How accurate are coat traits for discriminating wild and hybrid forms of Felis silvestris?

Elena Ballesteros-Duperón 1 , Emilio Virgós 2 , Marcos Moleón, José M. Barea-Azcón 1 ,  and José M. Gil-Sánchez 1
  • 1 Environment and Water Agency of Andalusia, Regional Ministry of Environment of the Junta de Andalucía, C/Joaquina Eguaras, 10, E 18013 Granada, Spain
  • 2 Escet, Department of Biology and Geology, University King Juan Carlos, C/ Tulipan, s/n, E-28933 Madrid, Spain
  • 3 Centre for African Ecology, School of Animal, Plant and Environmental Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Wits 2050, Johannesburg, South Africa
Elena Ballesteros-Duperón, Emilio Virgós, Marcos Moleón, José M. Barea-Azcón and José M. Gil-Sánchez

Abstract

Hybridisation between domestic cats, Felis catus, and wildcats, Felis silvestris, could lead to the genetic extinction of the latter; therefore, checking hybridisation rates in wild populations is of vital conservation importance. However, detecting hybridisation in the field is particularly challenging. Here, we aim to test the success of morphological-based procedures for discriminating wildcats from their hybrids and domestic cats, against genetic methods. We checked 17 putative Spanish wildcats by using two different classification systems based on coat patterns. None of the putative wildcats analysed in this study seemed to have an admixed genotype. Concordance between genetic and pelage approaches was almost total: only one coat classification produced mixed results with detection of one potential hybrid. Assignment was worse when performed in the field after a rapid examination of coat characters. We conclude that classification systems using coat traits could serve as surrogates of genetic approaches, but only after careful examination of those characters with more discriminatory power. Thus, the control of hybrid populations in the field as a management tool to preserve the genetic identity of wild forms is problematic if based on crude approaches or incomplete classification systems.

  • Balharry, D. and M.J. Daniels. 1998. Wild living cats in Scotland. Survey and Monitoring Report 23. Scottish Natural Heritage, Edinburgh, UK.

  • Barea-Azcón, J.M., E. Virgós, E. Ballesteros-Duperón, M. Moleón and M. Chirosa. 2007. Surveying carnivores at large spatial scales: a comparison of four broad-applied methods. Biodivers. Conserv. 16: 1213–1230.

    • Crossref
  • Beaumont, M., E.M. Barratt, D. Gottelli, A.C. Ktchener, M.J. Daniels, J.K. Pritchard and M.W. Bruford. 2001. Genetic diversity and introgression in the Scottish wildcat. Mol. Ecol. 10: 319–336.

    • PubMed
  • Corbett, L.K. 1979. Feeding ecology and social organization of wildcats (Felis silvestris) and domestic cats (Felis catus) in Scotland. PhD Thesis, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, UK.

  • Daniels, M.J., D. Balharry, D. Hirst, A.C. Kitchener and R.J. Aspinall. 1998. Morphological and pelage characteristics of wild living cats in Scotland: implications for defining the ‘wildcat’. J. Zool. 244: 231–247.

    • Crossref
  • Daniels, M.J., M.A. Beaumont, P.J. Johnson, D. Balharry, D.W. Macdonald and E. Barratt. 2001. Ecology and genetics of wild-living cats in the north-east of Scotland and the implications for the conservation of the wildcat. J. Appl. Ecol. 38: 146–161.

    • Crossref
  • Driscoll, C.A. and K. Nowell. 2010. Felis silvestris. In: IUCN 2013. IUCN of Threatened Species. Version 2013.2. www.iucnredlist.org. Downloaded on 1 February 2014.

  • Driscoll, C.A., M. Menotti-Raymond, A.L. Roca, K. Hupe, W.E. Johnson, E. Geffen, E. Harley, M. Delibes, D. Portier, A.C. Kitchener, N. Yamaguchi, S.J. O’Brien and D.W. Macdonald. 2007. The Near Eastern origin of cat domestication. Science 317: 519–523.

    • Crossref
  • Eichholzer, A. 2010. Testing the applicability of pictures taken by camera-traps for monitoring the European wildcat Felis silvestris silvestris in the Jura Mountains of Switzerland. MSc Thesis. University of Zürich, Switzerland. pp. 1–37.

