Masahiro Kamata, a long time Titular Member of the IUPAC Committee on Chemistry Education (CCE), visited Mongolia regularly since 2006, to advise school teachers. He used his contacts to initiate the negotiations to organize both a “Young Ambassadors for Chemistry” as well as a “Flying Chemistry Educator Program” (FCEP) at the University of Mongolia in Ulang Bataar from 17-22 September 2019. Ochirhuyay Bayanjargal, vice president of the University, worked together with CCE to organize the FCEP. 28 lecturers from the University, 27 secondary school teachers and 17 researchers from different institutions participated in the event. For IUPAC, two members from the Interdivisional Committee on Green Chemistry for Sustainable Development (ICGCSD), Anna Marakova and Aurelia Visa were presented and Jan Apotheker, Mei-Hung Chiu, and Masahiro Kamata represented CCE. The project was financed jointly by IСGCSD and CCE.
The focus of the three-day program of the FCEP was development of Green Chemistry in Mongolia. The university wanted to start a course in Green Chemistry; the secondary school teachers wanted to start a module about Green Chemistry; the researchers were interested in starting research in Green Chemistry. It was an ambitious program for a three-day session.
After the introductions and welcome by Bayanjargal, Jan Apotheker introduced IUPAC, as well as the International Year of the Periodic Table.
Anna Makarova made a short presentation on the topic “What is Green Chemistry?”. As part of this lecture, participants were given a definition of Green Chemistry and 12 basic Green Chemistry principles. Discussion the role Green Chemistry in implementation UN Sustainable Development Goals (2015) and its role in observing planetary boundaries. UN Environment (Global Chemicals Outlook II)  data were presented for the market size of the global green chemistry industry (2015-2020) and the global green chemicals market by region (2011-2020), of which the Asia-Pacific region have more than 30 %.
After her presentation Makarova organized a discussion framing the possible advantages of introducing Green Chemistry as well as a possible strategy (main activities) of the development of Green Chemistry in Mongolia. The VISIS method and technology “Pyramid” developed by Atkisson and others was used  for clarity and visualization of the discussion. The VISIS method takes it name from its five stages:
Vision and goals: In this case, the main goals of the object of research were the creation of courses and training modules as well as the organization of research projects in the field of green chemistry.
Indicators: This stage includes analysis of available data on the effects of the object of research on environmental, economic, societal and individual well-being dimensions, and identifying current trends.
Systems: This stage consists of system model construction and identification of critical cause-effect relationships within the system, with a subsequent search for leverage points (system components where the introduction of any changes and / or innovations can be the most effective).
Innovation: This stage includes selection and evaluation of stability-improving innovations that can contribute to sustainable development.
Strategy: This stage includes building a common strategy for the implementation of selected innovations.
During this workshop, since there were three groups (lecturers from the University, secondary school teachers, and researchers) with different, precisely defined visions and goals, three pyramids were created. After an engaging discussion, it appeared they had major concerns about the air pollution in Ulan Bataar, water pollution occurring in the streams of Mongolia, and the management of chemical waste, which is missing in Mongolia. The creation of courses and training programs was considered by the participants as one of the main elements of the strategy for solving these problems.
In the afternoon session Aurelia Visa gave an introduction about Green Chemistry research-challenges and opportunities.
This introduction outlines the directions of research in the field of ecological chemistry and its benefits for the environment, as well as in areas such as human health, society, economics, sustainability, and last but not least science. The need to use biomass and obtain energy from it has been detailed. The main argument for this initiative is that the vegetal material is produced as a result of the photosynthesis process, whereby, due to solar energy, simple molecules are transformed into complex organic molecules. Vegetal materials absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere during its growth and return it to the atmosphere during combustion. Therefore, the CO2 balance of described processes is zero, so it does not contribute to the greenhouse outcome. Several biomass conversion pathways have been described during the lecture.
Starting from the twelve principles of green chemistry, the topic of alternative solvents was analyzed in the sense of increasing interest both in the research community and in the chemical industry. The impact of solvents on pollution, energy consumption and contributions to air quality and climate change must be taken into account. Solvent losses are a major part of organic contamination, and solvent elimination accounts for a large proportion of the energy consumption in the process .
Another interesting topic was the use of alternative energy such as microwaves and ultrasounds to accelerate chemical reactions and improve synthesis results.
The importance of chemistry behind chlorine was taken into consideration. Chlorine compounds are used in the manufacture of a number of significant commercial products that may or may not contain chlorine in the final molecular structure. For these compounds, synthetic alternative pathways that adopt a holistic and proactive approach and do not use any chlorine derivative cannot offer new products and processes. Therefore, major chemical industries are already conducting research focused on addressing syntheses and processes in which chlorine or chlorine compounds are not involved.
These studies are not yet widely known because they are protected by confidentiality. Relevant examples for replacements to chlorine in industry and in academic syntheses will be useful to facilitate the development of significant and industrially implementable advanced technologies. Chemists deserve to be perceived as creative people who make a high contribution to the prosperity of mankind and are capable of leading and engaging in dialogue with economists, politicians, entrepreneurs and philosophers about sustainable development, rather than polluting the planet .
An important aspect for evaluating chemical remedies is the use of formulas for measuring reactions’ efficiency through conversion, yield, and selectivity. As these values do not account for pollution, the use of solvents and the resulting wastes have been reviewed in other values for measuring the green degree of the reaction. Thus, various metrics such as atom economy, e-factor, atom efficiency, effective mass yields, process mass intensity, carbon economy, SWOT analysis, and life cycle assessment were introduced.
