Jump to ContentJump to Main Navigation
Show Summary Details
More options …

The Linguistic Review

Editor-in-Chief: Hulst, Harry

4 Issues per year


IMPACT FACTOR 2016: 0.676
5-year IMPACT FACTOR: 0.831

CiteScore 2016: 0.52

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2015: 0.662
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2015: 0.573

Online
ISSN
1613-3676
See all formats and pricing
More options …
Volume 18, Issue 1-2 (Jun 2002)

Issues

Empirical assessment of stimulus poverty arguments

Geoffrey K Pullum / Barbara C Scholz
Published Online: 2008-02-27 | DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/tlir.19.1-2.9

Abstract

This article examines a type of argument for linguistic nativism that takes the following form: (i) a fact about some natural language is exhibited that allegedly could not be learned from experience without access to a certain kind of (positive) data; (ii) it is claimed that data of the type in question are not found in normal linguistic experience; hence (iii) it is concluded that people cannot be learning the language from mere exposure to language use. We analyze the components of this sort of argument carefully, and examine four exemplars, none of which hold up. We conclude that linguists have some additional work to do if they wish to sustain their claims about having provided support for linguistic nativism, and we offer some reasons for thinking that the relevant kind of future work on this issue is likely to further undermine the linguistic nativist position.

About the article

Published Online: 2008-02-27

Published in Print: 2002-06-26


Citation Information: The Linguistic Review, ISSN (Online) 1613-3676, ISSN (Print) 0167-6318, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/tlir.19.1-2.9.

Export Citation

Citing Articles

Here you can find all Crossref-listed publications in which this article is cited. If you would like to receive automatic email messages as soon as this article is cited in other publications, simply activate the “Citation Alert” on the top of this page.

[1]
Kyle Wagner, James A. Reggia, Juan Uriagereka, and Gerald S. Wilkinson
Adaptive Behavior, 2003, Volume 11, Number 1, Page 37
[2]
Valentine Reynaud
Philosophia Scientae, 2014, Number 18-3, Page 177
[3]
Paul M.B. Vitányi and Nick Chater
Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 2017, Volume 76, Page 13
[4]
Padraic Monaghan and Caroline F. Rowland
Language Learning, 2017, Volume 67, Number S1, Page 14
[6]
Thomas C. Scott-Phillips
Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 2017, Volume 24, Number 1, Page 186
[7]
Ileana Enesco and Juan Delval
Infancia y Aprendizaje, 2006, Volume 29, Number 3, Page 249
[9]
Colin Phillips and Lara Ehrenhofer
Linguistic Approaches to Bilingualism, 2015, Volume 5, Number 4, Page 409
[10]
Philip S. Gerrans
Biological Theory, 2013, Volume 8, Number 1, Page 20
[11]
Bernard Laks
Language Sciences, 2013, Volume 39, Page 31
[12]
CLIFTON PYE
Journal of Child Language, 2012, Volume 39, Number 03, Page 611
[13]
William Gregory Sakas and Janet Dean Fodor
Language Acquisition, 2012, Volume 19, Number 2, Page 83
[14]
Franklin Chang, Elena Lieven, and Michael Tomasello
Cognitive Systems Research, 2008, Volume 9, Number 3, Page 198
[15]
Denis Bouchard
Lingua, 2006, Volume 116, Number 1, Page 69
[16]
Philip Carr
Language Sciences, 2007, Volume 29, Number 5, Page 672
[17]
Nick Chater and Paul Vitányi
Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 2007, Volume 51, Number 3, Page 135
[19]
Gedeon O. Deák, Marni Stewart Bartlett, and Tony Jebara
Neurocomputing, 2007, Volume 70, Number 13-15, Page 2139
[20]
Robert C. Berwick, Paul Pietroski, Beracah Yankama, and Noam Chomsky
Cognitive Science, 2011, Volume 35, Number 7, Page 1207
[21]
András Kornai
Journal of Logic, Language and Information, 2011, Volume 20, Number 3, Page 317
[22]
Terry Regier and Susanne Gahl
Cognition, 2004, Volume 93, Number 2, Page 147
[23]
Jeffrey Lidz and Sandra Waxman
Cognition, 2004, Volume 93, Number 2, Page 157
[24]
Jeffrey Lidz, Sandra Waxman, and Jennifer Freedman
Cognition, 2003, Volume 89, Number 3, Page 295
[26]
Nameera Akhtar, Maureen Callanan, Geoffrey K Pullum, and Barbara C Scholz
Cognition, 2004, Volume 93, Number 2, Page 141
[27]
Christina Behme and S. Hélène Deacon
Philosophical Psychology, 2008, Volume 21, Number 5, Page 641
[28]
Paul E. Griffiths and Edouard Machery
Philosophical Psychology, 2008, Volume 21, Number 3, Page 397
[29]
Muhammad Ali Khalidi
Philosophical Psychology, 2009, Volume 22, Number 4, Page 505
[30]
Amy Perfors, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, and Terry Regier
Cognition, 2011, Volume 118, Number 3, Page 306
[32]
BRIAN T. PENTLAND
Journal of Institutional Economics, 2011, Volume 7, Number 02, Page 279
[33]
Adele E Goldberg
Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2003, Volume 7, Number 5, Page 219
[34]
Nick Chater and Christopher D. Manning
Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2006, Volume 10, Number 7, Page 335
[36]
Afra Alishahi
Synthesis Lectures on Human Language Technologies, 2010, Volume 3, Number 1, Page 1
[37]
Frederick J. Newmeyer
The Linguistic Review, 2008, Volume 25, Number 1-2
[38]
Ray Jackendoff
The Linguistic Review, 2007, Volume 24, Number 4
[39]
Heike Behrens
Linguistics, 2009, Volume 47, Number 2
[40]
Katrin Lindner and Annette Hohenberger
Linguistics, 2009, Volume 47, Number 2
[41]
Anders Holmberg
Theoretical Linguistics, 2010, Volume 36, Number 1, Page 1
[42]
Víctor M. Longa and Guillermo Lorenzo
Linguistics, 2008, Volume 46, Number 3
[43]
D. Kimbrough Oller
Biological Theory, 2008, Volume 3, Number 4, Page 344
[44]
Andrea Gualmini and Stephen Crain
Linguistic Inquiry, 2005, Volume 36, Number 3, Page 463
[45]
Vasiliki Folia, Julia Uddén, Meinou De Vries, Christian Forkstam, and Karl Magnus Petersson
Language Learning, 2010, Volume 60, Page 188
[46]
Nick Chater and Morten H. Christiansen
Cognitive Science, 2010, Volume 34, Number 7, Page 1131
[47]
Bruno Estigarribia
Cognitive Science, 2009, Volume 34, Number 1, Page 68
[48]
Anne S. Hsu and Nick Chater
Cognitive Science, 2010, Volume 34, Number 6, Page 972
[49]
Jeffrey L. Elman
Cognitive Science, 2009, Volume 33, Number 4, Page 547
[50]
Morten H. Christiansen and Nick Chater
Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2009, Volume 32, Number 05, Page 452
[51]
Julia Herschensohn
Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 2009, Volume 31, Number 02, Page 259
[52]
Robert Bley-Vroman
Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 2009, Volume 31, Number 02, Page 175
[54]
Morten H. Christiansen and Nick Chater
Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2008, Volume 31, Number 05
[55]
[56]
Vivian Cook
IRAL - International Review of Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching, 2003, Volume 41, Number 3
[57]
MUHAMMAD ALI KHALIDI
Mind & Language, 2007, Volume 22, Number 1, Page 92

Comments (0)

Please log in or register to comment.
Log in