Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
More options …

Statistics, Politics and Policy

Editor-in-Chief: Wagschal, Uwe

See all formats and pricing
More options …

The Spread of Evidence-Poor Medicine via Flawed Social-Network Analysis

Russell Lyons
Published Online: 2011-05-18 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.2202/2151-7509.1024

The chronic widespread misuse of statistics is usually inadvertent, not intentional. We find cautionary examples in a series of recent papers by Christakis and Fowler that advance statistical arguments for the transmission via social networks of various personal characteristics, including obesity, smoking cessation, happiness, and loneliness. Those papers also assert that such influence extends to three degrees of separation in social networks. We shall show that these conclusions do not follow from Christakis and Fowler's statistical analyses. In fact, their studies even provide some evidence against the existence of such transmission. The errors that we expose arose, in part, because the assumptions behind the statistical procedures used were insufficiently examined, not only by the authors, but also by the reviewers. Our examples are instructive because the practitioners are highly reputed, their results have received enormous popular attention, and the journals that published their studies are among the most respected in the world. An educational bonus emerges from the difficulty we report in getting our critique published. We discuss the relevance of this episode to understanding statistical literacy and the role of scientific review, as well as to reforming statistics education.

Keywords: Christakis; Fowler; Framingham; obesity; smoking; happiness; loneliness; statistical errors; scientific review

About the article

Published Online: 2011-05-18

Citation Information: Statistics, Politics, and Policy, Volume 2, Issue 1, ISSN (Online) 2151-7509, DOI: https://doi.org/10.2202/2151-7509.1024.

Export Citation

©2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston.Get Permission

Citing Articles

Here you can find all Crossref-listed publications in which this article is cited. If you would like to receive automatic email messages as soon as this article is cited in other publications, simply activate the “Citation Alert” on the top of this page.

