The Facility of Antiproton and Ion Research (FAIR) is a new international accelerator facility which is built in Darmstadt, Germany. The Republic of Poland belongs to the group of FAIR partner countries. The physics research program at FAIR will address a broad variety of topics, from fundamental problems to their applications in physics, biology and materials science [1, 2]. The core element of the FAIR facility is the superconducting (SC) synchrotron SIS100. The key components of SIS100 are the SC dipole magnets (DPM) and quadrupole modules (QDM). A single QDM contains two SC quadrupole magnets and a various number of SC corrector magnets. All SC magnets of SIS100 are of super-ferric type. In order to investigate the quality of DPMs and QDMs in terms of electrical integrity, Faculty of Electrical and Control Engineering (GUT) is developing a measurement and diagnostic system for SC magnets of SIS100 .
The high demand for the stability of the electrical parameters of SC magnets requires systematic quality control to be implemented at the stages of production, factory acceptance test (FAT), site acceptance test (SAT) – at both ambient & cryogenic conditions, prior to & after the installation in the accelerator tunnel, during machine commissioning and periodically during maintenance off time [4, 5, 6].
The measurement system proposed by GUT considers a comprehensive electrical integrity investigation, i.e.: high voltage DC test, temperature sensor check, voltage tap check, circuit correctness check and inter-turn insulation check. This paper focuses on the surge test (capacitor discharge) subsystem which enables the investigation issues related to the inter-turn insulation quality. This subsystem is called “HV-Discharge” and it utilizes a non-destructive diagnostic method based on a synchronised voltage & current measurement during a discharge of an external capacitor on a SC magnet coil. Since there are several magnet types at SIS100 that are characterized by an inductance which varies from 0.4 to 140 mH, the system has to be built in such a way that the capacitance and initial voltage can be adjusted in accordance to the required energy level. On account of the unavailability for testing of the first SC magnets, the study of the inter-turn fault effects was conducted on a special toroidal transformer for which a very accurate mathematical model was developed [7, 8, 9]. The model takes into account the nonlinearity and hysteresis of the magnetic yoke. In order to emulate the inter-turn faults in transformer windings, a dedicated test bench was constructed. The detailed study concerning the impact of inter-turn faults on voltage and current waveforms during the capacitor discharge on the transformer winding is presented within this paper.
2 Diagnosis method
It was assumed that the analysis of measurement results of each SC magnet type will be carried out at the time of the delivery to FAIR. This will allow to check the compliance with the reference values. In addition, a characteristic signature for each SC magnet will be created during this procedure. Periodic control measurements will allow to observe changes respect to the SC magnet signature and to compare them with the reference values. Exceeding the threshold values or a significant change in reference to SC magnet signature will be an indication of an electrical fault. This allows to make a decision to either repair or replace the SC magnet.
The measurement method requires a synchronised recording of the voltage and discharge current waveforms. The initially proposed diagnostic procedure concerns the frequency and the damping factor of both the discharge current and the voltage waveforms .
The research to select the appropriate criteria for the analysis of measured waveforms [4, 5, 6, 11] is still ongoing. In this paper, a new diagnostic procedure based on the calculation of the energy index of voltage and discharge current waveforms is proposed. In order to verify this method, a special test bench with a toroidal transformer was assembled see Figure 1. This test bench allows to emulate the inter-turn faults in transformer windings. Measurements on this test bench were conducted for system configurations that differ in the number of shorted turns.
The current i(t) and voltage u(t) waveforms during the discharge through the transformer winding are shown in Figure 2.
The basis of the diagnostic procedure is the analysis of the absolute power |p(t)| waveform defined by:
as an acceptance criterion. The computed Ea-indexes that correspond to the various number of shorted turns (N = 0..3) are shown in Figure 3 as well.
The change in the Ea-index unambiguously indicates an electrical fault in a form of a shorted turn of the transformer winding. In order to increase the measurement statistics, the calculation of the energy index has been repeated many times for various voltages, for which the capacitor bank was initially charged, and for a different number of shorted turns. Figure 4 shows a comparison of the energy (E) and the energy index (Ea) calculated for the performed measurements. Each bar represents the average value of 10 measurements. Using the energy as an acceptance criterion, an occurrence of a short-circuit cannot be identified. On the other hand, the Ea-index enables to identify the electrical fault.
3 Transformer model
The equivalent circuit model of the considered toroidal transformer connected to the “HV-Discharge” system is presented in Figure 5. The transformer is supplied from a capacitor bank C0 via feeder resistance Rf and feeder inductance Lf. The transformer incorporates two coupled windings: primary denoted by index “P” and secondary denoted by index “S”.
The primary winding is divided in two parts: the main part modelled by resistance Rp1 & inductance Mp1 and the short-circuited part modelled by resistance Rp2 & inductance Mp2. An electrical fault which short-circuits the turns of the primary winding is modelled as resistance Rsc and inductance Lsc. The eddy current effects and excess losses in the core are modelled with an additional circuit defined by inductance Me and resistance RFe. Resistance RFe represents both the classical and anomalous eddy current losses (which may be non-linear) .
