Picking over the bones: the practicalities of processing the Athenian war dead

Owen Rees 1
  • 1 Manchester Metropolitan University, , Geoffrey Manton Building, Oxford Road, Manchester, M15 6LL, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
Owen Rees
  • Corresponding author
  • Manchester Metropolitan University, Geoffrey Manton Building, Oxford Road, Manchester, M15 6LL, United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
  • Email
  • Search for other articles:
  • degruyter.comGoogle Scholar

Abstract

Thucydides’ account of the Athenian war dead creates a false image of a clean and efficient, systematic processing of the dead. To look beyond his description it is necessary to assess the practicalities involved in the process. In so doing, it has been necessary to reassess our own historical models. The logistics of identifying the dead accurately, combined with the amount of wood necessary to offer a complete cremation for hundreds of bodies, brings into question the notion that the war dead were cremated by tribe and kept separate up to their public burial. Similarly the notion of ash or bone returning to Athens is too clean, so use of the term “cremains” is proposed to offer an accurate terminology and bring ancient history in line with archaeological practices. When the practicalities and logistics involved in the processing of the dead are considered, some significant issues are raised concerning not only our own presumptions, but also the narrative that Thucydides himself offers.

  • Agelarakis, A. “On the anthropology project of 35 Salaminos Street site of Kerameikos, Athens: a brief account.” In Archaeologikes Symboles: Museum of Cycladic Art, Athens, Volume B: Attika, A’ and G' Prehistoric and Classical Antiquities Authorities, edited by S. Oikonomou and M. Dogka-Tole, 369–386. Athens: Museum of Cycladic Art, 2013.

  • Amandry, P. “Collection Paul Canellopoulos (I). Armes et lébès de bronze.” Bulletin de correspondance hellénique 95 (1971): 585–626.

  • Arrington, N. T. “Topographic semantics: the location of the Athenian public cemetery and its significance for the nascent democracy.” Hesperia 79 (2010): 499–539.

  • Arrington, N. T. “Inscribing defeat: the commemorative dynamics of the Athenian casualty lists.” Classical Antiquity 30 (2011): 179–212.

  • Arrington, N. T. Ashes, Images and Memories: the presence of the war-dead in fifth-century Athens. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2015.

  • Animal Health Australia. Operational manual: disposal (Version 3.1). Australian Veterinary Emergency Plan (AUSVETPLAN), ed. 3. Canberra, ACT: National Biosecurity Committee, 2015.

  • Badge, S., A. Bhole and P. Kokil. “Design and analysis of energy efficient crematorium for eco body burning.” International Journal on Emerging Trends in Technology 3 (2016): 4129–4133.

  • Bakewell, G. “Agamemnon 437: Chrysamoibos Ares, Athens and empire.” Journal of Hellenic Studies 127 (2007): 123–132.

  • Blackman, D., J. Baker and N. Hardwick. “Archaeology in Greece 1997–98.” Archaeological Reports 44 (1997–1998): 1–136.

  • Borza, E. N. “Timber and politics in the ancient world: Macedon and the Greeks.” Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society 131 (1987): 32–52.

  • Bradeen, D. W. “Athenian casualty lists.” Hesperia 33 (1964): 16–62.

  • Bradeen, D. W. “The Athenian casualty lists.” Classical Quarterly 19 (1969): 145–159.

  • Brulé, P. “La mortalité de guerre en Grèce classique. L’exemple d’Athènes de 490 à 322.” In Armées et sociétés de la Grèce classique. Aspects sociaux et politiques de la guerre aux Ve et IVes. av. J.-C., edited by F. Prost, 51–68. Paris: Errances, 1999.

  • Charlier, P., J. Poupon, M. Goubard and S. Descamps. “‘In this way they held funeral for horse-taming Hector:’ a Greek cremation reflects Homeric ritual.” Hesperia Supplements, Vol. 43. New Directions in the Skeletal Biology of Greece (2009): 49–56.

  • Chaston, C. Tragic Props and Cognitive Function: aspects of the function of images in thinking. Leiden: Brill, 2010.

  • Christ, M. “Conscription of hoplites in the Classical Athens.” Classical Quarterly 51 (2001): 398–422.

  • Connor, W. R. “Early Greek land warfare as symbolic expression.” In Studies in Ancient Greek and Roman Society, edited by R. Osborne, 12–37. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2004.

  • Crawley, R. Thucydides. History of the Peloponnesian war. London: J. M. Dent, 1910.

  • Crowley, J. Psychology of a Hoplite: the culture of combat in Classical Athens. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2012.

  • DeHaan, J. D. “Fire and bodies.” In The Analysis of Burned Human Remains, edited by C. W. Schmidt and S. A. Symes, 1–13. London: Academic, 2008.

  • Engels, J. Funerum sepulcrorumque magnficentia: Begräbnis- und Grabluxusgesetze in der griechisch-römischen Welt mit einigen Ausblicken auf Einschränkungen des funeralen und sepulkralen Luxus im Mittelalter und in der Neuzeit. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner, 1998.

