There has been renewed interest in the optical community to protect optical sensors and, more importantly, human eyes from accidental or intentional harm caused by high-intensity light sources. This is accomplished by optical limiters (OLs), which have low absorption at low light intensities and high absorption at higher intensities. Multiple nonlinear processes could be utilized for optical limiting, including nonlinear scattering, absorption, refraction, and multiphoton absorption . Materials exhibiting nonlinear absorption, specifically reverse saturable absorption (RSA), are among the most popular for OLs . RSA materials provide high transmission (low absorption) at low intensity of incident light, and low transmission when the intensity of incident light becomes high. Defined more rigorously, RSA occurs when the absorption cross-section of the excited states is larger than that of the ground states. RSA also requires the lifetime of the triplet state to be relatively long, which is reflected directly in the efficiency and the saturation intensity of the OL. The wide range of materials that exhibit RSA includes metals , organic dyes , , clustered metal particles , , synthetic compounds , carbon nanotubes , and two-dimensional materials , .
Unlike other nonlinear phenomena, there are surprisingly few efforts to develop complete multiphysics models of optical limiting devices based on RSA with resonant nanostructured optical elements. Such models would allow significant improvement of the size, weight, and power metrics of this class of OLs. One of the most sought-after requirements is obtaining RSA at normal illumination levels, which would greatly expand their area of applicability such as protective eyewear and automatically dimmed windows ,  and open up new opportunities for obtaining high-RSA materials at weak, incoherent light. Most RSA materials have extremely high saturation energies, defined as the energy required to reduce the linear transmittance to 1/e of its linear value. This limits the use of OLs based on those materials to very intense and/or very short laser pulses. Current efforts to optimize optical limiting properties are material-focused. Using material synthesis, chemical engineering, and functionalization of materials to increase their triplet state lifetime have been widely explored to get enhanced RSA characteristics at the power level of sunlight , . We believe that a critical limiting factor hindering the optimization and enhancement of OLs at the device level is the lack of material models that account for the quantum mechanical origin of RSA and its relevant representation in the time domain. Once an accurate model of RSA is available, boosting the performance of OLs using the current advances in nanophotonics and micro- and nano-fabrication should be made substantially more achievable. Thus far, there have been efforts to model saturable nonlinearities in the time domain using various methods such as a saturable harmonic oscillator  as well as two-level systems for saturable absorbers , . For RSA, the physical mechanism causing the absorption is somewhat more involved and requires taking into account different timescales as well as the absorption contributions of both the singlet and triplet states.
In this work, we propose an advanced time-domain numerical simulation approach that models the RSA process as an atomic multilevel system in a 3D full-wave multiphysics framework. We integrate our material model as a proprietary ADE (application domain extension) code in a commercial-grade solver based on the 3D finite-difference time-domain method. This approach allows expanding the versatility of target problems through the advanced pre- and post-processing features of the commercial solver . With this approach, we can simulate the different relaxations taking place in the material and get an idea of how they affect the nonlinear optical material response. Additionally, we can also realize a deeper understanding of the excitation mechanisms, and then employ this comprehensive knowledge to optimize optical limiting devices and systems. Similar to the experiment-fitted time-domain kinetic models of gain media , feedback from optical experiments should always be recommended for accurate material modeling in the design and optimization of real-life RSA devices. Advantages of our scheme include (i) self-consistent description of the excitation and relaxations dynamics, coupled to (ii) 3D full-wave multiphysics environment with the geometry discretization that can handle an arbitrary structural complexity, and accurately model focused/structured beams that match experimentallyused sources, without resorting to paraxial or non-paraxial approximations, and, finally, (iii) in-depth post-processing of the simulated data – time-resolved tracking of E-fields, polarizations, and population kinetics – getting physical insights into the system dynamics not otherwise available through experiment. Moreover, we use our multiphysics framework to design the plasmon-enhanced OL devices with an order of magnitude reduction in the saturation intensity. This is a critical improvement that brings the activation energies of the OLs to reduced illumination levels, thus significantly expanding the area of application for these devices. Following this introduction, a particular topology of a multilevel atomic system for modeling RSA is introduced and explained with more details in Section 2. Then, the numerical framework and results obtained from the discretized models are discussed in Section 3. Time dynamics of the system along with the effects of controlling parameters on the system optical response are studied. Also, the results from our model are compared withthose based on the classical Beer–Lambert law (BLL) by fitting the corresponding absorption cross-sections, thus verifying that our model reproduces the experimentally measured RSA data. Finally, two different designs of plasmon-assisted OLs are introduced in Section 3.1, and their saturation intensities are compared with that of a thin film of a given RSA material.