The Lagrange energy method is proposed to determine the mathematical model of the transformer. The generalized coordinates – loops of currents: iP1, iP2 and iFe are proposed in Figure 5. It is assumed that the electrical currents are denoted by: i = dq/dt = q̇. The Lagrange function is defined as follows:
The Rayleigh dissipation function is defined as:
The general form of the Euler-Lagrange equation system takes the form of:
where Θ defined by (8) is the total ampere-turns of all coils, Nk is the number of turns of the k-th coil and Mlk is the leakage inductance.
4 Simulation results
The measured i(t) and u(t) waveforms of the capacitor discharge through the transformer winding and corresponding |p(t)| are in accordance with simulations performed with the presented mathematical model of the toroidal transformer, see Figure 6 (case of U = 10 V and N = 1).
The waveforms of absolute power and the energy index obtained from simulations in respect to the various number of shorted turns (N = 0..3) are shown in Figure 7. The Ea-indexes were calculated with the use of equation (2).
The summary of energy indexes calculated from measurements and simulations in respect to the various number of shorted turns and for U=10 V is shown in Table 1. The uncertainty of the leakage inductance of the short-circuited path (Mp2) in the mathematical model is higher when the number of shorted turns increases. Therefore the simulation for N=3 is characterized by the highest computation error.
Comparison of energy index calculated from measurements and simulations
|Number of shorted turns||Criteria (energy index)|
|N = 0||0.0521||0.0522||−0.25%|
|N = 1||0.0427||0.0425||0.26%|
|N = 2||0.0374||0.0378||−1.18%|
|N = 3||0.0353||0.0362||−2.61%|
The article presents an analysis of voltage and current waveforms measured during a capacitor discharge through a transformer winding while emulating inter-turn faults. The conducted analysis, enhanced with accurate simulations that involve the feedback Preisach model of hysteresis, allowed to select an adequate acceptance criterion for the inter-turn insulation quality of transformer/electromagnet coils. The performed study constitutes the basis for the diagnostic method to be implemented in the surge test subsystem (“HV-Discharge”) which is currently being developed by FECE/GUT in the frame of the FAIR project. At the next stage of research, the presented diagnostic method will be verified and validated by performing measurements on a SC magnet prototype.
Stafiniak A., Floch E., Hahne P., Hess G., Kauschke M., Klos F., Marzouki F., et al., Commissioning of the Prototype Test Facility for Rapidly-Cycling Superconducting Magnets for FAIR, IEEE Trans. on Applied Superconductivity, 2008, 18, 1625–1628.
Henning W.F., FAIR An international accelerator facility for research with ions and antiprotons, Proceedings of European Particle Accelerator Conference (5-9 July 2004, Lucerne, Switzerland), 2004, 50-53.
Wołoszyk M., Ziółko M., Swędrowski L., The diagnostics of superconducting magnets electrical circuits, The Scientific Papers of Faculty of Electrical and Control Engineering Gdańsk University of Technology, 2016, 50, 103-107.
Iwasa Y., Leupold M., Weggel R., Hale J., Williams J., Diagnosis and analysis of an electrical short in a superconducting magnet, IEEE Trans. on Magnetics, 1983, 19, 704–706.
Takeuchi K., Asano K., Hayashi H., A diagnosis method for properties of superconducting magnet using fast current discharge, IEEE Trans. on Applied Superconductivity, 2001, 11, 2595–2598.
Stafiniak A., Szwangruber P., Freisleben W., Floch E., Electrical Integrity and its Protection for Reliable Operation of Superconducting Machines, Physics Procedia, Proceedings of the 25th International Cryogenic Engineering Conference and International Cryogenic Materials Conference, 2014, 67, 1106–1111.
Wilk A., Nieznanski J., Moson I., Nonlinear model of a wound iron core traction transformer with the account of magnetic, Proceedings of the XIX International Conference on Electrical Machines, 2010, 1-7.
Wilk A., Michna M., Cichowski A., Simulation of the remanence influence on the transient states of the single-phase transformer including feedback Preisach model, Proceedings of the 40th Annual Conference of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, 2014, 875–880.
Wilk A., Michna M., Simulation of the remanence influence on the transient states in a single-phase multiwinding transformer, Archives of Electrical Engineering, 2014, 66, 41–54.
Świsulski D., Wołoszyk M., Wołoszyn M., Ziółko M., Rafiński L., Stafiniak A., Testing of the superconducting magnets frequency characteristics, Elektronika ir Elektrotechnika, 2015, 103, 39–4.
Bernatt J., Examination of winding-isolation of transformers with the use of direct current, Przegląd Elektrotechniczny, 2015, 1, 41–44.