General Assembly of the United Nations, 6th Meeting, 2nd Working Session of the Ad Hoc Committee on Sovereign Debt Restructuring Processes, Apr. 28, 2015.Google Scholar

  • Cooper, Andrew F. and Bessma Momani (2005) “Negotiating Out of Argentina’s Financial Crisis: Segmenting the International Creditors,” New Political Economy, 10:305–320.CrossrefGoogle Scholar

  • Danielsson, Jon (2009) “The First Casualty of the Crisis: Iceland.” In: (Andrew Felton and Carman Reinhart, eds.) The First Global Financial Crisis of the 21st Century Part II. London: Centre for Economic Policy Research, pp. 11–12.Google Scholar

  • “Detroit’s 20 Largest Unsecured Creditors,” Detroit Free Press, July 19, 2013. Available at: http://archive.freep.com/article/20130719/NEWS01/307190029/detroit-bankruptcy-list-creditors.

  • Diaz, Hugo Ruiz (2003) “The Creation of an Arbitration Tribunal on Debt: An Alternative Solution? On The Position to Take as the CADTM.” Available at: http://www.world-governance.org/IMG/pdf_013_Setting_up_an_arbitration_tribunal_on_debt.pdf.

  • Eichengreen, Barry (2006) “Policy Proposals for Restructuring Unsustainable Sovereign Debt.” In: (I. Kaul and P. Conceicao, eds.) The New Public Finance, Chapter 3. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

  • England, Philippa (2005) “Book Reviews,” International & Comparative Law Quarterly, 54:265–276.Google Scholar

  • Fiorino, Daniel J. (2006) The New Environmental Regulation. Cambridge: The MIT Press.Google Scholar

  • Fitzgerald, Oonagh (2015) “Next Steps Towards a Multilateral Debt Workout Process,” CIGI Global Rule of Law Blog (June 4, 2015). Available at: https://www.cigionline.org/blogs/global-rule-of-law/next-steps-towards-multilateral-debt-workout-process-part-1 and https://www.cigionline.org/blogs/global-rule-of-law/next-steps-towards-multilateral-debt-workout-process-part-2.

  • Gelpern, Anna (2014) “A Skeptic’s Case for Sovereign Bankruptcy.” In: (Christoph Paulus, ed.) A Debt Restructuring Mechanism for Sovereigns: Do We Need a Legal Procedure? Oxford: Beck/Hart, p. 262.Google Scholar

  • Gillespie, Alistair (2013) “The English Legal System,” The English Legal System, 4.Google Scholar

  • Gitlin, Richard and Brett House (2014) “A Blueprint for a Sovereign Debt Forum.” (CIGI Paper No. 27, at 10) (Mar. 12, 2014). Available at: http://www.cigionline.org/publications/blueprint-sovereign-debt-forum.

  • Guzman, Martin and Daniel Heymann (2015) “The IMF Debt Sustainability Analysis: Issues and Problems,” Journal of Globalization and Development, 6(2):387–404.Google Scholar

  • Guzman, Martin and Joseph Stiglitz (2015) “Creating a Framework for Sovereign Debt Restructuring that Works.” In: (M. Guzman, J.A. Ocampo and J.E. Stiglitz, eds.) Too Little, Too Late: The Quest to Resolve Sovereign Debt Crises, Chapter 1. New York: Columbia University Press (forthcoming).Google Scholar

  • Hagan, Sean (2005) “Designing a Legal Framework to Restructure Sovereign Debt,” Georgetown Journal of International Law, 36:299–402.Google Scholar

  • Hathaway, Oona A. (2005) “Between Power and Principle: An Integrated Theory of International Law,” University of Chicago Law Review, 72:469–527.Google Scholar

  • Helleiner, Eric (2008) “The Mystery of the Missing Sovereign Debt Restructuring Mechanism,” Contributions to Political Economy, 27:91–113.Google Scholar

  • Horsefield, J. Keith. (1969) “The White Plan.” In: (Anne Salda, ed.) III The International Monetary Fund 1945–1965: Twenty Years of International Monetary Cooperation. Washington: International Monetary Fund, p. 95.Google Scholar

  • Hüpkes, Eva (2015) Adviser on Regulatory Policy and Cooperation at the Financial Stability Board (FSB), email to the author, July 14, 2015.Google Scholar

  • IMF Staff (2014) “The Fund’s Lending Framework and Sovereign Debt-Preliminary Considerations,” June 2014. Available at: http://www.imf.org/external/np/pp/eng/2014/052214.pdf.