2 RSA models
The band diagram of a material with RSA can be represented by an atomic four-level system with the Jablonski diagram shown in Figure 1A . When light illuminates an RSA medium, the atom is excited from the ground singlet state S0 to the first singlet state S1 by absorbing a photon of the incident light, Figure 1B. The excited atom in S1 can return to S0 by radiating the same photon, or it can exhibit an intersystem crossing (ISC) relaxation to the first triplet state T1. The atom at T1 can either relax to S0 or can be promoted to the second triplet state T2 by absorbing a second photon if the incident light intensity is sufficient (Figure 1C). The additional absorption associated with the elevations of atoms from T1 to T2 is the origin of RSA. It can be thought of as an additional channel for absorption in addition to the ground-state absorption channel (singlet pair) due to the match in their energy gap, which is true for materials exhibiting RSA , . For RSA to be efficient, a sufficient population of carriers should be transferred to T1, which requires efficient ISC and a long triplet-state lifetime. Also, the absorption cross-section of the excited triplet states must be larger than that of the ground singlet state.
2.1 Beer–Lambert law
BLL is commonly used in spectroscopy and chemical analysis to relate the absorbance of a given absorbing material to its concentration in a host medium and the path length. The rate equations that model carrier kinetics at the different states are commonly employed to approximate the absorption coefficient of the materials , , . Using the absorption coefficient with BLL, the intensity decay in uniformly absorbing samples can be found. Assuming three allowed relaxations, namely ISC from S1 to T1, relaxation form S1 to S0, and relaxation from T1 to S0, the rate equations governing the transitions inside the material are given by
where σG and σS are the ground-state and the singlet-state absorption cross-sections, respectively. Using this model, the time-dependent absorbance can be calculated, and the propagation of light intensity inside the sample can be straightforwardly obtained with a controlled accuracy and high efficiency even for tightly focused beams . This approach, however, does not provide a material model that can be used to simulate more involved optical devices with dispersive or nonlinear materials and other multiphysics complications. Also, this simple, yet efficient, methodology does not allow access to the electric E or magnetic H vector fields and local population kinetics close to the device’s nanostructured boundaries, and may not account for pumping dynamics following structured illumination. All these limitations are addressed with our full-wave multiphysics numerical framework, which includes a multilevel atomic model.
2.2 Four-level atomic system
As an example of a multilevel system, the atom or molecule of an RSA material is modeled using a four-level system with the Jablonski diagram shown in Figure 1A. The rate equations that govern all allowed transitions in a four-level system are given by
The population densities in the lower and upper singlet and triplet states, respectively, are
The induced macroscopic polarizations due to the transitions satisfy the Lorentz ordinary differential equation, given by
where γij is the dephasing constant between levels |i> and |j>. The energy spacing between the levels is
and Eqs. (3–6) are solved simultaneously using a full-wave solver on a staggered Yee grid by applying the classical central finite-difference approximation to the spatial and time derivatives , . The time-dependent electromagnetic fields are recorded and converted to the frequency domain using fast Fourier transform to obtain the transmission and reflection and, finally, the absorption.