Many of the principles of Green Chemistry can be applied in everyday life, such as waste prevention or more energy efficient industrial processes on a large scale to minimize waste and reduce environmental impact. Everyone is paying attention to pollution and how to reduce the impact of human activities on climate change.
At the end of the first day the participants visited the laboratories of the University. Sarangarel Davaasambuu, dean of the faculty, discussing chemistry related industries in Mongolia, started of the second day. These are mostly related to mining. 30 % of the GDP of Mongolia is related to mining, at the moment mainly coal and copper. There are other deposits of metals, including uranium and gold. These are mostly exported as fairly raw material to China. The other main source of income is agriculture. Mongolia has a vast area of steppe on which cattle, cow, horse and sheep are held.
Meat is exported. A specific local product, which needs an acquired taste is ayrak, a fermented horse milk. One of the major problems she reported was the lack of adequate management of chemical waste, resulting in pollution both of water and the environment.
In a short presentation about a number of chemical disasters, Aurelia Visa demonstrated the need for Green Chemistry. She also introduced some of the areas of research in Green Chemistry, focusing on reduction of waste and raising atom efficiency, as well as the use of solvents that are not detrimental for the environment. Finding different pathways for reactions, the use of catalysts optimizing atomic efficiency were some of the aspects discussed. Finding alternatives for solvents in the form of super critical liquids was another issue presented.
Before lunch Jan Apotheker gave an introduction about education. Starting with the introduction of the ideas of Piaget and Vygotsky, the framework for the design of a course was presented, based on the model of educational reconstruction (Duit, Gropengießer, Kattmann, Komorek, & Parchmann, 2012).
The idea is that scientific content is related to research on teaching and learning, for the design of the teaching and learning activities in a course.
For the design of the course the framework of constructive alignment (Biggs, 1996) was used. Based on the learning goals, learning and teaching activities are developed for the course. Based on these same learning goals assessment is designed, directly linked to the teaching and learning activities.
The group was first asked to formulate a more general learning goal for the course. It should express in one sentence the goal of the course. Subsequently the learning goals should be formulated in a more detailed way. These goals should be formulated SMART:
Higher education group
Two groups of about 8 members of university faculty worked on the design of a course, which were partly overlapping. They intend the course to be placed in the end of the third year. Interesting was that in one of the groups a lab session was envisioned, in which students are asked to design alternative pathways for a synthesis, which are as green as possible. In the subsequent steps they were asked to design a waste management for the waste produced during the reaction, so that the waste can be reused.
They were also asked to introduce formative assessment in the lecture design. At the end of the three day session they are in a position to merge the two proposals into one. It should be possible to introduce the new course in the next academic year.
Secondary education group
Ultimately two groups worked on a module for secondary education. One was planned for grade 10, the other for grade 9. The first group (9th grade) took drinking water as a subject. Using the 5E framework (Bybee et al., 2006) in which the educational activities are sequenced in 5 steps:
Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, and Evaluate. A sixth E was introduced between Elaborate and Evaluate: Exchange, making it a 6E model. The Exchange part lets the students share their results with others, either their peers or their parents; we suggested that the students should make an exhibit that can be exposed in the science centre the University is planning to construct in one of their buildings.
The water demonstrates one of the features of Green Chemistry: a cycle. After purification the water is used in the household, and is returned via a waste water plant to the surface water, which is used as a source for the drinking water.
The other module for 10th grade has batteries as a subject and looks into the differences between alkaline batteries and lithium batteries. Again here, a feature of Green Chemistry is introduced, the difference between a cradle to grave design for the alkaline batteries and a cradle to cradle design for the lithium batteries.
Both designs still need some work before they can be tried out in the classroom. We have asked the University to invite the group of teachers back to the university so they can keep on working together on the design of the module.
Anna Marakova and Aurelia Visa coached the research group. They started out with formulating ideas, performing a SWOT-analysis on the suggestions, and came up with a time line for research project. This project should, over a period of three years, lead to the construction of a reactor in which reactions in super critical water can be carried out. Ultimately they want to use this to introduce the use of super critical water into industry.
The research group with participants from different institutions, will continue to work on the proposal, which will be sent in to the Mongolian Science Foundation for financial support. The participants felt they had achieved first steps towards their objectives and will continue to work on their projects. Over time we will contact the university to find out how things have progressed.
Mongolian Chemical Society
During the three days we had a lunch with the chair of the Mongolian Chemical Society, Avid Budeebazar. He expressed an interest in joining IUPAC as an NAO.
The FCEP was made possible by the financial support of Green Chemistry LLC and the National University of Mongolia, as well as ICGCSD and CCE from IUPAC. During the week we had work lunches and dinners with several representatives from companies and institutions in Ulang Bataar, like the New Mongol Institute of Technology, The German Mongolian Institute for Resources and Technology, Synaps and Green Chemistry LLC. The last two are both companies trading in laboratory glassware and chemicals.
As a delegation we were fortunate to be able to meet Ghengis Kahn.
Atkisson A. The Sustainability Transformation. How to Accelerate Positive Change in Challenging Times. Published November 19th 2010 by Earthscan Publications. P. 323. ISBN 1849712441
Prat D., Hayler J., Wells A., Green Chem., 2014, 16(10) 4546-4551).
Tundo P., Pure Appl Chem, 2012, 83(3), 411-423