Does Foreign Aid Displace Domestic Taxation?

Patrick Carter 1
  • 1 Department of Economics, 8 Woodland Road, Bristol, Avon BS8 1TN, UK
Patrick Carter

Abstract

The existence of a negative relationship between aid and taxation would have far-reaching implications for international development agencies. This paper applies some recent methodological advances to the question and also discusses a range of problems with existing research. Previous results, which tend to show a negative relationship, are often based on econometric methods that rest on potentially restrictive assumptions. When more general methods, Panel Time Series estimators and the Group Fixed Effects estimator, are applied, there is little evidence that aid displaces domestic taxation.

  • Acemoglu, D. (2010) “Institutions, Factor Prices, and Taxation: Virtues of Strong States?” American Economic Review, 100(2):115–119.

    • Crossref
  • Acemoglu, D., S. Johnson and J. A. Robinson (2005) “Institutions as a Fundamental Cause of Long-run Growth.” Volume 1, Part 1 of Handbook of Economic Growth, Elsevier, pp. 385–472.

    • Crossref
  • Adam, C., S. O’Connell, E. Buffie and C. Pattillo (2009) “Monetary Policy Rules for Managing Aid Surges in Africa,” Review of Development Economics, 13:464–490.

    • Crossref
  • Agbeyegbe, T. D., J. G. Stotsky and A. Woldemariam (2004) Trade Liberalization, Exchange Rate Changes, and Tax Revenue in Sub-Saharan Africa. IMF Working Papers 04/178, International Monetary Fund.

  • Aiyar, S. and U. Ruthbah (2008) Where did All the Aid Go? An Empirical Analysis of Absorption and Spending. IMF Working Papers WP/08/34, International Monetary Fund.

    • Crossref
  • Allen, R. (2009) The Challenges of Reforming Budgetary Institutions in Developing Countries. Working Paper WP/09/96, IMF.

  • Arndt, C., S. Jones and F. Tarp (2013) Assessing Foreign Aid’s Long-run Contribution to Growth in Development. Working Paper, 2013.

  • Atoyan, R. and P. Conway (2006) “Evaluating the Impact of IMF Programs: A Comparison of Matching and Instrumental-variable Estimators,” The Review of International Organizations, 1(2):99–124.

    • Crossref
  • Baland, J.-M., K. O. Moene and J. A. Robinson (2010) “Governance and Development.” In: (D. Rodrik and M. Rosenzweig, eds.) The Handbook of Development Economics: Volume 5. Amsterdam: Elsevier.

    • Crossref
  • Banerjee, R. (2010) “New Evidence about the Relationship between Aid and Institutions.”

    • Crossref
  • Baunsgaard, T. and M. Keen (2010) “Tax Revenue and (or?) Trade Liberalization,” Journal of Public Economics, 94:563–577.

    • Crossref
  • Bazzi, S. and M. Clemens (2012) “Blunt Instruments: Avoiding Common Pitfalls in Identifying the Causes of Economic Growth,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 5(2):152–186.

  • Besley, T. J. and T. Persson (2009a) “The Origins of State Capacity: Property Rights, Taxation and Politics,” American Economic Review, 99(4):1218–1244.

    • Crossref
  • Besley, T. J. and T. Persson (2009b) State Capacity, Conflict and Development. Discussion Paper 7336, CEPR.

    • Crossref
  • Besley, T. and T. Persson (2011) Pillars of Prosperity: The Political Economics of Development Clusters. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

    • Crossref
  • Besley, T. J. and T. Persson (2013) “Taxation and Development.” In: (Alan J. Auerbach, Raj Chetty, Martin Feldstein and Emmanuel Saez, eds.) Handbook of Public Economics, vol. 5. Amsterdam: Elsevier, pp. 51–110.

    • Crossref
  • Bird, R. M. and E. M. Zolt (2005) “The Limted Role of the Personal Income Tax in Developing Countries,” Journal of Asian Economies, 16:928–946.

    • Crossref
  • Bonhomme, S. and E. Manresa (2012) Grouped Patterns of Heterogeneity in Panel Data. Working Papers 2012/1208, CEMFI.

  • Brautigam, D. and K. Botchway (1999) The Institutional Impact of Aid Dependence on Recipients in Africa. Working Paper.

  • Brautigam, D. A. and S. Knack (2004) “Foreign Aid, Institutions, and Governance in Sub-Saharan Africa,” Economic Development and Cultural Change, 52(2):255–285.

    • Crossref
  • Campbell, J. Y. (1987) “Does Saving Anticipate Declining Labor Income? An Alternative Test of the Permanent Income Hypothesis,” Econometrica, 55(6):1249–1273.