3 Numerical details and results
A 1-μm-thick dielectric film is modeled using the proposed four-level atomic model in a host medium with refractive index 1. The lifetime and scattering rate parameters of the model are as follows:
Crossings of molecules from S1 to T1 requires undergoing a spin conversion in a process called ISC . The efficiency of ISC is determined by the triplet quantum yield ΦT= (1/τISC+1/τS1)/τISC. The faster the ISC rate (1/τISC), the higher the triplet quantum yield. Here, the effect of ΦT on the system response is studied. The same sample as before is used while varying the ISC lifetimes to 1, 10, 100, and 1000 ps, corresponding to ΦT of 0.999, 0.99, 0.909, and 0.5, respectively. Transmittance versus input fluence at the four different cases is depicted in Figure 3A. It can be noticed that for τISC of 1, 10, and 100 ps, the material shows RSA behavior with increasing saturation fluence. However, at τISC=1 ns, the material acts as a saturable absorber. This matches the system dynamics very well. As seen in Figure 3B, at τISC=10 ps, the efficiency of the triplet quantum yield is high enough to allow for sufficient population transfer to T1 unlike at τISC of 1 ns (Figure 3C), where the population density at T1 is almost negligible and, as a result, the carrier density at S1starts to saturate, leading to saturation of system absorption and hence to increased transmission (see the green line in Figure 3A).
Next, we compare the results of a 1-μm-thick RSA film with varying Nd using a four-level atomic model and the classical BLL. The lifetimes of the films are
3.1 Plasmon-enhanced optical limiters
Reducing the light intensity required for activating OLs is crucial for the expanding their area of application. For example, in protective goggles, OL devices should be activated at normal levels of the incoherent light illumination. From RSA materials standpoint, this translates to a very long triplet lifetime. Thus far, most of the development in this direction has been focused on developing materials with these favorable properties. In addition to this, here we use the multilevel material models developed for RSA to optimize optical limiting devices, where, due to the local field enhancement from plasmonic structures, the nonlinear response from RSA materials is further intensified. This way, the light intensity required for activating a given RSA device is greatly reduced. As a proof of concept, we design two plasmonic structures with an embedded RSA material to study the reduction in the saturation energy. Figure 5A shows the RSA material, with the same parameters as before, with thickness d=200 nm on top of a silver grating. The bottom silver film is 20 nm thick (t2), and the periodic ridges of the grating are 10 nm high (t1) and 50 nm wide (w). The pitch of the grating structure () is 500 nm, and the optical properties of silver were obtained from . The second configuration is depicted in Figure 5B, illustrating the same 200-nm RSA layer sandwiched between two silver films with thickness h=10 nm. The geometrical parameters of the grating and the cavity are specifically chosen based on several parametric sweeps to maximize the linear transmission while reducing the saturation intensity. The spatial grid size isset to 10 nm inside the RSA medium and to 2.5 nm inside the silver. The linear transmittance is 0.93 in the case of bare RSA film, 0.46 in the case of RSA film on a grating, and 0.68 in the case of the RSA layer inside a cavity-like structure. Figure 5C shows the normalized transmittance as a function of the input fluence of all three structures: a bare 200-nm RSA, the 200-nm RSA film on a grating, and the 200-nm RSA inside a cavity-like structure. The transmittance in each case is normalized to its maximum for more straightforward comparison. As observed in Figure 5C, the saturation intensity for the bare RSA film is 2.651 μJ/cm2, for the RSA film on a grating is 1.019 μJ/cm2, and for the RSA film in a cavity-like structure is 0.2006 μJ/cm2. This is a 2.6-fold reduction in the saturation intensity for the grating structure and 13.2-fold reduction in the cavity configuration. The method is also successfully verified with a custom solver built on the finite-element time-domain method, FETD in COMSOL Multiphysics by combining the Wave Optics Module with additional ODEs in the time-domain .
A 3D full-wave analysis of the RSA devices with the ability to model light–matter interaction based on rate equations that could include non-paraxial structured beams and complex photonic structures with diverse material composition has been presented and validated. The results of the proposed model agree well with the classical Beer–Lambert equation used to fit the experimental RSA data while also providing a comprehensive physical understanding of the field and carrier dynamics within the absorbing material. Examples of two plasmon-enhanced OLs that utilize the field enhancement to lower the saturation intensity were proposed. More than one order of magnitude reduction of the light fluence required to activate the RSA structures with plasmonic elements was achieved. Using our technique, the numerical modeling and optimization of the devices with complex micro- and nano-structured materials and illumination are made possible, which opens up new opportunities to explore high-sensitivity, low-threshold OLs beyond homogeneous RSA light–matter limitations. Future work will include other important effects into our model, such as the Pauli exclusion principle, for more accurate representation of RSA materials.