  • International Capital Market Association (2015) “Standard Pari passu Provision for the Terms and Conditions of Sovereign Notes Governed by New York Law,” May 2015. Available at: http://www.icmagroup.com/assets/documents/Resources/ICMA-Standard-CACs-Pari-Passu-and-Creditor-Engagement-Provisions---May-2015.pdf.

  • International Monetary Fund (2014) Strengthening the Contractual Framework to Address Collective Action Problems in Sovereign Debt Restructuring. October 2014. Available at: http://www.imf.org/external/pp/longres.aspx?id=4911.

  • Jayadev, Arjun and Mike Konczal (2010) “The Boom Not the Slump: The Right Time for Austerity.” Economics Faculty Publication Series. Paper 26. Available at: http://scholarworks.umb.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1026&context=econ_faculty_pubs.

  • Johnson, Emily D. and Ernest A. Young (2012) “The Constitutional Law of State Debt,” Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Policy, 27:117–162.Google Scholar

  • Kenadjian, Patrick S. (2013) “The Aggregation Clause in Euro Area Government Securities.” In: (Patrick S. Kenadjian, Klaus-Albert Bauer and Andreas Cahn, eds.) Collective Action Clauses and the Restructuring of Sovereign Debt. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter GmbH, pp. 113–149.Google Scholar

  • King, Brett W. (1996) “The Use of Supermajority Voting Rules in Corporate America: Majority Rule, Corporate Legitimacy, and Minority Shareholder Protection,” Delaware Journal of Corporate Law, 21:895–941.Google Scholar

  • Kletzer, Kenneth M. (2003) “Sovereign Bond Restructuring: Collective Action Clauses and Official Crisis Intervention,” IMF Working Paper.Google Scholar

  • Mooney, Jr., Charles W. (2001) “Extraterritorial Impact of Choice-of-Law Rules for Non-United States Debtors Under Revised U.C.C. Article 9 and a New Proposal for International Harmonization.” In: (Michael Bridge and Robert Stevens, eds.) Cross-Border Security and Insolvency. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

  • Mooney, Jr., Charles W. (2016) “A Framework for a Formal Sovereign Debt Restructuring Mechanism: The KISS Principle (Keep it Simple, Stupid) and Other Guiding Principles,” Michigan Journal of International Law, 37 (forthcoming).Google Scholar

  • Muse-Fisher, John (2014) “Starving the Vultures: NML Capital v. Republic of Argentina and Solutions to the Problem of Distressed-Debt Funds,” California Law Review, 102:1671–1726.Google Scholar

  • Paulus, Christoph G. and Steven T. Kargman (2008) “Reforming the Process of Sovereign Debt Restructuring: A Proposal for a Sovereign Debt Tribunal.” Workshop on Debt, Finance and Emerging Issues in Financing Integration. Available at: http://www.un.org/esa/ffd/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/20080408_Kargman-Paulus-Paper.pdf.

  • Paulus, Christoph G. and Ignacio Tirado (2013) “Sweet and Lowdown: A ‘Resolvency’ Process and the Eurozone’s Crisis Management Framework,” Law and Economics Yearly Review, II.2:504–559.Google Scholar

  • Pottow, John A. E. (2005) “Procedural Incrementalism: A Model for International Bankruptcy,” Virginia Journal of International Law, 45:936–1015.Google Scholar

  • Pottow, John A. E. (2013) “Mitigating the Problem of Vulture Holdout: International Certification Boards for Sovereign Debt Restructurings,” Law & Economics Working Papers, 81. Available at: http://repository.law.umich.edu/law_econ_current/81.

  • Rodger of Earlsferry, Lord (2008) “Foreword.” In: (Ben Juratowitch, ed.) Retroactivity and the Common Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing.Google Scholar

  • Rogers, James S. (1983) “The Impairment of Secured Creditors’ Rights in Reorganization: A Study on Relationship between The Fifth Amendment and The Bankruptcy Clause,” Harvard Law Review, 96:973–1031.CrossrefGoogle Scholar

  • Rogoff, Kenneth and Jeromin Zettelmeyer (2002) “Bankruptcy Procedures for Sovereigns: A History of Ideas, 1976–2001,” IMF Staff Papers, 49:470–471. Available at: http://www.imf.org/External/Pubs/FT/staffp/2002/03/pdf/rogoff.pdf.