Lisa R. Goldberg
Quantitative Finance, 2019, Page 1
Thomas Malang, Laurence Brandenberger, and Philip Leifeld
British Journal of Political Science, 2019, Volume 49, Number 4, Page 1475
Alexandra Olteanu, Carlos Castillo, Fernando Diaz, and Emre Kıcıman
Frontiers in Big Data, 2019, Volume 2
Ricardo Ocaña-Riola
Statistics in Biosciences, 2016, Volume 8, Number 2, Page 204
Jacob C. Fisher
Sociological Methodology, 2019, Volume 49, Number 1, Page 258
Mark C. Pachucki and Elizabeth Goodman
Current Obesity Reports, 2015, Volume 4, Number 2, Page 217
Social Problems, 2014, Volume 61, Number 3, Page 329
T. Chomutare, E. Årsand, L. Fernandez-Luque, J. Lauritzen, and G. Hartvigsen
Methods of Information in Medicine, 2013, Volume 52, Number 02, Page 160
R. Conte, N. Gilbert, G. Bonelli, C. Cioffi-Revilla, G. Deffuant, J. Kertesz, V. Loreto, S. Moat, J. -P. Nadal, A. Sanchez, A. Nowak, A. Flache, M. San Miguel, and D. Helbing
The European Physical Journal Special Topics, 2012, Volume 214, Number 1, Page 325
Joseph P Davin, Sunil Gupta, and Mikolaj Jan Piskorski
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2013
Alexandra Olteanu, Carlos Castillo, Fernando Diaz, and Emre Kiciman
SSRN Electronic Journal , 2016
Chih-Sheng Hsieh and Hans van Kippersluis
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2015
Chih-Sheng Hsieh and Hans van Kippersluis
SSRN Electronic Journal, 2015
Thomas U. Grund and Travis Tatum
Network Science, 2019, Volume 7, Number 1, Page 123
Katherine Faust and George E. Tita
Annual Review of Criminology, 2019, Volume 2, Number 1, Page 99
Barak Ariel, Alex Sutherland, and Lawrence W. Sherman
Journal of Experimental Criminology, 2018
Indrani Saran, Günther Fink, Margaret McConnell, and William Stewart Agras
PLOS ONE, 2018, Volume 13, Number 11, Page e0207679
Aneel Karnani, Brent McFerran, and Anirban Mukhopadhyay
Journal of the Association for Consumer Research, 2016, Volume 1, Number 3, Page 445
Xianbi Huang, Mark Western, Yanjie Bian, Yaojun Li, Rochelle Côté, and Yangtao Huang
Sociology, 2018, Page 003803851876021
Christophe Van Den Bulte, Emanuel Bayer, Bernd Skiera, and Philipp Schmitt
Journal of Marketing Research, 2018, Volume 55, Number 1, Page 132
Jerry W. Kim, Bruce Kogut, and Jae-Suk Yang
American Sociological Review, 2015, Volume 80, Number 2, Page 299
Weihua An
Sociological Methods & Research, 2016, Volume 45, Number 4, Page 635
Robert W. Eyre, Thomas House, Edward M. Hill, and Frances E. Griffiths
Royal Society Open Science, 2017, Volume 4, Number 9, Page 170336
Carl A. Latkin, Tuo-Yen Tseng, Melissa Davey-Rothwell, Ryan D Kennedy, Meghan Bridgid Moran, Lauren Czaplicki, Catie Edwards, Oluwaseun Falade-Nwulia, Geetanjali Chander, and Amy R. Knowlton
Journal of Urban Health, 2017, Volume 94, Number 4, Page 534
Ashley I. Naimi
Epidemiology, 2016, Volume 27, Number 6, Page 843
Ammara Mahmood and Catarina Sismeiro
Journal of Interactive Marketing, 2017, Volume 37, Page 117
Fernando Gutierrez, Dejing Dou, Stephen Fickas, Daya Wimalasuriya, and Hui Zong
Journal of Information Science, 2016, Volume 42, Number 6, Page 798
Naoki Masuda, Issei Kurahashi, Hiroko Onari, and Attila Szolnoki
PLoS ONE, 2013, Volume 8, Number 4, Page e62262
Luke J. Matthews, Peter DeWan, Elizabeth Y. Rula, and Petter Holme
PLoS ONE, 2013, Volume 8, Number 2, Page e55234
Rachel Isba, Katherine Woolf, and Robert Hanneman
Medical Education, 2017, Volume 51, Number 1, Page 81
Tegan Cruwys, Michael J. Platow, Elizabeth Rieger, Don G. Byrne, and S. Alexander Haslam
European Review of Social Psychology, 2016, Volume 27, Number 1, Page 160
Lily Lin and Brent McFerran
Journal of Public Policy & Marketing, 2016, Volume 35, Number 1, Page 76
Sinan Aral and Dylan Walker
IEEE Intelligent Systems, 2011, Volume 26, Number 5, Page 91
Bailey K. Fosdick and Peter D. Hoff
Journal of the American Statistical Association, 2015, Volume 110, Number 511, Page 1047
Russell Lyons
Statistics, Politics, and Policy, 2011, Volume 2, Number 1
Carl A. Latkin and Amy R. Knowlton
Behavioral Medicine, 2015, Volume 41, Number 3, Page 90
Sharad Goel, Ashton Anderson, Jake Hofman, and Duncan J. Watts
Management Science, 2015, Page 150722112809007
Bernard Fortin and Myra Yazbeck
Journal of Health Economics, 2015, Volume 42, Page 125
Jennifer Long, Niki Harré, and Quentin D. Atkinson
Journal of Environmental Psychology, 2015, Volume 41, Page 155
Liye Ma, Ramayya Krishnan, and Alan L. Montgomery
Management Science, 2015, Volume 61, Number 2, Page 454
Tammy Leonard, Caitlin McKillop, Jo Ann Carson, and Kerem Shuval
Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 2014, Volume 51, Page 99
Nicole van Workum, Ron H. J. Scholte, Antonius H. N. Cillessen, Gerine M. A. Lodder, and Matteo Giletta
Journal of Research on Adolescence, 2013, Volume 23, Number 3, Page 563
Sandra D. Simpkins, David R. Schaefer, Chara D. Price, and Andrea E. Vest
Journal of Research on Adolescence, 2013, Volume 23, Number 3, Page 537
Lindsay K. Matteson, Matt K. McGue, and William Iacono
Journal of Individual Differences, 2013, Volume 34, Number 2, Page 90
Garry Robins
Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 2013, Volume 57, Number 6, Page 261
Sergey Melnik, Jonathan A. Ward, James P. Gleeson, and Mason A. Porter
Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science, 2013, Volume 23, Number 1, Page 013124
Tyler J. VanderWeele
Statistics in Medicine, 2013, Volume 32, Number 4, Page 591
Mark Lubell, John Scholz, Ramiro Berardo, and Garry Robins
Policy Studies Journal, 2012, Volume 40, Number 3, Page 351
Catherine A. Bliss, Isabel M. Kloumann, Kameron Decker Harris, Christopher M. Danforth, and Peter Sheridan Dodds
Journal of Computational Science, 2012, Volume 3, Number 5, Page 388
Marco D. Huesch
Social Science & Medicine, 2011, Volume 73, Number 12, Page 1756

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Log in