The authors appreciate the reviewers’ positive feedback and invaluable comments on the manuscript.
Funding:The authors acknowledge the financial support by DARPA/DSO Extreme Optics and Imaging (EXTREME) Program, Award HR00111720032, Funder Id: http://dx.doi.org/10.13039/100006502.
Kiran PP, Shivakiran Bhaktha BN, Rao DN, De G. Nonlinear optical properties and surface-plasmon enhanced optical limiting in Ag–Cu nanoclusters co-doped in SiO2 Sol-Gel films. J Appl Phys 2004;96:6717–23.
Li C, Zhang L, Wang R, Song Y, Wang Y. Dynamics of reverse saturable absorption and all-optical switching in C60. JOSA B 1994;11:1356–60.
Srinivas NN, Rao SV, Rao DN. Saturable and reverse saturable absorption of Rhodamine B in methanol and water. JOSA B 2003;20:2470–9.
Gurudas U, Brooks E, Bubb DM, Heiroth S, Lippert T, Wokaun A. Saturable and reverse saturable absorption in silver nanodots at 532 nm using picosecond laser pulses. J Appl Phys 2008;104:073107.
Sun X, Xiong Y, Chen P, et al. Investigation of an optical limiting mechanism in multiwalled carbon nanotubes. Appl Opt 2000;39:1998–2001.
Ouyang Q, Yu H, Wu H, Lei Z, Qi L, Chen Y. Graphene/MoS2 organic glasses: fabrication and enhanced reverse saturable absorption properties. Opt Mater 2013;35:2352–6.
Cheng Z, Li H, Shi H, Ren J, Yang QH, Wang P. Dissipative soliton resonance and reverse saturable absorption in graphene oxide mode-locked all-normal-dispersion Yb-doped fiber laser. Opt Exp 2015;23:7000–6.
Hirata S, Totani K, Yamashita T, Adachi C, Vacha M. Large reverse saturable absorption under weak continuous in coherent light. Nat Mater 2014;13:938.
Hirata S, Vacha M. Large reverse saturable absorption at the sunlight power level using the ultralong lifetime of triplet excitons. J Phys Chem Lett 2017;8:3683–9.
Varin C, Bart G, Emms R, Brabec T. Saturable Lorentz model for fully explicit three-dimensional modeling of nonlinear optics. Opt Exp 2015;23:2686–95.
Hill SC, Videen G, Sun W, Fu Q. Scattering and internal fields of a microsphere that contains a saturable absorber: finite-difference time-domain simulations. Appl Opt 2001;40:5487–94.
Mock A. Modeling passive mode-locking via saturable absorption in graphene using the finite-difference time-domain method. IEEE J Quantum Electron 2017;53:1–10.
Trieschmann J, Xiao S, Prokopeva LJ, Drachev VP, Kildishev AV. Experimental retrieval of the kinetic parameters of a dye in a solid film. Opt Exp 2011;19:18253–9.
Yang GY, Hanack M, Lee YW, Chen Y, Lee MK, Dini D. Synthesis and nonlinear optical properties of fluorine-containing naphthalocyanines. Chem–Eur J 2003;9:2758–62.
Kovsh DI, Yang S, Hagan DJ, Van Stryland EW. Nonlinear optical beam propagation for optical limiting. Appl Opt 1999;38:5168–80.
Lepkowicz R, Kobyakov A, Hagan DJ, Van Stryland EW. Picosecond optical limiting in reverse saturable absorbers: a theoretical and experimental study. JOSA B 2002;19:94–101.
Nagra AS, York RA. FDTD analysis of wave propagation in nonlinear absorbing and gain media. IEEE Trans Antennas Propag 1998;46:334–40.
Chang S, Taflove A. Finite-difference time-domain model of lasing action in a four-level two-electron atomic system. Opt Exp 2004;12:3827–33.
Yee K. Numerical solution of initial boundary value problems involving Maxwell’s equations in isotropic media. IEEE Transactions Antennas Propag 1966;14:302–7.