  • Frangeskou, V. “Tradition and originality in some Attic funeral orations.” Classical World 92 (1999): 315–336.

  • Fullbrook, M. A Small Town Near Auschwitz: ordinary Nazis and the Holocaust. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2012.

  • Garland, R. The Greek Way of Death. Second edition. Ithaca: Cornell U. P., 1985/2001.

  • Georgoulaki, E. “Religious and socio-political implications of mortuary evidence: case studies in ancient Greece.” Kernos 9 (1996): 95–120.

  • Goette, H. R. “Images in the Athenian ‘Demosion Sema.’” In Art in Athens During the Peloponnesian War, edited by O. Palaiga, 188–206. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2009.

  • Goldhahn, J. and T. Oestigaard. “Smith and death-cremations in furnaces in Bronze and Iron Age Scandinavia.” In Facets of Archaeology: essays in honour of Lotte Hedeager on her 60th birthday, edited by K. Childis, J. Lund and C. Prescott. Oslo: Oslo Archaeological Series, 2008.

  • Gomme, A. W. A Historical Commentary on Thucydides: Books II-III.2, The Ten Years War. Oxford: Clarendon, 1956.

  • Groneman, B. Eyewitness to the Alamo. Guilford: Lone Star, 2001.

  • Hamel, D. The Battle of Arginusae: victory at sea and its tragic aftermath in the final years of the Peloponnesian War. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins U. P., 2015.

  • Hammond, M. Thucydides: the Peloponnesian War. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2009.

  • Hansen, M. H. Three Studies in Athenian Demography. Copenhagen: Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab, 1988.

  • Hansen, T., editor. The Alamo Reader: a study in history. Mechanicsburg: Stackpole, 2003.

  • Hatch, T. Encyclopedia of the Alamo and the Texas Revolution. Jefferson: MacFarland, 1999.

  • Holck, P. Cremated Bones: a medical-anthropological study of an archaeological material on cremation burials. Oslo: Universitetet i Oslo, Antropologiske skrifter 1, 1987.

  • Honig, B. Antigone, Interrupted. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2013.

  • Hornblower, S. A Commentary on Thucydides, vol. III. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 2008.

  • Humphreys, S. C. “From a grin to a death: the body in the Greek discovery of politics.” In Constructions of the Classical Body, edited by J. I. Porter, 126–146. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 1999.

  • Huntsman, T. and M. J. Becker. “An analysis of the cremated human remains in a terracotta cinerary urn of the third-second century BCE from Chiusi, now in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York.” Etruscan Studies 16 (2013): 153–164.

  • Jacoby, F. “Patrios nomos: state burial in Athens and the public cemetery in the Kerameikos.” Journal of Hellenic Studies 64 (1944): 37–66.

  • Krentz, P. “Casualties in hoplite battle.” Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 26 (1985): 13–20.

  • Loraux, N. The Invention of Athens: the funeral oration in the Classical city. Trans. Alan Sheridan. Cambridge: Harvard U. P., 1986.

  • Lord, W. A Time to Stand. Lincoln: University of Nebraska, 1961/1978.

  • Low, P. “Commemorating the war dead in Classical Athens: remembering defeat and victory.” In War, Democracy and Culture in Classical Athens, edited by D. Pritchard, 341–358. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2010.

  • Matovina, T. M. The Alamo Remembered: Tejano accounts and perspectives. Austin: University of Texas, 1995.

  • McKinley, J. I. “Cremations: expectations, methodologies and realities.” In Burial Archaeology: current research, methods and developments, edited by C. A. Roberts, F. Lee and J. Bintliff, 65–76. Oxford: British Archaeological Report S211, 1989.

  • McKinley, J. I. “Bone fragment size and weights of bone from modern British cremations and its implications for the interpretation of archaeological cremations.” International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 3 (1993): 283–287.

  • McKinley, J. I. “Bone fragment size in British cremation burials and its implications for pyre technology and ritual.” Journal of Archaeological Science 21 (1994): 339–342.

  • McKinley, J. I. “The analysis of cremated bone.” In Human Osteology: in archaeology and forensic science, edited by M. Cox and C. May, 403–421. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2000.

  • McKinley, J. I. “In the heat of the pyre.” In The Analysis of Burned Human Remains, edited by C. W. Schmidt and S. A. Symes, 181–202. London: Academic, 2008, 181–202.

  • Meiggs, R. Trees and Timber in the Ancient Mediterranean World. Oxford: Clarendon, 1982.

  • Montague, P. Chełmno and the Holocaust: the history of Hitler's first death camp. London: I. B. Tauris, 2012.

  • Morris, I. Burial and Ancient Society: the rise of the Greek city-state. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 1987.

  • Morris, I. Death-Ritual and Social Structure in Classical Antiquity. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 1992.