  • Ryan, Molly (2014) “Sovereign Bankruptcy: Why Now and Why Not in the IMF,” Fordham Law Review, 82(5):2473–2520.Google Scholar

  • Sachs, Jeffrey (1995) “Do We Need an International Lender of Last Resort?” Frank D. Graham Lecture at Princeton University.Google Scholar

  • Sandleris, Guido (2008) “Sovereign Defaults: Information, Investment and Credit,” Journal of International Economics, 76:267–275.CrossrefGoogle Scholar

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2000) “Sovereign Debt Restructuring: A Bankruptcy Reorganization Approach,” Cornell Law Review, 85:956–1034.Google Scholar

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2002) “Global Decentralization and the Subnational Debt Problem,” Duke Law Journal, 51:1179–1250.CrossrefGoogle Scholar

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2004) “‘Idiot’s Guide’ to Sovereign Debt Restructuring,” Emory Law Journal, 53:1208–1211.Google Scholar

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2011) “A Minimalist Approach to State ‘Bankruptcy’,” UCLA Law Review, 59:322–353. Available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1807944.

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2012) “Sovereign Debt Restructuring Options: An Analytical Comparison,” Harvard Business Law Review, 2:95–122. Available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1872552.

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2014a) “Rollover Risk: Ideating a U.S. Debt Default,” Boston College Law Review, 55:1–37.Google Scholar

  • Schwarcz, Steven L. (2014b) “Sovereign Debt: The Statutory Solution,” International Financial Law Review, 33:38–39. Available at: http://www.iflr.com/Article/3405641/Sovereign-debts-statutory-solution.html.

  • Scott, Hal S. (2003) “A Bankruptcy Procedure for Sovereign Debtors?” The International Lawyer, 37:103–135.Google Scholar

  • Setser, Brad (2010) “The Political Economy of the SDRM.” In: (Barry Herman, José Antonio Ocampo and Shari Spiegel, eds.) Overcoming Developing Country Debt Crises. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar

  • Sheldon QC, Clive (2012). “A Justified Retrospective.” In: New Law Journal (April 27, 2012). Available at: http://www.11kbw.com/uploads/files/CSLegalWeekSpecialistCommercial.pdf (observing that where the retrospective).

  • Singh, Dalvinder (2011) “U.K. Approach to Financial Crisis Management,” Transnational Law & Contemporary Problems, 19:868–922.Google Scholar

  • Stewart, Richard B. (2001) “A New Generation of Environmental Regulation?,” Capital University Law Review, 29:21–182.Google Scholar

  • Stiglitz, Joseph E. and Martin Guzman (2015) “A Rule of Law for Sovereign Debt.” Available at: http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/sovereign-debt-restructuring-by-joseph-e-stiglitz-and-martin-guzman-2015-06.

  • Stiglitz, Joseph E., Martin Guzman, Domenico Lombardi, José Antonio Ocampo and Jan Svejnar (2015) “Frameworks for Sovereign Debt Restructuring,” (IPD-CIGI-CGEG Policy Brief from a November 17, 2014 conference held at Columbia University).Google Scholar

  • Thomas, Landon. “A Bold Proposal to Offer Greece Some Financial Relief,” New York Times, July 11, 2015.Google Scholar

  • Tran, Hung. “The IMF: What is it Good For?” Presentation at The Peterson Institute for International Economics, Washington, DC, Apr. 8, 2014. Available at: http://www.iie.com/events/event_detail.cfm?EventID=318.

  • Volokh, Alexander. “The Revival of the Contract Clause.” The Reason Foundation, Sept. 25, 2013. Available at: http://reason.org/news/show/pensions-contract-clause#sthash.LDDMTTBM.dpuf.

  • Westbrook, Jay L. (1996) “Creating International Insolvency Law,” American Bankruptcy Law Journal, 70:563–574.Google Scholar

  • Westbrook, Jay L. (2014) “Sovereign Debt and Exclusions from Insolvency Proceedings.” In: (Christoph Paulus, ed.) A Debt Restructuring Mechanism for Sovereigns: Do We Need a Legal Procedure? Oxford: Beck/Hart, p. 251.Google Scholar

  • Wood, Philip R. (2007) “Governing Law of Financial Contracts Generally.” Conflict of Laws and International Finance, 12.Google Scholar

About the article

Corresponding author: Steven L. Schwarcz, The Stanley A. Star Professor of Law and Business, Duke University School of Law, P.O. Box 90360, Durham, NC 27708-0360, USA, e-mail: ; and The Centre for International Governance Innovation (CIGI), Waterloo, Canada


Published Online: 2016-02-04

Published in Print: 2015-12-01


Citation Information: Journal of Globalization and Development, ISSN (Online) 1948-1837, ISSN (Print) 2194-6353, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/jgd-2015-0031.

Export Citation

©2015 by De Gruyter. Copyright Clearance Center

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Log in