  • EUROP. 1992. Council Directive 92/43/EECof 21ts May 1992 on the Conservation of Natural Habitats and of Wild Fauna and Flora. Appendix IV. Office for Official Publications of the European Union. Available at http://europa.eu/. Accessed 29 January, 2013.

  • Fernández, E., F. de Lope and C. de la Cruz. 1992. Morphologie crânienne du chat sauvage (Felis silvestris) dans le sud de la Pénisule Ibérique: importance de l’introgression parle chat domestique (F. catus). Mammalia 56: 255–264.

    • Crossref
  • French, D.D., L.K. Corbett and N. Easterbee. 1988. Morphological discriminants of Scottish wildcats (Felis silvestris), domestic cats (F. catus) and their hybrids. J. Zool. 214: 235–259.

  • Hertwig, S., A. Jungnickel, S. Stepanow, U.R. Böhle and M.S. Fischer. 2009. Regionally high rates of hybridization and introgression in German wildcat populations (Felis silvestris, Carnivora, Felidae). J. Zool. Syst. Evol. Res. 47: 283–297.

    • Crossref
  • Hubbard, A.L., S. McOrist, T.W. Jones, R. Boid, R. Scott and N. Easterbee. 1992. Is survival of European wildcats Felis silvestris in Britain threatened by interbreeding with domestic cats? Biol. Conserv. 61: 203–208.

    • Crossref
  • Kitchener, C., N. Yamaguchi, J.M. Ward and D.W. Macdonald. 2005. A diagnosis for the Scottish wildcat (Felis silvestris): a tool for conservation action for a critically-endangered felid. Anim. Conserv. 8: 223–237.

  • Krüger, M., S. Hertwig, G. Jetschke and M.S. Fischer. 2009. Evaluation of anatomical characters and the question of hybridization with domestic cats in the wildcat population of Thuringia, Germany. J. Zool. Syst. Evol. Res. 47: 268–282.

    • Crossref
  • Lecis, R., M. Pierpaoli, S. Birò, L. Szemethy, B. Ragni, F. Vercillo and E. Randi. 2006. Bayesian analyses of admixture in wild and domestic cats (Felis silvestris) using linked microsatellite loci. Mol. Ecol. 15: 119–131.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
  • López-Martín, J.M., F.J. García, A. Such, E. Virgós, J. Lozano, J. Duarte and A.J. España. 2007. Felis silvestris Schreber, 1777. In: (L.J., Palomo, J. Gisbert and J.C. Blanco, eds.) Atlas y Libro Rojo de los Mamíferos Terrestres de España. DGB-SECEM-SECEMU, Madrid, Spain, pp. 336–338.

  • Lozano, J. and A.F. Malo. 2012. Conservation of the European wildcat (Felis silvestris) in Mediterranean environments: a reassessment of current threats. In: (G.S., Williams, ed.) Mediterranean ecosystems: dynamics, management and conservation. Nova Science Publishers Inc., Hauppauge, NY. pp. 1–31.

  • Lozano, J., E. Virgós, A.F. Malo, D.L. Huertas and J.G. Casanovas. 2003. Importance of scrub-pastureland mosaics for wild-living cats occurrence in a Mediterranean area: implications for the conservation of the wildcat (Felis silvestris). Biodivers. Conserv. 12: 921–935.

    • Crossref
  • Lozano, J., E. Virgós, S. Cabezas-Díaz and J.G. Mangas. 2007. Increase of large game species in Mediterranean areas: is the European wildcat (Felis silvestris) facing a new threat? Biol. Conserv. 138: 321–329.

    • Crossref
  • Mendelssohn, H. 1999. The wildcat in Israel. Cat News 31: 21–22.

  • Nowell, K. and P. Jackson. 1996. Wild cats. Status survey and conservation action plan. UICN/SSC Cat Specialist Group, Gland, Switzerland.

  • Nussberger, B. 2012. Detecting introgression is important for wildcat conservation. Säugetierkundliche Informationen 8: 319–328.