  • Musgrave, J. “Dust and damn'd oblivion: a study of cremation in ancient Greece.” Annual of the British School at Athens 85 (1990): 271–299.

  • Noy, D. “‘Half-burnt on an emergency pyre:’ Roman cremations which went wrong.” Greece and Rome 47 (2000): 186-196

  • Osborne, R. “Democratic ideology, the events of war and the Iionography of Attic funerary sculpture.” In War, Democracy and Culture in Classical Athens, edited by D. Pritchard, 245–265. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2010.

  • Parker, R. Miasma: pollution and purification in early Greek religion. Oxford: Clarendon, 1983.

  • Phang, S., I. Spence, D. Kelly and P. Londey. Conflict in Ancient Greece and Rome: the definitive political, social, and military encyclopedia, vol. 1. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, 2016.

  • Piontek, J. “Proces kremacji i jego wpływ na morfologię kości w świetle wyników badań eksperymentalnych.” Archeologia Polski 21 (1976): 247–280.

  • Piper, F. “Gas chambers and crematoria.” In Anatomy of the Auschwitz Death Camp, edited by Y. Gutman and M. Berenbaum, 157–182. Bloomington: Indiana U. P., 1994.

  • Pritchard, D. “The symbiosis between democracy and war: the case of ancient Athens.” In War, Democracy and Culture in Classical Athens, edited by D. Pritchard, 1–62. Cambridge: Cambridge U. P., 2010.

  • Pritchett, W. K. The Greek State at War, Vol 4. Berkeley: University of California, 1985.

  • Quinn, C., L. Goldstein, G. Cooney and I. Kuijt. “Perspectives—complexities of terminologies and intellectual frameworks in cremation studies.” In Transformation by Fire: the archaeology of cremation in cultural context, edited by I. Kuijt, C. Quinn and G. Cooney, 25-32. Tucson: University of Arizona, 2014.

  • Raaflaub, K. “War and the city: the brutality of war and its impact on the community.” In Combat Trauma and the Ancient Greeks, P. Meineck and D. Konstan, 15–46. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014.

  • Raaflaub, K. “Lysistrata and war’s impact on the home front.” In Our Ancient Wars: rethinking war through the classics, edited by V. Caston and S.-M. Weineck, 38–74. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 2016.

  • Rackham, O. “Ancient landscapes.” In The Greek City: from Homer to Alexander, edited by O. Murray and S. Price, 85–112. Oxford: Oxford U. P., 1990.

  • Rawlins, L. The Ancient Greeks at War. Manchester: Manchester U. P., 2007.

  • Reverdin, O. La Religion de la Cité Platonicienne. Paris: De Boccard, 1945.

  • Rubincam, C. “Casualty figures in the battle descriptions of Thucydides.” Transactions of the American Philological Association 121 (1991): 181–198.

  • Steinbock, B. Social Memory in Athenian Public Discourse: uses and meanings of the past. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan, 2013.

  • Stoupa, C. “Γ’ Εφορεία Προϊστορικών και Κλασικών Αρχαιοτήτων, ανασκαφικές εργασίες: Οδός Σαλαμίνος 35.” ArchDelt 52, B’1 (1997): 52–56.

  • Stroud, R. S. “Thucydides and the Battle of Solygeia.” California Studies in Classical Antiquity 4 (1971): 227–247.

  • Stupperich, R. "Staatsbegräbnis und Privatgrabmal im klassischen Athen." PhD thesis, Münster, 1977.

  • Tucker, P. Exodus from the Alamo: the anatomy of the last stand myth. Havertown: Casemates, 2009.

  • Ubelaker, D. H. and J. L. Rife. “The practice of cremation in the Roman-era cemetery at Kenchreai, Greece: the perspective from archeology and forensic science.” Bioarchaeology of the Near East 1 (2007): 35–57.

  • Vanderpool, E. “Three prize vases.” Archaiologikon Deltion 24 (1969): 1–5.

  • Vaughn, P. “The identification and retrieval of the hoplite battle-dead.” In Hoplites: the Classical Greek battle experience, edited by V. D. Hanson, 38–62. London: Routledge, 1991.

  • Williams, A. W. The Alamo Defenders: a critical study of the siege of the Alamo and the personnel of its defenders. Ingleside: Capano Bay, 1931/2010.

  • Ziolkowski, J. E. Thucydides and the Tradition of Funeral Speeches at Athens. New York: Arno, 1981.

Purchase article
Get instant unlimited access to the article.
$42.00
Log in
Already have access? Please log in.


or
Log in with your institution

Journal + Issues

The Journal of Ancient History aims to provide a forum for scholarship covering all aspects of ancient history and culture from the Archaic Period to Late Antiquity (roughly the ninth century BCE through the sixth century CE). The journal publishes peer-reviewed articles concerning the history and historiography (ancient and modern) of the ancient Mediterranean world and of neighboring civilizations in their relations with it.

Search