    • Crossref
  • Carroll, C. D. (1994) “How does Future Income Affect Current Consumption?” The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 109(1):111–147.

    • Crossref
  • Clist, P. (2011) “25 Years of Aid Allocation Practice: Whither Selectivity?” World Development, 39(10):1724–1734.

  • Clist, P. and O. Morrissey (2011) “Aid and Tax Revenue: Signs of a Positive Effect Since the 1980s,” Journal of International Development, 23(2):165–180.

    • Crossref
  • Collier, P. (1999) “Aid ‘Dependency’: A Critique,” Journal of African Economies, 8(4):528–545.

    • Crossref
  • Collier, P. and A. J. Venables (2011) “Illusory Revenues: Import Tariffs in Resource-rich and Aid-rich Economies,” Journal of Development Economics, 94(2):202–206.

    • Crossref
  • Corbo, V. and P. Rojas (1991) World Bank-supported Adjustment Programs : Country Performance and Effectiveness. Policy Research Working Paper Series 623, The World Bank.

  • Crivelli, E., D. Benedek, P. S. Muthoora and S. Gupta (2012) Foreign Aid and Revenue: Still a Crowding Out Effect? IMF Working Papers 12/186, International Monetary Fund.

    • Crossref
  • Deaton, A. (2010) “Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about Development,” Journal of Economic Literature, 48(2):424–455.

    • Crossref
  • Devarajan, S., V. Swaroop and H. F. Zou (1996) “The Composition of Public Expenditure and Economic Growth,” Journal of Monetary Economics, 37(2):313–344.

    • Crossref
  • Dincecco, M. and M. Prado (2012) “Warfare, Fiscal Capacity, and Performance,” Journal of Economic Growth, 17:171–203.

    • Crossref
  • Djankov, S., J. Montalvo and M. Reynal-Querol (2008) “The Curse of Aid,” Journal of Economic Growth, 13(3):169–194.

    • Crossref
  • Dollar, D. and V. Levin (2006) “The Increasing Selectivity of Foreign Aid, 1984–2003,” World Development, 34(12):2034–2046.

    • Crossref
  • Easterly, W. and S. Rebelo (1993) “Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth: An Empirical Investigation,” Journal of Monetary Economics, 32(3):417–458.

    • Crossref
  • Feyzioglu, T., V. Swaroop and M. Zhu (1998) “A Panel Data Analysis of the Fungibility of Foreign Aid. World Bank Economic Review, 12(1):29–58.

    • Crossref
  • Fjeldstad, O.-H. (2013) Taxation and Development: A Review of Donor Support to Strengthen Tax Systems in Developing Countries. Technical report, 2013.

  • Gambaro, L., J. Meyer-Spasche and A. Rahman (2007) Does Aid Decrease Tax Revenue in Developing Countries? Mimeo, 2007.

  • Gang, I. N. and H. A. Khan (1991) “Foreign Aid, Taxes and Public Investment,” Journal of Development Economics, 24:355–369.

  • Gibson, C. C., K. Andersson, E. Ostrom and S. Shivakumar (2005) The Samaritan’s Dilemma: The Political Economy of Development Aid. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Gupta, S., B. Clements, A. Pivovarsky and E. R. Tiongson (2004) “Foreign Aid and Revenue Response: Does the Composition of Aid Matter?” In: (B. Clements, S. Gupta and G. Inchauste, eds.) Helping Countries Develop: The Role of Fiscal Policy. Washington: International Monetary Fund.

  • Gupta, S., B. Clements, E. Baldacci and C. Mulas-Granados (2005) “Fiscal Policy, Expenditure Composition, and Growth in Low-income Countries,” Journal of International Money and Finance, 24(3):441–463.

    • Crossref
  • Hagen, R. J. (2006) “Samaritan Agents? On the Strategic Delegation of Aid Policy,” Journal of Development Economics, 79(1):249–263.

    • Crossref
  • Heller, P. (1975) “A Model of Public Fiscal Behaviour in Developing Countries: Aid, Investment and Taxation,” American Economic Review, 65(3):429–445.

  • Keen, M. and M. Mansour (2010) “Revenue Mobilisation in Sub-Saharan Africa: Challenges from Globalisation II – Corporate Taxation,” Development Policy Review, 28(5):573–596.

    • Crossref
  • Khattry, B. and J. M. Rao (2002) “Fiscal Faux Pas?: An Analysis of the Revenue Implications of Trade Liberalisation,” World Development, 30(8):1431–1444.