  • Oliveira, R., R. Godinho, E. Randi and P.C. Alves. 2008a. Hybridization versus conservation: are domestic cats threatening the genetic integrity of wildcats (Felis silvestris silvestris) in Iberian Peninsula? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. B 363: 2953–2961.

    • Crossref
  • Oliveira, R., R. Godinho, E. Randi, N. Ferrand and P.C. Alves. 2008b. Molecular analysis of hybridisation between wild and domestic cats (Felis silvestris) in Portugal: implications for conservation. Conserv. Genet. 9: 1–11.

    • Crossref
  • Parent, G.H. 1974. Plaidoyer pour le chat sylvestre ou dix excellentes raisons pour protéger cet animal malconnu en Belgique et ailleurs. Homme Nat. 10: 1–5.

  • Pierpaoli, M., Z.S. Birò, M. Herrmann, K. Hupe, M. Fernandes, B. Ragni, L. Szemethy and E. Randi. 2003. Genetic distinction of wildcat (Felis silvestris) populations in Europe, and hybridization with domestic cats in Hungary. Mol. Ecol. 12: 2585–2598.

    • PubMed
  • Platz, S., S. Hertwig, G. Jetschke, M. Krüger and M.S. Fischer. 2011. Comparative morphometric study of the Slovakian wildcat population (Felis silvestris silvestris): evidence for a low rate of introgression? Mamm. Biol. 76: 222–233.

    • Crossref
  • Puzachenko, A.Y. 2002. Hybrid syndrome and method for identification of hybrids in museum collections of Felis silvestris and Felis lybica. Säugetierk. Inform. 26: 234–248.

  • Ragni, B. and M. Possenti. 1996. Variability of coat-colour and markings system in Felis silvestris. Ital. J. Zool. 63: 285–292.

    • Crossref
  • Ragni, B. and E. Randi. 1986. Multivariate analysis of chraniometric characters in European wildcat, domestic cat and African wildcat (genus Felis). Z. Säugetierkd. 51: 243–251.

  • Randi, E., M. Pierpaoli, M. Beaumont and B. Ragni. 2001. Genetic identification of wild and domestic cats (Felis silvestris) and their hybrids using Bayesian clustering methods. Mol. Biol. Evol. 18: 1679–1693.

    • Crossref
    • PubMed
  • Say, L., S. Devillard, F. Léger, D. Pontier and S. Ruette. 2012. Distribution and spatial genetic structure of European wildcat in France. Anim. Conserv. 15: 18–27.

    • Crossref
  • Stahl, P. and M. Artois. 1991. Status and conservation of the wild cat (Felis silvestris) in Europe and around the Mediterranean rim. Council of Europe, Strasbourg, France.

  • StatSoft Inc. 2001. STATISTICA for Windows, version 6.0. StatSoft Inc., Tulsa, OK.

  • Stuart, C. and T. Stuart. 1991. The feral cat problem in southern Africa. Afr. Wild. 45: 13–15.

  • Virgós, E. and A. Travaini. 2005. Relationship between small-game hunting and carnivore diversity in central Spain. Biodivers. Conserv. 14: 3475–3486.

    • Crossref
  • Virgós, E., J.L. Tellería and T. Santos. 2002. A comparison on the response to forest fragmentation by medium-sized Iberian carnivores in central Spain. Biodivers. Conserv. 11: 1063–1079.

    • Crossref
  • Yamaguchi, N., A.C. Kitchener, C.A. Driscoll, J.M. Ward and D.W. Macdonald. 2004. Craniological differentiation amongst wild-living cats in Britain and southern Africa: natural variation or the effects of hybridization? Anim. Conserv. 7: 339–351.

    • Crossref
Purchase article
Get instant unlimited access to the article.
$42.00
Log in
Already have access? Please log in.


or
Log in with your institution

Journal + Issues

Mammalia is a peer-reviewed journal devoted to the inventory, analysis and interpretation of Mammalian diversity. It publishes original results on all aspects of systematics (comparative, functional and evolutionary morphology; morphometrics; phylogeny; biogeography; taxonomy and nomenclature), biology, ecology and conservation of mammals.

Search