What Does Only Assert and Entail?
This paper investigates the semantics of English only and two equivalent expressions in Japanese -dake and -shika, giving attention to two aspects: (i) the debate over the status of two propositions that are involved in the use of ONLY expressions and (ii) the semantic and pragmatic differences among ONLY items, if any. We claim that a sentence with ONLY expressions entails both the affirmative and negative propositions. This view raises issues with Horn's original claim (1969) as well as van Rooij and Schulz's (2005) while supporting Atlas (1991, 1993) and Horn (2002). We claim then that the difference in strength between the affirmative and negative propositions emerges from what is asserted by that sentence. One of the bases for our claim is that there is a significant difference in behavior between entailment and assertion of a given sentence, following Horn (2002). This difference explains the difference between -dake on the one hand and -shika and -only on the other: -dake differs from only and -shika in that it asserts the affirmative proposition while -shika and only asserts the negative proposition.
References
Aoyagi, Hiroshi and Toru Ishii. "On Agreement-inducing vs. Non-Agreementinducing NPIs." NELS. North Eastern Linguistic Society 24 (1994): 1-15.Search in Google Scholar
Atlas, Jay David. "Topic/comment, presupposition, logical form and focus stress implicatures: The case of focal particles only and also." Journal of Semantics 8 (1991): 127-147.10.1093/jos/8.1-2.127Search in Google Scholar
Atlas, Jay David. "The importance of being ‘only’: Testing the neo-Gricean versus neoentailment paradigms." Journal of Semantics 10 (1993): 301-318.10.1093/jos/10.4.301Search in Google Scholar
von Fintel, Kai. "Exceptive constructions." Natural Language Semantics 1 (1993): 123-148.10.1007/BF00372560Search in Google Scholar
Giannakidou, Anastasia. "Affective dependencies." Linguistics and Philosophy 22 (1999): 367-421.10.1023/A:1005492130684Search in Google Scholar
Giannakidou, Anastasia. "Negative … concord?" Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 18 (2000): 457-523.10.1023/A:1006477315705Search in Google Scholar
Giannakidou, Anastasia. "Only, emotive factive verbs, and the dual nature of polarity dependency." Language 83 (2006): 575-603.10.1353/lan.2006.0136Search in Google Scholar
Hoeksema, Jack. "The logic of exception." ESCOL. Proceedings of Eastern States Conference on Linguistics 87 (1987): 110-113.Search in Google Scholar
Horn, R. Laurence. "A presuppositional analysis of only and even." CLS. Papers from Chicago Linguistic Society 5 (1969): 97-108.Search in Google Scholar
Horn, R. Laurence. "Assertoric inertia and NPI licensing." CLS. Papers from the 38th Annual Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, Parasession on Polarity and Negation (2002): 55-82.Search in Google Scholar
Konomi, Keiji. "‘Shika~nai’ Koobun no Koozoo." In Eigogaku no Siten, edited by Ohye Saburo, Sensei Tuitoo and Ronbunsyuu Henshuu-iinkai, 369-392. Kyushu Daigaku Syuppankai, 1989.Search in Google Scholar
Kuno, Susumu. "The syntax and semantics of the dake and shika constructions." Harvard Working Papers in Linguistics 7 (1999): 144-172.Search in Google Scholar
Moltmann, Friederike. "Exception sentences and polyadic quantification." Linguistics and Philosophy 18 (1995): 223-280.10.1007/BF00985445Search in Google Scholar
Muraki, Masatake. "The shika-nai construction and predicate restructuring." In Problems in Japanese syntax and semantics, edited by John Hinds & Irwin Howard, 155-177. Tokyo: Kaitakusha, 1978.Search in Google Scholar
Nathan, Lance. "Either: negative polarity meets focus sensitivity." Honors Thesis. Brown University, 1999.Search in Google Scholar
Numata, Yoshiko. "Toritate-shi." Ch.2 of Iwayuru Nihongo Joshi No Kenkyuu, edited by Keiichiro Okutsu, Yoshiko Numata and Takeshi Sugimoto. Tokyo: Nihongo no Bonjinsha, 1986.Search in Google Scholar
Numata, Yoshiko. "mo", "dake", "sae" nado -toritate- [Focusing on "mo", "dake", "sae" and so on]. Tokyo: Kuroshio Shuppan, 1992.Search in Google Scholar
Oyakawa, Takatsugu. "On the Japanese shika-nai construction." Gengo Kenkyuu 67 (1975): 1-20.Search in Google Scholar
van Rooij, Robert and Katrin Schulz. "Only: meaning and implicatures. The very incomplete short version." In Sinn und Bedeutung 9 (2005), edited by Emar Maier, Corien Bary and Janneke Huitink, 314-324.Search in Google Scholar
Watanabe, Akira. "The genesis of negative concord: syntax and morphology of negative doubling." Linguistic Inquiry 35 (2004): 559-612.10.1162/0024389042350497Search in Google Scholar
This content is open access.