  • Kimbrough, K. P. (1986) “Foreign Aid and Optimal Fiscal Policy,” The Canadian Journal of Economics/Revue canadienne d’Economique, 19(1):35–61.

    • Crossref
  • Knack, S. (2008) Sovereign Rents and the Quality of Tax Policy and Administration. World Bank Working Paper.

    • Crossref
  • Mahon, J. E. (2005) Liberal States and Fiscal Contracts: Aspects of the Political Economy of Public Finance. Paper prepared for the annual meeting of the American Political Science Association, Washington, DC.

  • Marchesi, S. and A. Missale (2013) “Did High Debts Distort Loan and Grant Allocation to IDA Countries?” World Development, 44:44–62.

    • Crossref
  • Mavrotas, G. (2005) “Aid Heterogeneity: Looking at Aid Effectiveness from a Different Angle,” Journal of International Development, 17(8):1019–1036.

  • McGillivray, M. (2009) “Aid, Economic Reform, and Public Sector Fiscal Behavior in Developing Countries,” Review of Development Economics, 13(3):526–542.

    • Crossref
  • Moore, M. (2007) “How does Taxation Affect the Quality of Governance?” Tax Notes International, 47(1):79–98.

  • Moore, M. (2008) “Between Coercion and Contract: Competing Narratives on Taxation and Governence.” In: (D. Brautigam, O.-H. Fjeldstad and M. Moore, eds.) Taxation and State-Building in Developing Countries. Cambridge and New York: University Press, pp. 34–65.

    • Crossref
  • Moss, T., G. Pettersson and N. van de Walle (2008) “An Aid-institutions paradox? A Review Essay on Aid Dependency and State Building in Sub-Saharan Africa.” In: (W. Easterly, ed.) Reinventing Foreign Aid. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

  • Nickell, S. J. (1981) “Biases in Dynamic Models with Fixed Effects,” Econometrica, 49(6): 1417–1426.

    • Crossref
  • O’Connell, S., C. Adam and E. Buffie (2008) Aid and Fiscal Instability. CSAE Working Paper.

  • Pedersen, K. (2001) “The Samaritan’s Dilemma and the Effectiveness of Development Aid,” International Tax and Public Finance, 8(5–6):693–703.

    • Crossref
  • Pesaran, M. H. and R. P. Smith (1995) “Estimating Long-run Relationships from Dynamic Heterogenous Panels,” Journal of Econometrics, 68(1):79–113.

    • Crossref
  • Pesaran, M. H. (2006) “Estimation and Inference in Large Heterogenous Panels with a Multifactor Error Structure,” Econometrica, 74(4):967–1012.

    • Crossref
  • Pesaran, M. H., Y. Shin and R. P. Smith (1999) “Pooled Mean Group Estimation of Dynamic Heterogeneous Panels,” Journal of the American Statistical Association, 94(446):621–634.

    • Crossref
  • Remmer, K. L. (2004) “Does Foreign aid Promote the Expansion of Government?” The American Journal of Political Science, 48(1):77–92.

    • Crossref
  • Robertson, D. and J. Symons (1992) “Some Strange Properties of Panel Data Estimators,” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 7:175–189.

    • Crossref
  • Ross, M. (2004) “Does Taxation Lead to Representation?” The British Journal of Political Science, 34(2):229–249.

    • Crossref
  • Sala-i-Martin, X., G. Doppelhofer and R. I. Miller (2004) “Determinants of Long-term Growth: A Bayesian Averaging of Classical Estimates (BACE) Approach,” American Economic Review, 94(4):813–835.

    • Crossref
  • Sarafidis, V. and T. Wansbeek (2012) “Cross-sectional Dependence in Panel Data Analysis,” Econometric Reviews, 31(5):483–531.

    • Crossref
  • Smith, R. P. (2001) “Estimation and Inference with Non-stationary Panel Time-series Data.” In: RC33 Conference, Cologne.

  • Temple, J. (2010) “Aid and Condtionality.” In: (M. R. Rosenzweig and D. Rodrik, eds.) Handbook of Development Economics 5. North Holland: Elsevier, pp. 4415–4523.

  • Van de Sijpe, N. (2010) Foreign aid and Government Behaviour. D.phil thesis, St Catherine’s College, University of Oxford.

  • Wei, S.-J. and Z. Zhang (2010) “Do External Interventions Work? The Case of Trade Reform Conditions in {IMF} Supported Programs,” Journal of Development Economics, 92(1): 71–81.

    • Crossref
Purchase article
Get instant unlimited access to the article.
$42.00
Log in
Already have access? Please log in.


or
Log in with your institution

Journal + Issues

Search